Ex-Wallabies slam 'weak' refs over series-deciding call
Lions fullback Hugo Keenan scored the match-winning try in the final minute of the second Test at the MCG, after Wallabies flanker Carlo Tizzano appeared to have been illegally cleaned out in the build-up.
Tizzano looked to have been hit high and recoiled holding his neck.
TMO Eric Gauzins and referee Andrea Piardi reviewed Lions flanker Jac Morgan's clean-out but ruled there was no foul play, allowing the try to stand.
Turinui, who played 20 Tests for the Wallabies, was adamant it should have been ruled out.
"The end is a penalty to the Wallabies and the referees were too weak to give it," Turinui said on Nine.
"The referees have got it wrong and it's cost the Wallabies survival in the series.
"The British and Irish Lions lead this series 2-0. It was brave to come back from them, but it is a terrible decision that decides this match."
Ex-England and Lions skipper Martin Johnson took a contrasting view, but former Wallabies captain Michael Hooper agreed with Turinui.
"I can see what the referee's saying but there's a penalty there, whether it's on head, on neck or whether he's going straight off his feet to ground," Hooper said on Nine.
"I would say if that was minute one it's a penalty and it was deserved to be awarded and the try overturned.
"If you're refereeing or judging by the letter of the law, minute one to minute 79 it doesn't matter."
Johnson disagreed.
"I didn't think there was enough there for a penalty that would change the game," he said on Nine.
"You have to be very, very sure to change the game on a ref's decision.
"I thought it wasn't a penalty."
Wallabies captain Harry Wilson was in no mood to discuss the incident when he was asked about it minutes after the match.
"I'm probably not in the right emotional state to talk about that," Wilson said on Nine.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
7 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Rugby Australia to seek answers from World Rugby over MCG call
Rugby Australia boss Phil Waugh has backed Wallabies coach Joe Schmidt over his post-match spray about the controversial decision to not penalise the Lions for foul play before their match-winning try at the MCG, and said RA would be seeking 'a high level of accountability' from World Rugby about the referee's calls this week. Waugh's firm stance came after Schmidt slammed Italian referee Andrea Piardi for not awarding a match-defining penalty in the 79th minute of the Lions' 29-26 win in Melbourne. Lions fullback Hugo Keenan scored in the last minute secure a series-clinching victory, but Schmidt came out swinging over an incident at the previous ruck, where Welsh flanker Jac Morgan cleaned out Carlo Tizzano with a hit on the back of the neck. The Wallabies argued Morgan should have been penalised for breaching Law 9.20, which prohibits contact above the shoulders at a ruck. With the Wallabies leading by two points, a penalty would have likely seen the series go to a decider on Saturday at Accor Stadium. Piardi reviewed the incident but ruled there it was not foul play because both players had arrived at the same time and Morgan had not used a shoulder. Schmidt said Piardi appeared unwilling to make a big call in the last minute, and the decision 'doesn't really live up to the big player safety push that they [World Rugby] are talking about. 'That decision, you only have to look at law 9.20. It's what they're there to enforce. A player who dives off his feet is clearly beaten to the position over the ball, makes neck contact, it was a tough one to take.' World Rugby chief executive Alan Gilpin and chairman Brett Robinson were guests at the MCG, ahead of 2027 Rugby World Cup events with Waugh and RA this week in Sydney.
The Age
7 hours ago
- The Age
Rugby Australia to seek answers from World Rugby over MCG call
Rugby Australia boss Phil Waugh has backed Wallabies coach Joe Schmidt over his post-match spray about the controversial decision to not penalise the Lions for foul play before their match-winning try at the MCG, and said RA would be seeking 'a high level of accountability' from World Rugby about the referee's calls this week. Waugh's firm stance came after Schmidt slammed Italian referee Andrea Piardi for not awarding a match-defining penalty in the 79th minute of the Lions' 29-26 win in Melbourne. Lions fullback Hugo Keenan scored in the last minute secure a series-clinching victory, but Schmidt came out swinging over an incident at the previous ruck, where Welsh flanker Jac Morgan cleaned out Carlo Tizzano with a hit on the back of the neck. The Wallabies argued Morgan should have been penalised for breaching Law 9.20, which prohibits contact above the shoulders at a ruck. With the Wallabies leading by two points, a penalty would have likely seen the series go to a decider on Saturday at Accor Stadium. Piardi reviewed the incident but ruled there it was not foul play because both players had arrived at the same time and Morgan had not used a shoulder. Schmidt said Piardi appeared unwilling to make a big call in the last minute, and the decision 'doesn't really live up to the big player safety push that they [World Rugby] are talking about. 'That decision, you only have to look at law 9.20. It's what they're there to enforce. A player who dives off his feet is clearly beaten to the position over the ball, makes neck contact, it was a tough one to take.' World Rugby chief executive Alan Gilpin and chairman Brett Robinson were guests at the MCG, ahead of 2027 Rugby World Cup events with Waugh and RA this week in Sydney.
AU Financial Review
9 hours ago
- AU Financial Review
Santos CEO mixes business and pleasure at the Wallabies
The last-minute try that saw the British and Irish Lions beat the Wallabies on Saturday will leave rugby fans with sore necks. It wasn't just the dubious nature of it, but the fact the locals put up such a good performance in front of more than 90,000 spectators at the MCG. More than half were Brits on tour, sure. But Rugby Australia chief executive Phil Waugh must have whiplash that they can draw a crowd like that on non-union turf. One who was spotted among VIPs and junketeers was Santos chief executive Kevin Gallagher. His presence is entirely expected, considering that his oil and gas company is a major sponsor of Australian rugby. But still, it was a nice distraction for him given he has so much on his mind.
