Supreme Court dismisses Hyatt International Southwest Asia's appeal in tax case
Remove Ads
The particulars of the SC order:
It is undisputed that the appellant's executives and employees paid frequent and regular visits to India to oversee operations and implement these so and so.
The finding of the assessing officer, based on travelogues and job functions, established continuous and coordinated engagement, even though no single individual exceeded the nine month stay the threshold under article 521.
The relevant consideration is continuity of business presence in aggregate, not the length of the stay of each individual employee.
Once it is found that there is continuity in the business operations, the intermittent presence or return of a particular employee becomes immaterial and An insignificant in determining the existence of a permanent establishment.
The High Court was correct in concluding that the appellant's role was not confined to high level decision making, but extended to substantial operational control and implementation.
The appellant's ability to enforce compliance, oversee operations, and derive profit linked fee from the hotel's earnings, demonstrate a clear and continuous commercial nexus, and control with the hotel's core functions.
This nexus satisfies the condition necessary for the constitution of a fixed place. Permanent establishment.
In view of the foregoing analysis, we affirm the finding of the High Court that the appellant has a fixed place of permanent establishment in India within the meaning of article 51, and that the income received under the zone so attributable to such be and is therefore taxable in India.
In a ruling that has significant implications for MNCs operating in India through permanent establishment (PE), the Supreme Court Thursday held that the income of Indian PE of UAE-headquartered Hyatt International Southwest Asia would be taxed as a distinct entity even if the global entity incurred losses.The court said there is no merit in Hyatt 's appeals. The company had argued that since it had suffered a loss at the entity level, no income should be attributable to the PE in India.A bench led by Justice JB Pardiwala dismissed the appeals filed by Hyatt against the Delhi High Court decision which held that the Indian PE of Hyatt International must be treated as a distinct entity for tax purposes.The apex court said that on the basis of all the materials available on record, Hyatt is a permanent establishment, so tax procedures are applicable to it.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
26 minutes ago
- Mint
Indian shares inch lower as Kotak earnings drag financials, trade deal delay weighs
By Bharath Rajeswaran and Vivek Kumar M (Reuters) -Indian shares inched lower on Monday as weak results from Kotak Mahindra Bank weighed on sentiment, while uncertainty over trade talks with the U.S. added to overall caution. The Nifty 50 fell 0.16% to 24,798.9 points and the BSE Sensex lost 0.2% to 81,325.4 as of 10:03 a.m. IST. The broader small-caps and mid-caps lost 0.3% and 0.2%, respectively. Negotiations between India and the United States remained deadlocked over tariff cuts on agriculture and dairy products, dimming hopes of an interim deal ahead of U.S. President Donald Trump's August 1 deadline. This is in contrast to a framework trade agreement struck between the U.S. and European Union over the weekend, easing fears of a bigger trade war between the two allies, which account for almost a third of global trade. High-weightage financials and private banks lost 0.2% and 1%, respectively, dragged by a 7% fall in Kotak Mahindra Bank after it posted a drop in quarterly profit. The IT index lost 0.5%, with Tata Consultancy Services shedding 1.6% after it announced plans to reduce its workforce by 2% in fiscal year 2026. The Nifty 50 and 30-stock Sensex have logged four consecutive weekly losses due to weak earnings, foreign outflows and uncertainty over the U.S.-India trade deal. "A dull earnings season and the lingering delay in the India-U.S. trade deal have clearly cast a shadow on market sentiment. With valuations still stretched across the board, investors are understandably treading with heightened caution," said G Chokkalingam, founder and head of research at Equinomics Research. Among individual stocks, Mphasis gained 2.4% on posting quarterly results in-line with estimates and on strong deal bookings, which has boosted the IT company's revenue growth outlook. SBI Cards and Payment Services lost 3.7% after missing profit estimates in the June quarter. (Reporting by Vivek Kumar M and Bharath Rajeswaran; Editing by Eileen Soreng and Mrigank Dhaniwala)
Economic Times
26 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Market in consolidation mode; triggers needed, says Sunil Subramaniam
Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads "Another reason for pharma's past underperformance is that FIIs were driving the selling pressure. They closely track export-oriented sectors. So the recent post-results bounce in pharma is largely driven by DIIs. FIIs still haven't firmed up their stance on India. They remain a bit cautious, especially because the delay in the BTA (Bilateral Trade Agreement) hasn't helped sentiment," says Sunil Subramaniam , Market like you said, the question is—why were they under pressure in the first place? I'd call it the Trump effect. Mr. Trump has been talking a lot about imposing heavy pharma tariffs. He hasn't actually done anything yet, but every time he makes such statements, it creates nervousness—whether he's targeting CDMO players or generics, and how he plans to go about it. That uncertainty has impacted the pharma sector, putting it under when individual companies are reporting good numbers, the market has no choice but to buy into them—because at least those companies are indicating a positive outlook. Plus, some of them may not even be impacted by tariffs, creating a window of opportunity. Also, the pharma space includes domestic-oriented businesses like hospitals and diagnostics, which are unaffected by U.S. tariff issues. So overall, pharma remains a defensive reason for pharma's past underperformance is that FIIs were driving the selling pressure. They closely track export-oriented sectors. So the recent post-results bounce in pharma is largely driven by DIIs. FIIs still haven't firmed up their stance on India. They remain a bit cautious, especially because the delay in the BTA (Bilateral Trade Agreement) hasn't helped we need to understand the market's movement over the last three months. Post-March, FIIs were actually buyers in April and May, and even in June, though to a lesser extent. Meanwhile, if you look at the end of March, mutual fund DIIs—especially domestic mutual funds—had built up cash positions to around 7.25% of their April and May, both mutual funds and FIIs were buying, which supported the market. But starting this month, mutual fund cash levels are back down to around 5%, which is close to their lower limit. That means DIIs don't have as much cash left to deploy, apart from the fresh SIP looking at last earnings season and market levels, domestic funds have largely deployed their cash. FIIs, on the other hand, had expected some action around the BTA by July 9, which then got pushed to August 1. But now, even that deadline seems unlikely to be met. The Indian trade delegation has returned from the U.S. without a deal. Sticking points remain—like agriculture—and they won't be easy to the question now is whether Trump will extend the 10% tariff pause beyond August 1 or slap a 26% tariff on India and then negotiate, like he did with Japan—imposing higher tariffs first and then signing a deal at 19%. That kind of uncertainty around the India-U.S. BTA is keeping FIIs factor is China. While China and the U.S. haven't signed a full BTA either, they seem to have reached some understanding. Meanwhile, China's markets have been beaten down so much that the one-year forward P/E is around 11—compared to India's 22. And China's economy is about 4.5 times larger than India's. Even at 4% growth, those are big numbers. So FIIs are starting to see more value in China, pulling some attention away from as for your question on the next trigger—clearly, a breakthrough on the BTA front, like an interim deal or assurance that tariffs will be capped below 20%, could bring FIIs back. On the domestic side, it's the ongoing earnings season. Results have been mixed. The IT sector, for instance, didn't post terrible earnings, but weak guidance is weighing heavily, especially in the absence of FII DIIs have already used most of their cash, their incremental buying will depend on the inflow from SIPs and earnings results. So companies with strong earnings and forward guidance will likely get DII if the early festival season gives good signs on the consumption front, that could also be a positive trigger. Until then, expect the market to remain in a sideways, consolidative phase for some time.
Economic Times
26 minutes ago
- Economic Times
India bonds may continue to see selling pressure at start of week
Indian government bonds are likely to see persistent selling pressure in early deals on Monday, as sentiment remains cautious after the benchmark bond yield rose above a key level in the previous session. ADVERTISEMENT The yield on the benchmark 10-year bond is likely to move between 6.33% and 6.37%, a trader at a private bank said, after closing at 6.3505% on Friday - the highest level since May 9. "Traders are losing interest and not building fresh positions, and hence we witnessed a large selloff after the debt auction on Friday," the trader said. The Reserve Bank of India sold 300 billion rupees ($3.47 billion) of the benchmark 2035 bond on Friday, the cutoff for which was in line with estimates, but the note witnessed selling pressure after the result was announced. Selling was exacerbated after the RBI governor's comments curbed expectations for rate easing, prompting those who were betting on an August cut to pare positions. ADVERTISEMENT Sanjay Malhotra said monetary policy, being forward-looking, will place greater focus on the outlook for growth and inflation, rather than their current levels, when the policy panel meets on August 6. Malhotra added that the bar for further easing is higher than it would have been if the stance was accommodative, though the RBI still has the flexibility to move the rates up, down or pause. ADVERTISEMENT A plunge in India's retail inflation to a more than six-year low and expectations that it will slip to a record low in July have led to increased talk of a rate cut in August. ADVERTISEMENT India's overnight index swap rates rose on Friday, as market participants trimmed rate cut bets for next week. The one-year OIS rate ended at 5.53% on Friday and the two-year OIS rate ended at 5.51%. The liquid five-year OIS rate settled at 5.73%. KEY INDICATORS: ** Benchmark Brent crude futures were 0.4% higher at $68.70 per barrel after easing 1.1% in the previous session ** Ten-year U.S. Treasury yield at 4.3938%; two-year yield at 3.9296% ($1 = 86.4750 Indian rupees). (You can now subscribe to our ETMarkets WhatsApp channel)
