Boeing paying $1.1B as DOJ dismisses criminal fraud case; families of victims in crashes set to object to deal
Clifford Law Offices said in a news release that the DOJ sent a letter to families on Thursday, informing them the government agency had filed a motion to dismiss the criminal fraud matter against Boeing.
Instead, the DOJ said it filed a non-prosecution agreement (NPA) against Boeing regarding two 737 MAX8 planes that crashed six years ago and killed 346 people.
The DOJ sent the letter as part of the federal Crime Victims' Rights Act, which requires them to inform crime victims of their actions.
Justice Department Strikes Tentative Deal Allowing Boeing To Escape Criminal Charges In Fatal 737 Max Crashes
Pro bono lawyer Paul Cassell, who also works as a professor at the S.J. Quinney College of Law at the University of Utah, represents several families of victims, and they have advised U.S. District Court Judge Reed O'Connor about their intentions to object to the DOJ's motion.
Read On The Fox Business App
The families were informed nearly a week after the DOJ said it had struck a tentative deal with Boeing that allows the company to avoid criminal prosecution for allegedly misleading regulators about the company's 737 Max plane before two crashes that killed 346 people.
Under the deal, Boeing will pay out $1.1 billion, including $445 million to a fund for the crash victims' families, the DOJ said in court documents last week.
Dc Plane Crash: Victim's Family Seeks $250 Million In First Legal Action Since Deadly Collision
In exchange, the DOJ will dismiss a fraud charge against the aircraft manufacturer.
The DOJ did not immediately respond to FOX Business' request for comment on the matter.
The news release noted that the families had been asking for a meeting with U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi since Feb. 6, with hopes of meeting before a final decision was made. The law firm said the families had never heard back, as of Thursday.
"Boeing must continue to improve the effectiveness of its anti-fraud compliance and ethics program and retain an independent compliance consultant," the department said last week. "We are confident that this resolution is the most just outcome with practical benefits."
Dc Plane Crash: Airport Employees Arrested Over Leaked Video Of Midair Collision
Last year, Boeing agreed to plead guilty to a criminal fraud conspiracy charge after two fatal 737 Max crashes in Indonesia and Ethiopia in 2018 and 2019. The company previously agreed to pay a fine of up to $487.2 million and face three years of independent oversight.
The deal announced last Friday did not go over well with relatives of those killed in the crashes.
"This kind of non-prosecution deal is unprecedented and obviously wrong for the deadliest corporate crime in U.S. history. My families will object and hope to convince the court to reject it," Cassell said.
Boeing has faced increased scrutiny from the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) since January 2024, when a new Max 9 missing four key bolts had a midair emergency, losing a door plug, Reuters reported. The FAA has capped production at 38 planes per month.
Last year, the DOJ found Boeing had violated a 2021 agreement that shielded the plane-maker from prosecution.
FOX Business' Louis Casiano contributed to this report.Original article source: Boeing paying $1.1B as DOJ dismisses criminal fraud case; families of victims in crashes set to object to deal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Washington Post
21 minutes ago
- Washington Post
Fired prosecutor who handled Capitol riot cases sues government
A prosecutor who handled some of the most high-profile cases against Jan. 6, 2021 rioters is suing the government over his dismissal last month, arguing that the decision was politically motivated. Former assistant U.S. attorney Michael Gordon is one of dozens of federal prosecutors the Justice Department has fired since President Donald Trump returned to office, despite such measures generally only being used in cases of misconduct, as The Washington Post reported last month. On Thursday, Gordon and two other former DOJ employees — Patricia A. Hartman, who was a public affairs specialist in the U.S. attorney's office for the District of Columbia, and Joseph W. Tirrell, who led the department's ethics office — filed a lawsuit Thursday over their terminations, which they said disregarded 'long-standing statutory and regulatory protections that govern how and when members of the civil service can be terminated, and the limits thereof.' They said they were informed of their removal from their posts in a one-page letter from Attorney General Pam Bondi, without being offered any 'cause, let alone a proper merit-based one, or required due process.' The attorney general, the lawsuit argues, 'does not have absolute authority to simply remove DOJ employees,' who are protected from being arbitrarily or unlawfully dismissed. 'Our justice system depends on the independence of prosecutors and civil service employees at the Department of Justice who enforce the law without fear, favor, or political pressure,' Abbe David Lowell, one of the attorneys representing the plaintiffs, said in an emailed statement Friday. 'When that independence is compromised, justice itself is at risk. This case is about protecting the integrity of our legal system. The DOJ employees at the center of this case served with distinction, followed the law, not politics, and were fired for it.' The DOJ did not immediately respond to an overnight request for comment. Gordon, who worked as an assistant U.S. attorney in the DOJ's Tampa office, consistently received 'Outstanding' performance ratings since he joined the office 8½ years ago, and received another top rating two days before he was fired in late June, according to the lawsuit. He also spent two years prosecuting some of the most high-profile Capitol riot cases, including Richard 'Bigo' Barnett, who was photographed lounging at a desk in the office of then-Speaker Nancy Pelosi; Eric Munchel, who was pictured inside the Capitol with plastic handcuffs; and Rebecca Lavrenz, who became known on social media as the 'J6 Praying Grandma.' Within the first hours of his second term, Trump issued a sweeping pardon to almost all of those convicted over the Capitol riot and commuted the sentences of the remaining 14. Trump also appointed Ed Martin, a lawyer who represented Jan. 6 defendants and helped organize the 'Stop the Steal' movement after Trump lost the 2020 election, as interim D.C. U.S. attorney — though he later withdrew the nomination. Gordon told The Post earlier this month that he was preparing a witness for trial shortly before 5 p.m. on a Friday when he was given the paper that said he was being let go without explanation — but said he knew the decision was related to his work on the Jan. 6 cases. 'What's shocking is that the Department of Justice — the part of the government that's supposed to uphold the law — is instead openly defying it, openly thumbing its nose at the very laws that it's supposed to enforce,' he said at the time. 'They're prioritizing revenge over public safety.' Two other assistant U.S. attorneys involved in prosecuting Jan. 6 cases were fired the same day, according to the lawsuit. Rep. Kathy Castor (D-Florida) wrote a letter to Bondi earlier this month, saying that the 'timing and circumstances of Mr. Gordon's termination raise serious concerns about political retribution.' The decision could also 'derail justice for victims' of a case Gordon was prosecuting at the time of his dismissal, which Castor described as 'one of the largest fraud schemes in Florida's recent history.' When he was fired, Gordon was the counsel of record in 17 federal cases and involved in 20 ongoing investigations and at least six trials set to take place between July and September, the case argued. Hartman, the public affairs specialist, spent almost two decades at the DOJ, and had also consistently received positive performance reviews before her dismissal in July, according to the lawsuit. She was 'the primary official' working on public affairs related to the Jan. 6, 2021 prosecutions, the lawsuit said, including handling media inquiries and issuing press releases. Tirrell, the senior ethics attorney, was also dismissed in July, after more than seven years as 'an exemplary employee' with the DOJ, the lawsuit said. He previously worked in the FBI for over a decade and also served as a naval officer for more than six years. Tirrell wrote on LinkedIn after his dismissal earlier this month that the oaths he took as a public servant 'did not come with the caveat that I need only support the Constitution when it is easy or convenient.' The lawsuit said that the plaintiffs would normally be able to turn to the Merit Systems Protection Board, which allows federal employees to appeal against suspensions and terminations. However, the lawsuit noted that Trump's firing of the MSPB's head meant the body lacks quorum and that any complaint with the MSPB would be 'futile.'
Forbes
21 minutes ago
- Forbes
This Is The Most Corrupt Place In America
Young woman holding a poster against corruption. Human rights and democracy concept. When people think about government corruption they often think of authoritarian countries like Russia, Venezuela, or North Korea. While these and other countries run by autocrats have high levels of corruption, democracies like the United States are not completely pure. In a recent analysis, Chris Edwards of the Cato Institute examines corruption in the United States by federal judicial district. He finds that Washington D.C. is the most corrupt place in the country, followed by the Eastern District of Louisiana, where New Orleans is located. Government corruption of any magnitude is a problem. It erodes citizens' trust in government and fosters animosity between voters and public officials. To measure the level of government corruption in America, Edwards' examines Department of Justice data on public corruption convictions across the country's 94 federal judicial districts. The top ten districts ranked by the average annual number of convictions from 2004 to 2023 are in the table below. As mentioned previously, the nation's capital tops the list, and three U.S. territories are in the top five. In the contiguous United States, districts in Montana, Oklahoma, Kentucky, South Dakota, and Tennessee share Eastern Louisiana's proclivity for corruption. The least corrupt areas, which are not shown in the table, are the state of New Hampshire and the Middle District of North Carolina, where Greensboro is located. Both have annual conviction rates of only 0.05. Top 10 federal judicial districts ranked by conviction rate. In addition to eroding trust in government, corruption has adverse effects on economic activity. One study that looks at country-level corruption finds that a 1% increase in the level of corruption reduces the rate of economic growth by 0.72%. The authors attribute most of the negative impact corruption has on growth to the political instability corruption causes, which generates uncertainty for businesses. Another study finds that countries with more corruption receive less foreign direct investment and experience higher inflation, both of which reduce growth. There is evidence that corruption reduces economic growth in America, too. One study finds that more state-level corruption reduces investment and the growth of output per worker. Another study finds that states with more corruption convictions from 1976 to 1980 experienced slower income growth over the next 20 years. This study also finds that states with more educated populations are less corrupt on average. To explain this finding, the authors suggest that educated voters are more inclined and better able to monitor public officials which reduces opportunities for corruption. Closer inspection of the economic data in places with the most corruption reveals these adverse economic effects. Take Louisiana and Illinois: Both states have reputations for being corrupt that are supported by the convictions data and recent stories. In Louisiana, federal officials recently arrested and indicted several former Louisiana law enforcement officials and businessmen allegedly involved in a U-visa scam. In Illinois, the corruption case around former Illinois House Speaker Michael Madigan is still playing out. A former CEO of Illinois utility company ComEd was sentenced just this week. In addition to high levels of corruption, both Illinois and Louisiana had personal income growth below the national average over the last year according to the most recent data from the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA). Income growth was 5.4% in Illinois, 5.9% in Louisiana, and 6.7% for the entire country. In the two states with the least corruption, New Hampshire and Utah, income growth was 6.6% and 7.2%, respectively. These are just a few observations, of course, but they are consistent with the studies discussed earlier. While government corruption in the United States is far below the levels of autocratic countries, it is still a problem that needs to be addressed. There are plenty of ideas, including strengthening the Inspectors General who oversee audits and investigations in government agencies; better enforcement of anti-corruption laws already on the books; more investigative journalism to uncover corruption; and greater protection and rewards for whistleblowers that reveal corruption. None of these are a silver bullet, but in combination they would help reduce corruption. Voters should also emphasize character when evaluating political candidates to reduce the number of dishonest people elected to office. Monitoring public corruption is important since we cannot address a problem we do not know about. The Cato Institute analysis is a reminder that public corruption is alive and well in America. Reducing it will improve local economies and cultivate more trust between voters and elected officials.
Yahoo
22 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Ghislaine Maxwell answered every question from DOJ officials, lawyer says
Ghislaine Maxwell answered every single question put to her by Department of Justice officials, her attorney has said. David Oscar Markus briefly spoke to reporters outside a Florida courthouse after the disgraced British socialite was grilled during a meeting with federal Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche on Thursday. Markus did not take questions, but said Maxwell 'never declined to answer' and did not invoke any privilege during the meeting. Prior to the meeting he said the team was looking forward to a 'productive day.' Blanche did not address media following the meeting. The Deputy Attorney General later posted on X saying: 'Today, I met with Ghislaine Maxwell, and I will continue my interview of her tomorrow. The Department of Justice will share additional information about what we learned at the appropriate time.' Maxwell, Jeffrey Epstein's former girlfriend, met with Blanche at the U.S. Attorney General's office, which is located inside Tallahassee's federal courthouse, in Florida. Maxwell is currently being held at the Florida Correctional Institution-Tallahassee, where she is serving a 20-year sentence for her role in a scheme to abuse minors. Blanche had announced Tuesday that he had contacted Maxwell's attorneys to pursue any potential new leads as Trump's MAGA base continues to blast the administration over its handling of the so-called 'Epstein Files.' But that announcement caused a stir among Democrats, with Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer writing on X: 'Under no circumstances should anyone from Trump's DOJ be allowed to privately interview Ghislaine Maxwell. 'The conflict of interest is glaring. It stinks of high corruption.' Maxwell, 63, was sentenced to 20 years prison in 2021 for her role in a scheme to sexually exploit and abuse multiple girls with Epstein and is serving time at the federal prison. Her attorneys have taken an appeal of her conviction to the Supreme Court. Her meeting with Blanche comes after the Wall Street Journal reported President Donald Trump had been told in May by Attorney General Pam Bondi that his name appeared in the Epstein Files 'multiple times'. The president denied such claims to reporters earlier this month. Appearing in the files does not indicate an individual has committed any wrongdoing and Trump has not been accused of misconduct in connection with the Epstein case. 'This is another fake news story, just like the previous story by The Wall Street Journal,' White House communications director Steven Cheung told the outlet about the claims Trump was named in the files. Solve the daily Crossword
