Gaughan, county appealing court ruling in vacancy case
Gaughan and the county, co-petitioners in litigation challenging the charter process, are also appealing the panel's ruling that the county lacks authority to proceed as a party in the legal matter.
With Senior Judges Carmen D. Minora and Vito P. Geroulo in the majority and Senior Judge Robert A. Mazzoni dissenting, the three-judge panel ruled Thursday that the charter supersedes a state rule of judicial administration that would have removed the county Democratic Committee from the replacement process. It amounted to a legal victory for the committee, which the charter tasks with playing a major role in filling vacancies when a Democratic commissioner or other elected Democratic county row officer leaves office mid-term.
Attorneys for Gaughan and the county filed a notice Friday in county court stating the parties are appealing the ruling in Commonwealth Court. The Scranton law firm Myers, Brier & Kelly filed the notice as part of its standing engagement, county spokesman Patrick McKenna said in an email, nothing there will be no further cost associated with the appeal.
The HRC specifically tasks the Democratic Committee with submitting the names of three potential candidates to fill the vacancy for consideration by the commissioned judges of the county Court of Common Pleas, and the judges with appointing McGloin's successor from that short list. That process played out controversially in late February when the committee held a closed-door vote to submit former county Economic Development Director Brenda Sacco, Olyphant Borough Council President James Baldan and Scranton School Director Robert J. Casey as potential appointees.
Gaughan and the county challenged the charter process in March, arguing it violates Pennsylvania Rule of Judicial Administration 1908. That rule, adopted by the state Supreme Court in 2019, says the county court alone, not a political party, 'shall receive applications from any interested candidates for the position' pursuant to a deadline established by the court.
Both sides made their respective cases in court filings and during oral arguments before the panel, with the committee arguing for the supremacy of the charter and Gaughan and the county for Rule 1908.
Minora and Geroulo ultimately ruled the charter process supersedes the rule of judicial administration, writing that Gaughan and the county's reading of Rule 1908 'simply defies logic and means every time the court issues a new rule, be it administrative or procedural, HRC communities better hold their breath lest their constitutionally guaranteed right to self-rule be consumed … by a pac-man like anonymous rule making committee unanswerable to any public input.'
Mazzoni, dissenting, wrote that the 'clear and unambiguous language in Rule 1908 … makes its application in this case compelling.'
'As noted in the language of Rule 1908, the application of this Rule makes the selection of a candidate more transparent and, of course, more diverse by creating a larger pool of worthy applicants,' Mazzoni wrote. 'A result which truly serves the ends of justice.'
The senior judges spoke in one voice on another element of the case, unanimously ruling that the county lacks authority to proceed as a party to the matter while rejecting the claim that county Solicitor Donald Frederickson can commence and prosecute litigation on behalf of the county without authorization from a majority of the commissioners. The county has no authority to proceed because Republican Commissioner Chris Chermak, one of two sitting commissioners, never authorized the county's participation, per the ruling.
Attorneys for Chermak — who himself objected to the use of county personnel, resources and taxpayer money to make the legal challenge — had argued in court against the county's participation for that reason.
The senior judges did, however, rule that Gaughan has standing to proceed in his official capacity as commissioner since he has a substantial, direct and immediate interest in the case.
'The employment of an appropriate selection process can have an impact on Gaughan's ability to function as a Commissioner,' they wrote.
The ruling notes that Chermak also has standing as a commissioner.
County President Judge James Gibbons has not provided specific details or a timeline on how the county judges might proceed in light of Thursday's ruling, now being appealed, which orders them to 'follow the directives of the Home Rule Charter' when filling McGloin's seat.
'We will provide information as it becomes available,' Gibbons said in an email.
Reached Friday morning, Frederickson said the appeal will stay Thursday's county court ruling pending a ruling from the appellate court.
The notice of appeal filed Friday is not the appeal itself, which will be filed at a later date.
County Democratic Chairman Chris Patrick declined to comment on the appeal beyond saying 'they have to do whatever they have to do.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Politico
35 minutes ago
- Politico
Valadao's allies shrug off Medicaid attacks
Presented by NOT SWEATING — Democrats are salivating at the chance to punish Rep. David Valadao for voting to slash spending on Medicaid in President Donald Trump's megabill. Even Republicans in Washington are warning the cuts could cost the GOP seats in the midterms. But, as Blake and Rachel Bluth report this morning, Valadao's Republican allies in his district are meeting the attacks with an entirely different calculation than in the Beltway. Republicans are cheering Valadao, who infuriated the MAGA base with his vote to impeach Trump after the riot at the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021, for his support of a major priority of the president's. And they are giving the Medicaid vote — and the perilous position it is putting Valadao in — a collective shrug. 'I don't believe this Medicaid thing is going to work. People won't fall for it,' said Cathy Abernathy, a fixture in Republican politics in the area and mentor to former Speaker Kevin McCarthy. 'I put my money on Valadao winning. I don't think it will be tight.' That nearly two-thirds of residents in Valadao's district receive Medicaid has not shaken his allies' confidence. Neither has the fact that Valadao last lost his seat in 2018 after voting to repeal the Affordable Care Act. Nor has the threat of depressed Republican turnout in next year's midterms, when the ballot won't include the five most powerful letters in American politics: T-R-U-M-P. But could Valadao's vote to impose stricter work requirements on Medicaid recipients at least present an electoral vulnerability? Linda Willis, the president of Bakersfield Republican Women, Federated, shook her head. 'No,' she said flatly, seated inside a country club ballroom where her group's monthly luncheon had just wrapped up. GOOD MORNING. Happy Thursday. Thanks for waking up with Playbook. Like what you're reading? Sign up to get California Playbook in your inbox, and forward it to a friend. You can also text us at 916-562-0685 — save it as 'CA Playbook' in your contacts. Or drop us a line at dgardiner@ and bjones@ or on X — @DustinGardiner and @jonesblakej. WHERE'S GAVIN? Returning to California after his campaign swing through rural South Carolina and an overnight pit stop in Nashville. CAMPAIGN YEAR(S) MIXED RECEPTION — Gov. Gavin Newsom packed church pews and community centers and cafes as he sprinted across South Carolina this week — the whooping crowds a sign of the opening the California governor may have in the state's early Democratic presidential primary. But as POLITICO's Tyler Katzenberger reports from the trail, Newsom's visit also laid bare how his campaign could be dragged down by a sense among some Democrats in the Southern state that California's liberal reputation may hobble him. 'The larger concerns that he has to allay are related to California, and the feeling many have that California is not representative of the rest of the country in terms of its politics,' said Jim Hodges, the most recent Democratic governor of South Carolina, a heavily-Republican state. After Newsom's two-day tour of the state, he jetted to Nashville, where he spoke with local Democrats and journalists at a brewery. ON THE AIRWAVES GAMING WARS — Native American tribes are on an offensive blitz in California this legislative session as they seek to stamp out online gaming. Their latest target: so-called internet sweepstakes, which allow users to compete in casino-style games by buying virtual coins that can be converted into cash or prizes. One of the most powerful casino tribes, the Yuhaaviatam of San Manuel Nation, recently launched a TV spot in the Sacramento media market that calls attention to sweepstakes offered by 'shady out-of-state and offshore companies.' The ad urges support for Assembly Bill 831, by Avelino Valencia, which would clarify that internet sweepstakes games that use dual-currency models are illegal. 'Their schemes have no real protections for minors or problem gamblers and contribute nothing to California's economy,' the ad states. CALIFORNIA DECODED 'JUST A WORKING DRAFT' — State Sen. Scott Wiener is appealing directly to major tech firms — including Google, Meta and ChatGPT-maker OpenAI — in an attempt to calm nerves and explain major changes he made to expand an artificial intelligence bill that would require companies to publish safety and risk assessments to help stop programs causing real-life damage. As POLITICO's Chase DiFeliciantonio scooped last night, Wiener sent letters to the firms in hopes of getting them on board with his second attempt at regulating artificial intelligence after his failed push last year rocked Silicon Valley with reverberations all the way to Washington. The letters were sent Tuesday — the same day Wiener amended his closely watched bill, which also protects AI whistleblowers. POLITICO first reported that he was considering those amendments. 'I invite you to engage with my team directly. Please reach out to my office with feedback and suggestions to improve this bill,' Wiener wrote. 'Our goal is to craft legislation that enhances transparency while fostering the innovation that drives California's economy and benefits the entire nation.' CLIMATE AND ENERGY MEGA PROBLEM — California lawmakers just weakened one of their bedrock environmental laws in the name of speeding up development. Now they're thinking about taking another chunk out of it to save clean energy projects from Trump. Read last night's California Climate to see why Republicans' assault on solar and wind is creating more urgency for the state to build faster. TOP TALKERS TUNNEL COLLAPSE IN LOS ANGELES — Mayor Karen Bass said on X late Wednesday that 'all workers who were trapped in the tunnel in Wilmington are now out and accounted for' after an industrial tunnel collapse. The Los Angeles Times reported the 'partial collapse of an L.A. County sanitation tunnel under construction left 31 workers scrambling to make their way to safety on Wednesday evening' and that all made it out. MENTAL HEALTH MATTERS — State Attorney General Rob Bonta, along with a multi-state coalition, is asking a federal judge to block the U.S. Department of Education from discontinuing school mental health grant funding as the issue plays out in court, a press release from Bonta's office said. The motion for a preliminary injunction seeks to ensure grantees who received messages from the Trump administration claiming that their grants would be reallocated will still receive funding. The move comes after Bonta recently sued the administration over the grants. 'HARD MIDDLE' APPROACH — Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman has been trying to maintain a measured approach following last month's protests over immigration raids and the Trump administration's subsequent deployment of the National Guard to the region, The Los Angeles Times reports. The Republican-turned-independent, who endorsed Kamala Harris in last year's presidential election and touts a 'hard middle' stance, said that he would prefer if immigration agents would let state-level cases play out before the federal government takes action. Hochman said that he's working hard to 'keep our focus in this office on the public safety aspect,' and that his office is not working with the federal government on immigration enforcement. AROUND THE STATE — Insurance giant Blue Shield of California and the UC Health system reached a deal after months of negotiations to extend a contract that covers a large group of patients, including state workers. (The Fresno Bee) — One of San Francisco's most iconic seafood restaurants has been flooded with low-star reviews after an influencer made a social media post suggesting that the owners are Trump supporters. (SF Standard) — The San Diego Unified School District board voted unanimously on a new bill banning students from using their cell phones during most of the day. (Voice of San Diego) Compiled by Juliann Ventura PLAYBOOKERS PEOPLE MOVES — Angela Hervig is joining Rep. Luz Rivas' (D-Calif.) office as a legislative assistant. She previously was a senior legislative adviser at the EPA and is a Biden White House alum. — Veteran security researcher Tom Cross has joined GetReal as head of threat research. He's an alum of IBM X-Force, Lancope and Drawbridge. BIRTHDAYS — Rep. Tom McClintock … POLITICO's Christopher Cadelago (favorite cocktail: Negroni) … former state Sen. Gloria Romero … Jessica Simpson … BELATED B-DAY WISHES — (was Wednesday): Marc Andreessen ... Ted Leitner … (was Tuesday): Melanie Perron at Pacific Coast Capitol Advisors WANT A SHOUT-OUT FEATURED? — Send us a birthday, career move or another special occasion to include in POLITICO's California Playbook. You can now submit a shout-out using this Google form.
Yahoo
39 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Trump welcomes IRS decision to let churches endorse political candidates
WASHINGTON (Reuters) -U.S. President Donald Trump on Wednesday welcomed the Internal Revenue Service's decision that houses of worship could endorse political candidates to their congregations without risking losing their status as tax-exempt nonprofits. "I love the fact that churches could endorse a political candidate," Trump told reporters at the White House. "If somebody of faith wants to endorse, I think it's something that I'd like to hear." In a court filing on Monday to resolve a lawsuit by two Texas churches and the National Religious Broadcasters, the IRS said traditional religious communications are exempt from a decades-old provision in the U.S. tax code that bars nonprofits - religious and secular - from endorsing political candidates. The Justice Department under Democratic President Joe Biden had defended the law's constitutionality in court, saying Congress was entitled to refuse to subsidize political activity through tax benefits. Trump has criticized the law. During his first term in office in 2017, Trump signed an executive order aimed at easing the ban on political activity by churches. "Those people were not allowed to speak up. Now they're allowed to speak up," Trump said. "I think it's terrific."
Axios
an hour ago
- Axios
By the numbers: Who gets Medicaid insurance in Colorado
About 1 in 5 Colorado residents receive Medicaid insurance and 39% are children, while another 6% are 65 and older. Why it matters: The numbers reflect the potential far-reaching effects of Medicaid cuts from President Trump's One Big Beautiful Bill Act, and raise the stakes for Democratic state lawmakers who are scrambling to preserve the safety-net program known as Health First Colorado. By the numbers: Here's a look at who benefits from Medicaid insurance and who would be most vulnerable to changes in the program. The figures are based on the latest state estimates from fiscal year 2023-24. 📉 1.22 million Colorado residents receive Medicaid coverage, state officials reported in July. 📊 39% are white, 33% are Hispanic or Latino. 7% are Black. 👶 44% of the state's births were covered by Medicaid and CHP+. ♿ The largest portion of expenditures, more than 40%, covers individuals with disabilities, who are 5% of those enrolled in Medicaid. 🏨 Colorado hospitals receive $3 billion in Medicaid, the largest share of payouts. 🚨 An estimated 377,000 Colorado residents are at risk of losing Medicaid coverage because of the new work requirements, and administrative costs to monitor employment status would cost the state $57 million a year. 🚩 Rural communities will take the brunt of the cuts. In five southern Colorado counties, more than 50% of the population received Medicaid. In Denver, 35% of the population is enrolled in the program, while in El Paso County it's 31%. ❗ The two congressional districts with the largest proportion of Medicaid enrollees are represented by Republicans who voted for the reconciliation bill.
