When is a two-pointer not a two-pointer? - FRC member Eamonn Fitzmaurice explains
And they were again highlighted at the weekend following the awarding of one point instead of two when Galway goalkeeper Conor Gleeson helped the ball over the bar, taking advantage of the rule.
Former Kerry manager and current FRC member Eamonn Fitzmaurice spoke about the incident on the RTE GAA Podcast and offered his opinion, while also explaining the thinking behind the rule.
"There is a lot you can say about the incident," said Fitzmaurice.
"It was a significant incident at that time of the game, the flow of the game, and everything else.
"You have to give huge credit to Conor Gleeson to get a touch on it, Stephen Cluxton did something similar in Portlaoise last weekend when he got a touch on one of the long Meath two pointers.
"I didn't think it was as conclusive as some people are saying, it did look like it was all the way over the bar, when Glesson managed to get a touch on it, so it should have been two in that case, and that's an officiating mistake."
Fitmaurice said that the rule did cause much debate when it came to predicting the scenarios that could arise from such a situation, which was really aimed at taking the uncertainty out of the situation and making it easier for the officials.
"The rationale is that we did debate around this particular one and it was trying to write a rule in terms of how far out do you allow a touch?" added Fitmaurice.
"If it comes in and a full-forward and full-back are competing for it and it is added to, is that still at two-pointer. And we debated if it was just the full back, it can stay as the two-pointer, and it could be [a question as to] who got a touch on it.
"So it was to try to make it as clean as possible from an officiating perspective.
"We saw yesterday what can happen in that situation and I know there was commentary around you'd hate to see that being a deciding factor in a game, especially in the knock-out games in the championshop
"And from the FRC perspective, when anything like that happens, we are discussing it, seeing if it is something that we need to consider.
"To me if someone kicks from outside the arc and the full forward touches it before it hit the ground, it becomes a one-pointer, but how do you decide how significant a touch, so that was the rationale."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Weekend That Was: A Kerry v Donegal All-Ireland final isn't the clash of styles you think it is
Styles make fights. The All-Ireland final looks like it will be billed as the best kind of showdown, a good old-fashioned ding-dong between two teams who favour different methods of skinning the cat. In the green and gold corner we have Kerry , keepers of the kicking flame, salty purveyors of it's-called-football-for-a-reason asides. And in the, eh, yellow and green corner we have Donegal , who would handpass their granny's coffin into the grave if they thought they could get it past the priest. That's presumably how it will be built up, at any rate. Watch out for a couple of weeks of very broad-brush painting of these two teams. It will be David Clifford v Michael Murphy ; Jack O'Connor v Jim McGuinness ; Shane Ryan v Shaun Patton. The smooth, slick footballing brilliance of princes of the Kingdom versus the systematic, relentless drive of the boys from the Hills. Some of it will ring true. But some of it will be the worst sort of guff too. The trick will be to separate the myths from the reality. READ MORE We have plenty to go on at least. Kerry and Donegal have played 18 matches between them in this year's championship to date so the sample size is bigger than it's ever been for a final. When these teams met in the 2014 decider, they had played a total of nine games between them to get there. There will be no secrets between them come 3.30 on Sunday week. The rest of us looking in from the outside will have no excuses for being ill-informed either. There are some obvious contrasts to be drawn. For one thing, Donegal tend to have a greater spread of scorers than Kerry. They saw a dozen players get on the scoresheet on Sunday, compared to seven for Kerry on Saturday. Ryan McHugh of Donegal in action against Meath's Jordan Morris during the All-Ireland SFC semi-final at Croke Park. Photograph: Ryan Byrne/Inpho Kerry have averaged a shade under eight scorers per game in their eight matches, Donegal have averaged almost exactly 10 per game in their 10. As Ciarán Kirk showed in these pages last week, Kerry rely heavily on David Clifford and Seán O'Shea for over half of their scores. Donegal are a more varied threat. [ David Clifford and Seán O'Shea carrying big scoring burden for Kerry Opens in new window ] And there's no doubting the essential truth that the two counties think about the game in contrasting ways. McGuinness has often referenced the fact that Donegal teams have traditionally leant on a running, handpassing game because they play so many matches in the wind up in the northwest. Whether this rings particularly true is debatable – they get plenty of wind around the Ring of Kerry too. But one way or another, it's in the county DNA and McGuinness has never been of a mind to change it. Donegal's game is about high-running, fast breaks, up and down the pitch. That's who they are. Kerry do it differently – but as McGuinness pointed out yesterday, not THAT differently when it comes right down to it. 'I suppose when you're playing a running game and a support game, everybody needs to be able to do that,' he said, referencing the spread of scorers. 'I think today everybody did do that and we were able then to rotate fellas inside and give them a breather and let other fellas go back and hopefully they're going to be able to defend to the same level and attack to the same level as well. 'Listen, the game has changed dramatically over the last number of months. We just felt that it was important to see how those changes would grow, if you like, and then bring our own template to how we want to play the game to that. And it's served us well. I think Kerry have done the exact same thing. 'I don't think Kerry have done a huge amount differently. They have their own way of playing as well. They play with their head up, they're looking for dink balls, they're looking for third-man runners, they're looking to support. In the same way we support off the shoulder, they're looking to do it the exact same way, only with a different kick or whatever it is beforehand. 'So, yeah, everybody's got their own principles and how they see the game. For me it's important just to keep what it is to be from your county very close to the centre, and then move with the rules. And I think we've done quite a good job on that front.' Kerry's Kieran Donaghy celebrates scoring a goal with James O'Donoghue during the 2014 All-Ireland final against Donegal. Photograph: Morgan Treacy/Inpho Though it may be a slightly self-serving point to make, McGuinness isn't entirely wrong. Kerry do like to let the ball do the work, it's true. But the basic thrust of both teams' game is the same – organised zonal defence, a manic zeal for breaking ball around the middle, get it up to the forwards. Kerry are not dogmatic about kicking at all costs. They indulge in plenty of handpassing too – and you can be sure they'll do so in the final. Kerry football is about winning, first and foremost. Never forget that. Go back to their last great coup, the 2014 final against Donegal. It was billed as a clash of styles all the way from the semi-finals onwards but Eamonn Fitzmaurice was adamant behind the scenes that Kerry weren't going to fall into Donegal's trap. Instead, they mimicked Donegal's low block and waited for a mistake, Kieran Donaghy pouncing on a botched kick-out for the killer goal. So yes, styles make fights. And in the new game, there isn't room for an old-style Donegal to sit back and turn a final into trench warfare. But this is Jack O'Connor's eighth final. As he pointed out on Saturday night, it's a fourth final for most of his Kerry team – or indeed a fifth, including the replay in 2019. They won't be taking any more chances with the ball than they need to. One thing feels pretty obvious after the weekend – the two best teams are in the final. Can't ask for much more than that from a championship.
The Irish Sun
2 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Jack O'Connor reveals ‘disappointing' side to Kerry's victory over Tyrone in All-Ireland semi-final
GAVIN White revealed Kerry's shock defeat to Meath was the kick in the backside the Kingdom needed to reignite their season. The Munster champions blew top spot in Group 2 of the All-Ireland series when the Advertisement 2 Jack O'Connor will be hoping to win Kerry's first All-Ireland since 2022 2 David Clifford starred as Kerry defeated Tyrone 1-20 to 0-17 But Jack O'Connor rallied his troops as they saw off Cavan, Armagh They battered the Breffni 3-20 to 1-17, White put in a trademark captain's display, sparking Kingdom attacks as his side fired 0-9 without reply in the second half to send sorry Tyrone packing. Advertisement Reade more on GAA Their skipper knows the Meath performance was not a true reflection of their talents and the wing-back gave an insight into the dressing-room mood after the loss. White said: 'After the Meath game we were all very disappointed in our performance. We knew that wasn't us. 'We got a bit of slack for it but we tried to keep all that out of the camp. We knew the quality that we have in training and we believed in what we were capable of. 'So we just battened down the hatches going into the Cavan game, went back to basics and built from there. Advertisement Most read in GAA Football 'Obviously the Armagh game was huge considering what happened last year, so we wanted to rectify that and thankfully we were able to bring that into Saturday as well. 'I'm over the moon that we're able to play as well as we are at the business end of the year and we look forward to an All-Ireland final in two weeks' time.' 'They have to be stopped!' - Meath new unofficial All-Ireland anthem splits opinions online The Kingdom blew Kieran McGeeney's men away with five two-pointers as another rampant second-half spell of 0-14 in 15 minutes killed the game. Against Tyrone at the weekend, they mixed kicking and running the ball, with David Clifford's first-half double score their only orange flag of the game. Advertisement The Kingdom instead hunted for goals and their star man rattled the onion bag just shy of the half-hour mark to put the Munster kingpins 1-7 to 0-8 in front. But they could have had so many more majors as Joe O'Connor, Paudie Clifford, Dylan Geaney and Killian Spillane all spurned chances. Boss O'Connor cursed the misses but was delighted with his side's ability to solve the puzzles that came their way. MATURITY AND EXPERIENCE PREVAILS The Kingdom chief said: 'I know we wasted chances — two or three at the back post that looked like tap-ins, it's disappointing, because we prided ourselves throughout the league on scoring goals. 'At least we created the chances — and the last day we were creating two-pointer chances. I think it's a sign of the team that they recognised what's in front of them. Advertisement 'There was a bit more space inside this time and they put the ball in and created those chances. Of course we'd have had an easier afternoon if we'd converted a few of them. "This is a mature team. Most of the boys are a good age. They are in their mid-to-late 20s — 27, 28, that is a good age group. They're mature lads and that was a mature performance. 'We slowed it down when we had to and we sped it up when we had to. I thought we kicked the ball through the lines well and found David in one-on-one situations, and that is always good for us.' And it proved fatal for Tyrone, who went 21 minutes without a score in the second half. Advertisement Darragh Canavan gave his all for the cause, firing 0-7, but Kerry grew with every kick as their unanswered nine-point flurry ended the match as a contest. HUGE WINS AND A BRIGHT FUTURE The Red Hands can still take the positives from reaching their first semi-final since going all the way in 2021 in Malachy O'Rourke's first year as manager. They And O'Rourke called on veterans Mattie Donnelly, 34, Niall Morgan, 33, Pádraig Hampsey, 31, Kieran McGeary, 31, and Peter Harte, 34, to stick around and help the youngsters transition into the senior set-up. Advertisement Under-20 star Eoin McElholm getting the nod to start against the Kingdom. LEADING BY EXAMPLE The Red Hand boss insisted: 'There'll be no talk of retirement, I would love if they were there to help guide it because there is a big vacuum there, if you like, between Under-20s and senior. 'You'd love it if they would. Those lads are brilliant ambassadors for Tyrone and the effort and work they put in, the example they show to the rest of the boys is second to none. 'It's a big gap and it just doesn't happen overnight. It's not just a case of people stepping up, there's a lot of work to be done and a big transition to be made. Advertisement "So the more experienced fellas that are about to guide them, the better. I take a lot of positives out of it. 'We've had four Championship victories, we went to Ballybofey and won, we went to Croke Park and beat Dublin as well. The boys have put in a lot of effort and we have improved. 'To get into the last four, you're going to be playing one of the top teams and Kerry are one of the top teams. Any weaknesses you have would be exposed more than in other games. 'There has been a lot of positives but at the same time a game like that shows the level you have to be getting at to challenge for top honours.' Advertisement SCORERS — Kerry: D Clifford 1-9, 3f 1tp; S O'Shea 0-3, 2f; J O'Connor 0-2, P Clifford 0-2, K Spillane 0-2, G O'Sullivan 0-1, D Geaney 0-1. Tyrone: D Canavan 0-7, 2f 1tp; M Donnelly 0-2, S O'Donnell 0-2, C Daly 0-2, R Canavan 0-2tpf, E McElholm 0-1, K McGeary 0-1.
RTÉ News
3 hours ago
- RTÉ News
RTÉ GAA Podcast: Kerry and Donegal set up Sam Maguire showdown, Kildare back in the big time
Enda McGinley and Nigel Dunne join Jacqui Hurley to look back on the All-Ireland football semi-final weekend. David Clifford once again led Kerry to an impressive triumph, this time over Tyrone. Donegal await in the final, but have they the tools to limit the Fossa man? Or will it matter, is it written in the stars for Jim McGuinness and Michael Murphy already? Kildare won the Tailteann Cup and will compete for Sam next year, but what is a realistic ambition for the Lilywhites?
