#FreeAlaa: Will hunger strikes release Alaa Abdel-Fattah? – DW – 06/05/2025
Calls for the release of the 43-year-old Egyptian-British activist Alaa Abdel-Fattah are gaining momentum again.
This week, the United Nations Working Group on Arbitrary Detention, or UNWGAD, stated that Abdel-Fattah's continued imprisonment in Egypt is illegal. Following an 18-month investigation, the group argued that no warrant or explanation was present at the time of the arrest, and that Abdel-Fattah was imprisoned for exercising his freedom of expression — a legal right in Egypt.
The report concludes with the call on the Egyptian government "to take the steps necessary to remedy the situation without delay…to release Abdel-Fattah immediately and accord him an enforceable right to compensation and other reparations, in accordance with international law."
Cairo is yet to comment on the ruling, but for Abdel-Fattah's family, who is based in London, the report comes "at an important moment," Omar Hamilton, Abdel-Fattah's cousin, told DW.
Abdel-Fattah's mother, Leila Soueif, has been on hunger strike in support of her son's release for around 250 days. This week, the health of the 69-year-old British citizen deteriorated massively.
"Our family is in the hospital every day," Hamilton told DW. "While we're doing what we can to keep her as comfortable as possible, she is mentally very strong and very determined."
Last week, Leila Soueif was admitted to hospital in London after reaching life-threateningly low blood sugar levels Image: #FreeAlaa
Last week, British Prime Minister Keir Starmer ramped up his support as well. Starmer phoned Egyptian President Abdel-Fattah el-Sissi for the second time this year to discuss the situation of Alaa Abdel-Fattah who has been a British citizen since 2022. Starmer called for clemency and said that the Egyptian government was causing the family great anguish. Neither further details, nor the Egyptian reaction were published.
According to the British newspaper The Guardian, a diplomatic source said that Egypt doesn't recognize Abdel-Fattah's dual citizenship.
The activist has been imprisoned for around a decade. In 2015, he was sentenced to five years for participating in a 2013 protest. In September 2019, he was rearrested during a widespread crackdown on political dissent. and handed a five-year sentence for "spreading false news" in December 2021.
Instead of releasing him in September 2024 at the end of his sentence if you count his pretrial detention, authorities ordered to keep him in prison until January 3, 2027. They argued that the two years he spent in pretrial detention are not to be counted toward his sentence, even though the time span exceeded Egypt's legal pretrial length.
Abdel-Fattah has also started a hunger strike himself some 100 days ago.
'Time is running out' for activist's mother
In addition to the latest report by the UN and the support by Starmer, scores of human rights organizations, too, have restarted campaigning for Abdel-Fattah's release, on social media at #FreeAlaa and politically.
Earlier this week, 21 rights organizations, including English PEN and Human Rights Watch, sent ajoint letter to Egyptian President el-Sissi.
One of the signatories, Yasmine Ahmed, UK Director at Human Rights Watch, told DW that "time is running out."
"The prominent writer and activist has been detained in Egypt unlawfully for over a decade as his mother Leila faces an imminent risk of death in a hospital in London," she said. "The UK government must use every point of political and diplomatic leverage they have to push Egypt to release the British citizen Alaa Abdel-Fattah."
While Abdel-Fattah may be the most prominent political prisoner in Egypt, he is far from the only one. Rights organizations estimate that between 65,000 and 70,000 political prisoners are kept behind bars. Officially, though, Egypt has never stated a number and ranks most of these prisoners as "terrorists."
Meanwhile, the latest report by Egypt's National Council for Human Rights, which was installed in 2003 to further Egypt's national human rights strategy, stated "notable progress " on civil and political rights for the period of June 2023 to June 2024.
"Nevertheless, several human rights issues persist and require intensified efforts and expedited action to overcome the associated challenges," the report states.
Egypt's National Council on Human Rights admitted that rights issues persist under President el-Sisi's rule Image: Hadi Mizban/REUTERS
Dire rights situation in Egypt
For Christian Achrainer, a researcher at Denmark's Roskilde University who has extensively published on Egypt, these words of progress and calls for intensified efforts sound hollow.
"The human rights situation in Egypt has not changed much, it is still very bad," he told DW.
In his view, none of the governmental bodies that are tasked with improving the country's human rights situation have had a positive impact.
"Slightly positive developments have been counteracted by other measures," Achrainer said. "Some political prisoners were released, while others were re-arrested."
"In general, freedom of press and freedom of expression remain extremely restricted, and people continue to be imprisoned for expressing their opinions," Achrainer said.
Egypt's political leverage
Despite increasing international attention and calls for Abdel-Fattah's release, Egypt "is not impressed," Achrainer observes.
"Cairo is fundamentally aware of its very good negotiating position with Europe at the moment," he explained.
"The multi-billion Euro migration deal in 2024 clearly shows that Europe is prepared to look the other way on human rights issues if Egypt ensures that fewer refugees and migrants come to Europe."
Also, Cairo's contacts with all parties to the conflict in Gaza, the fight against terrorism, economic interests and the potential role in conflict-ridden neighboring countries like Libya and Sudan boost Egypt's position as key player in the region.
"All of this means that the regime knows that it is not forced to act in the case of [Abdel-Fattah] or in the area of human rights in general," Achrainer said.
Leila Soueif's determination to continue her hunger strike until Alaa Abdel-Fattah is released remains undeterred, her nephew Omar Hamilton told DW. Image: Vuk Valcic/Zuma/picture alliance
'All political prisoners should be freed'
Despite this dire rights situation, Egyptians have been submitting petitions and official telegrams to the presidency with their name and address on it asking for Abdel-Fattah's release, Omar Hamilton told DW.
"And people all around the world hold vigils and protests," he added.
Since Leila Soueif has been hospitalized last Thursday, Abdel-Fattah's family and supporters also gather daily in front of St Thomas' hospital in London.
"There's an incredible amount of energy pouring in from around the world," Hamilton said. "And not only us, but all people believe that Alaa should be freed, actually that all the political prisoners should be freed."
Abdel Fattah is one of many: Human rights activist Hossam Baghat
To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video
Edited by: Carla Bleiker
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
DW
an hour ago
- DW
NGOs: Gaza airdrops smack of 'cynicism' and are 'futile' – DW – 07/30/2025
As famine takes hold in Gaza, human rights organizations have criticized the plans by Germany and other countries to drop aid in via airlifts. They say this is symbolic politics and inefficient. "We need urgent action now," said Ross Smith, director of emergency preparedness and response at the UN World Food Programme (WFP) this week, as he told the press in Rome that the famine currently underway in Gaza was "unlike anything we have seen in this century. It reminds us of previous disasters in Ethiopia or Biafra in the past century." "Worst-case scenario of famine unfolding in the Gaza Strip," read an alert issued by the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC). The UN's hunger monitoring initiative has concluded that mounting evidence shows that "widespread starvation, malnutrition, and disease are driving a rise in hunger-related deaths." It added: "Latest data indicates that famine thresholds have been reached for food consumption in most of the Gaza Strip and for acute malnutrition in Gaza City." Most of the more than 2 million inhabitants of the already densely populated Gaza Strip, which has a total area of 365 square kilometers (141 square miles), are currently living in extremely overcrowded refugee camps in an even more limited space because the Israeli army has declared large parts of the strip militarized zones. Israeli Prime Minister Benyamin Netanyahu recently declared there was "no policy of starvation in Gaza, and there is no starvation in Gaza." Israel has barred international journalists from entering Gaza. Dozens of Palestinian journalists have been killed. Since the weekend, members of the international community have been trying to find ways of alleviating the acute misery in Gaza. On Sunday, Jordan and the United Arab Emirates parachuted 25 tons of aid into Gaza. Germany and France also announced airdrop missions. "This work may only make a small contribution to humanitarian aid, but it sends an important signal: We are here, we are in the region," said Germany Chancellor Friedrich Merz. Aid organizations expressed dismay. "Using airdrops for the delivery of humanitarian aid is a futile initiative that smacks of cynicism," said Doctors Without Borders (MSF) emergency coordinator in Gaza Jean Guy Vataux. He said that airdrops were "notoriously ineffective and dangerous." The Berlin-based Center for Humanitarian Action (CHA) said it was "the most senseless airlift ever" as well as "symbolic politics and a waste of money." Its director Ralf Südhoff said that airlifts were up to 35 times more expensive than land convoys. Marvin Fürderer, an emergency relief expert at the German charity Welthungerhilfe, also described the airdrops as "symbolic" and "ineffective." He told DW that one fundamental problem of the approach was that aid would be "dropped into a high-risk environment, without coordination, without a designated drop zone and without safety structures." He added that it would likely not reach those who needed it most but those who were "still mobile enough to fight their way through the rubble and crowded streets to get to a place where aid had been dropped and then to wrangle for it." Almost every day, Palestinians are killed trying to access food at the few hubs run by the controversial Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF). The US nonprofit is backed by President Donald Trump's administration and the Israeli government and was set up to distribute humanitarian aid after Israel banned the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA) from operating in Gaza and the other Occupied Palestinian Territories earlier this year. However, it has failed to provide security: The UN accuses the Israeli military of firing on people standing in line. This week, UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Volker Türk said that "more than one thousand people have been killed since the end of May as they tried to get food." International NGOs have called on Israel to allow the unhindered entry of aid into Gaza and for those organizations that used to provide supplies at around 600 distribution hubs to be permitted to resume their activities. At a press conference in Berlin, Riad Othman, a Middle East expert at the German-based human rights organization Medico International, explained that before October 7, 2023, the population of Gaza and its economy were being supplied by 500 to 600 trucks per day. "Today, even 600 trucks a day would not be enough to meet demand because not only has the essential infrastructure and healthcare system been systematically destroyed in Gaza, but so too has agriculture," he added. A truck can typically hold about 20 tons of aid, which includes medical supplies and drinking water, as well as food. On October 7, 2023 the militant Palestinian organization Hamas and other groups killed more than 1,200 people in Israel in a coordinated attack. They also took 250 hostages back to Gaza. Israel launched a counterattack and declared that it would destroy Hamas. The Gaza Health Ministry says that at least 60,000 people have died, at least 147 from starvation. After violating a ceasefire agreement in March, Israel blocked all aid supplies to Gaza for more than 80 days. Now, Israel says it is observing daily pauses in fighting in parts of Gaza and once again allowing aid to be delivered via land. Israel's far-right National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir has criticized this, saying it is akin to providing life support for the enemy. Julia Duchrow, the secretary general of Amnesty International's German section, said that there was "ample evidence that Israel is using hunger as a weapon of war." She called on the German government to stop supplying arms to Israel and to increase diplomatic pressure on the Israeli government. The Israeli government has denied many international NGOs access to Gaza. Welthungerhilfe can only provide aid via local partners, Fürderer told DW, saying that a permanent ceasefire was crucial and that the border crossings had to be opened to allow humanitarian aid in. He said that if this were to happen, Welthungerhilfe could immediately bring in aid from Jordan. "The convoys could start within hours, as soon as the political conditions on the ground allowed," he pointed out. By contrast, he said, the airdrops would call for logistical reorganization that would be costly. "It is very interesting that this is now being considered, at a time when the government wants to cut humanitarian aid by 53%," Fürderer said. "In a situation like this, it is difficult to spend millions on symbolic, ineffective airdrops." The German air force already has some experience dropping aid into Gaza. In spring 2024, A400M military transport aircraft flew airdrop missions for 10 weeks, dropping 315 tons of aid supplies in view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video
DW
3 hours ago
- DW
Fact check: Tsunami unleashes fake films and misinformation – DW – 07/30/2025
An earthquake in the Pacific triggered tsunami waves across the US, Japan, and Russia — and a flood of misinformation online. DW separates fact from fiction. A powerful earthquake off Russia's east coast has prompted evacuations across the Pacific, from Japan to Peru, and caused tsunami waves in Russia, Japan, and Hawaii. Among the footage circulating online, misinformation is also spreading fast. DW Fact check has seen false information ranging from shared out of context to AI-generated fakes and entirely fabricated claims about the situation on the ground. The American talk show host and actress Oprah Winfrey, who lives part time in Maui, Hawaii, has been the target of harsh criticism. She owns a property there and the private road running up to it has sparked debate: Claim: "In Maui, Hawaii people are moving to higher ground. Oprah Winfrey has refused to let people use her private road," a user claims on X. DW Fact check: Misleading At the time the post was published on X, the road in question was already open to traffic, as the Maui Police Department clarified in a statement: "Oprah's road is open to get Upcountry." A spokesperson for Oprah Winfrey reacted to the claims in a statement shared with Newsweek: "As soon as we heard the tsunami warnings, we contacted local law enforcement and FEMA to ensure the road was opened. Any reports otherwise are false." Nevertheless, the claim that Oprah Winfrey would block her street to public traffic even in the face of the approaching tsunami persisted. On X in particular, posts to this effect reached millions of people, and the narrative also spread on Threads and TikTok. People reacted with anger to these posts. Some users posted videos showing that the road is open to traffic. This, as well as confirmation by the Maui police, undermine claims that Oprah Winfrey is blocking public use of her road to higher areas of the island of Maui, showing such posts to be misleading. As with previous breaking news events, much of the content being shared is older footage which is falsely labeled to suggest it shows the aftermath of the recent magnitude-8.8 quake. One of the most viral videos shows a couple in a rooftop swimming pool fleeing as heavy tremors begin. Claim: "What it's like at the rooftop swimming pool of a high-rise building during an M7.7 earthquake," says the post on X, which has 2.6 million views at the time of writing. DW Fact check: False While the footage is real and does show an earthquake's impact, it is not from the recent quake in eastern Russia. The video was filmed at a hotel in Bangkok on March 28, 2025, during a magnitude-7.7 earthquake centered in central Myanmar. Tremors were felt in Thailand and southwestern China. The clip can be verified via reverse image search and appears in media reportsfrom that time. Back then, a lot of fake content was shared, allegedly showing the aftermath and impact of the earthquake. DW Fact check found at the time that some of this information was false. Another post on Xclaims to show the "insane tsunami footage out of Russia." However, a reverse image search traces it back to a four-year-old video showing the impact of tsunami waves in Greenland. The original clip can be found in media reportsof the time. Back then, a massive landslide triggered a tsunami wave that caught local fishermen by surprise. A third video, also circulating on X, allegedly shows tsunami waves hitting land. But this clip was first posted in 2017and shows waves striking Durban North Beach in South Africa. It has been mislabeled in the past, including in 2023when it was posted along with the false claim it showed a tsunami following the Turkey-Syria earthquake. A viral postwith 6.4 million views on X shows screenshots from a TBS News DIG report about stranded whales on a Japanese beach. The post speculates that they may have been stranded by the tsunami. Claim: "In Tateyama City, Chiba Prefecture, a whale is flipping over for unknown reasons, possibly due to the impact of a tsunami," says the post. DW Fact check: UnknownA reverse image search confirms the footage is from a TBS News report. Agency photos from The Yomiuri Shimbun/AP, via picture alliance verify that whales were indeed stranded. However, according to Chiba prefectural police, the whales had been beached the day before the tsunami and the events are believed to be unrelated. A report by The Asahi Shimbunquotes expert Tajima Yuko from the National Museum of Nature and Science, who notes that if unusual underground sounds occurred before the quake, their effects on whales remain unknown. The article also quotes Mika Kuroda from the NPO Stranding Network Hokkaido who says there is no factual basis for suggestions that stranded whales are precursors for earthquakes, not least because dolphins or whales are stranded every day in Japan. Artificial intelligence also contribute to the wave of disinformation. Several viral posts about a tsunami alert in California following an earthquake in Russia circulate misleading visuals. One of such viral images can be seen in a post on X stating: "Balboa is gone." It refers to Balboa Island, a waterfront neighborhood in Newport Beach, California, connected to the mainland by a bridge, ferry, and multiple public docks. The image shows rows of submerged buildings that are almost entirely underwater, with only their roofs and top floors visible. In the background, a bridge can be seen above the waterline. DW Fact check: Fake This is an AI-generated image. While a tsunami watch was issued for parts of California, the projected impact was expected several hours after this image was posted. At the time of posting, there were no official evacuation orders in San Francisco. Moreover, the image contains visual inconsistencies. Despite the water appearing to engulf buildings, the foot of the bridge in the background is entirely visible, suggesting water levels are not consistent across the image. The original post garnered over 95.2K views. DW Fact check also tested this image on AI-detecting tools like AIorNot and Hive Moderation, both of which identified it as 99% AI-generated. Another misleading videocirculating online claims to show real-time impact of the tsunami: "BREAKING — Tsunami footage from the Russian Earthquake is starting to roll in," says a post on X. One of the videos shows people lying on a beach as a large wave approaches and crashes over the sand. In the subsequent clip, a similar wave is shown engulfing the shore. DW Fact check: Fake This video is also AI-generated. None of the people in the footage visibly react to the incoming wave, even as it approaches and washes over them. The wave formation itself is also inconsistent with natural behavior, emerging out of nowhere without any visible buildup.
DW
3 hours ago
- DW
NATO ex-employees accuse the alliance of going DOGE – DW – 07/30/2025
In unusually direct criticism, former NATO insiders say the alliance is being shaped to reflect Donald Trump's priorities. Officials, however, insist the restructuring is independent and overdue. Since NATO Secretary-General Mark Rutte forged a consensus on massive spending hikes and flattered the United States president, Donald Trump has developed a newfound appreciation of the alliance. And, as a result, many people at NATO breathed a sigh of relief. But not everyone gave Rutte a hero's welcome. The secretary-general is facing a barrage of criticism, some of it public, over what his team calls an "optimization" of NATO resources. What might in normal times be described as a bureaucratic reshuffle, has created a different impression in the current trans-Atlantic climate. Some observers say Rutte is reconfiguring NATO to please the White House — and are doing so in ways that don't serve the alliance's broader or longer-term interests. Dr. Gerlinde Niehus, who held many positions at NATO over 26 years, has taken the lead in lambasting the changes. She went so far as to say that Rutte is following the controversial Elon Musk-driven downsizing under the "Department of Government Efficiency" (DOGE). "Taking inspiration from the ill-conceived US 'DOGE' exercise, [the reorganization] is largely a sleek ingratiation aligned to US MAGA politics," Niehus wrote in a LinkedIn post, opinions which she later confirmed to DW directly. "Under the disguise of 'efficiency,' NATO HQ functions which could become the target of Donald Trump's ire for their presumed 'wokeness' or 'irrelevance' are either downgraded, tucked away or dissolved." To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Niehus refers to two changes she finds particularly disturbing: The transfer of the office of NATO's Special Representative for Women, Peace and Security (WPS) out of the secretary-general's office and the merger of the Climate and Energy Security Section with Defence Policy and Planning. She says these actions have been taken to "ensure lower visibility" of these issues. In Washington, DC, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has all but eliminated WPS programs at the Pentagon, and Trump is famously dismissive of efforts to combat climate change. Is it a coincidence that some of NATO's changes seem to mirror White House priorities? A senior NATO official who spoke on condition of anonymity insists the more dangerous security environment, not any single ally, has compelled the reorganization of staff structures. "The secretary-general, like his predecessors, wants to ensure that the NATO Headquarters is organized so that it can function efficiently and effectively," the official told DW, "That is the impetus behind this structural reform, which is not aimed at cutting costs or numbers of staff but at better aligning areas of work." Perhaps the most visible difference will be the shuttering of NATO's Public Diplomacy Division (PDD). This has traditionally housed NATO's press operations; co-sponsorship of projects on issues such as societal resilience, interaction with students and other visiting groups; and general outreach to citizens. Many people in PDD will need to find other positions, while some will see their functions move to other units. The press office will be put directly under the secretary-general and the spokesperson's office. The other division being cut is Executive Management, which covers a range of tasks from recruitment to the internship program to archives. NATO sources say the number of posts being cut is not huge, perhaps 40 overall, because others are being created at the same time. Meanwhile, they say, there are some 300 vacancies. But Niehus, who spent many years in NATO public diplomacy and engagement efforts, still finds the elimination of PDD and reassignment of remaining communications staff hard to fathom at a time when she believes the alliance should be working overtime to "foster informed discussions on NATO and wider defense matters in our societies." She also fears the co-sponsorship grants program, which works with think tanks, universities and other civil society initiatives, "will come to a grinding halt." This takes on added significance with the U.S. government having disbanded its USAID global humanitarian assistance agency, which also helped fund some of these activities and services. But the senior NATO official told DW that the alliance's outreach efforts will not diminish; rather, PDD is "being reshaped into a more focused office of strategic communications." Other changes likewise "all drive toward the same principle — better alignment so that we can deliver on the crucial work of the alliance." NATO sources say the grants program will not be ended, although there may be a temporary pause to allow the bureaucratic changes to take effect. One former US State Department diplomat, given anonymity to discuss their views, agrees with the critics that there are risks to this shake-up if funding or staffing for public outreach is downgraded. Having served in both NATO and European Union public diplomacy posts in Brussels and around the world, this retired official fears the changes seen at both NATO and in the US could further fuel alienation and apathy among the public, both in alliance territory and other parts of the world. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video The former official sees that happening in practice, for example, through long-distance conversations held at 5:30 a.m. once a week, as they continue mentoring a colleague posted in Asia. "My mentee told me that in her last conversation with her ambassador, she was considered 'failing' because the newspapers carried more about Australian assistance and Chinese assistance than American assistance," the retired official recounted, referring to the elimination of the USAID presence in this country. "She was 100% blamed for that. How are you supposed to win against the Chinese when we have nothing?" Back at NATO headquarters, regardless of whether it was an official order or not, some employees working in areas such as Women, Peace and Security and Climate have been encouraged not to make these parts of their job particularly visible. Several people have shared their experiences first-hand with this reporter. One prominent advocate on these issues, Hannah Neumann, a German Green member of the European Parliament, said she has similar stories from her NATO contacts. Neumann says she considers this "super frustrating because it doesn't make any sense from a purely scientific, security, political perspective.' However, she also emphasizes that it's essential to ensure that work on these topics keeps going. At present, she said she's been assured that this is happening — even if people have to change offices and keep their heads down to do it.
