The police must fight crime, not legal speech
So I was horrified, last November, when police officers called on Telegraph journalist Allison Pearson. It was initially believed that they were investigating a so-called non-crime hate incident (or NCHI), based on a comment she'd posted on social media.
In my view the police should have only one overriding priority: catching criminals and protecting the public from crime. This emphatically does not extend to acting as the thought police or intervening when someone makes an off colour remark online.
People are perfectly entitled to say whatever they like, including things that are offensive, provided that they are not illegal. These boundaries are set out by Parliament in law. It's illegal to incite racial or religious hatred, express support for a proscribed terrorist organisation such as Hamas or to use threats or intimidation to harass someone.
But saying that women don't have penises, criticising a religion or simply saying something offensive are not illegal. It follows that people should not be harassed or investigated by the police for any of these things.
And yet they are. Police investigated and recorded personal data on around 13,000 NCHIs last year – taking up around 30,000 hours of police time. This personal data – where no crime has been committed – is then potentially disclosable by the police as part of an enhanced criminal record check for years to come.
NCHIs were never legislated for by Parliament. They were created through police guidance in the early 2000s in response to the murder of Stephen Lawrence and further entrenched in 2014. The inquiry into Stephen Lawrence's murder found that the previous extreme racism exhibited by his killers should have been identified and his death thereby prevented.
Where hatred is such that it is likely to lead to an actual crime, then there is a good case for police taking an interest – as they would in relation to any intelligence that might be a precursor to criminal activity.
But over the years, NCHIs have expanded beyond all recognition and have strayed far from this original intention. Reporting in the Telegraph only yesterday showed that the police now don't even bother to analyse NCHIs for patterns of possible criminality.
NCHIs have been investigated and personal details recorded over the most absurdly trivial things. This has included singing a song with the word 'Africa' in the lyrics; commenting on EU citizens working here; a mobility scooter being ridden on a pavement; commenting on the trans debate; an intemperate email sent between family members and even playground arguments between children.
It is clear the police are now wasting colossal amounts of their time on NCHIs and infringing our ancient rights to free speech while they do so.
In 2023 while in government, Conservatives introduced tighter rules on NCHIs to try to stop this abuse. But a report by HM Inspector of Constabulary in September 2024 found that the new rules were being ignored. The Police had simply carried on as before.
I have raised this in Parliament over recent months and it's clear that the Labour government has no real intention of fixing this problem. This is why the Conservatives are now announcing a new policy: NCHIs as a category of incident should be scrapped in their entirety.
Police should only investigate or record something where it is likely to be genuinely necessary to prevent or investigate crime. This will free up tens of thousands of hours of police time to catch real criminals and help restore free speech. Instead of policing Twitter, police should spend more time catching burglars and mobile phone thieves.
The Conservatives will table this as an amendment to the Crime and Policing Bill currently going through Parliament and will force a vote. Then it will be clear which MPs are willing to stand up for common sense, getting police priorities straight and for free speech – and which MPs are not.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
36 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
How an influencer mum's trip to Israel triggered a referral to anti-radicalisation police... and to officers knocking on her door
A mother was referred to anti-radicalisation group Prevent and investigated by the police over concerns she had been radicalised because she had visited Israel. Holly Passmore, 43, was stunned to find officers at her door two weeks after her visit to the country. The single mother-of-two, who is not Jewish, had been part of a delegation of social media influencers invited by the Israeli embassy for a trip that included visiting Kfar Aza, one of the kibbutzim where British hostage Emily Damari was abducted by Hamas terrorists on October 7, 2023. The police demanded to know why she had visited Israel, whether she was planning to go back and whether she felt safe to go there. 'I asked them, 'What do you think happened? That the Jews kidnapped me?'' said Ms Passmore, who has had an interest in Jewish people after studying the Holocaust for her degree. 'I kept saying to them, 'I don't understand why you are here' and they said only that they were there to check on me.' She said when the officers first knocked on the door of her County Durham home and explained they were there to talk about safeguarding, she worried it was about her autistic son. 'But then they mentioned Israel and said, 'We aren't here about your son, but about you, we've had a complaint'. I was absolutely gobsmacked,' said Ms Passmore of the July 4 visit. 'Then they came out with all these questions, 'When did you go? Why did you go? Who did you go with? Why are you interested in this?' I said to them, 'Is this real?' She had a second visit ten days later after she complained about her doorstep interrogation to local Reform councillor and former television presenter Darren Grimes, who wrote to Durham Constabulary. This time Ms Passmore, who posts on X as @MummyisTired and has nearly 17,000 followers, faced a Prevent officer and a police superintendent. It was the first time she learned someone had reported her to Prevent. 'They kept saying to me that if the person has vulnerabilities, they have to be checked out, but I've looked into Prevent since and that doesn't explain the processes they've had to get through to being on my doorstep,' said Ms Passmore, who is on the autism spectrum and has ADHD. 'The Prevent wording is that it's for people who are vulnerable to exploitation but that is theoretically anybody. Who do they think is exploiting me into what?' Ms Passmore said that on the second visit she was told the investigation wasn't about her trip to Israel, even though that is what all of the questions on the earlier interrogation were about. Fiona Sharpe, a spokeswoman for Labour Against Antisemitism, said: 'The stated aim of Prevent is to safeguard against people, particularly vulnerable ones, from being radicalised. It is hard to understand what evidence was given to them to warrant visiting a woman just because she had visited Israel. Visiting Israel is certainly not a crime.' Dr Daniel Allington, an expert on anti-Semitism at King's College London, said attacking people who support Israel is a new tactic of extremists. He said: 'People of a certain political persuasion love to make the malicious insinuation that Britons travelling to Israel are somehow equivalent to Britons travelling to Isis. But Israel is an ally, a trading partner, a democracy – in every sense a friend of the UK.' A Durham Constabulary spokeswoman said: 'Each Prevent referral is reviewed to determine whether further action is required including, where appropriate, assessment to determine if there is an immediate security threat, or whether a vulnerable person is at genuine risk of radicalisation.'
The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
Australia condemns Israel for ‘indefensible' Gaza deaths as it joins coalition of countries denouncing Israel
The thousands of civilian deaths in Gaza from Israel's bombing campaign are 'indefensible', minister Tony Burke has said, after Australia joined 27 other countries condemning Israel for denying humanitarian aid to Palestinians. The international statement – signed by Australia, the United Kingdom, France, Canada, New Zealand and Japan among others – warned 'the suffering of civilians in Gaza has reached new depths'. It expressed horror at the deaths of hundreds of people at aid distribution sites through Gaza, and demanded Israel comply with its obligations under international humanitarian law. 'The Israeli government's aid delivery model is dangerous, fuels instability and deprives Gazans of human dignity. We condemn the drip feeding of aid and the inhumane killing of civilians, including children, seeking to meet their most basic needs of water and food,' the statement said. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email 'It is horrifying that over 800 Palestinians have been killed while seeking aid. The Israeli Government's denial of essential humanitarian assistance to the civilian population is unacceptable.' The statement pleads for the end of the war in Gaza and calls for the immediate and unconditional release of Israeli hostages 'cruelly held captive by Hamas since 7 October 2023 [who] continue to suffer terribly'. Burke, Australia's home affairs minister, said Australia wanted to see the war stop. 'We've seen too many images of children being killed, of horrific slaughter, of churches being bombed. The images that we've seen have been pretty clear that so much of this is indefensible and – as that statement referred to – aid being drip-fed in,' he told the ABC on Tuesday. On Monday, Israel launched substantial air raids and a ground operation in Gaza, targeting Deir al-Balah, the main hub for humanitarian efforts in the devastated Palestinian territory, amid warnings of widening starvation. The latest assault began a day after the highest death toll in 21 months inflicted by the Israeli military on desperate Palestinians seeking food aid, with at least 85 killed in what has become a grim and almost daily slaughter. The UN food agency, the World Food Programme, said the majority of those killed on Sunday had gathered near the border fence with Israel in the hope of getting flour from a UN aid convoy when they were fired on by Israeli tanks and snipers. Burke said the federal government hopes 'something will break' the conflict in Gaza, voicing alarm over 'the increasing sight of people being killed on their way simply to get food and water'. 'None of this changes the fact that the hostages need to be released, of course that needs to happen,' he said. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion 'What we are watching on the other side of the world is indefensible. The hostages still need to be released, but the war needs to end.' On Monday afternoon, the Israeli foreign ministry rejected the joint statement, saying it was 'disconnected from reality'. 'The statement fails to focus the pressure on Hamas and fails to recognise Hamas's role and responsibility for the situation,' the ministry said. 'Hamas is the sole party responsible for the continuation of the war and the suffering on both sides. At these sensitive moments in the ongoing negotiations, it is better to avoid statements of this kind.' Federal parliament returns on Tuesday, with rallies and events to be held in Canberra calling on the government to do more to address the deteriorating humanitarian situation in Gaza. A coalition of aid groups including Amnesty International and Médecins Sans Frontières will hold a 24-hour vigil where speakers will read the names of more than 17,000 Palestinian children killed by Israeli forces in Gaza. The Greens senator David Shoebridge is also expected to table an open letter to Anthony Albanese from more than 2,500 healthcare workers from across Australia urging stronger action to address the humanitarian crisis. Responding to the international joint statement, Shoebridge wrote on X that it was ' a welcome, if extremely late, step'. Independent senator David Pocock wrote: 'While welcome, we need more than words from the international community to stop the killing of civilians in Gaza, especially those seeking aid.'
Scottish Sun
2 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Britain joins 24 nations demanding Israel end war in Gaza claiming bloody conflict has plumbed ‘new depths'
Read on for a list of the nation's demanding peace Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) BRITAIN joined 24 other nations demanding Israel end its war in Gaza yesterday claiming the bloody conflict had plumbed 'new depths.' The joint statement said it was 'horrifying' that more than 800 Palestinians in the strife-torn Hamas terror stronghold have been killed seeking food - including dozens yesterday. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up But Israeli forces stepped up action in the central Gazan city of Deir al-Balah yesterday - despite fears October 7 hostages are being held there. An unprecedented joint statement condemning the war was signed by the foreign ministers of Australia, Austria, Belgium, Canada, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Japan, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland and the UK. It said: 'We come together with a simple, urgent message: the war in Gaza must end now. The suffering of civilians in Gaza has reached new depths. 'We condemn the drip feeding of aid and the inhumane killing of civilians, including children, seeking to meet their most basic needs of water and food. 'The hostages cruelly held captive by Hamas since 7 October 2023 continue to suffer terribly. We condemn their continued detention and call for their immediate and unconditional release. "A negotiated ceasefire offers the best hope of bringing them home and ending the agony of their families.' Israel's strongman president Benjamin Netanyahu was urged to heed Donald Trump's US peace moves. The statement added: 'Further bloodshed serves no purpose. We reaffirm our complete support to the efforts of the US, Qatar and Egypt. 'We are prepared to take further action to support an immediate ceasefire and a political pathway to security and peace for Israelis, Palestinians and the entire region.' Hamas-controlled health officials said yesterday that the toll of Palestinians killed since Israel attacked following the October 7 terror attacks which killed 1,200 has now topped 59,000. Parish priest Gabriel Romanelli is being treated after Israel hit Holy Family Catholic Church in Gaza
