Failure to provide secure care beds for children at risk an ‘affront to the rule of law'
Tusla
, the Child and Family Agency, to provide secure care beds to the most at risk, vulnerable children is an 'affront to the rule of law', a High Court judge has said.
Judge John Jordan, presiding over the weekly 'no beds' list on Thursday, heard updates on three children in respect of whom secure care orders have been made but who cannot get a bed due to staff shortages.
The hearing comes a week after an inquest jury, which found
Daniel McAnaspie
(17) died by unlawful killing while in the care of the State, recommended increased funding for Tusla to ensure timely access to secure care for the most at risk young people.
Meath coroner's court heard the boy, who was murdered in Blanchardstown in February 2010 and his decomposed body found in Co Meath three months later,
had 'begged' to be taken into secure care
in the months before his death.
READ MORE
Three applications by social workers for secure care were refused by a HSE special care committee due to lack of beds.
A child or young person who is deemed to be at such a risk to themselves, or others, as to need therapeutic residential care may be detained in secure care by the High Court.
On Thursday Judge Jordan heard a 15-year-old boy with a neuro-developmental disorder was 'free-falling'. His father believed without secure care the boy 'will die', the court heard.
The boy is misusing alcohol and drugs, was found in possession of detergent tablets 'for no reason', is engaging with a family with criminal links, has been assaulted and needs dental care for knocked-out teeth. He faces 90 criminal charges.
A 16-year-old girl who is self-harming and has attempted suicide, has been 'drawn into a life of criminality, drug dealing ... dealing in crack cocaine as a result of being ... exploited by a criminal gang', the judge said.
She is at physical risk due to travelling in stolen cars and has been 'subjected to sexual exploitation'.
Supports put in place for a 17-year-old girl for whom a secure bed order was made in November, were 'not keeping [her] safe'.
Recently sexually abused by a person known to pose a risk to children, she was 'very, very reluctant' to be interviewed by gardaí, saying she 'had arranged for a vigilante beating to be delivered to the person she identified as the perpetrator instead', the court heard.
She turns 18 next month, becoming ineligible for secure care.
'This is unsatisfactory,' the judge said. 'This child should have been in special care if the Child and Family Agency complied with the order they applied for ... That is an appalling situation and it is very difficult to argue [the girl] has not suffered as a result.'
The judge said he was 'tired of the excuses and the platitudes' from the agency. 'Children are suffering and it is known they are suffering,' he said.
'Nobody, no judge should have to sit and listen to anyone, not least the State or an embodiment of the State, attempting to excuse noncompliance with a court order which they applied for and obtained.'
The court heard the number of secure care beds had fallen in recent weeks, from 15 to 14. There are 26 such beds but 12 remain closed due to staff shortages.
The situation had 'gone backwards', said the judge. 'This system in crisis, this dysfunctional system is getting worse ... It is an indictment of the State that those special care beds are not available.'
Legal representatives for Tusla, present in court, did not object to his comments.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Garda injured while arresting sword-wielding suspect
A garda was hospitalised after suffering injuries while arresting a man armed with a sword in south Dublin on Sunday. The incident occurred in the Ballyogan area of Dublin 18 just after 1.30am on Sunday. Gardaí based in Blackrock responded to reports of a man wielding a sword. While arresting the suspect, a male garda sustained injuries, according to a Garda statement. He was taken to hospital for assessment and has since been discharged. The suspect, a man in his 40s, has since been charged in connection with the incident. He is due before Dublin District Court on Monday morning.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Hilary Weston, who helped build Penneys and Brown Thomas, has died aged 83
Hilary Weston, the Dublin-born businesswoman who helped build Penneys and Brown Thomas as part of her husband Galen Weston 's family retail empire, has died aged 83. Ms Weston died in England, where she lived in recent years. She was prominent in the early days of Penneys after the family business bought the ailing Todd Byrne's department store and established the budget fashion chain. She is said to have personally overseen the production of clothing for the in-house brand the company introduced early on, Primark , which would ultimately give its name to the wider chain outside Ireland. She was later prominent in running Brown Thomas for a considerable time after her husband purchased the long-established retailer. In the years that followed she served as vice-chair of Holt Renfrew, the group's luxury retail chain in Canada. She held a variety of other positions in the wider family's interests, which included the conglomerate Associated British Foods (ABF), of which Penneys was a subsidiary; Fortnum & Mason; and Loblaws, the largest food retailer in Canada. She also oversaw a major property development in Florida. Born Hilary Frayne in Dún Laoghaire in 1942, she was the eldest of five children and attended Loreto Abbey, Dalkey. She started to work as a model in the 1950s and was successful at it, working extensively in Ireland and internationally. She met her future husband after he saw her on a billboard advertisement and had auctioneer Corrie Buckley arrange an introduction. The couple married in 1966. Having initially settled at the Roundwood Park estate in Wicklow, the family moved to Toronto in 1971 and Ms Weston later became a Canadian citizen. In August 1983, the IRA attempted to kidnap Mr Weston at Roundwood but An Garda Síochána had apparently been tipped off. The family was not there and two of the kidnappers were killed, while others were arrested during a gunfight with armed police. The family went on to sell the estate and are said to have become more private afterwards. Mr Weston, who was born in England but brought up in Canada, moved to Ireland in 1962 to establish Power supermarkets. He later took over the Quinnsworth chain before eventually selling the retailer to Tesco in the 1990s. Brown Thomas subsequently acquired the Switzer group of stores and then Arnotts, the Irish operation becoming part of the Selfridges group, which the family sold in 2021 for a price reported to have exceeded €4 billion. Penneys, though, which was established by Arthur Ryan with Galen Weston for ABF in 1969, would ultimately represent the Irish business's greater contribution to the wider group. The company now employs more than 80,000 staff across 17 countries and had sales of close to €11 billion in 2024. The Sunday Times put the wider family's fortune at some £17.75 billion in its most recent rich list. Ms Weston was still involved in various aspects of the business until recent years and played a role well as the many related charitable foundations which had been established to support a range of causes and made donations running into hundreds of millions of euro over the years. In 1979, she set up the Ireland Fund of Canada, a chapter of Tony O'Reilly's Ireland Fund, to raise money for good causes here. Between 1997 and 2002 she served as lieutenant governor of Ontario, donating the salary to an initiative to help young people from poor backgrounds into employment. She also authored two successful books on homes and gardens. She was predeceased by her husband, who died in April 2021, and is survived by their two children, Alannah and Galen jnr, both of whom are involved in the family business.
Irish Times
7 hours ago
- Irish Times
Croatian truck driver remanded in custody over €2 million drugs haul in Cork
A truck driver has been remanded in custody charged in connection with a €2 million drugs seizure from a consignment of steel at the Port of Cork . Robert Slivar (59), of no fixed abode but from Ivanic, Croatia , was brought before a special sitting of Cork District Court on Saturday. He was charged with two offences relating to the seizure of 93 packages of cannabis grass, weighing 107kg and worth €2.1 million. Mr Slivar, who arrived in Cork by ferry from Zeebrugge in Belgium , was charged with cannabis possession and possession of cannabis for sale or supply at the Port of Cork, Ringaskiddy, on July 27th, contrary to section 3 and section 15 of the Misuse of Drugs Act 1977. The alleged discovery was made by a sniffer dog, customs officers and gardaí . READ MORE Det Garda Ryan Dillon, of the Cork city divisional drugs unit, gave evidence of arrest, charge and caution, telling the court Mr Slivar made no reply to either charge when they were put to him after caution outside Togher Garda station. Insp Ray Dunne said gardaí sought for Mr Slivar to be remanded in custody, but defence solicitor Diarmuid Kelleher said his client, who was assisted throughout the proceedings by a Croatian interpreter, was seeking bail. Det Garda Dillon outlined objections to bail, citing the seriousness of the charges, the alleged strength of evidence in the case and fears Mr Slivar poses a flight risk as he has no ties to Ireland. Judge John King refused bail and remanded Mr Slivar in custody to appear again at a special sitting of Cork District Court on Wednesday. The judge also requested a statement of means from the accused before deciding whether to grant free legal aid.
