X, India spar over lawyer's ‘Tom, Dick, and Harry' remark for government officials
X has long been at loggerheads with Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government over content removal requests.
The remarks were made during a hearing on the U.S. firm's challenge to a government-run website it says is a 'censorship portal' that allows officials to issue content removal orders. New Delhi says the website is only to swiftly notify companies of their due diligence obligations.
India is a critical growth market for X owner Musk, who is getting closer to launching his other key ventures Starlink and Tesla in the country.
Top Indian court scraps JSW Steel's bid to acquire Bhushan Power, case lawyers say
During the court hearing, X's lawyer, K. G. Raghavan, said it recently received a notice from the railways department to remove a video in which a car was being driven on a railway track. That was news, but the government found it unlawful, he told the court.
'This is the danger, My Lord, that is done now, if every Tom, Dick, and Harry officer is authorised,' Raghavan told the high court in the southern state of Karnataka.
The phrase drew immediate condemnation from India's Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, who said 'officers are not Tom, Dick, or Harry … they are statutory functionaries'.
'No social media intermediary can expect completely unregulated functioning,' Mehta said.
India's IT ministry and X did not respond to Reuters queries.
In 2021, X, formerly called Twitter, was locked in a stand-off with the Indian government over non-compliance with legal orders to block certain tweets. It later complied, but is still locked in a court fight related to the move.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
30 minutes ago
- Business Recorder
A comment on Finance Act 2025—II
Disruption and distortion The tax regime introduced is a final tax regime. This means that such transactions which were earlier subject to normal tax are now going to be taxed at the aforesaid rates which will be final tax on such transactions. This change will create a big disruption and distortion and the whole business model may change if the business is switched to digital mode. A comment on Finance Act 2025—I This will improve documentation; however the final regime, which is creating distortion, is to be rolled back, over the time, when there is adequate documentation. Exclusion These new provisions will not apply to exports of goods (Section 154) and export of services (Section 154A), which will continue to be taxed under the present regime. Digital Presence Tax for Foreigners General For foreigners a new kind of tax under the name 'Digital Presence Proceeds Tax Act, 2025' has been introduced. This is a tax on proceeds of foreign vendors as are deemed to be attributable to Pakistani users based on their significant digital presence in Pakistan where: (i) The transaction is carried out through foreign online marketplace or e-store; (ii) They arise in connection with digitally ordered services and goods; and (iii) A Pakistani user is a party to the transaction. This tax applies to those cases where digital transactions are not covered under domestic digital transactions as referred above. This includes both goods and services. Rate The tax rate for collection for cross-border transactions of digitally ordered goods and services shall be as under. a. Services @ 5% of the payment including of advertisement on social media platforms b. Goods 5% of the payment made to foreign provider This tax therefore effectively relates to transactions undertaken by platforms like 'Amazon', 'Google' etc. Background and perspective The tax as imposed is a replica of the tax imposed in India. The present status in India is indicated below: The Indian Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman unveiled the change while introducing amendments to the 2025 Finance Bill in the lower house of parliament, which approved the tax measures in the budget. '(I) have proposed to remove (the) 6 percent equalisation levy for advertisements,' she told parliament. India's 6 percent equalisation levy, or digital tax, affects online advertising services provided by foreign companies, requiring them to withhold and remit the tax to the government. Last year, New Delhi abolished a levy of 2 percent on non-resident e-commerce firms for providing online services. This means that this taxation has been very strongly resisted by international companies, especially those in the USA. Special kind of presence in Pakistan This tax is levied on such services which are otherwise not taxable under normal regime as such digital presence is not treated as permanent establishment in Pakistan and even if it is so the activity is not considered to be attributable to Pakistan. In order to overcome that deficiency this specific law is introduced with a particular definition of digital presence which has been defined in the Act as under: Significant digital presence in Pakistan. – A foreign vendor shall have significant digital presence in Pakistan under this Act, where the foreign vendor supplies digitally ordered services and goods from outside Pakistan to any user in Pakistan, if the aggregate amount exceeds one million rupees in a financial year along with one of the following additional factors – (a) Existence of a user base and the associated data input; (b) Billing or collection in local currency or with a local form of payment; (c) Responsibility for the final delivery of goods and services to Pakistani consumers; (d) Responsibility for the provision by the foreign vendors of other support services (aftersales services, repairs and maintenance); and (d) Continued marketing and sales promotion activities, online or not, to attract customers. Collection and Payment of Tax Every payment intermediary including a banking company, financial institution, licensed exchange company or payment gateway responsible for making a payment in whole or part remitting outside Pakistan, to a foreign vendor for digitally ordered services or goods shall deduct tax from the gross amount paid. Definitions-Digital Tax for Foreigners 'digitally delivered services' means any service delivered over the internet or electronic networks, where the delivery is automated and required minimal or no human intervention including music, audio and video streaming services, cloud services, online software application services, services delivered through online inter-personal interaction i.e. tele-medicine, e-learning etc., online banking services, architectural design services, research and consultancy reports, accounting services in the form of digital files or any other online facility; (d) 'e-commerce' means sale or purchase of goods and services conducted over computer networks by methods specifically designed for the purpose of receiving or placing of orders either through websites, mobile applications or online marketplace having digital ordering features by using either mobile phones or automated computer-to-computer ordering system; (e) 'e-store' means the online platform including websites and software applications used to conduct e-commerce, which involves buying and selling goods or services including digital products, through electronic transactions over the internet or other computer networks; (f) 'online marketplace' means Online interfaces that facilitate, for a fee, the direct interaction between multiple buyers and multiple sellers for digital orders for supply of goods and services, without the platform taking economic ownership of the goods or rendering the services that are being sold; and (g) 'payment Intermediary' means any third part entity including a banking company, financial institution, a licensed foreign exchange company or payments gateway that facilitate the transfer of funds or payment instructions between two or more parties to enable, process, route or settle payments in a financial transaction, without being the ultimate source or recipient of the payment. Embargo/restriction on economic transactions The Finance Act, 2025 has for the first time laid down embargo/restrictions on certain economic transactions. Two kinds of transactions have been included: a. Those relating to acquisition of assets etc; b. Those relating to withdrawal from a bank account. (To be continued) Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
2 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Indian stocks muted as Reliance Industries offsets broader losses
MUMBAI: India's benchmark indexes ended flat on Tuesday, as gains in heavyweight Reliance Industries on solar business optimism offset broader sectoral losses, with investors awaiting cues from US trade talks. The Nifty 50 rose 0.1% to 25,541.80 points and the BSE Sensex added 0.11% to 83,697.29. The MSCI Asia ex-Japan index rose 0.5% after Canada dropped its digital services tax on US tech firms—boosting hopes of progress in global trade negotiations. India could finalize an interim trade deal with the US as early as this week, the Financial Times reported, while Reuters said Indian officials are extending their visit to Washington to resolve outstanding issues. Seven of the 13 major sectors declined on the day. The broader small-caps and mid-caps were little changed.
Business Recorder
2 hours ago
- Business Recorder
S&P 500, Nasdaq edge down as Tesla slides
NEW YORK: The S&P 500 and the Nasdaq dropped from record highs on Tuesday, as Tesla shares were hit by a renewed spat between CEO Elon Musk and President Donald Trump, while better-than-expected economic data backed the US central bank's patient stance on rate cuts. Tesla dropped 5% after Trump threatened to cut off the billions of dollars in subsidies that Musk's companies get from the federal government, after Musk revived his criticism of Trump's wide-ranging tax-cut and spending bill. The Republican-controlled US Senate voted 51-50 to pass the bill that enshrines many of Trump's top priorities into law while adding $3.3 trillion to the national debt. The bill, now headed back to the House for final approval, aims to partly cover the tax-reduction costs by cutting Medicaid and some food assistance programs for low-income Americans. The blue-chip Dow got a boost from healthcare stocks such as UnitedHealth and Amgen, and was just about 600 points away from its all-time high touched in December. Data showed US job openings increased unexpectedly in May, suggesting labor market resilience despite trade and economic uncertainties. US Treasuries fell in response, pushing the 2-year yield to a near one-week high. Earlier in the day, Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell reiterated the US central bank plans to 'wait and learn more' about the impact of tariffs on inflation before lowering rates, again setting aside Trump's demands for immediate and deep rate cuts. The S&P 500 and the Nasdaq Composite posted record closing highs on Monday, capping their best quarter in over a year as hopes for more trade deals and possible rate cuts helped markets recover from concerns about chaotic US trade policies and geopolitical tensions. Market focus now shifts to Thursday's nonfarm payrolls report, which could help recalibrate bets for a rate cut as soon as July. Money markets are pricing in a 21.2% likelihood for a July rate cut and see about 64 basis points worth of cuts by the end of this year, per LSEG data. At 11:43 a.m. ET, the Dow Jones Industrial Average rose 394.56 points, or 0.89%, to 44,489.33, the S&P 500 lost 18.03 points, or 0.29%, to 6,186.92 and the Nasdaq Composite lost 212.08 points, or 1.04%, to 20,157.66. Technology stocks, down 1.4%, led the decline among the major S&P sectors, while material stocks climbed 2.4% and the healthcare sector added 2%. Advancing issues outnumbered decliners by a 1.85-to-1 ratio on the NYSE and a 1.11-to-1 ratio on the Nasdaq. The S&P 500 posted 18 new 52-week highs and no new lows while the Nasdaq Composite recorded 63 new highs and 53 new lows.
