logo
Should Rishabh Pant be allowed a batting sub? Parthiv Patel weighs in on ICC rule

Should Rishabh Pant be allowed a batting sub? Parthiv Patel weighs in on ICC rule

India Today2 days ago
Former Indian wicketkeeper Parthiv Patel has said that while Rishabh Pant's injury during the Manchester Test is unfortunate, there is nothing wrong with the ICC's rule that prevents replacement wicketkeepers from batting. If Dhruv Jurel replaces Pant in the fourth Test, he will be allowed to keep wickets but will not be permitted to bat.As per Section 24.1.2 of the ICC playing conditions, 'a substitute shall not bowl [or bat] or act as captain but may act as wicket-keeper only with the consent of the umpires.' Since 2017, the MCC has allowed substitute wicketkeepers in cases of genuine injury or illness, provided the on-field umpires approve it.'advertisement'I am okay with the rule'Patel, who played 25 Tests in his career from 2002 to 2018, said that since teams often try to exploit the concussion substitute rule, the ICC's regulations regarding wicketkeeper replacements is fair.
'See, there are already quite a few grey areas that teams try to exploit. Like in T20 cricket, we've seen how the concussion rule is sometimes taken advantage of. So, in an ongoing game, if someone gets injured, what do you do?' JioHotstar expert, Parthiv Patel said while replying to India Today's query.'I think it's only fair. At least now, the rule has changed so that a wicketkeeper can be replaced by another wicketkeeper. Earlier, that wasn't even allowed - someone else from the team would have had to keep wickets.'But I'm okay with the rule. It's unfortunate that Rishabh got hit, but it is what it is. What can you do about it? Parthiv added.On Day 1, Pant sustained a painful blow on his toe while trying to play a reverse scoop off Chris Woakes. After being hit, he winced in pain and received treatment. But he failed to recover and had to be taken off the ground. Later, he was carried off in an ambulance. Pant was batting on 37 off 48 balls with two fours and one six.After the day's play, the BCCI released a statement saying that Pant was under the observation of the Indian team's medical staff.Pant had scored 37 runs off 48 balls, including two fours and a six, before retiring hurt.India ended Day 1 at 264 for 4, with Yashasvi Jaiswal and Sai Sudharsan both scoring fifties.- EndsTune InMust Watch
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

WTT Contender Lagos: Sathiyan-Akash pair wins men's doubles title; Sreeja loses to Hashimoto
WTT Contender Lagos: Sathiyan-Akash pair wins men's doubles title; Sreeja loses to Hashimoto

First Post

time15 minutes ago

  • First Post

WTT Contender Lagos: Sathiyan-Akash pair wins men's doubles title; Sreeja loses to Hashimoto

Sathiyan Gnanasekaran and Akash Pal defeated the French pair of Leo De Nodrest and Julles Rolland in straight games in just under 22 minutes to be crowned men's doubles champions in Lagos. read more Sathiyan Gnanasekaran and Akash Pal pose with their trophies after being crowned men's doubles champions at the WTT Contender event in Lagos, Nigeria. Image credit: Reliance Foundation India's Sathiyan Gnanasekaran and Akash Pal won the men's doubles title beating French pair of Leo De Nodrest and Julles Rolland in straight games in just under 22 minutes at the WTT Contender event in Lagos, Nigeria on Saturday. However, ace woman paddler Sreeja Akula went down 1-4 to second seed Honoka Hashimoto in a 48-minute battle. Hashimoto won 11-7, 11-3, 11-4, 9-11, 13-11 in a hard-fought encounter. Sreeja didn't find her rhythm in the first three games as she was nearly down and out in just 20 minutes, losing three games on trot. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD However, she fought back winning the fourth game and also took the fifth game to the tie-breaker. Earlier, Indian men's doubles pair brushed aside the challenge from the French in quick time winning 11-9, 11-4, 11-9 at the Sir Molade Okoya Thomas Indoor Sports Hall in the Nigerian capital. More from Sports Belgian GP: Lando Norris seals pole position after Max Verstappen wins sptrint The Indian pair dominated the summit clash from start to finish winning 19 points on their own service and another 14 on the opposition serve.

China Open 2025: Satwiksairaj, Chirag Shetty lose to familiar foes in semifinals
China Open 2025: Satwiksairaj, Chirag Shetty lose to familiar foes in semifinals

India Today

time15 minutes ago

  • India Today

China Open 2025: Satwiksairaj, Chirag Shetty lose to familiar foes in semifinals

Former World No. 1 and India's top-ranked men's doubles pair, Satwiksairaj Rankireddy and Chirag Shetty, crashed out of the China Open, a Super 1000 tournament held in Changzhou, on Saturday. The Indian duo lost in straight games to World No. 2 Aaron Chia and Soh Wooi Yik of Malaysia, 13-21, 17-21, in under an was a subdued performance from the Indian stars, who had displayed impressive form en route to the semi-finals. The Malaysian pair dominated proceedings from start to finish, never allowing Satwik and Chirag-renowned for their explosive style-any space to settle or build momentum. In both games, the Indians were constantly on the back foot, unable to mount any sustained pressure on their defeat marked their third consecutive loss to Aaron and Soh, who continue to be a significant obstacle for the Indian pair. Of the 14 meetings between the two pairs, the Malaysians have emerged victorious 11 times. Notably, one of their most painful defeats came in the quarter-finals of the Tokyo Olympics in 2021. Satwik and Chirag are now enduring a title drought spanning over a year. Although they started the 2025 season strongly-reaching the semi-finals of both the Malaysia Masters and the India Open-a title still eludes them. Their most recent victory came in May 2024, when they clinched a Super 500 crown in Thailand. Their 2024 season was marred by injury concerns, following a disappointing show in the Paris the setback, the Indian duo can draw positives from yet another strong showing at the Super 1000 level. They booked their place in the semi-finals with a hard-fought win over the Malaysian pair Ong Yew Sin and Teo Ee Yi in the quarter-finals on has been a year of consistent results for the pair, who also reached the semi-finals at the India Open, Singapore Open, and Malaysia Open earlier in the RESULTS IN SINGELSMeanwhile, in the women's singles draw, India's PV Sindhu was knocked out in the Round of 16 by 17-year-old compatriot Unnati Hooda. However, the teenager's run ended in the quarter-finals, where she was defeated in straight games by former world champion Akane the men's singles, there was further disappointment as Lakshya Sen exited in the first round, while HS Prannoy bowed out in the second round. (With PTI inputs)- EndsMust Watch

Jasprit Bumrah's awkward action hard to sustain, but keeps delivering: Kapil Dev
Jasprit Bumrah's awkward action hard to sustain, but keeps delivering: Kapil Dev

India Today

time28 minutes ago

  • India Today

Jasprit Bumrah's awkward action hard to sustain, but keeps delivering: Kapil Dev

India's first World Cup-winning captain, Kapil Dev, has backed Jasprit Bumrah despite growing concerns over the pacer's fitness, saying the fast bowler has consistently delivered when it mattered most. His remarks came after Bumrah endured a disappointing outing against England on Day 3 of the fourth Test in Manchester on Saturday, July recent times, Bumrah has found himself in the spotlight for the wrong reasons. Fans have grown increasingly frustrated with his recurring injury issues, particularly in high-stakes Test matches. His struggle to find pace and rhythm during the third day's play at Old Trafford only intensified doubts around his durability in the at the PGTI Schedule announcement, Kapil Dev pointed out that Bumrah's action puts extra strain on his body and makes a long Test career more challenging. 'I think everybody is different. Times have changed, bodies are different. They are working differently. It is difficult to judge. Yes, he is one of the fast bowlers we have, but his action is so awkward, and it is difficult to sustain,' Kapil said, as quoted by PTI.'We didn't think he would be able to play this far because he puts too much stress on the body. But still, he is delivering to the Indian team. So hats off to him,' he SHUBMAN GILL TIME: KAPIL DEVKapil also spoke in defence of Shubman Gill, who is currently leading India in the absence of Rohit Sharma. Gill's captaincy has come under scrutiny after India's poor showing in Manchester, but Kapil urged patience, reminding everyone that this is Gill's first assignment as Test captain.'Give him time. This is his first series; he will commit mistakes and there will be many positives over the period of time, he will learn. There is no problem if he is learning. There will be mistakes, but he is learning from his mistakes—that is very important,' he said.'This is a young team, they are getting the opportunity to play and in the coming days these players will win. It is just a new team. Any new team in the world takes time to adjust. Gill is a new captain, and he will learn a lot and I think this series will be a learning step,' Kapil concluded.- EndsTune InMust Watch

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store