N.S. woman wrongly diagnosed with terminal cancer: ‘Absolutely devastating'
Armed with the 'grim diagnosis' that had also claimed her mother's life, Patey began telling family and friends and making end-of-life preparations.
'I put a claim in through my bank for critical illness insurance and just put my name on the list for medically assisted dying,' the Halifax-area woman said.
'I just came to terms with it. This is what it was, just absolutely devastating.'
But days later, Patey's family physician called with shocking news.
'I got another call from my primary care physician stating, actually, there had been a critical patient error at the IWK (Health Centre). And the file with the grim diagnosis did not even belong to me,' she said.
Story continues below advertisement
'I didn't even really believe her. I mean why should I? They had made this mistake once, how could they make it again?'
Initially told tumour was benign
Patey first discovered a lump in her breast in October 2023, just a few weeks after her mother died of breast cancer.
She went to the Breast Health Clinic at the IWK Health Centre in Halifax over the course of a year and had multiple ultrasounds.
'Throughout that entire process I said, 'You know, is doing a mastectomy an option because of my history?' They stated, quote-unquote, 'We're not there yet.''
She had a biopsy on the tissue from her left breast at the end of April this year.
On May 17, Patey said she received a call with 'great news, 'and was told the tumour was benign and had no traces of breast cancer.
Get weekly health news
Receive the latest medical news and health information delivered to you every Sunday. Sign up for weekly health newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
'My husband and I obviously celebrated. We told all my friends and family, it was just such a big relief.'
Two and a half weeks later on June 4, her family doctor called to tell her there had been a mistake and she did indeed have cancer. The devastating news came just five days after she finished a successful thyroid cancer treatment.
Story continues below advertisement
Patey provided Global News with a copy of the written biopsy result stating 'breast tissue (left upper outer quadrant mass)' was found to have 'invasive ductal carcinoma.'
She credits her family physician, who also works in the IWK part-time, for pursuing the truth about her diagnosis.
By Friday — two days after her terminal diagnosis — her family physician confirmed it was actually an error.
Patey's lab report states 'breast tissue (left breast mass at 10 to 12 o'clock)' had 'benign breast tissue' and was 'negative for in situ and invasive malignancy.'
Furthermore, her family doctor physically went to the IWK to check the slides.
'A director in the pathology department spoke to my primary care physician directly … and verbally admitted that it was a critical patient error,' she said.
'They are investigating it but she can't comment anymore because it is an ongoing investigation. So no, I have no idea if the other woman has found out and they haven't admitted anything to me on paper.'
At this point, Patey isn't confident about her biopsy results and wants to receive something in writing.
'The first thing I'm looking for is an apology'
Patey said she is left doubting Nova Scotia's health-care system and is pursuing legal action.
Story continues below advertisement
But the first thing she wanted was an explanation and an apology.
'I have called them 17 times. I've left multiple messages. I've filed a complaint with the Nova Scotia Health Authority. I filed a complaint through the patient advocate services to the IWK, and I have received absolutely no response, not an apology, nothing, absolutely nothing,' she said Monday.
'I wouldn't even have known about this error, I don't think, at this point in time, if it wasn't for my primary care physician looking at me like I'm an actual human being, and I'm not just a number in a system somewhere.'
Patey received a call Tuesday from an IWK representative who confirmed the error and apologized. They said a written explanation was coming.
Through it all, Patey said she and her family have been left traumatized by what happened.
'It's absolutely devastating to get a diagnosis like that. I had to look my husband in the face and tell him,' she said.
'(We have) all these plans for our future and (I had to) say, 'I may not be here to live out those plans with you.' I mean we're crying ourselves to sleep every night.'
And the fact there is another woman and family out there impacted by this error weighs heavily on her.
Story continues below advertisement
'The part that also breaks my heart is there is a poor woman out there walking around thinking that she has a benign breast tumour and she has cancer. She has a terminal illness and she might not have any idea,' she said.
'If this happened to me, who else does it happen to and who else will it happen to? There has to be something in place so this doesn't happen again to anybody.'
In a statement to Global News, a spokesperson from IWK Health said 'concerns of this nature are taken seriously.'
'Due to patient privacy, IWK Health is unable to comment on specific cases,' wrote spokesperson Andrea Slaney.
'However, concerns of this nature are taken seriously and a formal investigation process is followed with engagement from IWK's Quality, Patient Safety and Patient Experience team.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Global News
an hour ago
- Global News
Canadians with Down syndrome live until 60 on average, study finds
Janet Charchuk knows that having Down syndrome puts her at higher risk of getting Alzheimer's disease at a younger age than the average person. 'It is something that I do worry about at times,' she said in an interview from her home in Alberton, P.E.I. But she's doing everything she can to prevent it. 'Your diet, your sleep, exercise,' Charchuk said. '(Having) friends and being social and doing brain exercises.' Her favourite brain exercise is word searches. She also stays physically active and social, working at an equine therapy ranch, competing in the Special Olympics and serving on the board of advocacy group Down Syndrome International. At 42, Charchuk is among the growing number of people with Down syndrome living well into adulthood. A recent study estimates there were 22,367 people with the developmental disability in Canada as of 2020 — with 30 per cent of them age 40 and older. Story continues below advertisement 5:56 Raising Awareness on World Down Syndrome Day In Canada, 'the average lifespan of someone with Down syndrome is about 60 years old,' said Dr. Brian Skotko, senior author of the study published earlier this year in the journal Genetics in Medicine. That's a notable increase from an average life expectancy of about 53 years of age in 1970. Back in 1950, the study said, there were an estimated 5,138 people with Down syndrome in Canada and most died as children at an average age of four. Fewer than one per cent of them survived to age 40 years and older. Still, a 60-year life expectancy falls far short of the Canadian average of 82 years. For people with Down syndrome, 'there's one big culprit getting in the way, and that is Alzheimer's disease,' said Skotko. 'The number one cause of death in adults with Down syndrome are complications related to Alzheimer's,' which could include falls, memory loss, or choking, he said. Story continues below advertisement People with Down syndrome have an extra copy of chromosome 21, which also happens to be a chromosome associated with amyloid plaque linked to Alzheimer's disease, Skotko said. Get weekly health news Receive the latest medical news and health information delivered to you every Sunday. Sign up for weekly health newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy The study is the latest in a series of country-specific efforts to get the most accurate possible estimates of the Down syndrome population — including the U.S., Australia, New Zealand and Europe — spearheaded by Skotko, who is the director of the Down syndrome program at Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston. 'People with Down syndrome, if we want them to have a voice and the right policies and the right information and supports, we need to have an accurate accounting of their numbers,' said Skotko. Laura LaChance, a co-author of the study and the executive director of the Canadian Down Syndrome Society, said that includes understanding how many people with the disability are adults and the various medical, financial and social supports needed to help them live as long as possible and age well. 'Because individuals with Down syndrome didn't live that long historically, the system still really treats Down syndrome as a pediatric issue, a children's issue,' she said. 1:53 Calgary teen takes over western wear business that supports kids with Down syndrome It 'hasn't kept up to date in supports or pathways or inclusive strategy that's tailored to adults with Down syndrome,' she said. Story continues below advertisement But several doctors and advocates are hoping to change that. One big step is educating more primary-care providers about not only the link to Alzheimer's disease, but also to screen for other conditions — including cardiovascular risks, underactive thyroid and sleep apnea — that adults with Down syndrome are particularly prone to. 'Adults with Down syndrome might not be able to communicate their symptoms as clearly or go to a doctor early. So preventive care is very important — otherwise we'll miss those diagnoses,' said Heidi Diepstra, lead of the developmental disabilities primary care program at Surrey Place in Toronto. Although annual health exams are no longer recommended for the general population in several provinces, they're essential for people with Down syndrome, said Diepstra, who helped develop a specific Down syndrome 'health watch' checklist posted online by the College of Family Physicians of Canada. Primary-care providers can use the checklist to help avoid 'diagnostic overshadowing,' where clinicians see symptoms in patients but just assume they are part of having Down syndrome rather than investigating further to find the underlying condition, such as depression or hypothyroidism, she said. The checklist was first developed in 2011 and is expected to be revised by Surrey Place once more funding becomes available, Diepstra said. Even though 'anecdotally' they know some primary health-care providers are using it, it needs to be more widely incorporated into medical practice to meet the needs of patients with Down syndrome, she said. Story continues below advertisement '(We) know from research data that health disparities continue to exist for people with IDD (intellectual and developmental disabilities),' Diepstra said. 'This means we need to do more to increase the awareness and uptake of these tools with health-care providers in Canada.' 2:00 New Brunswick man with Down Syndrome defies the odds Dr. Liz Grier, a family doctor and medical director of Ongwanada Developmental Services in Kingston, Ont., said both physical and emotional care for adults with Down syndrome has improved over the years — whether they're living with aging parents or in supportive housing — contributing to longer and healthier lives. 'There's better involvement of both medical and social service supports in terms of engaging day programming and other activities,' she said. But Grier also believes care for people with Down syndrome can improve further, leading to longer life expectancy. Story continues below advertisement She said in addition to primary-care providers, it's important for family members and caregivers to be on the watch for both physical and mental health symptoms so the person with Down syndrome can be screened and treated early. Even the high risk of Alzheimer's disease can be managed to some degree, Grier said. Getting enough vitamin B12 and treating sleep apnea are both medical interventions that can help, she said. Supporting people with Down syndrome to live a 'fulfilling, engaging' life is also vital in helping stave off dementia, Grier said. 'Keep the brain stimulated, keep the brain healthy with the right vitamins and nutrients that it needs, stay active from a physical health perspective … all of those pieces contribute,' she said.
Global News
13 hours ago
- Global News
A year after report into boy's torture, death, B.C. still laging on reforms: Advocate
WARNING: This story deals with situations that may be distressing to some readers. Discretion is advised. One year after releasing a report into the horrific abuse and death of an 11-year-old boy, British Columbia's representative for children and youth says the province must do more to protect kids in government care. The report, titled Don't Look Away – How one boy's story has the power to shift a system of care for children and youth, profiled the preventable death of 'Colby' (a pseudonym to protect his privacy), an Indigenous boy born with medical challenges and who was placed in multiple foster homes. 2:02 B.C. boy's story of torture, neglect has power to inspire reform: report He ultimately died in February 2021 while in the care of two extended family caregivers, four days after suffering repeated beatings from his mother's aunt. When he died, he had multiple fractures and injuries to his brain, head, lungs, organs and skin — and weighed just 63.5 pounds (28.8 kilograms), not much more than half the weight of an average child his age. Story continues below advertisement The report, penned by representative for children and youth Jennifer Charlesworth, called for an overhaul of the province's child welfare system, including more family support services, improved violence prevention resources, better support for people providing kinship care and improved collaboration between agencies. 'Our hope was that it would point government in the direction of not just tweaking at the edges, but actually substantively shifting their approach to child, youth and family services, what we called the 'North Star' with a different way of thinking about things and with a much deeper focus on child wellbeing, which of course brings in mental health, health care, education, poverty reduction,' Charlesworth said Tuesday. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy But Charlesworth said despite some progress, the province has a long way to go. She said the province has yet to produce a child wellbeing strategy and action plan, nor a timeline for a first draft. And she said that despite welcome efforts by the province to improve staffing, much of the new hiring so far has been to fill vacancies, not to expand the workforce enough to deliver the kinds of services that are necessary. 2:29 Torture, death of boy in care prompts demand for change from B.C. watchdog Charlesworth said her concerns were further exacerbated by the current economic climate which is simultaneously putting more pressure on low-income families, while creating pressure for the government to cut services just as they're needed most. Story continues below advertisement 'We see on a daily basis that in the absence of doing the preventive services, we see very expensive services needed to be provided when a child is older, when the family is in a significant state of crisis or when the child has come into care,' she said. 'It's going to require an infusion of resources to support families in the short term in order to achieve better outcomes in the longer term — but if our kids aren't thriving, if they are struggling, and if we've got families that are falling to pieces and unable to care for their children, there are significant social, emotional, and financial costs attached to that.' Minister of Children and Family Development Jodie Wickens told Global News the province has fulfilled nearly two-thirds of the report's recommendations, and remains committed to implementing the rest. 'Minister (Grace) Lohr stood up at the time and apologized on behalf of government, and we took action immediately,' she said. 'So there are a number of small, quick actions that our government and my ministry took. And then there are larger systemic actions that will take much longer, some of which that are generational in nature.' 2:54 Father of boy who died in foster care demands accountability The province has improved integration between ministries and renewed its commitment to First Nations self-determination. Story continues below advertisement Critics say the improvements to the system aren't enough. 'It's on the brink of collapse, the brink of functional collapse. And in Colby's case we can directly attribute the lack of staffing to his death,' said BC Conservative children and family development critic Amelia Boultbee. 'Many children are currently not safe in the system that MCFD currently has designed, especially due to staffing.' The province was currently working on a child and youth wellbeing plan and outcomes framework. If you require emotional support the following resources are available: Kid's Help Phone (1-800-668-6868, or text CONNECT to 686868) is available 24 hours a day, seven days a week to Canadians ages five to 29 who want confidential and anonymous care from a counsellor. KUU-US Crisis Line (1-800-588-8717) is available to support Indigenous people in B.C., 24 hours a day, seven days a week. The Métis Crisis Line (1-833-638-4722) is available 24 hours a day, seven days a week. Youth in BC ( Online Chat is available from noon to 1 a.m. in B.C. Mental Health Support Line (310-6789 – no area code) will connect you to your local B.C. crisis line without a wait or busy signal, 24 hours a day. Crisis line workers are there to listen and support you as well as refer you to community resources. Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls Crisis Line (1-844-413-6649) is available to individuals impacted by missing and murdered Indigenous women, girls and LGBTQ2+ people, 24 hours a day, seven days a week. The National Indian Residential School Crisis Line (1-866-925-4419) provides 24-hour crisis support to former Indian Residential School students and their families.
CBC
a day ago
- CBC
Unsanitary conditions, rooms without locks among 'failures' at shelter sites, says official
Social Sharing Unhygienic conditions, bedrooms without locks and assaults against residents were among the problems plaguing two supportive housing sites in Halifax before the province cut ties with the non-profit managing the locations, a government official alleged Monday. Suzanne Ley, executive director of employment support and income assistance with the Department of Opportunities and Social Development, said she knew conditions were subpar at the sites, but the full extent of the problems was not known until Out of the Cold was dismissed and she took a closer look at the situation. "I would say there are some pretty significant failures in things like safety and infrastructure," she said. Ley said she received reports of non-residents entering the sites at night and assaulting the occupants. The facilities lacked in some basic supplies, such a drinking cups. Ley also said staff were not helping residents access health care, and in some cases even "gatekeeping" or "being a barrier" to health care. "The level of support really doesn't reflect what is needed in a high-acuity setting like this," Ley said. In an interview last week, Out of the Cold said it was blindsided by the split and thought it had been addressing concerns previously raised by the province. The group's board and leadership declined to comment any further following Ley's new accusations. Ley's department abruptly ended its contract with Out of the Cold last week after partnering with the group for the past three years. The group ran two supportive housing sites — one in Halifax and one in Dartmouth — with capacity for more than 60 people. Ley said many of the residents were chronically homeless prior to being admitted, and many are dealing with drug and alcohol addiction and/or mental illness. The province has opened several supportive housing sites in recent years, with the type of support varying by location and by resident. Ley said the two sites Out of the Cold was running are intended to provide among the most intensive level of support available. Previous threat of termination In August of 2023, the department told Out of the Cold in a letter that it was concerned about "criminal activity," including allegations of drug and human trafficking, inadequate support for residents, inadequate training for staff and delays in accountability reporting. The province threatened termination, unless a number of conditions were met. Ley said after that, the department worked with the non-profit and hired a consultant to help the group. She said Out of the Cold was showing efforts at improvement. "We felt really optimistic in 2024," she said. But, she recalls, not every concern was addressed, and some issues that were addressed gradually came back. Ley said the Justice Department has twice investigated the operations. She did not elaborate on those probes. When the second investigation began last fall, she said her department began preparing to transition to a new service provider. The Atlantic Community Shelter Society took over for Out of the Cold last week. On the day of the transition, the Department of Opportunities and Social Development complained to Halifax Regional Police about the sites. Neither the department nor police would provide any other details. The vice-chair of the board for Out of the Cold said last week he suspected that part of the split was due to Out of the Cold's harm-reduction approach, which did not require residents to be sober, in a recovery program, or medicated if they were dealing with mental illness. He said he expected new rules for residents, such as restrictions on drug or alcohol use or requirements for residents to follow prescribed treatment programs. Ley said "residents will see and feel a difference in their day-to-day," but insisted that did not mean rolling out new, stricter rules. "We want to make sure that people are able to come as themselves, come with all of their challenges and be supported in whatever the next step looks like," she said. Ley said any changes would be in the interest of safety, such as ensuring needles are being disposed of appropriately and rooms are being kept clean.
