Sebi's plan set to derail Metropolitan Stock Exchange's comeback
The Metropolitan Stock Exchange of India (MSEI) had raised
₹
238 crore from broking firm Groww's parent Billionbrains Garage Ventures, Zerodha's Rainmatter Investments, Share India Securities, and Securocorp Securities India in December 2024.
The bourse planned to offer a derivative contract for its flagship SX40 index. All National Stock Exchange Ltd's derivatives expire on Thursday, BSE Ltd's on Tuesday, and the MSEI had set Friday expiry for its SX40 contracts.
Also read:
Sebi eases ESG rating rules. But experts warn of short-term risk
The exchange offers trading but generates minuscule daily volumes at 30,950 on 5 May. By contrast, NSE's cash trading volumes on May 5 stood at 293.72 crore, while for BSE it was 58.59 crore. MSEI was betting that an independent derivative expiry day would help it gain some market share from NSE and BSE.
Sebi's plan could thwart MSEI's bid to position itself as an alternative to its more established and larger rivals, experts said.
'It is highly unlikely that the market regulator will allow a separate day expiry for MSEI because then it circumvents Sebi's original plan to reduce the number of weekly expiries," said a broker on the condition of anonymity. If the exchange does not get a separate expiry day, it will have no economic value, the broker said.
Established in 2008 by Jignesh Shah and associated entities, it was previously known as MCX-SX. Shah was allegedly involved in the National Spot Exchange Ltd fraud, which came to light in 2013--he denied wrongdoing.
Also read:
Primary markets see a slow start to 2025 amid increased volatility
Sebi published a consultation paper on March 27, proposing that all equity derivatives contracts of an exchange should either expire on Tuesdays or Thursdays. This would provide 'optimal spacing between expiries in a week and avoid concentration risk".
If all exchanges have expiries on the same day, traders might naturally go where there's the most liquidity, like NSE or BSE, said Nilesh Sharma, executive director and president (broking) at SAMCO Securities. Sharma said traders will always prefer better price discovery and liquidity, which is available on the NSE and BSE.
Latika Kundu, managing director and chief executive of MSEI, said that as a market infrastructure institution, it has been entrusted with the responsibility of building markets that support the country's economic growth. To reach India's goal of becoming a developed nation, it needs multiple players to help build competitive capital markets, she said.
To create a healthy competitive environment, there has to be an enabler, an exclusive expiry assigned to MSEI in this case, Kundu said. 'If that is taken away, we risk reverting to a duopoly or even monopoly, as the equity cash and equity derivatives markets are interdependent on each other."
Brokers and investors were betting on the revival of MSEI. Its unlisted shares traded for about
₹
2 apiece for years. However, after Zerodha and Groww's entry in December, the indicative share price touched
₹
9 and went to
₹
12 in January, before falling to trade at
₹
6 currently, according to data from Unlisted Arena, which trades in unlisted and delisted shares.
Zerodha and Share India Securities declined to comment, while queries emailed to Groww and Securocorp Securities India remained unanswered. An email sent to Sebi also remained unanswered.
Apart from the SX40 index, the MSEI also offers the SX Bank index. The Nifty 50 futures on the NSE, expiring on May 29, recorded a volume of 76,211 contracts. The Sensex futures contract on the BSE, set to expire on May 26, saw a modest volume of 136 contracts. The MSEI's SX40 futures contracts show zero trading volume.
Sebi's expiry proposal is just one of the issues plaguing MSEI. Not many brokers offer the exchange's contracts to their clients. It also lags its peers in infrastructure required to carry out these derivative trades seamlessly.
'The contracts on the MSEI exchange are live, but for trading volumes to build, brokers must obtain the necessary licences from the exchange and bring in customers," said Suvajit Ray, head of products of IIFL Capital Services Ltd. 'Once licensed, brokers can offer these contracts, but actual volumes will depend on customer participation—placing trades, paying premiums, and engaging in settlements."
Ray added that if not immediately, then gradually, once the exchange's infrastructure is in place, governance standards are met, and operational processes are streamlined, MSEI could function like any other exchange. 'It may start with lower volumes and fewer participants, but as brokers come on board and traction builds, we can see volumes."
Also read:
Mint Primer: Why Sebi wants investors to skip opinion trading
Kundu of MSEI said the exchange has already started upgrading the technology of its network, infrastructure and systems to ensure seamless connectivity and a better trading experience for members.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
14 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Figma extends gains after blockbuster NYSE trading debut
Design software maker Figma's shares surged another 20% in morning trading on Friday, extending strong debut-day gains after a blowout U.S. initial public offering that has reignited the tech listing market. The San Francisco, California-based company's shares closed at $115.5 on Thursday, compared with its IPO price of $33. The 250% surge lifted Figma's market value to nearly $68 billion, far exceeding the $20-billion valuation in a now-scrapped buyout deal with Photoshop maker Adobe. Figma's $1.22-billion offering, the fourth-largest U.S. IPO of the year, is being seen as a potential catalyst for other startups eyeing a flotation after a three-year freeze in the tech listings market. The deal's strong reception renewed hopes of a broader reopening of the pipeline, as private companies and investors look to capitalise on improving market conditions and strong demand for growth names. Figma, which has highlighted its focus on AI, has also benefited from Wall Street's enthusiasm for the technology. The boom fueled a sharp rally in tech stocks over the past year and drove up valuations and investor demand for companies seen as central to the AI ecosystem. "In order for application software companies to remain relevant and provide value to end users, they will need to implement GenAI capabilities which represents a potential catalyst for adoption and increased usage of Figma," D.A. Davidson analyst Gil Luria said in a note. Founded in 2012 and led by CEO Dylan Field, Figma provides cloud-based collaborative design tools, with a roster of marquee clients including Google, Microsoft, Netflix and Uber. Though the blockbuster performance is good news for the IPO market, particularly for high-growth tech listings, the sharp surge suggests Figma may have priced its IPO too conservatively, potentially leaving money on the table. Bankers typically target a first-day rise of 10% to 20% to balance strong demand with optimal fundraising.
Hindustan Times
44 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Is Bengaluru's luxury housing market softening amid job losses and economic uncertainty? Experts weigh in
Once considered immune to demand swings, Bengaluru's luxury housing market is showing signs of softening, buyers say. Amid rising white-collar job losses and economic uncertainty, some top developers are offering flexible payment schemes like 25:75 and upfront discounts, deals that were once rare in the ₹2.5 crore-and-above segment. Bengaluru's luxury housing market is showing signs of softening as developers offer 25:75 payment plans and discounts, a shift driven by job losses and uncertainty. (Picture for representational purposes only) (Pixabay) "Several developers are offering 25% upfront payment, the remaining 75% on possession. Were there similar kinds of offers 6 months ago as well? Why are they providing such enticing offers if 'all is well?' one of the buyers wrote on Reddit. This comes at a time when home sales in Bengaluru declined by 8% year-on-year in Q2 2025, dropping to 15,100 units from 16,350 a year ago, even as average property prices jumped 12%, according to ANAROCK data. "After a period marked by aggressive launches and record sales, developers are now exhibiting a more cautious and quality-focused approach. In Q2 2025, the emphasis has noticeably shifted to completing ongoing projects and refining delivery standards rather than aggressively adding to supply," Anuj Puri, chairman of ANAROCK Group, said. Also Read: TCS layoffs: Will job cuts in the tech sector trigger a real estate downturn in Bengaluru? Developers recalibrate strategies amid cautious sentiment Experts say that they are beginning to see some developers recalibrate their offerings, not in a drastic way, but enough to cater to a wider range of buyers. Some are shifting toward mid-premium segments to make homes more accessible. For example, Bengaluru-based Prestige Group is planning to shift focus to the mid-market housing segment in the ₹2 to ₹3 crore range to tap into growing demand from salaried homebuyers seeking quality homes in FY25. "The pivot this year is a conscious move towards mid-segment housing, which continues to see strong demand, especially in tech-driven cities like Bengaluru and Hyderabad,' Praveer Srivastava, senior vice president at Prestige Group, previously told According to Nomaan Ellahi, associate principal partner, Square Yards, this shift is not necessarily due to a collapse in demand. Instead, it's a response to changing buyer behaviour. 'Post-COVID, homebuyers, especially NRIs and HNIs, are looking for not just bigger homes, but better amenities. These are typically available only in projects priced ₹3 crore and above. However, in the last year or so, financial caution has increased, especially with worries of layoffs and tech sector stress.' Since early 2024, major global firms such as Intel, Microsoft, and Tesla have announced large-scale layoffs aimed at cutting costs and improving operational efficiency. Simultaneously, the rapid rise of automation and artificial intelligence is reshaping the IT employment landscape, shifting demand toward specialised skills in emerging technologies. While this transition is opening up new job avenues in advanced tech sectors, experts note that it has also led to a slowdown in hiring for conventional IT roles. Recently, Tata Consultancy Services (TCS) announced plans to trim its workforce by 2% in the 2026 financial year, translating to over 12,000 job cuts. Experts warned that this could mark the beginning of a broader shift, particularly in tech-driven housing hubs like Bengaluru. Longer decision-making cycle slows luxury momentum Vivek Rathi, head of research at Knight Frank India, noted that the decision-making cycle for homebuyers in the premium segment has grown significantly longer. 'Wealth creation has slowed amid financial insecurities driven by the global slowdown, and that affects homebuying confidence. Buyers today are more deliberate; they want to explore all available options, negotiate better deals, and find the 'right' product before closing.' Even with robust sales momentum over the past 2–3 years, inventory levels have built up. 'It now takes about 2 to 2.5 years to absorb available inventory in many areas,' Rathi said. 'It's not a broad-based supply-demand mismatch, but in pockets like the IT corridor, oversupply and aggressive pricing, particularly from Grade A developers, are creating hurdles.' Also Read: Will Bengaluru real estate market be impacted as tech layoffs impact tenants and buyers? Experts weigh in Tech corridors in Bengaluru are feeling the heat Experts said Whitefield, once a star performer in the city's luxury real estate landscape, is a case in point. 'In some cases, Grade A developers are pricing homes ₹1,000 per sq ft above the market average,' said Ellahi. 'When inventory runs into the thousands, such pricing becomes difficult to sustain. Experts pointed out last year that several Grade A developers launched projects in Whitefield and the southern IT corridor of Electronic City. "However, sales momentum in Whitefield was slow, likely due to pricing being on the higher side. That may be one reason why many developers are now expected to focus more on the mid-segment going forward. Still, the luxury segment remains important, offering developers both higher margins and a way to elevate their brand positioning," Ellahi said. In contrast, experts point out prime locations like Indiranagar, Koramangala, and HSR Layout, which have seen consistent luxury demand. "Most developers launching projects in such areas opt for limited units, making the offerings more exclusive and premium, often priced in the ₹2–4 crore range. Beyond ₹4 crore, we're seeing significant traction from HNIs, NRIs, and even buyers from other parts of Karnataka, including neighbouring states like Telangana," Ellahi said. Mid-segment remains the sweet spot, but supply is thin Experts agree that the ₹80 lakh to ₹1.5 crore price band remains the most resilient. 'This bracket is driven by salaried professionals with ₹10–15 lakh annual CTCs,' Ellahi said. 'The issue is that there isn't enough quality supply in this segment, and it's forcing some buyers to either wait or stretch their budgets into higher-risk territory.' Luxury still key for branding, backed by GCC demand Despite current headwinds, developers are unlikely to abandon the luxury segment altogether, experts say. Luxury helps build brand visibility and attracts marquee buyers, they said. 'Moreover, demand from Global Capability Centres (GCCs), which are steadily expanding their footprint in Bengaluru, is offering a cushion against declining IT-led demand.' He said that while IT job insecurity has slowed certain market segments, GCCs are showing long-term commitment to real estate. Their need for housing is helping maintain a base level of demand in key luxury corridors. "If you look at the ₹3 crore home buyer segment, we're essentially talking about households with at least ₹50 lakh in annual income. There are people in Bengaluru who meet this benchmark," Rathi said. He pointed out that much of the demand in this segment is upgrade-driven, people who are looking to move into better homes. "Another important point is that buyers now have access to other income sources like equity investments, which serve as a support system and are currently not under too much stress.
Economic Times
44 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Delta Air assures US lawmakers it will not personalize fares using AI
AP FILE - A man waits for a Delta Airlines flight at Hartsfield-Jackson International Airport in Atlanta on Jan. 7, 2022. Delta Air Lines said on Friday it will not use artificial intelligence to set personalized ticket prices for passengers after facing sharp criticism from U.S. lawmakers and broad public concern. Last week, Democratic Senators Ruben Gallego, Mark Warner and Richard Blumenthal said they believed the Atlanta-based airline would use AI to set individual prices, which would "likely mean fare price increases up to each individual consumer's personal 'pain point.'" Delta said it has not used AI to set personalized prices but previously said it plans to deploy AI-based revenue management technology across 20% of its domestic network by the end of 2025 in partnership with Fetcherr, an AI pricing company. "There is no fare product Delta has ever used, is testing or plans to use that targets customers with individualized prices based on personal data," Delta told the senators in a letter on Friday, seen by Reuters. "Our ticket pricing never takes into account personal data." Senators praised Delta's commitment not to use AI for personal pricing but expressed many questions and want more details about what data Delta is collecting to set prices. "Delta is telling their investors one thing, and then turning around and telling the public another," Gallego said. "If Delta is in fact using aggregated instead of individualized data, that is welcome news." Delta declined comment on Gallego's statement. The senators cited a comment in December by Delta President Glen Hauenstein that the carrier's AI price-setting technology is capable of setting fares based on a prediction of "the amount people are willing to pay for the premium products related to the base fares." Last week, American Airlines CEO Robert Isom said using AI to set ticket prices could hurt consumer trust. "This is not about bait and switch. This is not about tricking," Isom said on an earnings call, adding "talk about using AI in that way, I don't think it's appropriate. And certainly from American, it's not something we will do." Democratic lawmakers Greg Casar and Rashida Tlaib last week introduced legislation to bar companies from using AI to set prices or wages based on Americans' personal data and would specifically ban airlines raising individual prices after seeing a search for a family obituary. They cited a Federal Trade Commission staff report in January that found "retailers frequently use people's personal information to set targeted, tailored prices for goods and services -- from a person's location and demographics, down to their mouse movements on a webpage." The FTC cited a hypothetical example of a consumer profiled as a new parent who could intentionally be shown higher-priced baby thermometers and collect behavioral details to forecast a customer's state of mind. Delta said airlines have used dynamic pricing for more than three decades, in which pricing fluctuates based on a variety of factors like overall customer demand, fuel prices and competition, but not a specific consumer's personal information. "Given the tens of millions of fares and hundreds of thousands of routes for sale at any given time, the use of new technology like AI promises to streamline the process by which we analyze existing data and the speed and scale at which we can respond to changing market dynamics," Delta's letter said. (Join our ETNRI WhatsApp channel for all the latest updates) Elevate your knowledge and leadership skills at a cost cheaper than your daily tea. Jane St: How an options trader smelt a rat when others raised a toast TCS job cuts may not stop at 12,000; its bench policy threatens more Unlisted dreams, listed disappointments? NSDL's IPO leaves pre-IPO investors riled. Regulators promote exchanges; can they stifle one? Watch IEX Did Meesho's Valmo really deliver a knockout punch to e-commerce logistics? Sebi's settlement with market intermediaries: More mystery than transparency? Trump tantrum: Check the Indian pulse of your portfolio. 71 stocks from 5 sectors for whom Trump may not even be noise F&O Radar| Deploy Short Strangle in Nifty to gain from Theta decay Stock Radar: PI Industries stock showing signs of momentum; takes support above 50-DEMA – time to buy?
