GMC Updates Fitness to Practise Rules Amid PA Criticism
The changes follow long-standing criticisms of the GMC's approach to fitness to practise (FtP) investigations and its promises to introduce more compassionate procedures.
However, the updated guidance drew immediate criticism for treating doctors under the same regulatory framework as physician associates (PAs) and anaesthesia associates (AAs).
Key Changes to Assessment Process
The updates to FtP guidance provide case examiners with a framework for assessing whether concerns received by the GMC should be interpreted as meaning that a doctor may pose a risk to the public. This follows changes made last year by the regulator to investigations involving violence and dishonesty. These gave decision-makers more discretion in minor cases judged to represent a lower risk to public protection.
The new guidance introduces three core questions for decision-makers when assessing whether concerns should proceed to investigation:
What is the seriousness of the concern?
What is the impact of relevant context?
How has the doctor responded?
Factors that may increase seriousness include repeat behaviour, abuse of position, or allegations involving vulnerable individuals. Decision-makers will also consider working environment, personal circumstances, and whether the professional has shown insight and remediation.
Investigation Triggers
Fitness to practise investigations may still be initiated for:
Misconduct
Poor performance
Criminal conviction or caution
Physical or mental ill-health affecting practice
Determination by another regulatory body
Insufficient knowledge of English
The thresholds for FtP concerns remain unchanged, but the assessment process will be more structured.
The Medical Protection Society (MPS) welcomed the GMC's efforts 'to deliver a fitness to practise process that is fairer and more compassionate'. Dr Rob Hendry, the society's medical director, told Medscape News UK : 'Finding out that fitness to practise is being called into question can have a significant impact on a doctor's mental wellbeing.'
He added that the MPS had 'long called for more to be done to ensure doctors are not dragged through this stressful process unnecessarily'.
Doctors' Association Raises Concerns
The new guidance brings FtP decisions for doctors into line with how cases involving PAs and AAs are considered.
The GMC assumed responsibility for regulation of PAs and AAs in December 2024. The move was vigorously opposed by many in the medical profession, particularly by GPs who wanted medical associates kept out of general practice altogether.
The Doctors' Association UK (DAUK) appreciated the GMC's attempt to clarify its guidance but expressed concern about aligning doctor regulation with PA and AA processes.
Helen Fernandes, DAUK chair, highlighted that the GMC has not set standards or scope of clinical practice for medical associates. 'If there was an issue around the clinical decision-making of a PA or AA, there are no standards against which they can be judged," she told Medscape News UK .
This contrasts with doctors' clinical conduct being assessed against strict standards for many years.
DAUK has expressed unease about how doctors will be held accountable for supervising PAs and AAs, noting that the GMC has attributed supervision responsibilities to anyone working with them in a team.
"This guidance seems to add more confusion to an already confused picture, which we believe doesn't help our members – but more importantly, doesn't help our patients or the wider public," Fernandes said.
The updated guidance is available on the GMC's website.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
29 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Gangs promoting small boats crossings on social media face jail under new crackdown
Gangs promoting small boat Channel crossings on social media will face up to five years in prison as part of a new crackdown announced by the government. An amendment to the Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Bill – currently going through parliament – will introduce a new, UK-wide offence to criminalise the creation of material for publication online which promotes or offers services facilitating a breach of UK immigration law. This could include small boat crossings, the creation of fake travel documents like passports or visas, or explicitly promising illegal working opportunities in the UK. While facilitating illegal migration is already a crime, the government said the proposed changes would 'add another string to law enforcement's bow, better enabling them to disrupt the gangs while they are publicising people smuggling activities and provide an additional tool when building a case against those peddling this content'. Approximately 80 per cent of migrants arriving via small boats told officials that they used social media during their illegal journey to the UK, including to locate or communicate with an agent or facilitator associated with an organised crime group, according to Home Office analysis. Individuals caught by the offence could receive a prison sentence of up to five years and a fine. It comes after the number of migrants arriving in the UK after crossing the English Channel topped 25,000 in record time, after some 898 people made the journey in 13 boats on Wednesday – the third highest daily number of crossings this year. The home secretary said ministers are 'determined to do everything we can' to prevent people smuggling gangs from helping people to make the dangerous crossing. 'Selling the false promise of a safe journey to the UK and a life in this country – whether on or offline – simply to make money, is nothing short of immoral', said Yvette Cooper. 'These criminals have no issue with leading migrants to life-threatening situations using brazen tactics on social media.' She added: 'We have to stay one step ahead of the ever-evolving tactics of people-smuggling gangs and this move, part of our Plan for Change to boost border security, will empower law enforcement to disable these tactics faster and more effectively, ensuring people face proper penalties.' Rob Jones, director general of the National Crime Agency, said: 'We know many of the people-smuggling networks risking lives transporting people to the UK promote their services to migrants using social media. 'The majority of migrants arriving in the UK will have engaged with smugglers in this way. This is why we work with social media companies to target smugglers' accounts, and we've increased the pace of takedowns.' In 2025 so far, 25,436 people have made the dangerous journey across the Channel – up 51 per cent on this point last year (16,842) and 73 per cent higher than at this stage in 2023 (14,732), according to PA news agency analysis. It is the earliest point in a calendar year at which the 25,000 mark has been passed since data on Channel crossings was first reported in 2018. Last year, the figure was passed on 22 September, and in 2023, it was on 2 October. With Nigel Farage's Reform UK surging in the polls, the figures come as a fresh blow to Sir Keir Starmer, whose pledge to tackle small boat crossings is a central pledge of his mission for government. The high numbers of crossings come despite the prime minister announcing a major 'one in, one out' returns deal with France last month. While it is hoped the deal will bring the spiralling numbers under control, the crossings have so far continued at pace.
Yahoo
29 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Cooper: Fast-track scheme to tackle asylum backlog coming
The Home Secretary plans to introduce a fast-track scheme to tackle the asylum backlog that aims to turn around decisions within weeks. Yvette Cooper said Labour was planning a 'major overhaul' of the appeal process in the hope it would help to make a significant dent in the numbers. 'We need a major overhaul of the appeal [process] and that's what we are going to do in the autumn… If we speed up the decision-making appeal system and also then keep increasing returns, we hope to be able to make quite a big reduction in the overall numbers in the asylum system, because that is the best way to actually restore order and control,' Ms Cooper told The Sunday Times. The aim would be to compress the process so decisions and returns could happen 'within weeks', the newspaper reported, citing a source familiar with the plans. The Government faces pressure to cut how many asylum seekers are housed in hotels while awaiting the outcome of a claim or appeal. The Home Secretary has previously said she was eager to put a fast-track system for decisions and appeals in place so that people from countries considered safe would not sit in the asylum system for a long time. 'We should be able to take those decisions really fast, be able to take those decisions, make sure that they go through the appeals system really fast and then also make sure they are returned really quickly as well,' she told the Home Affairs committee in June. 'That would mean a fast-track system alongside the main asylum system, I think that would be really important in terms of making sure that the system is fair. 'That will require legislation in order to be able to do that, as well as a new system design.' The Government is also seeking to reduce the number of Channel crossings. More than 25,000 migrants have arrived in small boats this year so far. Tensions over asylum hotels have flared up in recent weeks, with a protest and counter-protest taking place on Saturday outside the Thistle City Barbican Hotel in north London, and also in Newcastle. Chancellor Rachel Reeves has pledged to end the use of hotels to house asylum seekers by the end of this Parliament. Asylum seekers and their families are housed in temporary accommodation if they are waiting for the outcome of a claim or an appeal and have been assessed as not being able to support themselves independently. They are housed in hotels if there is not enough space in accommodation provided by local authorities or other organisations.
Yahoo
43 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Like Justin Timberlake, these 15 celebrities have Lyme disesase and shared their journeys with fans
After wrapping his mammoth tour, singer Justin Timberlake shared a personal health update with fans and explained that touring had been tougher than ever due to his Lyme disease diagnosis. Lyme disease, an infection caused by bacteria called Borrelia burgdorferi (are spread by ticks), can "cause arthritis, memory problems, neurological symptoms, Bell's palsy, cardiac arrhythmias, depression and anxiety", Dr Deborah Lee previously told Cosmopolitan UK. It can also be "a cause of chronic fatigue with a clinical picture similar to chronic fatigue syndrome." Many people are able to treat the disease with antibiotics meaning it cannot progress, but unfortunately for some it can cause life-altering symptoms on a long-term basis. Sharing his own experience, Timberlake said, "If you've experienced this disease or know someone who has — then you're aware: living with this can be relentlessly debilitating, both mentally and physically. When I first got the diagnosis I was shocked for sure. But, at least I could understand why I would be onstage and in a massive amount of nerve pain or, just feeling crazy fatigue or sickness." He added that at one point, quitting touring seemed like an option but he ultimately decided that the joy performing gives him outweighed the downsides. "I'm so glad I kept going." Here are 15 celebrities who've opened up about their Lyme disease diagnosis: This article is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice or diagnosis. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical with Lyme disease: Avril Lavigne Singer Lavigne had a really difficult time during the earlier stages of her diagnosis, saying it left her bed-bound for two years, but is now back to making music and doing well – proving recovery is possible. "I spent the last few years at home sick fighting Lyme disease," she wrote in a letter to fans on her website. "[At one point, I] had accepted death and could feel my body shutting down. I felt like I was drowning. Like I was in a river being pulled in a current. Unable to breathe." Lavigne added, "A single bug bite can f*ck you up hard. People aren't aware that Lyme must be treated almost immediately."Celebrities with Lyme disease: Bella Hadid The model has been candid about the difficulties she's faced following her Lyme disease diagnosis, sharing honest posts of her journey and recovery on social media. "If you look back at work pictures from the past eight years you can tell the difference between me when my Lyme flares up and me when I'm healthy," she said. "She's a different girl. I feel so bad for her." In an Instagram post following months of intensive treatments, Hadid wrote, "If you are struggling – it will get better. I promise. Take a step away, stay strong, have faith in your path, walk in your truth and the clouds will start to clear up. I have so much gratitude for and perspective on life, this 100+ days of Lyme, chronic disease, co-infection treatment, almost 15 years of invisible suffering, was all worth it if I'm able to, God willing, have a lifetime of spreading love from a full cup."Celebrities with Lyme disease: Justin Bieber Back in January 2020, Bieber took to Instagram to clear up some speculation about his health, telling fans he was working hard to recover from Lyme disease. "It's been a rough couple years," he told them, pointing out that allegations that he was dealing with a substance abuse issue had been hurtful. "They failed to realise I've been recently diagnosed with Lyme disease, not only that but had a serious case of chronic mono which affected my skin, brain function, energy, and overall health." "I've been battling and OVERCOMING!!" the singer added. "I will be back and better than ever."Celebrities with Lyme disease: Hailey Bieber While luckily not impacted to the same extent as her husband, Justin Bieber, the make-up mogul revealed on Women's Health's Going for Goal podcast that she too had faced a Lyme disease diagnosis – showing just how differently it can impact individuals. "Lyme disease is an interesting thing because a lot of people don't believe it's real, and a lot of people think it's BS," she said. "But I've had it before, I've dealt with it. My husband has it and deals with it very deeply. "I think it's about finding the right doctors who believe in getting to the bottom of any health issues that you might have."Celebrities with Lyme disease: Riley Keough Speaking about seeking treatment for Lyme disease and how it impacted on her family planning, the Daisy Jones and the Six star told Vanity Fair, "I used this little break that I have to come and try and see if I can alleviate [my Lyme disease] a bit. It's a holistic treatment centre and offers all kinds of things that you can't really do in America yet, like cleaning your blood." She also discussed how her condition influenced her decision to choose surrogacy for her daughter, who she welcomed in 2022 with husband Ben Smith-Petersen."I can carry children, but it felt like the best choice for what I had going on physically with the autoimmune stuff."Celebrities with Lyme disease: Kelly Osbourne In her memoir, Osbourne wrote about her battle to be diagnosed. "I had started entering my symptoms into online quizzes, and the results kept coming back Lyme disease. I got tested. The results were positive: I had stage III neurological Lyme disease. I was relieved to finally know what was going on, but I was also scared sh*tless." She has since stated that stem cell therapy has helped to alleviate her symptoms, although this is not a formally recognised with Lyme disease: Shania Twain In a documentary of her life, Not Just A Girl, Twain recalled her symptoms and how she was initially worried she would never be able to sing again. "My symptoms were quite scary because before I was diagnosed, I was on stage very dizzy. I was losing my balance. I was afraid I was going to fall off the stage," she said. "I was having these very, very, very millisecond blackouts, but regularly, every minute or every 30 seconds." The diagnosis process was difficult, the star also recalled. "It took several years to determine what it was. It wasn't anything obvious. Nobody connected the Lyme disease to it. In the end, a neurologist finally connected that it was the nerve to each vocal cord." Twain now says she has "a grip" on the disease, and is back touring, singing and doing what she loves in the music with Lyme disease: Ben Stiller Actor Stiller has told press that he has had periods of living symptom-free from Lyme disease, but that it has stayed in his system. "I got it in Nantucket, Mass., a couple of years ago. My knee became inflamed and they couldn't figure out what it was, then they found out it was Lyme," he said. "I'm symptom-free now, but Lyme doesn't ever leave your system. It's a really tough thing."Celebrities with Lyme disease: Miranda Hart After taking a break from her acting and comedy career due to her health, Hart wrote a poignant book, I Haven't Been Entirely Honest With You, about her experience of living with Lyme disease – something she attributes to being bitten by a tick as a teenager while holidaying in the US. While promoting the book, Hart said on BBC Radio 4, "I thought I need to research this whole wellness expertise and dialogue that's out there, but I was at bed at home alone, the doctors didn't know what to do with me and I couldn't have a cold plunge or go on a yoga retreat. "So I thought what are the universal truths? So I did years of research, when I felt able to, and in the book there are 10 keys, which I call my treasures, to living well. And they've really genuinely [helped]. I feel like despite the suffering it came from, that I'm living a life of joy and meaning and fulfilment in a way I never have before."Celebrities with Lyme disease: Justin Timberlake Following a two-year tour, Timberlake told fans on Instagram that he'd been juggling a Lyme disease diagnosis as well as a gruelling schedule – but that working and performing was worth it for all the joy it provides him with. "If you've experienced this disease or know someone who has — then you're aware: living with this can be relentlessly debilitating, both mentally and physically," he said. "When I first got the diagnosis I was shocked for sure. "But, at least I could understand why I would be onstage and in a massive amount of nerve pain or, just feeling crazy fatigue or sickness."Celebrities with Lyme disease: Yolanda Hadid Like her daughter Bella, Yolanda Hadid has also been living with Lyme disease for a number of years – and wrote about it in her book, Believe Me: My Battle with the Invisible Disability of Lyme Disease. "I honestly don't have the proper words in my vocabulary to describe to you the darkness, the pain, and the unknown hell I've lived these past years. I actually did not live," she shared in a speech about her illness, too. Thankfully, Hadid has been in remission for years now and says she's feeling well, happy and healthy, with diet having a big impact on her with Lyme disease: Mark Ruffalo When The Quiet Epidemic, a film about a young student and a scientist who are both diagnosed with Lyme disease and who embark on a joint quest for answers, came out, Ruffalo urged people to take note and watch it. "From personal experience, Lyme disease can be brutal, persistent, and misdiagnosed. The healthcare industry is way behind on this disease," he with Lyme disease: Ramona Singer The Real Housewives star said she counts herself "blessed" to have caught her Lyme disease in its early stages and to have been able to start an effective antibiotics regime, along with overhauling her diet. "You must get tested [for Lyme disease] once a year, especially if you're in an area where there are deer," she told E! News. "But, we caught it early and I'm very lucky and very blessed."Celebrities with Lyme disease: Amy Schumer Actor and comedian Schumer asked her followers for advice on living with Lyme disease in 2020, saying she was on medication and feeling "good" but wanted to hear the experiences of with Lyme disease: Alexis Ohanian The Reddit founder and entrepreneur who is married to Serena Williams has shared his experience of Lyme disease, saying he was asymptomatic when diagnosed. "Doing a full battery of health scans, tests, etc, and found out I have lyme disease," he wrote on X. "Wild. No symptoms, thankfully, but gonna treat." You Might Also Like A ranking of the very best hair straighteners - according to our Beauty Editors Best party dresses to shop in the UK right now 11 products you'd be mad to miss from the Net A Porter beauty sale
