Jobseekers are avoiding part-time roles in fear of losing other social welfare
In order to ensure unemployed people are motivated to get a job again in the future, the government has been told to increase means-tested social welfare allowance thresholds so that they are in line with the national minimum wage or a recipient's earnings.
It comes as Fine Gael leader and Tánaiste Simon Harris
floats the possibility that the jobseekers' allowance would be removed
from the overall increases to social welfare, in favour of higher increases to pensioners.
The Tax Strategy Group, an expert advisory panel at the Department of Finance, said this week that 'inconsistencies' have appeared in Ireland's social welfare system as it has evolved since the late 1800s.
It explained, in its annual reports to government ahead of the budget this year, that jobseekers are disincentivised from picking up shifts in part-time roles in case they impact the specific thresholds of income which are disregarded from social welfare payments.
A portion of a person's income is not taken into account when assessing how much they are entitled to from a social welfare payment. This means that you can earn a certain amount of money, without it affecting your entitlements.
Advertisement
In some cases, the threshold of income that is disregarded from the means test, which will later determine the value of the total payment, is surpassed when jobseekers take up part-time roles, leaving them with not enough money to rely on each week.
It can also impact any other means-tested social welfare payments that they may be receiving, the tax experts' report said.
'This is a penal approach that acts to disincentive an unemployed person from taking up part-time work,' the
report from the Tax Strategy Group said this year
.
It has recommended that a system should be agreed whereby the values of these thresholds increase annually, 'whether aligned with the National Minimum Wage or earnings', to make sure that jobseekers find work.
It added that this change would avoid situations where a person's social welfare entitlements are impacted or reduced, and that it should be done in order to achieve Ireland's policy aims for social welfare.
The report later questioned if there was indeed a 'policy rationale for creating this deviation' – in which case, the state should disregard the advice, it said.
Speaking earlier this month, Tánaiste Harris said he was not convinced that dole increases should be in line with other social welfare payments, such as pensions and disability payments.
'When there are other supports out there for very many people who can't work for very many good reasons. That's my opinion. We'll thrash it out all that out at the time of budget,' he told reporters.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Extra.ie
5 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Why couples on €100k can't afford vast bulk of three-bedroom semi-Ds
Property prices are now so high that a couple on a combined income of more than €100,000 will only be able to afford an average-priced new three-bed semi in one of five locations nationwide, a new housing report shows. The couple also need a minimum 10% deposit under the Central Bank's lending rules. Adding to the burden, estate agents expect prices to increase by an average of 5% over the next 12 months. Up to 70% of agents report that low supply is the main driver of house price inflation. Some 60% believe prices are increasing but will level off soon, while another 18% believe they have peaked. Fianna Fáil leader Micheál Martin and Fine Gael leader Simon Harris. Pic: Sasko Lazarov/ Some 88% of estate agents describe current residential property prices as 'expensive' or 'very expensive' – that's up from 83% in January. The Society of Chartered Surveyors Ireland (SCSI) Residential Mid-Year Market Monitor 2025 report highlights that affordability challenges have intensified for first-time buyers. The average typical listed price for a three-bed semi in the first six months of this year is €357,850, 12.3% higher than a year previously and 40% higher than at the onset of Covid. In the most expensive counties outside Dublin, a couple will face a shortfall of €65,200 in Wicklow and €22,000 in Kildare for that house type. The current rate of inflation in the market is the highest seen in the decade since mortgage market rules were introduced. The surge in inflation is relatively broadly based, with the Dublin figure of 12.3% in line with the average for the rest of the country, according to the latest House Price Report. In the rest of Leinster, the annual increase in prices is 14.3%, whereas inflation is close to the national average in both Limerick city at 12.8% and Galway city at 12.5%. In Waterford city, the rate is higher again at 15.2%, while in Cork city the increase in prices is slower, at 8.6%. Areas around the country highlighted by the report show that prices in Dublin stand at €467,913, up 12.3%. A Galway city average house costs €426,348, which is up 12.5%, followed by Cork city at €369,938 – up 8.6%. Limerick city stands at €311,086 – up 12.8%. The rest of the country has average house costs reaching €309,954 which is up 12.5%. Pic: Shutterstock SCSI president Gerard O'Toole said the report indicated mounting concern over the supply of housing and a recent slowdown in home-building. He said a total of '51% of agents in our survey cite lack of supply as the main factor driving price inflation, up from 46% a year ago. 'In 2023, the figure was 35%, so we can really see the impact the lack of supply is having on house prices. At the same time, 70% of agents are reporting low stock levels of new and second-hand homes, again underscoring the persistent challenge of limited supply in the market. 'Over the past five years more than half of agents have consistently highlighted low stock levels, stressing that constrained supply remains a fundamental issue affecting the market,' he added. 'With the ESRI forecasting that 37,000 new homes will be built this year, well short of the Government's target of 41,000, the urgent need to address infrastructural shortcomings and for the Housing Activation Office to become fully operational as soon as possible can't be overstated. 'The other main factors, which 20% of our members believe are influencing price movements, include the state of the economy. 'A further 16% said the continued availability of Government support schemes such as Help to Buy and First Home Scheme are influencing house prices. 'We have had 12 years of continuous price growth and the level of increases we have seen in recent years is just not sustainable. 'In the medium to long term, the only way to ensure prices stabilise is to ramp up supply,' Mr O'Toole said.
Irish Examiner
10 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Alcohol health labelling 'will add over a third to costs'
Taoiseach Micheál Martin was lobbied by business representative group Ibec to delay the introduction of alcohol warning labels for 'at least' four years due to tariff fears. Ibec chief executive Danny McCoy warned the Fianna Fáil leader that the new requirements would lead to packaging and labelling costs increasing by 'over one-third'. The letter also suggested that some distillers had even suspended brewing in fear of impending tariffs by the US administration. Mr McCoy also sent the letter to Tánaiste and trade minister Simon Harris and health minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill in early June. The Government agreed earlier last week to suspend the rollout of warning labels for two years. In May 2023, then health minister Stephen Donnelly signed the Public Health (Alcohol) (Labelling) Regulations 2023. It was envisaged that the law would make it mandatory for alcohol product labels to state the calorie content and grams of alcohol in the product. They would also warn about the risk of consuming alcohol when pregnant and about the risk of liver disease and fatal cancers from alcohol consumption. The change was due to come into effect in May 2026, to allow a three-year implementation period for the drinks industry. However, there have been rumblings in recent weeks that the plan would be postponed, with Mr Harris saying that it would be additional disruption and a 'potential trade barrier' as tariff negotiations continue. At Tuesday's Cabinet meeting, the Tánaiste told ministers that Ms Carroll MacNeill will defer the plans for two years. This is despite reports that it would be a four-year pause. Correspondence released under Freedom of Information (FoI) shows that the Taoiseach was being lobbied by Ibec to drop the labelling plans. On June 3, Mr McCoy called for the plans to be dropped for four years 'at least'. 'The wider drinks sector, but particularly many of the new emerging distilleries, have significant exposure to these new tariffs and the wider trade uncertainty,' wrote Mr McCoy. 'The majority of distilling across the country is now suspended. The introduction of new labelling requirements for the drinks sector, which will add over one-third to product labelling and packaging costs, should be suspended for at least four years to give some certainty to operators. 'Reducing regulatory burden costs to free up resources to allow companies invest in finding new markets would be a positive development.' Mr McCoy said that the legislation had been cited by the US administration in its 2025 National Trade Estimate Report on Foreign Trade Barriers, which he said was 'cause for further concern and reason for this legislation to be deferred'. He added: 'The industry does not want this to be an issue of disagreement in overall efforts to secure a resolution on trade relations and restoration of a tariff-free trading environment.' Further correspondence shows the letter was also forwarded from the Taoiseach's office to the Department of Enterprise several days later seeking an update on enterprise minister Peter Burke's engagement with Ms Carroll MacNeill. A letter sent from Mr Burke to Ms Carroll MacNeill on May 15 was also released under FoI. He said that recent months have seen 'significant global uncertainty and a rapidly shifting trading landscape', which he said 'could have profound competitiveness implications for small open economies like Ireland'. Mr Burke said that Ireland would be the first country in Europe to introduce the labels. 'The proposed measures will mean increased production and sale costs for Irish producers and importers and add to the price payable by consumers at a time when prices are also rising due to a multitude of other factors,' wrote Mr Burke. 'Notwithstanding the overarching health benefits of the proposal, I would ask you to consider pausing the introduction of the proposed new requirements.' Calls not to delay plans Meanwhile, Mr Martin was urged not to delay the plans and received a letter just last week from Alcohol Action Ireland chief executive Sheila Gilheany. She said that 'postponing alcohol health information labelling is not consequence free given the thousands harmed by alcohol in Ireland.' Read More Delaying alcohol warning labels prioritises profiteering over health, says Irish Medical Organisation
Irish Times
11 hours ago
- Irish Times
Coalition warned against diluting contentious Occupied Territories Bill
The Government will be warned not to allow the potential for legal challenges to be used as an excuse to water down the legislation known as the Occupied Territories Bill . The Oireachtas foreign affairs committee will this week publish its report on a proposal to ban trade with illegally occupied territories in Palestine. The report, finalised on Friday, is understood to recommend widening the legislation to include a ban on services as well as goods. There have been stark warnings from business lobby groups that such a measure could damage the Republic's trading relationship with the US and cause economic harm to Irish businesses and households. The Occupied Territories Bill is now undergoing pre-legislative scrutiny Listen | 41:13 The committee will tell the Government to model the ban on trade with illegal settlements in Palestine on 2014 trade restrictions with Russia regarding illegally occupied territories in Ukraine. The committee, chaired by Fianna Fáil TD John Lahart , which did not have statistics on the volume of trade in services between the State and illegally occupied territories, will call on Minister for Trade Simon Harris to collate and publish such information. It will also tell Mr Harris to establish what kind of backlash the State would face in terms of trade and diplomacy should it ban trade with the occupied Palestinian territories. [ Republic joins 25 states urging end to Gaza war Opens in new window ] Ministers will also be advised to consider what defences could be available to a business charged with an offence under the proposed law. . It is understood that the committee believes further work is required from the Government before the law could be enacted. And it will ask that Attorney General Rossa Fanning's advice on the complex Bill is 'expedited' so it can move forward as a matter of urgency. During meetings before the Dáil rose for the summer recess, Mr Lahart was critical of 'misinformation' about the Bill and the State's motivation for passing it – much of which was repeated by senior US political figures. Chairwoman of US House Republicans Lisa McClaine described the Bill as a type of 'extreme anti-Semitic hate'. [ How life in the West Bank is deteriorating for Palestinians Opens in new window ] It is understood that the committee's report will call on the Government to explain the motivation behind the Bill to European Union and international colleagues, while also lobbying Brussels for further collective EU action against Israel. The committee will propose a Government-funded public communications campaign for domestic and international audiences to explain the facts of the Bill and to challenge misinformation spread about it.
