Why the State ‘breaking even' on AIB and the banks isn't the whole story
The
Department of Finance
says the State has made a surplus of €600 million on its €29.4 billion bailout of
AIB
,
Bank of Ireland
and
PTSB
. Some media reports refer to the State basically breaking even, but such phrasing conceals more than it reveals.
Firstly, the headline figure is in nominal terms. Adjusted for inflation, the real value of that €29.4 billion – doled out between 2009 and 2011 – is far higher. A euro in January 2011 is worth €1.29 today, which puts the cost of the bailout at roughly €38 billion in today's money.
Then there's interest. The State borrowed to fund the bailout. For AIB alone, the Comptroller & Auditor General put debt servicing costs at €7.1 billion by the end of 2021.
READ MORE
That's before you factor in opportunity cost: what else that money could have done, were it deployed differently.
An investor who bought a dud stock in 2009 and finally got out at break-even might feel relief. However, a $1,000 investment in the S&P 500 in 2009 would be worth over $9,000 by 2025. Time has a cost; so does tying up capital in low-return assets.
Inflation, interest costs, opportunity costs – the framing around the break-even point is problematic. It is more of a psychological concept than a financial one.
To be fair, the objective was never to turn a profit. The bailout was about stabilising the banking system and preventing economic collapse, but that makes the implicit 'we made money' narrative all the more grating. It reframes an emergency rescue as a shrewd investment, which it wasn't.
Breaking even offers closure, but it's no triumph.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
32 minutes ago
- Irish Times
AI should be a ‘core component' of the education system, National Skills Council recommends
The Government has been urged for AI to be embedded as a 'cope component of the education system' by the National Skills Council (NSC) to ensure the Irish workforce can contribute to AI innovation. In a strategic advice document published by the State agency on Thursday, the NSC suggested upskilling and training be focused on areas in which the use of AI 'enhances and augments existing skills and capabilities'. 'The aim should be to improve the productivity of employees, and encourage working with AI technology, rather than replace them,' it said. The NSC said it was turning its attention to AI and the need 'to attract, develop and retain the crucial competencies and talent needed to address the transformational shift of AI in our workforce'. READ MORE It highlighted a study by the Implement Consulting Group for Google , which suggested that matching OECD levels of digital innovation could create 14,000 jobs in the economy and add €1.8 billion to Ireland's GDP annually. The advisory body suggested the 'AI era' requires new thinking about innovation and Ireland's competitiveness and proposed the organisation of a National AI Skills Summit. The advisory body recommended a change to the State's spending rules to 'address the specific purpose' of the fund and to listen to employers in making decisions on allocating the National Training Fund (NTF). The council suggested the Government create a formal process by which employers can contribute to decision-making on spending on the training fund and what skillsets the state invests in. It recommended a forum for employers and social partners be reinstated 'to support the innovation and reform agenda of higher education to meet the needs of learners, existing and future employees alongside a strategy for implementation.' Kevin Marshall, the chairman of the council urged the government to 'rethink how we invest in skills' and called for the 'voice of employers' to be heard in making decisions on the allocation of funds from the NTF. The NSC advised the Government to establish a national skills observatory to collate skills and labour market information. This would act as the Government's 'central information broker and repository for skills and labour market information'. Structurally, the advice suggested the observatory would build on the Skills and Labour Market Research Unit (SLMRU) based in SOLAS, and would be 'reinforced' by governance from both the Higher Education and Further Education systems. 'This should be supported by a costed and fully considered long-term funding strategy for the apprenticeship system in Ireland,' the NSC said, calling for it to be 'urgently prioritised' and issued with 'clear timelines'. It encouraged the government to adopt a multi-year approach to its funding supports and to have transparency in funding decisions. To encourage SMEs to develop and upskill employees, it recommended the establishment of a national training voucher scheme funded through the NTF and to consider introducing a discretionary fund.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Permission given for new office block on Dublin City Arts Centre site
Dublin City Council has granted planning permission to Ventaway for a 14 storey office block scheme for a site on the former City Arts Centre at City Quay in Dublin 2. The council has granted planning permission to the firm, headed up by developer, David Kennan and Winthrop engineering group founder, Barry English, despite opposition from the Office of Public Works (OPW), an inner city primary school, a religious trust and An Taisce. In granting planning permission to Ventaway Ltd, a Council planner's report concluded that the scheme 'will result in the redevelopment of a massively underutilised vacant site in a prominent location within the city centre'. The report found that the proposed alterations 'ensure that the development will not only create valuable commercial space but will also add much needed artistic spaces, while also providing managed space for the adjoining school'. READ MORE Underlining the scale of the scheme, the council has ordered Ventaway to pay €3.18 million in planning contributions towards public infrastructure and €1.08 million towards Luas works. The current plans follow An Bord Pleanala refusing planning permission in May 2024 to Ventaway to develop what would have been Dublin's tallest building at 24 storeys for the same site. Ventaway lodged its revised plans last December and the scheme - designed by architects, Henry J Lyons - is 61.05m tall, which is a 46.95m lower than the high scheme refused in 2024. Principal of City Quay National School, Philip Kelly, told the council that the school's board of management were objecting 'in the strongest possible terms' to the new planning application. The OPW is the State agency charged with the care and management of the James Gandon designed Custom House and in its objection, the OPW stated that the construction of a building at this scale and magnitude 'has the potential to adversely impact the historic and architectural character of the Custom House'. In a separate objection on behalf of St Laurence O'Toole Trust and The Administrator of the Parish of the Immaculate Heart of Mary, planning consultant, Declan Brassil stated that the scheme 'represents a significant overdevelopment of the site'. The country's largest industry lobby group, IBEC also weighed in, stating that approval should be granted. IBEC's Head of Infrastructure and Environmental Sustainability, Aidan Sweeney told the Council that the proposal 'offers an effective revitalisation of a prime location in the city centre and is exactly the sort of project Dublin requires going forward'.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Housing target should be revised up to 60,000 homes per year, Dublin Chamber says
A national target of 60,000 new homes per year should be set, with half of these delivered in the Greater Dublin Area to align with increased population growth and pent-up demand in the region, Dublin Chamber has urged the Government. The proposal is contained within the business lobby's pre-budget submission. Just 30,330 homes were completed during 2024, while the programme for government pledges to deliver more than 300,000 by the end of 2030. This year's target is 41,000. 'Dublin does not have sufficient housing and infrastructure to meet its current needs, and the future outlook is bleak,' Dublin Chamber said. The group also called on Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe to increase the standard rate income tax band by a minimum of €2,100 for single earners and €4,200 for married couples. READ MORE It said this adjustment would help 'redress the lack of indexation in recent years and ensure that workers are not penalised for modest income growth that simply keeps pace with inflation'. It also called for capital gains tax on disposals of investments in unquoted, actively trading Irish companies to be cut from 33 per cent to 20 per cent. 'This measure would directly incentivise entrepreneurial risk-taking,' it said. 'It would also more effectively appeal to gain-seeking investors than existing measures such as the Employment and Investment Incentive Scheme (EIIS).' The group was also critical of the supports available to small businesses. It said Dublin's start-up ecosystem 'is faltering', and that early-stage funding has 'declined sharply' since peaks in 2021. 'Instead of attracting entrepreneurs and founders, the current system often deters them, weighed down by misaligned and bureaucratic supports,' it said. Furthermore, it called Ireland's non-residential stamp duty rate of 7.5 per cent a 'significant barrier' to commercial development across offices, logistics, and retail. 'In an already high-cost market, this rate adds a substantial upfront cost, undermines project viability, and deters both domestic and international investment,' it said. It recommended a return to the pre-2017 rate of 2 per cent to 'unlock stalled development, ease supply constraints, and support wider economic growth'. The group said businesses are 'increasingly dissatisfied and frustrated' by the lack of delivery of infrastructure by the Government. 'Many do not believe that the investments proposed under the Programme for Government will happen, given past delays,' it said. On water, it said Dublin faces a 'major crisis', and that the provision of water and wastewater in the Greater Dublin Area is 'wholly inadequate and in need of urgent review'. 'The risk of a water shortage due to necessary maintenance and remedial work is high and rising,' it said. 'The lack of water and wastewater is a direct limiting factor on the delivery of affordable accommodation across the Greater Dublin Area. 'Currently, Uisce Éireann has no mandate or increased funding to support the supply of new housing developments. This must change and Government must put in place a multiannual budget for the utility to ensure new housing developments are connected.' At present, the Greater Dublin Area is 'excessively reliant' on a single water source, with 85 per cent coming from the Liffey. The group said the Eastern and Midlands Water Supply Project is 'urgently required' to meet the needs of half of Ireland's population. 'This must be accompanied by the Greater Dublin Drainage Scheme (GDDS), as the need for wastewater facilities has risen in line with the growing population,' it said. 'The need for adequate wastewater facilities and the building of the GDDS cannot be overstated. If this facility is not built, this will have a detrimental effect on the provision of housing.'
