Deadly George building collapse was 'entirely preventable': Macpherson
Public works and infrastructure minister Dean Macpherson, who released the findings of investigative reports into the building collapse following a meeting with families on Saturday, said the results were "serious, far-reaching and in many respects alarming".
He said he would introduce a number of legislative reforms, including modernising regulations to avoid future tragedies and establishing a hotline for construction stakeholders to report safety concerns.
Macpherson called for a police investigation into those criminally responsible for the tragedy. He said the Council for the Built Environment report found eight major faults:
Serious safety concerns were raised well before the collapse as workers noticed cracks in columns, strange vibrations in the slab, and even visible holes through the walls in the basement as early as 2023;
Despite these warning signs, site managers reportedly instructed workers to patch the damage with sand and mortar, rather than halting construction and escalating the matter for formal investigation;
concrete used in the slabs did not meet required specifications and this was a basic material failure;
The so-called 'competent person' responsible for the structural system did not have the necessary competency requirements to oversee a project of this complexity (a five-storey building);
The geotechnical study of the site, critical in determining soil stability and groundwater conditions, was not only incomplete, but grossly deficient with key tests and geological mappings being missing;
The Health and Safety Agent appointed to monitor site compliance resigned midway through the project saying they could no longer ensure safe working conditions. This was not reported to any of the relevant authorities which would halted construction;
There was a lack of coordination between regulatory authorities including planning departments, NHBRC inspectors, DPWI professionals, and labour officials; and
The National Building Regulations and Building Standards Act which was last meaningfully amended in 1996 is outdated.
Parallel to this investigation, the Engineering Council of South Africa (ECSA) investigated the culpability of the engineer involved in the construction project.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald
3 days ago
- The Herald
IDT CEO Tebogo Malaka placed on suspension over R800m oxygen tender
The board of trustees of the Independent Development Trust (IDT) has placed its CEO Tebogo Malaka on precautionary suspension with immediate effect. The decision on Friday follows the board's receipt and consideration of a final forensic report this week relating to procurement irregularities in the R800m pressure swing adsorption (PSA) oxygen plant tender. The investigation, ordered by public works and infrastructure minister Dean Macpherson, recommended disciplinary action against Malaka, general manager for supply chain management Dr Molebedi Sisi and other officials. The IDT said its precautionary suspension was aligned with internal policies and the Labour Relations Act and was instituted to allow for an independent and unhindered investigation into the serious matters raised. 'The board emphasises this is not a disciplinary sanction. Ms Malaka remains an employee of the organisation and has not been found guilty of any misconduct.' To ensure continuity and organisational stability, the board asked Macpherson to second a senior official to serve as acting CEO. The minister seconded Carmen-Joy Abrahams to the role with immediate effect. TimesLIVE
IOL News
4 days ago
- IOL News
ActionSA seeks parliamentary investigation into DA MP Macpherson's comments
ActionSA MP Alan Beesley calls for action against Public Works and Infrastructure Minister Dean Macpherson for allegedly making racist remarks against their supporters. Image: National Assembly Archives ActionSA says it has approached Parliament to investigate DA's KwaZulu-Natal chairperson, Dean Macpherson, for denigrating its supporters as 'pharas', the phrase used to refer to worthless or drug-addicted people. In a statement issued on Thursday, ActionSA MP Alan Beesley said his party wrote to the Joint Committee on Ethics and Members' Interests requesting an investigation into Macpherson in his capacity as the DA MP and Public Works and Infrastructure Minister. Macpherson referred to ActionSA supporters as pharas outside the Pietermaritzburg High Court on July 24 during the hearing of legal action, which the DA and ActionSA jointly launched against eThekwini Municipality's failure to address the city's sewerage problems. This reporter has a video of Macpherson addressing DA members in the presence of their provincial leader, Francois Rodgers. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Next Stay Close ✕ During an interview with this reporter, Macpherson repeated the same word, which translates to hobos. Pharas is a shortened version of the Zulu word amaphara, which means hobos, street beggars, and drug addicts. 'These terms, directed at a group of predominantly black ActionSA supporters, are not only deeply offensive but, in the context of our country's painful history, cannot be divorced from their racially charged and dehumanising connotations,' said Beesley. He said it was unethical for Macpherson, as DA's senior leader, MP, and minister, to 'resort to such racist and inflammatory rhetoric'. 'This kind of conduct is fundamentally incompatible with the values enshrined in the Constitution and the responsibilities of elected public officials. 'Despite ActionSA's public call on 28 July 2025 for an immediate apology, Minister Macpherson has refused to retract his remarks or offer any sign of remorse for the harm caused,' said Beesley. In the video, Macpherson is heard saying: 'There is a smallanyana (little) party, (referring to ActionSA), they just brought up some people and we don't know who they are since they are paras, they gave them some green T-shirts. 'When you asked which party (they belong to), they said 'angazi' (I don't know), 'I am just here for one meal and one drink', and they were here for just singing and dancing.' Beesley called for the Ethics Committee to act against Macpherson to preserve Parliament's dignity, 'but more importantly, to affirm the fight against racism in South Africa'. 'We have therefore called on the Ethics Committee to take decisive action against this errant minister and at the very least ensure that he issues a written public apology to ActionSA supporters and to the people of South Africa at large,' he said. The animosity between the two parties was laid bare outside the court, where their supporters were there to support the court action. The DA supporters who carried placards picketed against the eThekwini Municipality as their party had been granted the right to do so. The ActionSA's provincial leader, Zwakele Mncwango, alleged that Macpherson had approached the police to disperse his party members because their party had not applied for picketing. Mncwango said ActionSA members were not picketing when they were approached by police, adding that police stopped removing ActionSA supporters after he and Rodgers intervened. In response to questions sent by this reporter, Macpherson described ActionSA as 'nothing other than an attention-seeking organisation with dubious motives'. He said ActionSA seemed to be always working on distracting him whenever he fights corruption, for reasons he did not understand. 'It was in January of this year that they called for me to be suspended after they tried to push claims that I bribed journalists in relation to the exposes being written about the IDT (Independent Development Trust), and now they come up with bogus claims of racism, just as we have concluded the investigation into IDT. 'Their agenda is very clear: to attack and discredit me so that I back off investigating corruption and maladministration in the department,' said Macpherson.
The Citizen
6 days ago
- The Citizen
IDT CEO, officials must face disciplinary action over R800m tender
DPWI minister confirms providing the Hawks with a forensic investigation report to supplement their criminal investigation. A forensic investigation report into the allegedly irregular and corrupt R880 million hospital oxygen plant tender managed by the Independent Development Trust (IDT) has recommended that disciplinary action be taken against IDT CEO Tebogo Malaka, IDT general manager for supply chain management Dr Molebedi Sisi, and other officials. On Tuesday Minister of Public Works and Infrastructure Dean Macpherson said the PwC report did not identify any relationship and/or links between the appointed contractors and the IDT or Department of Health (DoH) officials. But Macpherson believed the murkiness surrounding particularly Bulkeng, one of the preferred service providers, would 'have been a red flag right at the beginning'. He added that the department can only work off the evidence provided to it, but if any evidence came forward to suggest something else, they would also look into it. Macpherson said he took a number of actions to ensure consequence management and accountability, including writing to the Hawks and providing them with the report to supplement their current criminal investigation into this matter. '…where criminal allegations exist, I want to ensure the highest chances of success,' he said. ALSO READ: Fake licence and ballooned budget: PwC report places IDT seniors at centre of R800m oxygen tender Macpherson said he had also briefed the minister of health and the newly constituted IDT board on the contents of the report. He stressed that 'accountability must follow and will follow' and the disciplinary process going forward is for the new IDT board to determine. 'South Africans deserve to know how their money was spent – and misused. 'We are not just reacting to this scandal. We are using it as an opportunity to get things right in our entities and department. 'Public Works and Infrastructure has immense potential to be a force for good in South Africa. That's why we must use every opportunity to better our systems and to build towards this goal,' he said. Macpherson quoted directly from a section of the forensic report, which he said 'lays bare the depth of the procedural failings and regulatory breaches uncovered during the investigation.' ALSO READ: Zikalala slams 'spurious' allegations about R45m IDT lease deal, heads to Public Protector Report findings The report found Malaka failed to exercise oversight and confirmed she relied entirely on internal supply chain management (SCM) staff to assure her that the process had followed proper procurement protocol. It further found that Malaka did not verify any of the documentation, act on the red flags raised by the DoH or convene the necessary risk committees to assess the matter. Macpherson said Malaka did not act alone: the report also singles out Sisi for his role in misleading internal stakeholders and failing to act in accordance with his responsibilities. The report found Sisi advised against cancelling the request for quotation (RFQ) process, despite clear warnings from the DoH. It further found that Sisi assured Malaka and evaluation committees that the procurement process was compliant, when in fact key regulatory requirements, such as valid South African Health Products Regulatory Authority (SAHPRA) licences, had not been enforced. 'Instead, both the CEO and Dr Sisi approved contracts and accepted flawed internal assurances,' Macpherson said. ALSO READ: Profits on R1.6 billion tenders to be repaid, orders tribunal The report said it therefore appears the IDT appointed eight service providers on the panel for the roll-out of the plants without confirming that any of them met the required criteria, adding that a SAHPRA licence was again not included as a mandatory requirement in the RFQ document. It said Sisi reported that there was an inherent requirement that the original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) be SAHPRA registered and bidders were not specifically requested to supply evidence that they were SAHPRA registered, as the equipment was to be procured from the SAHPRA-registered OEMs. The report said Bulkeng, as one of the preferred service providers, did not have the required authorisation to use Atlas Copco's SAHPRA licence and the use of it in Bulkeng's submission to the IDT appears to be irregular. It said the SAHPRA criteria should have been included from the establishment of the panel of service providers and the entire process therefore appears to be irregular. The report said the pre-tender estimate for the project at tender stage was R216 959 849.70 and at design stage R253 317 911.83. It said the DoH was subsequently requested to approve increased funding for the roll out and implementation of the oxygen plants to R592 564 686.66, with the project cost therefore increasing when the market was tested by 174% from the initial estimated budget of R216 006 750. ALSO READ: Macpherson says urgency of court challenge against him 'self-created' According to the report, Bulkeng was awarded facilities with a total offer of R428 069 345.04, which exceeded its Construction Industry Development Board (CIDB) grading threshold of R200 million. Macpherson said this means Bulkeng did not qualify at all to be awarded that project. The report further highlighted that the minutes of meetings of the Bid Specification Committee, Bid Evaluation Committee, Management Bid Adjudication Committee and Executive Bid Adjudication Committee are very vague and contain limited information relating to the items discussed during these meetings. Further, the submission documents that were presented often contained incorrect and incomplete information, such as the correct dates of meetings, and record-keeping of these minutes was poor, as none of the meeting recordings could be obtained. ALSO READ: Public works to investigate entity over R800m oxygen plant tender 'A monumental failure in governance' Macpherson said these findings represent 'a monumental failure in governance and adherence to IDT and IDT policies and National Treasury regulations – undermining the integrity of public procurement and threatening donor funds'. He said the SAHPRA compliance requirement originally stipulated in the project execution plan and the DoH's MoA was deliberately removed from the final request for proposals. 'This opened the door for ineligible bidders to participate and win massive contracts. 'Meeting minutes were missing or incomplete – which is shocking but not surprising. 'Committee appointments were not properly constituted. Bid scores were not properly documented. Price negotiations were not transparent,' said Macpherson. He said Bulkeng's CIDB grading limited it to contracts of no more than R200 million and yet the IDT awarded it contracts worth R428 million. Macpherson said only R13.5 million was paid out for the project, which means the IDT is technically short of this amount. He said the PwC forensic report cost R1.9 million. This article was republished from Moneyweb. Read the original here.
