MP who was suspended over vile WhatsApp group 'embarrassingly' admits he edited a photo to make it look like he'd gone to Armed Forces Day
An MP who was suspended over a vile WhatsApp group has 'embarrassingly' admitted he edited a photo to make it look like he attended Armed Forces Day.
Andrew Gwynne, the member for Gorton and Denton, Greater Manchester, was exposed for his racist and sexist comments by The Mail on Sunday in February.
The former public health minister's remarks in the chat called Trigger Me Timbers included a vile post saying he hoped a pensioner who did not vote Labour would die before the next election.
The MP, who apologised for his 'badly misjudged comments', is now under investigation by the Commons' standards watchdog over potentially 'causing significant damage to the reputation of the House'.
When this newspaper revealed the messages in February, Mr Gwynne was sacked as a health minister and 'administratively suspended' by the Labour party immediately.
And now, he has posted an image purporting to be of him at Armed Forces Day celebrations in his home town of Denton on Saturday, June 28.
But members of the public quickly noticed his pose and attire were the exact same as a shot of him on the other side of his constituency, in Levenshulme, the day before.
Mr Gwynne has since apologised: 'It [was] just a simple mistake. As soon as I saw it had been posted I removed it.
'I had forwarded 15 images taken by my son to my office, who do my social media posts.
'I don't look at social media anymore as it's not good for my mental ill health which I'm really struggling with right now.
'I do, however, do the infographics that go up as no-one else can use Canva since Tim [Hammersley-Rich, his former senior researcher] left.
'I had intended [to do] a covering photo apologising for not being in attendance and this is the early saved part of that from Canva, which must have saved to my camera roll and I forwarded it with the rest.
'In the end, I just thought it best to have pics from the day without an explanation which is what's up.
'A simple, honest mistake rectified very quickly and just a little bit embarrassing.'
Mr Gwynne's constituency office stands besides Denton's Victoria Park, where the event to celebrate and honour service men and women took place.
But it has also been the scene of demonstrations calling for the resignation of the MP, who since his suspension has served as an independent candidate.
The face of his Tameside borough councillor wife Allison Gwynne, who is also suspended over the WhatsApp scandal, has been scrawled over on information posters.
And Tony Moran, a Labour Party member of 56 years who has worked alongside Mr Gwynne in Denton, told of his feelings on the controversy.
The chair of the town's Victoria Park Community Centre aid: 'This has cut deep. If he thinks he's coming back, he must be deluded, because he's toxic now as an MP.
'Nobody will vote for him now. He was laughing at people behind their backs.
'People have been upset and felt betrayed because some of the comments are about some of the people he's supposed to be representing.
'And if I saw him, I'd say, "Hang your head in shame".
'What Andrew's done, though, is he's created a cult and if you're not in that cult, he doesn't answer you.
'Sometimes you have to have a s*** sandwich and you have to deal with it. But no. He's very immature. He's passionate about being liked, he doesn't like rejection.
'Everybody in life goes through a dark patch, don't they? If he's saying, "I'm mentally ill", I'd be the first to say, "Right, how can we help you? What can we do?"'
'If he's using it as a card, it's too big an issue.'
Mr Gwynne is not the first Tameside MP to be caught up in a row over using doctored images.
In 2007, then Stalybridge and Hyde representative James Purnell faced controversy over a picture purporting to show him at Tameside Hospital in Ashton-under-Lyne.
The snap also featured other MPs, including a young Mr Gwynne, who has served as a member in the area since 2005.
But in fact, Mr Purcell's image was actually inserted into the photograph - as he had not shown up to the photo call on time.
The hospital said in a statement: 'As we would not be able to stage a repeat of this historic day for the hospital, we decided to take a photograph of Mr Purnell in the same spot very shortly after, and merge it with the earlier photograph, to which Mr Purnell kindly consented.
'We apologise if anyone feels misled.'
Mr Gwynne (pictured in 2019) was stripped of his job as health minister and had his membership of the Labour Party suspended by Sir Keir Starmer when he was told by The Mail on Sunday about vile WhatsApp messages the MP had sent
But his office said at the time: 'It is not as if he was never there. In no way did James say, "Just add me in so it looks like I was there".'
Mr Gwynne was stripped of his job as health minister and had his membership of the Labour Party suspended by Sir Keir Starmer when he was told by The Mail on Sunday about vile WhatsApp messages the MP had sent.
A Government spokesman said: 'The Prime Minister is determined to uphold high standards of conduct in public office. He will not hesitate to take action against any Minister who fails to meet these standards, as he has in this case.'
In one particularly shocking comment, the Gorton and Denton MP said he hoped a 72-year-old woman would soon be dead after she dared to ask about her bins.
He also made anti-Semitic slights and 'jokes' about a constituent being 'mown down' by a truck in the leaked messages from the local group chat called Trigger Me Timbers.
The Stockport resident wrote to her local councillor saying she hadn't voted Labour, but added: 'As you have been re-elected I thought it would be an appropriate time to contact you with regard to the bin collections.'
After the councillor shared the letter among fellow Labour figures in the WhatsApp group, Mr Gwynne wrote a suggested response: 'Dear resident, F*** your bins.
'I'm re-elected and without your vote. Screw you. PS: Hopefully you'll have croaked it by the all-outs.'
In one particularly shocking comment, the Gorton and Denton MP (pictured in 2017) said he hoped a 72-year-old woman would soon be dead after she dared to ask about her bins
'All-outs' are elections at which every council seat is contested at once.
Accepting his fate after The Mail on Sunday exclusively revealed his vile messages, Mr Gwynne wrote on social media: 'I deeply regret my badly misjudged commments and apologise for any offence I've caused.
'I've served the Labour Party all my life and it was a huge honour to be appointed a minister by Keir Starmer.
'I entirely understand the decisions the PM and the party have taken and, while very sad to have been suspended, will support them in any way I can.'
The messages were exchanged in a group called Trigger Me Timbers, which Mr Gwynne shares with more than a dozen Labour councillors, party officials and at least one other MP, all based on the outskirts of Manchester.
The MoS gained access to thousands of messages from the closed group, which was set up in 2019, and discovered a barrage of abusive texts. Among them are:
Mr Gwynne saying someone 'sounds too Jewish' and 'too militaristic', apparently from their name alone;
Racist comments about veteran Labour MP Diane Abbott, mocking her historic achievement in becoming the first black MP at either Despatch Box for Prime Minister's Questions;
Sexist comments about Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner performing a sex act;
Mr Gwynne mocking a local Labour leader as 'Colin C*mface'.
It comes after the former councillor (pictured) was investigated over comments in the WhatsApp group
Shortly after, a second MP was suspended by Labour over their membership of the vile WhatsApp group.
Oliver Ryan, the 29-year-old Burnley MP, lost the Labour whip in Parliament and now sits as an independent in the House of Commons.
It comes after the former councillor was investigated over comments in the WhatsApp group.
Police confirmed they had received complaints about the WhatsApp messages and had recorded a non-crime hate incident while making 'initial inquiries'.
In the private chat, Mr Ryan took part with others in apparently homophobic banter as they joked about a fellow Labour MP being gay.
In a series of posts, Mr Ryan also made cruel remarks about a local Labour leader and life-long lollipop man in Greater Manchester called Colin Bailey.
A Labour spokesman said: 'As part of our WhatsApp group investigation, Oliver Ryan has been administratively suspended as a member of the Labour Party.
'As soon as this group was brought to our attention, a thorough investigation was immediately launched and this process is ongoing in line with the Labour Party's rules and procedures.
'Swift action will always be taken where individuals are found to have breached the high standards expected of them as Labour Party members.'
The Tories at the time demanded Sir Keir Starmer now expel both Mr Ryan and Mr Gywnne from Labour and 'show some leadership'.
But a senior Labour figure earlier dodged on whether those MPs involved in the WhatsApp group should be kicked out of the party for good.
Home Office minister Dame Angela Eagle condemned the messages exchanged in the group - but insisted 'anyone can make mistakes'.
It was claimed earlier this month Labour had privately urged Mr Gwynne not to resign - for fears of losing another by-election to Nigel Farage's Reform UK.
Sources said the former health minister, who now serves as an Independent MP, was facing appeals from party officials at national and local level not to resign and trigger a by-election in his Gorton and Denton seat.
They said Labour was 'scared stiff' that if he stood down, it would hand Mr Farage another by-election triumph akin to Reform's shock victory in Runcorn and Helsby last month.
But local Labour officials are also said to be worried snatching Mr Gwynne's Greater Manchester seat would give Reform a platform to oust nearby Labour big-hitters Deputy PM Angela Rayner and Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds at the next general election.
The claims came after Sir Keir made clear he now considered Reform to be Labour's main enemy, saying the Tory party was 'sliding into the abyss'.
In the Runcorn and Helsby contest, Mr Farage's party overturned a 14,696 Labour majority.
With a 13,413 majority, Mr Gwynne's seat looks to be even more vulnerable.
One insider predicted: 'With Reform riding high in the polls, there'd be only one winner if Gwynne resigned from the Commons and that'd be the candidate Nigel Farage picked to stand.
'There's no way Labour would hold it – they're scared still of Reform.'
The 72-year-old from Stockport who Mr Gwynne insulted said she was angry he had not stood down yet.
She added:: 'If he wants to resign, Labour should allow it. I know Reform has won a seat, and they don't want to lose another.'
But one Labour MP dismissed the idea the party wanted Mr Gywnne to stay on, stressing the strong action it had taken when his offensive messages were revealed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
36 minutes ago
- The Independent
Project to reinterpret slave trader statues in London launched
Plaques have been unveiled on the statues of slave traders in London which reveal the 'enormous wrongdoings' of the men as part of a new project to reinterpret them. The City of London Corporation has launched Revealing The City's Past, its project to reinterpret the statues of slave traders former lord mayor William Beckford and former MP Sir John Cass. It reflects a commitment to historical accountability by the City Corporation for its role in the transatlantic trade in enslaved African people, the City Corporation said. At the City Corporation's Guildhall headquarters, plaques unveiled on Monday and fixed to the Beckford and Cass statues, acknowledge and condemn the men's role in the transatlantic trade in enslaved African people, the City Corporation said. The project's steering group, including Culture&, Creative Arts Social Consultancy, and the City Corporation, worked with the City Corporation's staff and local residents, and consulted inter-generational and accessibility panels to enable content from a range of different perspectives. Featuring texts by artist and heritage professional, Rachael Minott, the plaques are accompanied by poems from John Agard and Courtney Conrad. The project's digital platform offers visitors and online audiences a deeper exploration of the City's historic ties to slavery, the City Corporation added. The project's content brings Caribbean diaspora voices to the forefront and encourages reflection on how the legacy of enslavement continues to shape shared spaces, the City Corporation said. William Beckford was a two-time lord mayor of London in the late 1700s who accrued wealth from plantations in Jamaica and held African slaves. Sir John Cass was a 17th and 18th century merchant, MP and philanthropist who also profited from the slave trade. In January 2021, the City Corporation's primary decision-making body, the Court of Common Council, voted to remove the statues. However, after the then government later introduced its Retain and Explain policy, advising that public memorials should remain in place with added historical context, the City Corporation reconsidered. The Court of Common Council voted to keep the statues and develop the Revealing The City's Past project in response. Policy chairman of the City of London Corporation, Chris Hayward, said: 'This project has brought together many talented people, most importantly, voices from the Caribbean diaspora who have historically been excluded from the narrative on Beckford and Cass's legacy and wealth. We are deeply grateful for their expertise, creativity, and insight. 'The enormous wrongdoings of Beckford and Cass are laid bare by this project, leaving no doubt about the contempt in which these two men should be held. 'Against the wishes of many, these statues remain. 'Here at Guildhall, two slave traders still stand but we do not stand with them. 'We are fully committed to race equity and to making our spaces safe and welcoming for all.' Chairman of the City of London Corporation's culture, heritage, and libraries committee, Brendan Barns, said: 'These statues represent prejudice, cruelty, and greed. 'It cannot be denied that the City's links to slavery are a stain on our history, and we should never attempt to erase or gloss over the past. 'With the installation of these plaques and the creation of a wealth of online resources, we are taking positive action to educate current and future generations about this evil form of commerce.' Chief executive officer and artistic director of Culture&, Dr Errol Francis, said: 'Culture&'s involvement in this project to 'retain and explain' the statues in the City of London's Guildhall has called upon a wide range of our skills as well as our lived experience as people with ancestral links to the atrocities associated with the legacy of William Beckford and Sir John Cass. 'We have helped convene the inter-generational advisory panel, choose designers, commission poets, work on the editing of historical texts, and more still. 'We hope that this work will go some way towards explaining how London's merchants and politicians were involved in profiteering from the enslavement of Africans. 'We are aware of the historical importance of this work, from which we hope that the learning will inform the future policy and practice around contested heritage.'
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Sunderland's Crown Works Studios' backer pulls out of film hub
New investment is being sought to finance a major film studio after one of its backers pulled £450m Crown Works Studios project in Sunderland is being designed as a major hub for the TV and film industry and it is hoped it will allow major projects to be created in the north-east of International confirmed it had withdrawn from the project but declined to give a reason for the remaining backer, Fulwell Entertainment, said it remained committed to working with Sunderland City Council to find "appropriate private funding" to allow the development to continue. Crown Works Studios is set to be built on the banks of the River Wear and it is hoped it will create thousands of jobs in the government has already provided £25m towards the project, while the council and the North East mayoral authority have committed to invest about £120m, according to the Local Democracy Reporting much of the funding was expected to come from a joint venture between Fulwell and Cain, which had intended on building 19 sound stages at the riverside site. A spokesperson for Fulwell Entertainment said: "Fulwell Entertainment remains committed to working with the council to find appropriate private funding, complementing the combined NE authority and wider government funding needed to make these world-class production studios a reality." Labour-led Sunderland City Council said the proposals were "being presented to the investment market, with the aim to put in place a final funder and developer later this year".Council leader Michael Mordey said: "These studios represent a game-changing opportunity for the city and we cannot wait to see them progress. "There's an absolute commitment to secure the best possible delivery partner to move this forward and we expect that we will have funding confirmed and be ready to progress the first phase of the studios by the time remediation works complete later this year."Labour's North East Mayor Kim McGuinness said she remained confident Crown Works Studios would be "a flagship site in a thriving industry for years to come." The council's Liberal Democrat opposition leader, Paul Edgeworth, said he hoped the studios would not turn out to be an "empty promise"."Labour have every lever at their disposal to make sure this project is a success," he said. "Sunderland council, the regional mayor and the government must now make it their top priority to make sure this development gets off the ground." Follow BBC Sunderland on X, Facebook, Nextdoor and Instagram.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Even after the welfare rebellion, it is too soon to write off Keir Starmer
In a parallel universe, and perhaps a happier one for him, Sir Keir Starmer would have ended up as attorney general in some sort of Labour government, led by someone other than him. He confessed as much to his sympathetic biographer, Tom Baldwin, some time ago. More recently, this accidental prime minister has been unburdening himself in a series of interviews to mark his first, rather difficult year in office. 'In office', that is, rather than 'in power', as the old saying goes, because his authority has been draining away at an alarming rate lately. It seems to be getting him down. The leadership was a job Sir Keir may not have wanted that much, but it was almost thrust into his safe hands after the debacle of the 2019 general election, and he did his duty. Picking up the pieces after Jeremy Corbyn stepped down, the most famous son of a toolmaker in the country was soon rolling up his sleeves – a favourite expression – and rebuilding his party in his image. He took on the role because there was no one else in the party capable enough, and willing to take it on. He thought, as did virtually everyone, that it would take two terms to unwind Boris Johnson's thumping majority. As it turned out, Mr Johnson and his colleagues, most notably Dominic Cummings and Liz Truss, plus Brexit, helped make sure that the task of returning Labour to government could be undertaken rather more quickly. Sir Keir and his advisers did well to campaign in such a way as to secure a landslide Commons majority – but at 34 per cent of the vote, their mandate was less solid than it looked, and Sir Keir's personal ratings never approached the stellar figures achieved by, say, Tony Blair, or indeed Mr Johnson. Now, those ratings are heading towards nadirs suffered by prime ministers much further into their tenure. The general sense of malaise seems to have entered the prime minister's soul, confessing to any passing journalist his regrets, mistakes and failures, including, most unfortunately, not realising what an impact his 'island of strangers" speech would make. The latest U-turn, on reforms to social security, must surely eat further into his self-confidence. It is not so much the details of the changes – they are mostly sensible – but the way they have been wrung out of the government that has done the damage. Despite early warnings, Sir Keir seems to have failed to engage with the whips and his own ministers until it was too late to prevent an open mutiny of such strength that any premier would have had to back down. As a result, Sir Keir looks like he is following his backbenchers rather than leading them – weak. This is bad enough, but the measures in the revised welfare reforms aren't all that popular with the general public. At least when the prime minister climbed down on the pensioners' winter fuel payment and the grooming gangs inquiry, eventually, he was on the right side of public opinion. He may not get much credit, but at least he tried to rescue some goodwill; the U-turn on welfare doesn't even have that meagre consolation. In fact, it might have been better to pause and work for a more comprehensive resolution that protected the fiscal position and the welfare of vulnerable people. As the Liberal Democrat spokesperson Steve Darling reminded more experienced colleagues in the chamber, rushed legislation has often proved bad legislation. After all, there is no logic in someone with exactly the same mobility challenges as an existing claimant receiving less financial assistance. This messy compromise is an unfortunate way to mark the Labour government's first year of ' change ' – changing their minds three times in as many weeks. Still, hope springs eternal in the Labour Party, as it generally must. Sir Keir's battalion of sorrows has arrived remarkably quickly, but they are not so different from the 'mid-term blues' that have awaited almost every government since the Second World War. The prime minister can be proud of his record on foreign affairs – three substantial trade deals, including the Brexit reset, plus an inexplicably warm relationship with Donald Trump. Proof, at last, that opposites attract. The prime minister has also ended long-running disputes relating to the Chagos Islands and Gibraltar – and, albeit far too little and too late, has at least now declared that the conduct of Israel's war in Gaza is unacceptable. The UK should be boosting spending on defence, and trying to sustain Nato and the defence of Ukraine. The prime minister has done all of that, too. Domestically, things have not proceeded so smoothly – and that has hammered his authority, as rounds of elections and the resurrection of Nigel Farage show. Only if the public perceives tangible changes in the quality of public services will they be prepared to back Labour for a second term of office. The same goes for the economy more broadly, and on control of migration. The government still has time on its side here, if it is not complacent. It needs a 'narrative' – but also improvements people can see and sense. Thanks to his restless health secretary, Wes Streeting, the NHS is being reformed and restored, and waiting times are coming down. There is clearly much more to do, but previous prime ministers have been through worse, and some even went on to win, against all odds. One year in, it is far too soon to write off Sir Keir, unless he himself decides to do so.
