U.S. short-seller Viceroy Research makes scathing claims on Vedanta Group
Viceroy Research, which has a short position on VRL's debt stack, said the Vedanta group structure was 'financially unsustainable, operationally compromised' and was a 'severe, under-appreciated risk to creditors'.
'VRL is a 'parasite' holding company with no significant operations of its own, propped up entirely by cash extracted from its dying 'host': VEDL,' it said.
VRL and its web of intermediate holding companies held no material operating assets and carried about $4.9 billion in gross interest-bearing liabilities as of FY25, said the report. The survival of VRL depends on its ability to extract cash from publicly listed VEDL, which holds stakes in group companies including Hindustan Zinc and BALCO, it said.
The upstreaming process was inefficient because a significant portion of dividends issued leaks to minority shareholders, as VRL holds only 56% of Vedanta and 62% of Hindustan Zinc. Among other allegations, the report said VRL has extracted $338 million as 'brand fee' annually from VEDL and its subsidiaries in FY24 alone.
VRL used loans from VEDL subsidiaries to purchase VEDL stock on-market, but over $122 million of VEDL loans were 'written off' in a blatant violation of the Companies Act, it said.
The 87-page Viceroy Research report accused VRL of draining VEDL, forcing it to take on more debt and deplete its cash reserves, impaired creditors' ability to recover their principal, a situation that resembled a 'Ponzi scheme', it said. VEDL promoted capital-intensive projects that it could not afford to raise fresh capital, which was paid out to VRL, it alleged.
Other allegations included inflated asset values of VEDL's subsidiaries, capex fraud, expenses being kept off-balance sheet, and governance failure.
Shares of Vedanta and Hindustan Zinc slipped 3% each to ₹441 and ₹425 on Wednesday.
Vedanta denies
Vedanta Group dismissed Viceroy Research report as 'a malicious combination of selective misinformation and baseless allegations to discredit the group'.
The release of the Viceroy report came just a day before VEDL's annual general meeting (AGM).
Terming the report 'false propaganda', the company said, 'The timing of the report is suspect and could be to undermine the forthcoming corporate initiatives. Our stakeholders are discerning enough to understand such tactics.'
The group further noted that the report's authors had included extensive disclaimers stating that the content was educational and opinion-based, and not factual, it said.
The Viceroy Research is the second attack on the Vedanta Group. In 2018, VRL was delisted from the LSE amid protests outside its final annual general meeting.
(The writer is with The Hindu businessline)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India.com
an hour ago
- India.com
Air India to restore some international flights after fatal crash
New Delhi: Air India on Tuesday said it is set to partially restore its international flight schedule that was temporarily reduced for 'safety checks' following the tragic crash in Ahmedabad on June 12. The airline said it will resume some of the flights starting from August 1, while full-restoration is planned for October 1. 'That Pause enabled Air India to perform additional precautionary checks on its Boeing 787 aircraft as well as accommodating longer flying times arising from airspace closures over Pakistan and the Middle East,' said the Tata Group-owned airline. From August 1 to September 30, Air India will operate 3x weekly flights between Ahmedabad and London (Heathrow), replacing currently operating 5x weekly flights between Ahmedabad and London (Gatwick). The Tata Group-owned airline had reduced flights to Europe and North America by 15 per cent till mid-July to increase contingency aircraft to cater for cancellations. Most of the cancelled flights were operated by Boeing 787 aircraft and were grounded due to enhanced inspections mandated by the DGCA. The disruption was further compounded by the closure of Iranian airspace. As the schedule reductions taken as part of the Safety Pause had been implemented until July 31 2025 and the restoration to full operation is being phased, some services initially planned to operate between 1 August and 30 September 2025 will be removed from the schedule. 'Air India is proactively contacting affected passengers to offer re-booking on alternative flights or a full refund, as per their preference. Air India apologises for the inconvenience. With the partial restoration, Air India operate more than 525 international flights per week on 63 short, long and ultra long-haul routes,' said the airline. Meanwhile, the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) has instructed airlines to carry out checks on the locking mechanism of fuel control switches of Boeing aircraft in their fleets. The move comes in the wake of the preliminary investigation report into last month's tragic Air India Boeing Dreamliner crash at Ahmedabad, in which 260 people were killed. One of the key findings of the Air Accidents Investigation Bureau's preliminary report on the crash was that the twin engines of the ill-fated Boeing plane shut down seconds after take-off as the fuel supply was cut off.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Govt nominees on Hindustan Zinc board may quiz management on Vedanta tomorrow
New Delhi: Government nominees on the Hindustan Zinc Ltd (HZL) board will likely quiz the management on the company's dealings with its promoter Vedanta Ltd and other related parties at the next board meeting on July 17, people aware of the development said. The government had a 27.92% stake in HZL while Anil Agarwal-controlled Vedanta Ltd held 61.84% as of June 30. "The idea (behind asking fresh questions to the HZL management) is not to doubt the company's financial position or cast aspersions but to be reassured of its corporate governance practices and other financial and operational aspects," one of the persons cited above told ET. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Exclusive McAfee Discount Ends Soon McAfee Shop Now The move comes in the aftermath of short-seller Viceroy Research accusing Vedanta's parent entity Vedanta Resources this month of being a "parasite" running a "ponzi scheme" that has "pushed the entire group to the brink of insolvency." Vedanta has called the claims a "false propaganda" based on information already available in the public domain and asserted that "the authors have tried to sensationalise the context to profiteer from market reaction." Live Events The US-based short-seller has also questioned HZL's payment of about Rs 1,560 crore in "brand and strategic services" fees to Vedanta, adding that this was without commercial justification. In response to ET's queries, an HZL spokesperson said "'Vedanta' is a prominent global brand in the natural resources sector and the brand is a registered intellectual property of Vedanta Resources. Vedanta Ltd, HZL and other group companies use the brand under a brand license/sub-license agreement and pay a board-approved brand and strategic services fee for its usage." "This structure reflects a standard intercompany licensing model used globally by diversified groups and is fully compliant with Indian accounting, tax and governance regulations, and follows internationally accepted practices," the spokesperson added. Asked if the company intends to explain its stance on the Viceroy Research report to the government nominees in the July 17 board meeting, the spokesperson said as a policy, the company "does not disclose the agenda or discussion points of upcoming board meetings." "Outcomes of such meetings, as required, will be communicated through appropriate channels post conclusion." Another person said nominees of minority shareholders asking questions at a company's board meeting on emerging issues is a legitimate practice and "there is no reason why the government wouldn't do that." The HZL board has three government nominated directors.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
50 LDA plots, 2 complexes on e-auction
Lucknow: At least 50 residential plots in Basant Kunj Scheme and two major commercial complexes have been listed for e-auction by the Lucknow Development Authority (LDA). According to LDA officials, 252 square metre plots located in Sector-G near Gau Ghat, adjacent to the Green Corridor, have been put up for auction for the first time. The base rate was fixed at Rs 32,955 per sqm. These plots, with an estimated collective value of Rs 310 crore, were planned in a prime residential area. Additionally, several high-value properties identified through a land audit were also included. A 2.5-hectare plot near SSB in Gomti Nagar Extension, valued at nearly Rs 100 crore, was selected for e-auction. Commercial and nursing home plots in Vishal Khand, Gomtinagar, measuring 1800 sqm, have also been listed. Two multi-storey commercial complexes constructed earlier by the authority have been put up for sale. The five-storey Ratan Khand complex (6729.6 sqm) was valued at Rs 87 crore, while the Mansarovar complex (1586.43 sqm) was valued at Rs 15.27 crore. Both were included in the current auction. Officials have been asked to prepare plans for high-rise residential buildings on LDA-owned land near Balu Adda (4200 sqm) and Bhadeva in Aishbagh (5000 sqm), which were identified through the same land audit process.
