Young woman's strip search akin to 'sexual assault', court told
WARNING: This article contains graphic content.
Last month, the state of NSW made a dramatic backflip in the case, admitting police acted unlawfully when they searched Raya Meredith at the Splendour In The Grass music festival, ordering her to bend over while naked and remove a tampon.
Her barrister Kylie Nomchong SC on Monday told the hearing her client would be making an additional claim for aggravated damages due to feelings of "hurt and distress" caused by police previously denying her account for more than two years.
Kylie Nomchong SC said Raya Meredith was searched based on a drug dog sniffing in her direction.
(
AAP: Regi Varghese
)
Ms Nomchong told the court her client was subjected to "assault, battery and false imprisonment" during the search, and the only basis for it had been a drug dog "sniffing in [Ms Meredith's] direction".
She said police did not follow the statutory safeguards that NSW parliament had put in place around strip searches.
"She was not asked for her consent, she was questioned during the search, the search was not done in private," Ms Nomchong said.
"She was asked to strip, expose all parts of her body, drop her breasts, bend over and expose her anus and vagina.
"We say these things are akin to things that would happen during a sexual assault."
'Not an isolated' incident
Ms Nomchong said that when Ms Meredith was following commands to bend over, "a male police officer walked into the cubicle unannounced and observed the plaintiff in this position".
No drugs were found during the search and Ms Nomchong said Ms Meredith was left traumatised.
She outlined the broader ramifications of the class action, which is believed to be one of the biggest ever brought against NSW Police.
"This is an extraordinary story, but it is not an isolated one,"
she said.
"There were many thousands of persons strip searched at festivals in the claim period," she said.
Photo shows
A photo of a man with a beard.
New data obtained by the ABC has found First Nations and diverse communities were disproportionately represented in New South Wales police searches between 2020 and 2023.
Ms Nomchong said the state of NSW had failed to adequately train officers on strict rules that surround strip searches, and then deployed large numbers of police to music festivals between 2016 and 2022 knowing and expecting a large number of searches would be conducted.
She said the parliament had made it clear strip searches were only supposed to be used "in the most extreme of circumstances" but that was not the way they were being executed by NSW Police.
"We say there was a pattern of conduct of NSW Police carrying out strip searches at music festivals as a matter of routine," she said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
13 hours ago
- Perth Now
Jailed Perth Grandmother prepares for appeal in Tokyo court
Perth grandmother Donna Nelson is preparing to appear in the Tokyo High Court on Thursday hoping to appeal her drug smuggling conviction. It is understood the brief hearing will allow the court to decide on what evidence can be used at Nelson's appeal, and if the appeal is even allowed to proceed. It follows her conviction at trial in Japan last December which saw the 59-year-old sentenced to six years behind bars under difficult conditions in Japanese prison. 'It hit us all very hard, because we were so confident that she would be coming home, and we just thought it's so obvious that she wasn't aware of what was going on and she shouldn't be where she is,' said Kristal Hilaire, the eldest of Nelson's five daughters. Ms Hilaire was preparing to fly to Japan yet again this weekend to support her mother. Perth grandmother Donna Nelson was sentenced to six years jail in Japan. (HANDOUT/NELSON FAMILY) Credit: AAP The journey has become all too familiar for Nelson's family, who have visited as often as they can since her shock arrest at Narita International Airport in January 2023. Nelson was found with 2kg of methamphetamine concealed inside her suitcase. The Perth community leader and one-time Greens political candidate has always maintained her innocence, insisting she is the victim of a romance scam. At trial Nelson told a Japanese courtroom she had no idea the man she believed she was going to marry had hidden the drugs in the case. 'The nerves for Thursday are kicking (in), because there's a chance that they will say we are going to reject the appeal altogether,' Ms Hilaire said. 'We're hoping that some of the evidence her lawyers have been working on will be admitted, and there's a witness that they want to have admitted as well.' 'We're just crossing our fingers and really hoping that she gets the best chance at putting her full story out there and coming home.' A sketch of Donna Nelson on the first day of her drug smuggling trial. Credit: Yoshitaka Enomoto/7NEWS / Yoshitaka Enomoto/7NEWS If an appeal goes ahead, Nelson's legal team will push for an acquittal and, at the very least, a dramatic reduction in sentence. 'It's crazy that she's gotten through all this time if she didn't have a positive mindset, I feel like someone would lose their mind,' Ms Hilaire said. 'They don't get things like TV or anything like that. They're just alone in their own presence for 23 and a half hours a day. 'Once every three days, they can have a shower if it's not a weekend or public holiday.' Since her arrest Nelson has also not been allowed to make any phone calls, with communication to her family limited to very short, restricted prison visits if they are in Japan. Otherwise, she has been allowed to write letters. 'She would be allowed to have five small pages once a week,' Ms Hilaire said. 'With five daughters and the three grandkids, it's not even a page for each person. 'And it takes like, three weeks for that letter to get to you, so you never really know how she was doing in real time.' Ahead of the hearing Nelson has been transferred to a detention facility in Tokyo, closer to the high court, which has no limit on letter-writing pages. It will make it easier to write home to her five children and three grandchildren, with a fourth grandchild on the way as her daughter Janelle Morgan is expecting in November. 'Mum will never tell us how hard it is to cope, but I know it would have been really, really hard for her to feel like she's not here throughout Janelle's pregnancy,' Ms Hilaire said. 'She's praying for a miracle, that she can be home for the birth of her next grandchild. 'It just makes her even more eager and desperate to get home.'
ABC News
20 hours ago
- ABC News
Man killed in police shooting in Townsville, north Queensland
A man has been killed in a police shooting in north Queensland. Officers were called to Mitchell Street in North Ward in Townsville just before 10am on Saturday. The ABC understands the man sustained gunshot wounds to his chest and legs. He died at the scene. No police officers were injured. A crime scene has been declared on Mitchell Street, between McKinley and Landsborough Streets. Police have urged members of the community to avoid the area, but said there is no further threat to the public.
Sydney Morning Herald
a day ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Jake and Callum Robinson: Mexican authorities say Perth brothers killed near beach known for drug-running
Loading Gerardo, also known as 'El Kekas', Angel Jesús and Ari Gisselle were all arrested soon after the alleged killings, while a fourth man – Irineo Francisco – was arrested some time later. Gerardo, Jesús and Francisco were charged with aggravated homicide, aggravated robbery, violent robbery, grand theft auto and forced disappearance. Gisselle was charged with the same offences, excluding forced disappearance. Gerardo and Francisco both appeared via video link from the 'El Hongo' prison, while Gisselle and Jesús appeared in person in court on Thursday. Gisselle and Jesús were manacled together at the ankles. The ABC reported that court documents revealed Gerardo and Francisco's alleged links to the Sinaloa cartel were behind their transfer to a prison branded as being among the world's toughest. Jesus Gerardo, known as El Kekas. Credit: The men have different attorneys, but two failed to appear in court, leading to the rescheduling of the pre-trial hearing to later this month. Gerardo's attorney requested to join all the charges together on the same indictment to streamline further court processes. The outcome of the request will be determined at the pre-trial hearing on July 25. It is understood there have been difficulties in determining and agreeing on the facts of the case, and that Gisselle, Jesús and Francisco could have their charges changed to exclude aggravated homicide. All four will remain in prison until the next hearing. The Robinson family made no statement about the proceedings other than thanking followers on Instagram for their support. A Mexican not-for-profit aimed at combating corruption said it was important to see justice where '99 per cent of murders never see the light'. It said nearly two-thirds of Mexican people had lost trust in the local justice system, and 77 per cent of Mexicans believed crime was often only prioritised when it was subject to media or political pressure. Human rights organisations have said previously that many victims of crime in Mexico are predominantly Mexicans, with cartels avoiding targeting tourists due to the potential of attracting attention. A demonstrator's bodyboard reads in Spanish 'No more violence' during protests at the death of the Robinson brothers and their American friend in Ensenada, Mexico, last year. Credit: AP The fourth body in the well where the bodies of the men were found was believed to be that of a farmer who recently lost control of the ranch to the Sinaloa cartel. Authorities have previously said the men's deaths were not connected to cartel violence, and were instead petty theft gone wrong. The Tijuana Cartel, Cártel de Jalisco Nueva Generación, and Sinaloa Cartel are warring at present for control of the region. Start the day with a summary of the day's most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights. Sign up for our Morning Edition newsletter. This story has been updated to more accurately reflect the sources of some information pertaining to the case.
