How did global ad giants allegedly collude to fix prices in India's media market?
Watchdog reviews ad executives' WhatsApp chats detailing coordination
Meeting records show ad executives celebrated pricing pact
Regulator determined on initial basis that conduct breached competition law
NEW DELHI, June 20 — Omnicom Media's India chief was frustrated. It was October 5, 2023 and a rival was trying to poach the US firm's client by offering lower prices, just weeks after global advertising agencies and broadcasters struck secret pacts on ad rates in the South Asian country.
The attempt to woo the client violated the agencies' agreement, Omnicom Media's India CEO Kartik Sharma wrote in a WhatsApp group comprising a who's who of advertising, according to excerpts of the discussion documented by antitrust investigators and verified by Reuters.
'This kind of practice is not in the spirit of what we are collectively trying to achieve,' Sharma wrote, without identifying the parties.
Shashi Sinha, then India CEO of New York-based IPG Mediabrands, suggested an industry group should 'admonish the agency'.
The exchanges form part of a confidential dossier compiled by India's antitrust watchdog that chronicles how global advertising companies, including leading US and European firms, coordinated to rig prices in the world's most populous nation.
Reuters reviewed evidence from the Competition Commission of India (CCI) investigation, including a 10-page document with messages and records of meetings between top advertising executives, and two industry agreements under scrutiny for antitrust violations; and interviewed two people familiar with the probe. The key details, which haven't been previously reported, centre on WhatsApp interactions involving 11 industry executives. They include the top India or South Asia executives of WPP's GroupM; US-based Omnicom Media and Interpublic's IPG Mediabrands; France's Publicis and Havas Media; Japan's Dentsu and India's Madison World.
Over WhatsApp and in meetings, the executives coordinated responses to clients, which 'resulted in alignment of competing advertising agencies,' CCI officials said in the August 9 dossier, determining on an initial basis that the conduct contravened competition law.
The firms agreed to cooperate on pricing, including not to undercut each other; colluded with broadcasters to deny business to agencies that didn't comply; and discussed financial terms involving at least four Indian clients over conference calls, according to the investigation documents.
The documents don't indicate whether the agencies' foreign headquarters were aware of the executives' actions.
A spokesperson for WPP Media, which until May was known as GroupM, told Reuters it was aware of the investigation but declined to comment further. A Dentsu India spokesperson confirmed Reuters reporting that it had disclosed industry practices to the CCI in February 2024 under the regulator's leniency programme, which enables lesser penalties for firms that share evidence of malpractice. The spokesperson didn't address specific evidence raised in the dossier but said the firm had implemented stricter audits and controls.
The other agencies and their executives didn't respond to Reuters questions about the antitrust probe and information in the dossier. The regulator also didn't respond to queries. Reuters has reported that in March, as part of the continuing investigation, the regulator raided the Indian offices of many advertising firms and an industry group that represents broadcasters, including the Reliance-Disney venture and Sony.
CCI investigations typically take several months. The regulator can't press criminal charges, but can impose financial penalties on the media agencies of up to three times their profit or 10 per cent of an Indian entity's global turnover, whichever is higher, for each year of wrongdoing.
Omnicom Group and Interpublic Group logos are seen in this illustration taken December 9, 2024. — Reuters pic
Secret pacts
WPP Media, the world's largest media buying agency, last year — when it was still known as GroupM — won new India business worth US$447 million, followed by Omnicom's US$183 million, according to research firm COMvergence.
But India's near-US$30 billion media and entertainment sector is grappling with weak consumer sentiment. Ad spending will rise 7 per cent to US$19 billion in 2025, the slowest growth in three years, according to GroupM estimates.
The CCI is investigating the role of two industry bodies, the Advertising Agencies Association of India (AAAI) and the Indian Broadcasting & Digital Foundation (IBDF), in orchestrating the suspected cartel.
The former group is led by WPP Media India head Prasanth Kumar, while the broadcasting body's president is Kevin Vaz, a top Reliance-Disney venture executive. Neither industry group responded to requests for comment.
The dossier shows the AAAI circulated guidelines to ad agencies in August 2023: They must charge clients whose annual spending exceeds US$29 million a minimum 3 per cent commission for digital ads and 2.5 per cent for traditional media. Lower-spending clients would pay higher minimum commissions of up to 8 per cent.
A month later, the industry associations entered a joint pact, agreeing no agency would 'unilaterally offer any discount' on rates while pitching for business.
The pact, reviewed by Reuters, declared its aim was to eliminate 'lower pricing as a reason to award a pitch'.
The advertising firms began coordinating their activities at least as early as August 2023, according to the CCI documents.
Ad executives who met on December 1 that year hailed their collaboration as a 'great success' and resolved to continue, according to meeting minutes cited in the CCI's evidence.
'All aligned'
In the US, the Federal Trade Commission this month sought information from advertising agencies as part of a probe into whether they coordinated boycotts of certain sites. The Justice Department in 2016 probed agencies it suspected of rigging bids to favour in-house units, but eventually closed the case without bringing charges. Brewer Anheuser-Busch InBev used CCI's leniency programme to blow the whistle on an industry cartel in India in 2017.
In the case of the ad industry, Dentsu India told Reuters it filed its leniency application with the CCI not as a reaction to external pressure but out of a decision to 'support reform from within'.
Two people with knowledge of the matter told Reuters the evidence Dentsu submitted included a transcript of the WhatsApp group. The group, formed in August 2023 and reviewed in part by Reuters, was named 'AAAI media agencies' and contained scores of chat messages.
Participants included Kumar of WPP's media company, Sharma of Omnicom Media, IPG Mediabrands' Sinha, Havas Media India CEO Mohit Joshi, Dentsu South Asia CEO Harsha Razdan and then-media business CEO Anita Kotwani, Publicis South Asia chief Anupriya Acharya and Madison boss Sam Balsara, the investigators' evidence shows.
Members of the group discussed advertising pitches and coordinated on interactions with clients such as food delivery giant Swiggy, drug maker Cipla, SoftBank-backed e-commerce firm Meesho, and Kshema Insurance.
In Swiggy's case, the AAAI arranged a Zoom call with media agency heads to discuss the company's advertising pitch. Later, GroupM's Kumar, as AAAI president, suggested an email response to Swiggy explaining the industry's agreed position on rebates.
'Ok all aligned thanks,' he wrote after a consensus emerged.
Kshema told Reuters the insurer was unaware of the matter. The other clients didn't respond to questions.
During another discussion on client rebates, an unspecified Dentsu executive told rivals over WhatsApp that 'the lowest we go to is retain 30 per cent and 70 per cent we pass back to the client,' according to the CCI dossier.
CCI officials noted in the document that advertisers and the broadcasters' group had sought to penalise enterprises that didn't comply with the pricing pacts.
In an email to Walt Disney in August 2023, Kumar wrote that broadcasters should refrain from granting business to a firm that had breached the pacts, ITW Consulting, though he said it had later agreed not to approach clients directly.
ITW didn't respond to Reuters questions. Tensions heated up again over WhatsApp three months later.
Sharma, of Omnicom Media, learned that ITW had done another 'direct deal with a client of ours' for advertising on streaming platform Hotstar, which was run by Disney.
This irked Sharma, as Hotstar had the rights for the cricket World Cup held in India at the time.
'This nuisance has to stop,' he wrote in the group. — Reuters
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
3 minutes ago
- New Straits Times
India equity benchmarks track Asian peers higher after US-Japan deal
MUMBAI: India's equity benchmarks opened higher on Wednesday, tracking gains in their Asian peers after the US announced a trade deal with Japan, fuelling expectations of more to come. However, the prevailing uncertainty over India-US interim trade deal ahead of President Donald Trump's August 1 deadline limited gains in the Indian market. The Nifty 50 rose 0.22 per cent to 25,122.75 points and the BSE Sensex added 0.30 per cent to 82,430.50 as of 9:15am IST. All the major sectoral indexes logged gains. The broader small-caps and mid-caps traded flat. Japanese shares led the rally in Asian equities on Wednesday following the trade deal announcement. MSCI's broadest index for Asia-Pacific stocks outside Japan also advanced 0.7 per cent. The prospects of an interim trade deal between India and the US before Washington's August 1 deadline have dimmed, with talks deadlocked over tariff cuts on key agricultural and dairy products, Reuters reported, citing two Indian government sources.
Malay Mail
5 hours ago
- Malay Mail
Without papers: Ghost lives of millions of Pakistanis
KARACHI, July 23 — Ahmed Raza is invisible in the eyes of his government, unable to study or work because, like millions of other Pakistanis, he lacks identification papers. In the South Asian nation of more than 240 million people, parents generally wait until a child begins school at the age of five to obtain a birth certificate, which is required for enrolment in most parts of Pakistan. Raza slipped through the cracks until the end of elementary school, but when his middle school requested documentation, his mother had no choice but to withdraw him. 'If I go looking for work, they ask for my ID card. Without it, they refuse to hire me,' said the 19-year-old in the megacity of Karachi, the southern economic capital. He has already been arrested twice for failing to present identification cards when stopped by police at checkpoints. Raza's mother Maryam Suleman, who is also unregistered, said she 'didn't understand the importance of having identity documents'. 'I had no idea I would face such difficulties later in life for not being registered,' the 55-year-old widow told AFP from the single room she and Raza share. Pakistan launched biometric identification cards in 2000 and registration is increasingly required in all aspects of formal life, especially in cities. In 2021, the National Database and Registration Authority estimated that around 45 million people were not registered. They have declined to release updated figures or reply to AFP despites repeated requests. To register, Raza needs his mother's or uncle's documents—an expensive and complex process at their age, often requiring a doctor, lawyer or a newspaper notice. The paperwork, he says, costs up to US$165 (RM698.40) —a month and a half's income for the two of them, who earn a living doing housework and odd jobs in a grocery shop. Locals whisper that registration often requires bribes, and some suggest the black market offers a last resort. 'Our lives could have been different if we had our identity cards,' Raza said. 'No time or money' In remote Punjab villages like Rajanpur, Unicef is trying to prevent people from falling into the same fate as Raza. They conduct door-to-door registration campaigns, warning parents that undocumented children face higher risks of child labour and forced marriage. Currently, 58 percent of children under five have no birth certificate, according to government figures. Registration fees depend on the province, ranging from free, $0.70 to $7 -- still a burden for many Pakistanis, about 45 percent of whom live in poverty. 'Our men have no time or money to go to the council and miss a day's work,' said Nazia Hussain, mother of two unregistered children. The 'slow process' often requires multiple trips and there is 'no means of transport for a single woman,' she said. Saba, from the same village, is determined to register her three children, starting with convincing her in-laws of its value. 'We don't want our children's future to be like our past. If children go to school, the future will be brighter,' said Saba, who goes by just one name. Campaigns in the village have resulted in an increase of birth registration rates from 6.1 per cent in 2018 to 17.7 per cent in 2024, according to Unicef. This will improve the futures of an entire generation, believes Zahida Manzoor, child protection officer at Unicef, dispatched to the village. 'If the state doesn't know that a child exists, it can't provide basic services,' she said. 'If a child does not have an identity, it means the state has not recognised their existence. The state is not planning for the services that the child will need after birth.' Muhammad Haris and his brothers, who have few interactions with the formal state in their border village in the mountainous province of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, have not registered any of their eight children. 'The government asks for documents for the pilgrimage visa to Mecca,' a journey typically made after saving for a lifetime, he told AFP. For him, this is the only reason worthy of registration. — AFP
Malaysian Reserve
2 days ago
- Malaysian Reserve
Hindustan Zinc beats consensus, backed by all-time high silver prices and first quarter lowest cost of production
UDAIPUR, India, July 21, 2025 /PRNewswire/ — India-based Hindustan Zinc Limited, a Vedanta Group company and the world's largest integrated zinc producer, announced its financial results for the first quarter ended 30th June 2025 on 18th July 2025. The company registered its highest ever first quarter mined metal production of 265 KT. Also, the company clocked record quarterly alloy production from subsidiary Hindustan Zinc Alloys (HZAPL), taking overall share of value-added products to c.24%. The company registered the lowest ever first quarter zinc cost of production (COP)^ at US$ 1,010/MT, better 9% YoY. The company delivered a profit, beating estimates to US$ 261 million with an industry leading EBITDA margin of c.50%. Hindustan Zinc, amongst the top five silver producers globally, has witnessed continued significant contribution from the silver segment to profitability at c.41%. During the quarter, the company secured two critical mineral blocks, Potash in Rajasthan and Rare Earth Elements (REEs) in Uttar Pradesh. In the same period, the company's renewable energy consumption increased to c. 19%, on track to progressively achieve 70% by FY28. Along with that, Hindustan Zinc's Board approved the first phase of plans towards doubling production capacity with an investment of US$ 1.4 billion to set up a new 250 KTPA integrated smelting complex alongside similar expansion of mines & mills capacities. Historically, Hindustan Zinc has maintained investment grade rating 'AAA' and recently received ratings reaffirmation at CRISIL AAA/Stable/CRISIL A1+. Arun Misra, Chief Executive Officer, said: 'Delivering our highest-ever first quarter mined metal production at the lowest-ever zinc cost of production reflects our relentless focus on operational efficiencies and cost leadership. We have further strengthened our growth pipeline with Board approved Phase-1 of plans towards doubling the production capacity. Coupled with the addition of critical minerals blocks and rare earth elements, we are poised to transform into a multi-metal powerhouse, unlocking sustained value for our stakeholders.' USD-INR rate is 85.57^since underground transition About Hindustan Zinc Limited Hindustan Zinc Limited, a Vedanta Group company, is the world's largest integrated zinc producer and recognized as the world's most sustainable metals & mining company by the S&P Global CSA 2024. Disclaimer This release contains forward-looking statements that may differ from actual results. We undertake no obligation to update them. Photo:
