Are COEs broken? How to fix Singapore's car quota system
In this episode of TransportBT by The Business Times, host Derryn Wong is joined by associate professor Walter Theseira of the Singapore University of Social Sciences. Together, they take a hard look at the logic, politics and pain points behind the COE) system.
If you've ever questioned whether the system still works and who it really works for—this one's worth your time.
Why listen?
Because we need more than hot takes Prof Theseira doesn't just comment on COE headlines. He advised the Land Transport Authority, contributed to international transport studies, and spent years researching Singapore's car ownership model. If anyone can make sense of this, it's him.
Because the Acting Transport Minister's comments stirred real debate From private hire cars to system efficiency, Mr Jeffrey Siow's remarks raised eyebrows. Wong and Prof Theseira dig into what was said, what was really meant, and what the public response tells us.
BT in your inbox
Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox.
Sign Up
Sign Up
Because the public isn't just reacting to prices—it's reacting to fairness This episode doesn't shy away from the emotional undertow. The duo examines how public sentiment is shaped by perceived inequality and whether the system can regain trust.
Because big ideas deserve airtime Prof Theseira floats bold suggestions, including phasing out COEs altogether and replacing upfront costs with pay-as-you-drive models. They won't all land, but they're designed to provoke smarter conversations.
Because transport policy affects everyone Whether you drive, ride, rent or wait endlessly for a Grab, this episode helps you understand the trade-offs shaping your daily journey.
TransportBT is a podcast of BT Correspondents by The Business Times. Join Derryn Wong every month as he breaks down the headlines and the policy moves behind them for you. Listen now at bt.sg/podcasts . Got feedback or an idea for a future episode? Drop us a line at btpodcasts@sph.com.sg.
---
Written and hosted by: Derryn Wong (derrynwong@sph.com.sg)
With Walter Theseira, Associate Professor of Economics, Singapore University of Social Sciences
Edited by: Emily Liu & Claressa Monteiro
Produced by: Derryn Wong, Emily Liu & Howie Lim
A podcast by BT Podcasts, The Business Times, SPH Media
Share your thoughts with us at btpodcasts@sph.com.sg .
---
Follow BT Correspondents:
Channel: bt.sg/btcobt
Amazon: bt.sg/btcoam
Apple Podcasts: bt.sg/btcoap
Spotify: bt.sg/btcosp
YouTube Music: bt.sg/btcoyt
Do note: This podcast is meant to provide general information only. SPH Media accepts no liability for loss arising from any reliance on the podcast or use of third party's products and services. Please consult professional advisors for independent advice.
Discover more BT podcast series:
BT Money Hacks at: bt.sg/btmoneyhacks
BT Mark To Market at: bt.sg/btmark2mkt
WealthBT at: bt.sg/btwealthbt
PropertyBT at: bt.sg/btpropertybt
BT Podcasts at: bt.sg/podcasts
BT Market Focus at: bt.sg/btmktfocus
BT Branded Podcasts at: bt.sg/brpod
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
40 minutes ago
- Business Times
Tesla's sales fall most in a decade in another rough quarter
[AUSTIN] Tesla fell short of Wall Street's expectations in one of the automaker's worst quarters in years, a sign of the toll that rising competition and a backlash against chief executive officer Elon Musk have taken on the company. Adjusted earnings were 40 cents per share, Tesla said on Wednesday (Jul 23), just below the average analyst estimate. Revenue fell 12 per cent to US$22.5 billion, the sharpest decline in at least a decade. Still, the report was free of new bombshells and the company said it continues to move forward with robotaxi and affordable-vehicle plans, providing a measure of relief for investors. That comes 'despite a sustained uncertain macroeconomic environment resulting from shifting tariffs, unclear impacts from changes to fiscal policy and political sentiment', Tesla said. The revenue drop was due to a decline in vehicle deliveries, lower regulatory credit revenue and a lower average selling price for its cars. Tesla also reported a decline in energy generation and storage revenue. The company did see a boost from the business segment that includes its supercharging network. The shares were little changed at 4.48 pm in extended trading in New York. The stock's value has fallen 18 per cent since the start of the year to Wednesday's close but has largely rebounded from lows in March and April. Some investors are looking past Tesla's uneven financial results and towards Musk's promises of a future built around artificial intelligence, humanoid robots and self-driving technology. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up 'If one thinks Tesla is at its core just an auto business, then the results were poor,' Adam Crisafulli, founder of the market intelligence firm Vital Knowledge, said in a research note. 'If one thinks Tesla is an AI/robotics juggernaut, then you will probably feel the same about its prospects after the Q2 release as you did before.' Polarisation Tesla's brand has become increasingly polarising following Musk's support of President Donald Trump. During his brief role helping the administration, Musk's attempts to slash government spending generated criticism from many of Tesla's traditionally left-leaning consumers, while some investors worried the project was a distraction. A number of analysts have adjusted their expectations downward in recent weeks. Revenue from regulatory credits, an area that has become a significant revenue stream for the company, fell more than 26 per cent to US$439 million in the second quarter. That's down from US$595 million in the first quarter and US$890 million in the same period a year earlier. That income is expected to drop sharply as the Trump administration eliminates penalties for automakers that fail to meet federal fuel economy standards. Tesla reported gross margin, a gauge of profitability, that exceeded the average estimate. Investors are still eager for more details on robotaxis' path forward, including how quickly the service can grow in Austin and go to other cities. The company said it aims to further improve and expand the service, but did not give timelines or specific locations. Tesla also reported the 'first builds of a more affordable model in June'. The company had previously said production of its more-affordable model would begin in the first half of this year. The model is seen as a key factor to helping reverse the company's recent sales declines. 'The guidance was very sparse,' Ben Kallo, senior analyst at Baird, said. He added that the company offered fewer forward-looking details than in the previous quarter. 'All in all, not a lot of fireworks,' he said. BLOOMBERG
Straits Times
12 hours ago
- Straits Times
Philippines settles for limited US tariff relief, but defence ties intact
Find out what's new on ST website and app. Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr taking a picture with US President Donald Trump at the White House on July 22. – Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr flew to Washington on July 20, hoping to turn warm diplomatic ties with the US into tangible economic gains. But instead of a breakthrough, he is returning to Manila with a modest concession: a 1-percentage point cut in the reciprocal tariff rate on Philippine exports to the US, from 20 per cent to 19 per cent. In exchange, the Philippines agreed to remove tariffs on key American goods, including cars. It was not the outcome Manila had hoped for. The new rate is still higher than the 17 per cent announced in April by US President Donald Trump, and analysts say it spotlights the Philippines' limited bargaining power when dealing with an unpredictable but transactional US partner. Philippine trade negotiators had initially aimed to secure a free trade agreement or a bilateral comprehensive economic partnership deal. 'Well, that's how negotiations go,' Mr Marcos told reporters hours after Mr Trump announced the revised tariff rate on his Truth Social platform. 'When we arrived here in Washington, the tariff rate was 20 per cent... so we tried very hard to see what we can do,' he added, referring to the 1-percentage-point decrease. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Singapore's domestic recycling rate drops to all-time low of 11% Singapore Male victim of fatal Toa Payoh fire was known to keep many things, say residents Singapore HDB launches 10,209 BTO and balance flats, as priority scheme for singles kicks in Singapore Five teens arrested for threatening boy with knife, 2 charged with causing hurt Singapore Money, housing and isolation the biggest struggles for youth leaving children's homes: Study Singapore Sota parent portal taken down for urgent patching following global cyberattack alerts Singapore COE prices for cars mostly unchanged; premium for commercial vehicles up 2.9% Singapore Cyclist charged after allegedly hitting elderly pedestrian, killing him That cut came at a cost. Mr Marcos confirmed the Philippines would open up previously protected sectors, including car imports from the US. Other American goods set to receive zero tariffs are still being determined. The Philippines also committed to buying more US products such as soya beans, wheat and medication, which Mr Marcos framed as a move to help Filipinos access more affordable essential goods. US Secretary of State Marco Rubio said on July 23 that the US is set to give the Philippines some US$60 million (S$76 million) in foreign assistance funding to support energy, maritime and economic growth programmes. Mr Rubio said the State Department also plans to work with the US Congress to allocate US$15 million to support investments and job creation along the Luzon Economic Corridor, a trilateral initiative with Japan and the Philippines launched in April 2024 to boost infrastructure and connectivity across Manila and surrounding provinces. Lopsided deal? Still, the asymmetry in the deal is hard to ignore. While Mr Trump praised Mr Marcos as a 'strong negotiator' during their joint press conference ahead of their bilateral meeting, he also quipped that the Philippine President was 'negotiating too tough', hinting that a larger concession had been left on the table. The result, analysts say, was not a clear win for Manila, but a strategic compromise. Dr Aries Arugay, visiting senior fellow at the ISEAS – Yusof Ishak Institute in Singapore and chairman of the University of the Philippines' Political Science Department, described the outcome as underwhelming. 'We are worse off than the original' position of the Philippines, he told The Straits Times, noting that South-east Asian neighbours like Vietnam and Indonesia had secured steeper tariff reductions from the Trump administration. 'Marcos was really hoping to make economic gains out of this trip. Unfortunately... the general outcome was not really what was expected,' Dr Arugay said. For Washington, success in this negotiation was always going to be measured differently. Mr Trump appeared content with the outcome, and he did not press the Philippines to increase its defence spending, as he has done with other allies. Manila may have accepted the limited economic gain to preserve goodwill with its treaty ally amid rising tensions with Beijing over the South China Sea, said Mr Georgi Engelbrecht, senior analyst for the Philippines at the International Crisis Group. 'I have a feeling (the Marcos government) was also thinking the priority is to keep Trump close to us, and what we can get is what we can get... It's not perfect, but it could have been worse,' Mr Engelbrecht told ST. Strong military ties Still, the Philippines was able to reaffirm its longstanding defence ties with the US, one of the key goals of Mr Marcos' trip. In that sense, both Dr Arugay and Mr Engelbrecht said Mr Marcos achieved what he needed: a reaffirmation of military cooperation with the US, no public scolding from Mr Trump, and enough progress to signal continuity in the alliance – even if it fell short of a clear economic win. Both Mr Trump and Mr Marcos voiced support for a planned US-funded ammunition production and logistics hub in Subic, a former US military base turned freeport zone located north-west of Manila. Touting America's military stockpiles, Mr Trump said the ammunitions hub is 'very important' and part of broader US efforts to bolster its posture in the Indo-Pacific, where Washington is locked in a rivalry for influence with China. Mr Marcos cast the project as part of his administration's 'self-reliant defence programme', aimed at modernising the Armed Forces of the Philippines and reducing dependence on foreign suppliers. 'It will help the Philippine modernisation of the military,' said Dr Arugay, but added that it also 'really reinforces American presence in the country through the EDCA sites'. He was referring to the Filipino military bases that American troops have access to under the Enhanced Defence Cooperation Agreement. The US initially had access to five bases, but Mr Marcos expanded that to nine in 2023. The proposed ammunition facility, initiated under the Biden administration with bipartisan support in the US Congress, is not without risks. Its location in Subic places it within striking distance of the South China Sea, raising concerns over potential escalation. But Mr Engelbrecht downplayed those fears, saying: 'China's not going to launch a rocket just because of that alone.' What matters more is Philippine control over how such facilities are used, he added. 'These are still Philippine bases. Marcos would still need to green-light any activity that the US wants to do,' Mr Engelbrecht said. Despite failing to get a steeper tariff cut, Mr Marcos was the first South-east Asian leader to meet Mr Trump at the White House since his re-election in 2024. That alone sent a signal that Mr Marcos remains a reliable US partner, said the analysts. Yet the challenge moving forward is clear: The Philippines cannot afford to rely on the US alone. 'The Philippines must hedge and diversify, like Indonesia did with its EU trade deal,' said Mr Engelbrecht. Dr Arugay agreed, saying: 'The Marcos administration should not put all its strategic economic and security eggs in the US basket. We must look for new markets.'
Business Times
13 hours ago
- Business Times
S$15.8 million deal at Leedon Residence tops Q2 resale gains with seller earning S$3.3 million profit
[SINGAPORE] A 8,051-square foot (sq ft) unit at Leedon Residence was sold for S$15.8 million in June, earning the seller a tidy S$3.3 million in profit after eight years – making it the most profitable transaction by quantum in the second quarter of 2025. The first-floor unit at the freehold luxury condominium in the prime District 10 was bought for S$12.5 million, or S$1,553 per square foot (psf), back in February 2017, according to data crunched for The Business Times by real estate consultancy Cushman & Wakefield. On a psf basis, the unit went at SS$1,962 psf in June 2025. With a holding period of 8.4 years, the annualised profit works out to 2.8 per cent, with the seller's gross gain amounting to about 26 per cent. Notably, resales at Leedon Residence have recently proved to be highly profitable, coming out on top in the last two quarters. In Q1, two of the five most profitable transactions were from the development, with a 6,125 sq ft unit topping the list with the sale price of S$16 million, with a gross gain of S$4 million. Prior to that, in Q4 2024, another two Leedon Residence units were among the five biggest winners, with profits ranging from S$2.6 million to S$3 million. Cushman's Q2 data also showed that the five biggest money-making transactions by quantum in the recent quarter were either freehold properties or those with a 999-year leasehold title, located in the prime Core Central Region (CCR) or Rest of Central Region (RCR). Such units tend to command a premium, noted Cushman & Wakefield research head Wong Xian Yang. A NEWSLETTER FOR YOU Tuesday, 12 pm Property Insights Get an exclusive analysis of real estate and property news in Singapore and beyond. Sign Up Sign Up In terms of percentage gains, executive condominium (EC) transactions proved yet again to be the most profitable in Q2, continuing a trend that emerged in Q1 2023. Of the top five winners, four were units at the Hundred Palms Residences EC along Yio Chu Kang Road. These apartments were held for an average of just under eight years before being sold for an 'attractively high profit' of 130 to 139 per cent, said Wong. He pointed out that 74 units have been sold since the development reached its five-year minimum occupation period in December 2024, with the majority seeing capital gains of more than 100 per cent. The most profitable EC transaction in Q2 was for a 2,121 sq ft unit at the 99-year leasehold The Tampines Trilliant. It was sold for S$2.9 million (S$1,362 psf) in June, up 143 per cent from the seller's original price of S$1.2 million (S$561 psf) in January 2012. Given a holding period of 13.4 years, this works out to an annualised profit of 6.8 per cent and the seller netting S$1.7 million in profit. Excluding ECs, the top five resale gainers by percentage were found in the city fringe and suburbs, with gross gains ranging from 92 to 119 per cent. Topping the list was a 1,098 sq ft unit at 284 Joo Chiat Road in District 15. The freehold unit was sold for S$1.9 million (S$1,717 psf) in May, more than double its original price of S$860,000 (S$783 psf) in February 2017. This works out to an annualised profit of 10 per cent over a holding period of 8.2 years. Biggest losses Cushman & Wakefield's data also tracks the biggest loss-making transactions on a quarterly basis. The deal that spilled the most red ink in Q2, in terms of both quantum and percentage, was a 2,056 sq ft unit at the 99-year leasehold Marina Bay Suites in District 1. It changed hands for S$4.1 million (S$1,985 psf) in June, about a third lower than its original price of S$6.1 million (S$2,985 psf) in December 2012. Based on a holding period of 12.4 years, this translates to annualised losses of 3.2 per cent. All the biggest losers in the quarter were located in the prime CCR and purchased during varying periods of the market cycle, Wong added. For its study, Cushman & Wakefield examined caveats for non-landed private homes that were transacted in Q2 2025 with a prior purchase history between January 2012 and June 2025. The analysis excluded transaction costs and taxes, such as buyer's stamp duty and seller's stamp duty. Overall, prime CCR properties accounted for 62 per cent of loss-making deals in Q2 of this year, caveat data of landed and non-landed private homes showed. The RCR accounted for 30 per cent of such deals; and the Outside Central Region, 9 per cent. While the CCR saw a larger share of loss-making deals, Wong noted that the majority of resale transactions in the region – at 79 per cent – were still profitable. On the other hand, the proportion of loss-making deals for landed and non-landed homes inched up to 3.3 per cent in Q2, from 2.7 per cent in the previous quarter. Still, the figure remains relatively low, hovering at this level over the past two years, after declining from its peak of 21.8 per cent in Q2 2020. Wong attributed the low levels of loss-making deals to homeowners' strong holding power as well as resilient upgrading demand for private homes amid still-low unemployment rates and strong household balance sheets. Government flash estimates indicated that growth in public housing resale prices had slowed to 0.9 per cent quarter on quarter in Q2, after prices rose 1.6 per cent in Q1, following their 9.6 per cent gain for the year of 2024. Given the growing resale prices, this may enable more Housing and Development Board flat owners to channel the proceeds of a sale to upgrade to a private home. Wong reckons that private residential prices are likely to rise around 2 to 3 per cent for the whole of 2025, easing slightly from the 3.9 per cent price growth in 2024. 'Barring new cooling measures and unforeseen economic shocks, the overall levels of loss-making deals are expected to remain low,' he added.
