logo
A necessary search winds down

A necessary search winds down

Opinion
It was the right thing to do. It was always the right thing to do. And most Manitobans knew it.
Early this week, Premier Wab Kinew visited the Prairie Green landfill to mark the end of the search for human remains at the site. He was joined by family members of Morgan Harris and Marcedes Myran, by supporters, and by people involved in the search for a ceremony and smudging.
The search was not completely a success — the family of Myran had hoped the search would find a larger part of her remains than were located, and wanted the search to include a larger area — but there is at least the consolation that Myran was found.
BROOK JONES / FREE PRESS
Prairie Green Landfill in the RM of Rosser, Man.
Watching the conclusion of this part of the search for the remains of victims of Jeremy Skibicki — a further search continues at the Brady landfill for Ashlee Shingoose — brings home how important the search was in the first place, and how dispiriting it was that the PC government of the day not only wouldn't launch a search, but actively campaigned on the decision not to search.
There have been plenty of apologies and admissions that the decision was a poor one since then: the Progressive Conservatives have apologized, the Winnipeg Police Service has said it regrets its decision to say that a search was not necessary, and the list goes on.
But what's surprising is that anyone ever thought the matter was up for political debate, that anyone felt that the potential cost of the search was a legitimate reason to say that two women should have their final resting place be a landfill.
Consider this.
George Mallory and Andrew (Sandy) Irvine disappeared while climbing Mount Everest in June of 1924, and there have been questions ever since about whether the pair had made it to the mountain's summit.
Mallory's remains were found in 1999, but nothing was found of Irvine until September, 2024, when a documentary team found a foot inside a boot and sock protruding from a melting glacier. The sock had a label with Irvine's name sewn on it, and the remains are being compared to the DNA of family members for final confirmation.
The film crew that found foot, sock and boot knew how important the discovery was — and not just for understanding more about the Mallory expedition.
'It's the first real evidence of where Sandy ended up,' Jimmy Chin, a National Geographic filmmaker, told National Geographic. 'When someone disappears and there's no evidence of what happened to them, it can be really challenging for families.'
Weekday Evenings
Today's must-read stories and a roundup of the day's headlines, delivered every evening.
Irvine's relative Julie Summers said was 'moved to tears' when she learnt of the boot's existence a report from the PA Media news agency said. 'I have lived with this story since I was a seven-year-old when my father told us about the mystery of Uncle Sandy on Everest.'
It's why we search for the lost. Because it matters.
Because it's important to family members to know what has happened to their relatives, and where those relatives rest. It matters days after someone disappears, and it matters 100 years later, and it continues to matter, no matter how many years pass. All of us should be able to try and put ourselves in others' shoes.
We search for the remains of those lost at sea, lost on land, lost in war and lost in terrorist attacks. Millions of dollars have been spent on all sorts of searches, from hunts for famous explorers and the remains of their expeditions — like those of the Franklin expedition — to searches for individuals who vanish from their vehicles in blizzards, seeking, and failing to find shelter.
Helping find the missing is part of being in the community that we call humanity.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

NDP questions PCs' pre-election ‘dark of night' $18-M rail port infrastructure grant
NDP questions PCs' pre-election ‘dark of night' $18-M rail port infrastructure grant

Winnipeg Free Press

time13 hours ago

  • Winnipeg Free Press

NDP questions PCs' pre-election ‘dark of night' $18-M rail port infrastructure grant

The provincial government is investigating why its predecessor did not publicize an $18-million contract that was finalized in the leadup to the 2023 election campaign. Finance Minister Adrien Sala confirmed Monday that the province — for the second time in three months — is looking into the Progressive Conservatives' dealings with JohnQ, an economic development corporation run by 12 municipalities in Manitoba. Under the leadership of then-premier Heather Stefanson, the PC government awarded a hefty grant to JohnQ in August 2023 to develop a regional rail port south of Winnipeg. MIKAELA MACKENZIE / FREE PRESS FILES Finance Minister Adrien Sala confirmed Monday that the province is looking into the Progressive Conservatives' dealings with JohnQ, an economic development corporation run by 12 municipalities in Manitoba. 'Why, in the dark of night, did the former government send $18 million out the door without any kind of an announcement or any type of press release?' Sala said Monday. 'That is something that should worry the average Manitoban.' The multimillion-dollar sum was spent on purchasing a plot of farmland located in the Rural Municipality of Ritchot for a future rail park. It also covered the cost of now-complete engineering and environmental assessments on the site west of Highway 75. Concerns about the brokering of that Aug. 29, 2023 deal have become 'more prominent' in recent weeks, Sala said. The finance minister did not elaborate on the timing of the inter-departmental probe that is underway in his office, as well as in the Transportation and Economic Development departments. Premier Wab Kinew's team wants to ensure taxpayers are getting 'good value for money,' he said, noting that proceeding with this project would involve costly infrastructure upgrades. Sala released JohnQ's last progress report, which is more than a year old; the July 10, 2024 document recommends modifications be made to nearby roadways and a ring dyke be constructed. 'The NDP's current fascination with JohnQ… is nothing more than a fishing expedition,' PC MLA Wayne Ewasko said in a statement. The representative for Lac du Bonnet has defended the former government's agreements with JohnQ to build a rail port and 22 stand-alone child-care facilities. The conglomerate was founded to promote collaboration and best practices when building infrastructure 'to avoid costly duplication,' added Ewasko. Deputy education minister Brian O'Leary flagged concerns about procurement processes related to the nearly $100-million 2022 child-care construction deal in a letter to the auditor general in April. Sala's office indicated the province has not requested the auditor general also look at the rail park deal, but that is a possibility if more information is not uncovered internally. JohnQ's chief executive officer said the 2023 agreement included 'clear deliverables and timelines' that have been met to date. 'The mayors and reeves who lead JohnQ view this as a significant opportunity for true regional collaboration and regional economic development,' Colleen Sklar said in a text. Sklar said her team is committed to working with all governments to move the rail port forward 'responsibly and transparently' within the parameters of current agreements. Citing confidentiality requirements, she declined to provide specific details about the project. Sala indicated that he is concerned about the former government's operations, rather than any specific vendor. Wednesdays A weekly dispatch from the head of the Free Press newsroom. 'Manitoba does stand to benefit from leaning into our central position and we certainly do see opportunities around us becoming a transportation-logistics hub here in Canada. However, whether or not this particular rail port has a role in that is not yet clear to us,' he said. The finance minister accused the PCs of having 'a record of questionable decision-making,' citing the Sio Silica scandal. Stefanson and two of her ex-cabinet ministers were recently found to have disregarded the caretaker convention after losing the 2023 election and attempting to approve a controversial sand mine. The 'JQ Rail Oversight Committee' was formed in October 2023, the same month as the last provincial election. Maggie MacintoshEducation reporter Maggie Macintosh reports on education for the Free Press. Originally from Hamilton, Ont., she first reported for the Free Press in 2017. Read more about Maggie. Funding for the Free Press education reporter comes from the Government of Canada through the Local Journalism Initiative. Every piece of reporting Maggie produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.

If Tories aren't careful, old yellow dog could learn new NDP tricks in rural byelection
If Tories aren't careful, old yellow dog could learn new NDP tricks in rural byelection

Winnipeg Free Press

time18 hours ago

  • Winnipeg Free Press

If Tories aren't careful, old yellow dog could learn new NDP tricks in rural byelection

Opinion If the stars align just so, they might end up calling this the 'Miracle of Spruce Woods.' Speculation has run rampant that Premier Wab Kinew has delayed calling a byelection in Spruce Woods to give the NDP a chance to steal a seat from the Progressive Conservatives. At first blush, it seems like an enormous long shot. Spruce Woods — vacated in March when MLA Grant Jackson resigned to run for the federal Conservatives in April's election — is located squarely in the heart of what PC supporters lovingly refer to as 'yellow dog' country. The term was reportedly first coined in the 1960s by a Tory who claimed the party could run a yellow dog in most western and southern Manitoba rural ridings and win. So entrenched are the PCs in some of these ridings that the NDP and Liberals rarely put up much of a fight. The Tories may still win the byelection — which, by law, must be held no later than Sept. 16 — but they will have to do it in the face of a stiffer-than-usual challenge from the governing NDP. Kinew's party is already feeling pretty unbeatable following the historic June 2024 byelection win in Tuxedo, the seat abandoned by former premier Heather Stefanson after after she led the PCs to a resounding defeat at the ballot box in October 2023. Now, NDP sources confirmed that Kinew and his strategists believe Spruce Woods could also be winnable, largely because of a series of forces and events that could conspire to weaken the PC brand. First off, there is the riding itself. The current version of Spruce Woods was formed out of parts of Minnedosa, Turtle Mountain and Arthur Virden — all yellow-dog ridings. But in a 2018 electoral boundaries redistribution, it also picked up polls from Brandon, which is more fertile ground for New Democrats. Then, there is the rising tide of far-right populism that has saturated some parts of southern and western Manitoba. The PCs were so concerned about the growing support for libertarian independents and fringe parties that they ventured way out on the far right of their policy spectrum in the 2023 general election. The Tories pinned their dim re-election hopes on pledges to stand firm against any search of the Prairie Green landfill to find the remains of Indigenous victims of a serial killer, and the vague pledge to support the mantra of 'parental rights' that was embraced by anti-LGBTTQ+ activists. While those policies could not stop the NDP in its march to a majority, some Tory strategists believe they helped retain seats in yellow-dog country. PC Leader Obby Khan has disowned both campaign planks, and while that may be good for the party's future fortunes in Winnipeg, it could have the opposite effect outside the Perimeter Highway. There are also issues to consider around the rather-ambiguous process that resulted in Khan's leadership victory. Under a new system that awarded points to a candidate based on the number of party members who actually voted in the leadership race, he prevailed over populist Wally Daudrich, who won the raw vote by 53 votes. The results suggested Daudrich had tapped into the far-right sensibilities of voters, some traditional PC voters and others who are farther right than the Manitoba Tories have been willing to go. Will Daudrich supporters show up to vote for a candidate running for a party led by Khan, the leader who many rural residents believe won on a technicality? Maybe, but maybe not. The business of byelections is much different than general elections. Campaigns get significantly less media attention and far fewer people show up to vote; in most byelections, total turnout is half or less than it would be in a general election. That means an upstart party, particularly one that is motivated and has the cash to conduct a blitz of the riding, needs fewer gross votes to win. Finally, there are questions surrounding the Tories' capacity to campaign in Spruce Woods. They are currently cash-poor, having spent heavily on a failed election effort. Parties that lose elections typically find it hard to raise money, and Manitoba's PCs are no different. Tuesdays A weekly look at politics close to home and around the world. It does not help that Khan has kept a decidedly low profile since the legislature rose for the summer. Party sources confirmed he has been immersed in pressing internal PC business and unable to get out to press the flesh with Manitobans. Khan is dealing with the need to hire a new party CEO, the impending sale of longtime PC Winnipeg headquarters at 23 Kennedy St. and finding a new generation of senior staff to support him in the months and years ahead. The Tories are understandably frustrated that Kinew has not yet called the byelection. However, the PCs need to move quickly to unknot their knickers so that they can get down to the business of bringing their 'A' game to Spruce Woods. Under current conditions, if they pause — even for a moment — to take voters in this riding for granted, this yellow dog could find a new owner. Dan LettColumnist Dan Lett is a columnist for the Free Press, providing opinion and commentary on politics in Winnipeg and beyond. Born and raised in Toronto, Dan joined the Free Press in 1986. Read more about Dan. Dan's columns are built on facts and reactions, but offer his personal views through arguments and analysis. The Free Press' editing team reviews Dan's columns before they are posted online or published in print — part of the our tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.

Letters, July 21
Letters, July 21

Winnipeg Free Press

timea day ago

  • Winnipeg Free Press

Letters, July 21

Opinion Energy plans Upon seeing the $7-billion price tag for upgrading the hydro system, my first thought was: how much dispersed hydro generation could that buy? And wouldn't that be safer than having so many of our energy eggs in one vulnerable basket? This reminds me of a few years ago when one of the Hydro honchos essentially told us they were in the hydro power business, not the wind and solar power business. My thought then was that a more responsible stance would be to consider themselves to be in the electric energy business — for Manitoba — whatever the source. Indeed, new power technology options are being developed every day. Our myopic reliance on giant hydro plants and long, long transmission corridors might very well become non-primary technology. And the most vulnerable option for our province. I may be missing something in all this, but I am not confident that Hydro has embraced a power generation worldview that isn't literally water/hydro powered. And I still wonder what's their vision on power generation beyond that? And as a Crown corporation, what's their sense of their role and responsibility in all this? Dan O'Dell Winnipeg The detailed analysis in the Free Press confirms what many Manitobans have long suspected but few in government have had the courage to address: Manitoba Hydro is teetering on the edge of a financial precipice. The staggering $20-billion debt load, combined with poor governance, lack of strategic vision, and politically manipulated rates, has created a dangerous imbalance — one that now threatens the financial health of both the utility and the province itself. Projects like Keeyask and Bipole III have ballooned in cost and delivered questionable value. Meanwhile, repeated political interference — from rate suppression to board turnover — has left Hydro rudderless, unable to make sound long-term decisions or invest wisely in future infrastructure. Let's not be misled: low rates have neither attracted major employers nor benefited taxpayers in the long run. In fact, they have effectively masked inefficiencies and delayed a necessary shift toward demand management, conservation, and green energy innovation. The result? Nearly $1 billion in annual interest payments and mounting risk of a credit downgrade. It is time to stop treating Hydro as a political tool and start governing it like the complex, high-stakes utility it is. That means restoring board independence, grounding rate decisions in economic reality, and holding Hydro leadership accountable for productivity and fiscal discipline. Manitobans deserve transparency, not talking points. Yog Rahi Gupta Winnipeg Blending faith and science Re: 100 years later, the Scopes 'Monkey Trial' still resonates (Think Tank, July 17) It is true, as Allan Levine argues, that the supposed conflict between science and the Bible still resonates today. One reason for this is that in our polarized world we tend to view reality through one lens only while excluding other explanations. This too often puts science on the scrimmage line against a particular understanding of the Bible. But science and the Bible, properly understood, are not opposing explanations; they complement one another. Science can be understood as a kind of map with its own way of describing reality. But a map of Canada does not exhaust our understanding of Canada. The Canadian Museum for Human Rights argues that all persons are created with equal dignity and rights. Science can help us understand this conviction, but we need something beyond the maps of science to more fully grasp it. And we need an understanding of the Bible other than creationism in order to engage science with integrity. Yes, this issue does have to do with life's meaning. Ray Harris Winnipeg Talk elsewhere Re: 'Hold your conversation' (Letters, July 15) Bravo to letter writer Ken McLean for voicing the concern that many of us have at live performances and in particular at the Winnipeg Folk Festival. If you must have a conversation, please take it away from the seating area where other people are trying to listen to the performance. Don't just raise your voice so that your friend can hear you above the performer. And, if someone asks you to take your chat elsewhere, please don't look at them as if you're the one who's being inconvenienced. Don Sourisseau Winnipeg Water bill too high We are all enjoying the wonderful summer so far, being at the lake, travelling or at home. If you are living in a house particularly in Winnipeg, please look at your recent water bill statement from the water and waste department. You might be surprised that an unexpected high water bill arrived to be paid within a period of time. Wow! Why am I paying such a high amount for water for a three-month period, I ask myself. What's with this statement? Is the amount due, correct? Is there a possibility of a calculated error? I called the water department recently. Their reply to my question: the city is building a new treatment plant, therefore we need revenue to complete the project. As I see it, to compensate for any losses in construction of this endeavour, Winnipeggers will cover the deficit. From December of 2024 to June of 2025, my water bill has increased by 15 per cent. Why such an increase? If you look at your water bill, the sewer cost ratio is probably almost twice in comparison to the water usage. Did your area have any sewer upgrades? If it did, then the increase justifies the water bill amount. My area hasn't had any sewer work done to substantiate an increase in fees. As Winnipeggers, we are being bombarded this year with a property tax increase, garbage collection increase and a water bill increase, 'three strikes' and many people are out financially. This is unreasonable and unsustainable. Grocery prices are skyrocketing, inflation is growing and imposed tariffs have a negative impact on our economy. Tremendous strain on the citizens of Winnipeg. What is next to swallow? My recommendation to the city, to alleviate the burden of paying the high water bills, is to introduce the same format that Manitoba Hydro operates on, pay monthly not quarterly. People would be able to budget and manage their financial monthly household expense, not get burdened with astronomical water bills. Peter John Manastyrsky Winnipeg Well wishes for columnist Re: Finally at a loss for an opinion (Think Tank, July 12) I am certain I join many readers of these pages in saying a heartfelt 'thank you' to professor Paul Thomas for the huge contribution his thoughtful columns have brought to the public issues of our times. His was always an informative and well-researched voice. I wish him well. Paul Moist Winnipeg

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store