Carson Beck: Preseason scouting report for the new Miami QB
At 6'4', 220 pounds, Beck has good size and a solid frame to stand tall in the pocket. He has good awareness in traffic and smooth enough feet to find open space. However, his average athleticism and speed get him in trouble, and his ball security in the pocket was an issue.
Beck is solidly average as a passer and is the quintessential 'high variance' quarterback. He's frustrating to watch because his flashes are so good, but his consistency isn't there.
Check out my full Carson Beck preseason report and grade on my Substack.
His arm strength is above average, as Beck can confidently rip it from a solid base. He knows how to put good touch on layered throws, but his accuracy, anticipation, and decision-making limit him.
Beck's processing is NFL-ready, but he's a beat late to get the ball out. Often, his throws end up in contested situations because he hesitates. This can be improved, but his anticipation is average right now.
In rhythm, Beck is reasonably accurate at all levels. However, his accuracy drops when he's off-platform or on the move. He's at his best in the short and intermediate areas, but he'll get loose with his ball placement when he doesn't have a solid base. He's dangerous with the ball outside the pocket, recklessly throwing into tight windows.
Beck's decision-making is the most disappointing aspect of his game. He threw 12 interceptions in 13 games last season, which could have easily been more. There are too many poor decisions to put faith in this guy.
He's a smart but adequate ball carrier who will take what the defense gives him, then go down to avoid a hit. Beck is not a running threat.
Beck has the arm strength and experience to play in the NFL, but his inconsistent accuracy, anticipation, and decision-making will limit him at the next level. How much better can he get after five years and two seasons starting at a high-level program?
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Washington Post
15 minutes ago
- Washington Post
NFLPA selects David White as interim executive director
The NFL Players Association took a bit of time but, with teams at training camps, moved to fill its leadership void from outside the union. Player representatives voted Sunday night to appoint David P. White the NFLPA's interim executive director. The election of White, the other finalist when the union elected Lloyd Howell in 2023, came 17 days after Howell's resignation a little more than two years into his term as executive director.
Yahoo
28 minutes ago
- Yahoo
NFL Veteran Rushed To Hospital After 'Illegal' Tackle At Practice Sunday
NFL Veteran Rushed To Hospital After 'Illegal' Tackle At Practice Sunday originally appeared on The Spun. A veteran member of the Colts backfield reportedly suffered a severe lower leg injury during Sunday's training camp practice after being taken down by an illegal hip-drop tackle during a live session. According to Stephen Holder of running back Salvon Ahmed was immediately taken to the hospital for X-rays after grabbing at his ankle in serious pain. Per the Colts beat reporter, Ahmed's ankle "was stuck in an awkward position" after being tackled from behind by undrafted free agent Trey Washington at the goal line and players immediately gathered around said a prayer for their teammate. The 26-year-old was then placed onto a stretcher and carted off the field. Head coach Shane Steichen talked about the situation during today's media session and explained how hard it can be to simultaneously manage injuries while also attempting to build a physical football team that's ready for the regular season. "Never want to see that happen," Steichen said. "I know we don't encourage hip-drop tackles. I know Trey's down in the dumps, and I don't think he's trying to do that. We're just trying to create an edge. ... Those [backups] are going to have to tackle come preseason." "I think training camp is where you want to create the edge and the toughness and the identity of your football team, so you have live periods," the coach explained. "There's a lot of thoughts going on in my head during that situation. I talked to some of the leaders on the team. We wanted to get that last 2-minute situation in. Felt that we needed that. They were on board with that." Ahmed also went undrafted out of Washington but caught on with the Miami Dolphins for four seasons before coming to Indy where he signed as a FA earlier this year. We certainly send our best to Ahmed and his family and hope he comes back stronger than Veteran Rushed To Hospital After 'Illegal' Tackle At Practice Sunday first appeared on The Spun on Aug 3, 2025 This story was originally reported by The Spun on Aug 3, 2025, where it first appeared.
Yahoo
42 minutes ago
- Yahoo
NFLPA hires David White as interim executive director, replacing Lloyd Howell
The NFL Players Association has a new leader. The NFLPA on Sunday night announced the hiring of David White to take over as the interim executive director in a move that was necessitated by the stunning resignation of Lloyd Howell Jr. on July 17. The Athletic's Dianna Russini reported that JC Tretter, the union's chief strategy officer, and Don Davis, the chief player officer, emerged as the lead candidates following Howell's departure. Tretter later resigned from his position. NFLPA CONTROVERSY EXPLAINED: What to know about grievances, Lloyd Howell, next steps One union official, who asked not to be identified because of the sensitivity of the situation, said that a voting player representative from all 32 teams participated in the Board vote. The person also said that on the final short list of candidates, there were multiple internal candidates and multiple external ones. The Board conducted interviews with each candidate over the last two weeks, and the process was player-led and voted on by the Board. The person also said that ultimately, the Board voted on their elected candidate this evening. NFLPA leadership initially expressed their support for Howell, but the fallout from the "Pablo Torre Finds Out" podcast's release of a 61-page arbitration report proved to be too much. The report revealed the NFLPA agreed to keep the arbitration decision from earlier this year about potential collusion by the league confidential – despite evidence that "commissioner Roger Goodell and former general counsel Jeff Pash instructed teams at the March 2022 league meeting to limit guaranteed money in players' contracts." Howell was later found to be a paid, part-time consultant for the private-equity firm The Carlyle Group since March 2023, as reported by ESPN. It highlighted a potential conflict of interest as the group was given approval by the NFL to seek a minority ownership stake in a team. More revelations regarding Howell's conduct have come to light following his resignation. On July 18, ESPN reported that Howell submitted expense reports charging the union for two visits to strip clubs. The former leader's controversial tenure was short-lived and came to an end just over two years following his hiring on June 28, 2023. Now White will be tasked with cleaning up the mess that was left behind in addition to restoring trust between the union and its membership. They won't have the luxury of time, however, as training camps are already underway and the regular season is fast approaching. NFL writer Chris Bumbaca contributed to this story. All the NFL news on and off the field. Sign up for USA TODAY's 4th and Monday newsletter. This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: NFLPA hires David White to replace Lloyd Howell
