Walpole Island First Nation member wants special governance for off-reserve residents
A Walpole Island First Nation member wants there to be special governance for off-reserve residents.
Steven 'Talking Bear' Amaro would like to see a special council created to represent the interests of members who don't live on the reserve.
'Imagine just having a one-party system with no voice?' Amaro questions.
Like half of the 5,000 members of Walpole Island First Nation (WIFN), Amaro lives off the reserve.
'But that doesn't mean you aren't actively involved in what happens on the First Nation,' Amaro says.
He is lobbying Indigenous Services Canada (ISC) to use Section 17B of the Indian Act 'to open up another opposition party where you're guaranteed to have a voice.'
In a statement to CTV News ISC rejects Amaro's effort.
Walpole Island First Nation carries out its leadership selection under the provisions of the Indian Act (i.e., Sections 74-79) and the Indian Band Election Regulations (IBER).
The Indian Act and the IBER do not provide a structure for creating political parties in First Nations elections. Therefore, any questions regarding political party creation fall outside the provisions of the Act and Regulations and should be directed to the First Nation.
Section 17(b) of the Indian Act refers to the recognition of new bands under the Indian Act. It is not a pathway to the creation of a political party.
Amaro is undeterred.
He has asked Chiefs of Ontario to support him in his cause to create a new party for off-island members.
It too has rejected his request, so Amaro is seeking a judicial review of that decision.
'I've been essentially just stifled at every which way,' Amaro said.
Amaro has ran, unsuccessfully, in three consecutive elections to sit on WIFN Chief and Council and he says he is now barred from attending meetings.
'Since 2018, I've been denied services and I've only been allowed to attend Chief and Council four times. And the last time I was served with a cease and desist, that's four different administrations,' Amaro said.
'And I don't even know these people. So just because I'm asking questions that they don't like, I'm no longer allowed.'
Amaro tells CTV News he has requested support, through WIFN, for a tourism business he wants to start but has been rejected.
He feels like he was rejected because of his disputes with Chief and Council.
WIFN Chief Leela Thomas responded to CTV News requests for an interview.
Because of the cease-and-desist order against Amaro, Chief Thomas declined to answer any questions as the matter remains before the courts.
The cease-and-desist order – which Amaro showed to CTV News – directs him to stop 'making any further untrue and damaging statements concerning any member of WIFN Chief and Council.'
The letter, written in February 2023 by the law firm hired by WIFN, accuses Amaro of making false statements about the Chief and Council 'in an attempt to persuade them to become members of a new band you wish to form.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
22 minutes ago
- CBC
Municipal police chiefs say Nova Scotia RCMP expansion counters national trend
Municipal police chiefs in Nova Scotia say the province's decision to expand the RCMP moves in a direction opposite the rest of Canada and could lead to less effective services for residents. A Deloitte review into the structure of policing in Nova Scotia released last month suggested that Nova Scotia should create a provincial police force offering both special services and local policing to better serve the public. In response, the PC government is expanding the RCMP to operate as the provincial service, rather than create an independent force like the Ontario Provincial Police or Quebec's Sûreté. The review said there is room in such a model for municipal forces that can meet provincial standards. But the province said municipal forces that need access to special services — like emergency response or dive teams — to meet those standards must pay for the RCMP to supply them in new contracts. Chief Ryan Leil of New Glasgow Regional Police, speaking on behalf of the municipal chiefs' caucus in the Nova Scotia Chiefs of Police Association, said they are concerned this new requirement could come with a major price tag, forcing towns with their own departments to switch to the RCMP. "Why is the province taking that autonomy away from the municipal police agencies to be able to collaborate and support one another?" Leil said Monday. He said municipal agencies provide high-quality policing in urban areas where residents are used to seeing response times of just a few minutes, while the Deloitte review noted people in rural areas — which the RCMP usually police — complained of slow response times. "We think that we are well represented in our communities, and we want to invest in what is working … the models that we have currently in our municipalities are working," Leil said. He said it makes sense to have multiple forces with special services to offer across the province as contingencies, so there are other options if an RCMP service is tied up. The review recommended starting with the RCMP as the provincial police service, because this would mean "fewer costs and risks" due to current RCMP agreements with the federal government. The current RCMP contract policing agreements with provinces, territories and municipalities expire in 2032. But the review also said the province could eventually move to an independent provincial police service that would allow for more oversight and control. The policing review was recommended by the Mass Casualty Commission, which was highly critical of the RCMP response to the 2020 Nova Scotia mass shooting that claimed 22 lives, and called for organizational change. Leil said he understands that an independent provincial force would not be a "light lift," and would be very expensive to set up with the need for new training facilities and infrastructure, but it has become the trend across Canada. Besides established models in Ontario and Quebec, Alberta announced in April it was moving to create a provincial police entity. Just before leaving the prime minister's office earlier this year, Justin Trudeau said provinces should transition away from the RCMP as contract policing. Within the Atlantic region, the Royal Newfoundland Constabulary recently took over territories from the RCMP following concerns the Mounties were not providing enough resources. "Our province, our country has been through some very unfortunate experiences, and we've seen grave impacts to public safety over the past number of years," Leil said. "We shouldn't shy away from doing the right thing, even if it is the most amount of work and the greatest amount of investment we have to make." Scott Feener, police chief for the Town of Bridgewater, said they created their own police dog unit and other services years ago, because it would take days for the Nova Scotia RCMP to send requested resources. Feener said he's concerned the Mounties will take years to scale up to the staffing levels needed to properly police their current areas and ensure they have the special services that can support an entire province in a timely manner. "My vision would be our municipal servicing the way it is, or services growing in size," Feener said. "If they move away from it, there will be a decrease in service … our public safety within town will deplete." Justice Minister Becky Druhan said in an interview Tuesday that she has confidence in the Nova Scotia RCMP's "ability to step up and deliver what we're asking them to do." She said the Deloitte review's recommendations, like bringing in one record system for police, and increasing the number of special constables rather than sworn police members, will improve the quality of policing in Nova Scotia. When asked about the national trend toward independent provincial forces, Druhan said that "would take significant extensive resources" and Nova Scotia would have to first expand the RCMP model into a provincial force, even if it wanted to go in that direction. "Our focus is really on Nova Scotians and our provincial landscape in Nova Scotia around policing is very different than the other provinces," Druhan said. "Nova Scotia is unique in a variety of ways — both the way in which policing has unfolded historically, also our geography and our population." When asked about the province's requirement to have municipal forces contract new special services from the RCMP, Druhan said it is a "reflection" of the review's point that a provincial service is the best way to provide consistency. Audits on all municipal forces and the RCMP on those provincial policing standards begin this fall, and Druhan said the province will work with municipalities "to determine next steps following that." Druhan had a meeting with the Town of Bridgewater on Tuesday that included the mayor, chief administrative officer and chair of the town's police board, but not the police chief. The minister said she will meet with the rest of the municipalities served by their own police departments in the next few weeks about their policing needs, and what a new funding formula will look like. A statement from Druhan said her office appreciates the Nova Scotia chiefs' perspectives, and while her current focus is on meeting with municipalities, she plans to reach out to chiefs in the "near future."
CBC
22 minutes ago
- CBC
A year after daughter's death, London dad urges action as Ontario reports rise in intimate partner violence
WARNING: This story contains discussion of intimate partner violence. One year after his 17-year-old daughter was killed by her boyfriend, Brett Broadfoot says he's learned a lot about how gaps in the legal system are failing women and girls facing domestic violence. "We have victims willing to step up and say what's happened to them, and then be left wondering why their abuser is on the street waiting to go to court with no monitoring," said the London, Ont., man. He spoke to CBC News ahead of the one-year anniversary of Breanna's killing and as new provincial police figures indicate a rise in the number of intimate violence cases. Breanna Broadfoot, 17, died in hospital on July 18 — two days after she was stabbed in a case that police have linked to intimate partner violence. An 18-year-old was shot by police, who say he had confronted them with a knife, and later died in hospital. Breanna's dad said she had a peace bond against the man who killed her. The protection order, commonly used in cases of domestic violence and other criminal offences, puts specific conditions on defendants to prevent them from committing harm. It didn't help in Breanna's case. "Unfortunately, what happened to my daughter is exactly what happens to a lot of these women where they still don't feel protected because the person that has abused them is left to be out on the streets, and that should not be happening," he said. "The reality is right now [alleged abusers] can do what they want and say, 'Yes, I won't communicate with this person or come near them,' but who's genuinely monitoring that?" Push for legislative change A CBC analysis of data from Ontario Provincial Police has found reports of intimate partner violence rose by 18.1 per cent in 2024: 6,289 compared to 5,326 in 2023, when there was a 13.5 per cent increase over 2022. Last month, the Ontario New Democratic Party introduced another bill that would require the province to recognize intimate partner violence as an epidemic and create an "implementation committee" to review the 86 recommendations from the 2022 Renfrew County inquest. (A similar bill, 173, received two readings and was referred to the province's justice committee last year, but the committee was dismantled amid February's provincial election.) The inquest followed the 2015 killings three women in the rural county. All were killed by the same man and on the same day. The recommendations provide a roadmap of systemic changes that could prevent domestic violence and femicide, and give oversight and accountability for perpetrators in the justice system and supports for survivors. The bill passed its first reading and is expected to be revisited in the fall. London West MPP Peggy Sattler is among its co-sponsors. She believes the declaration would allow the government to have more tools to address the issue. "When you declare an epidemic, it enables the government to mobilize resources to implement policy changes, make investments and to engage in the co-ordination needed to address a serious public health emergency — and that's what intimate partner violence is," said Sattler. "It has significant repercussions in our justice system, in our health-care system, and that's why so many organizations and experts have been repeating that call." Sattler said an implementation committee would include both experts and politicians from different ministries who would report back to the Legislature, to create accountability for which recommendations are being enforced. She also wants more investments in education and prevention, justice reform, affordable housing, and funding for shelters and agencies that help individuals fleeing abuse. Sattler noted the province can make the declaration without a bill, pointing to provinces such as New Brunswick and Nova Scotia, which have recognized intimate partner violence as an epidemic, along with 106 Ontario municipalities, including London. Broadfoot believes the province declaring intimate partner violence an epidemic would be a good first step, but he also wants grassroots action. Raising awareness about domestic violence keeps the family going as they cope with the grief of Breanna's death, said Broadfoot, who has since joined the board of directors for the London Abused Women's Centre. "We continue to move forward and find the courage and strength to keep going each day, but there's a piece that has been taken from us," he said. "That grief will never go away, but it just comes in waves now." On Friday, the Broadfoots will host an event at Ed Blake Park to honour Breanna's memory.
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
Exodus of N.L. cabinet ministers challenges Liberal Party momentum, prof says
One by one, veteran Liberal Party politicians are bowing out of the campaign trail ahead of Newfoundland and Labrador's upcoming fall provincial election. The trail of resignations started in May 2024 when former St. John's South MHA Tom Osborne resigned from provincial politics after a 28-year career. Then, in September, former energy minister Andrew Parsons announced he wouldn't be running in the 2025 provincial election after a 14-year political career. He formally resigned in May 2025 following the change in the provincial Liberal leadership. Parsons' resignation followed that of former Premier Andrew Furey, who stepped down in February after serving for four and a half years. Furey has since returned to working as an orthopedic surgeon in St. John's, but has not ruled out a future in politics. Furey's resignation triggered a Liberal leadership race in March, which saw Windsor-Lake MHA John Hogan become premier in May. Five cabinet ministers out A formal provincial election must take place by October 2025. With the six-week campaign trail getting closer, five of Hogan's cabinet ministers, and one backbencher, have decided not to seek re-election. Seniors Minister John Abbott was the first to tender his resignation from provincial politics. Elected in 2021 as MHA for St. John's East-Quidi Vidi, Abbott attempted to become the Liberal leader twice. First up against Furey, then Hogan. He chose to resign at the end of the summer following a lawsuit over the controverted 2021 provincial election. Then on July 7, Finance Minister and Deputy Premier Sioban Coady announced that she will not seek re-election after spending a decade in provincial politics, and three years in federal politics between 2008 and 2011. A week later, on Monday, three cabinet ministers announced that they will also not seek re-election after spending a decade in provincial politics. The first was Industry, Energy, and Technology Minister Steve Crocker. Shortly after came Justice and Public Safety Minister John Haggie, and then Environment and Climate Change Minister Scott Reid. Lake Melville MHA Perry Trimper is also moving on. He announced his decision to leave politics in May. Liberal momentum challenged Political science professor Alex Marland told CBC the exodus of long-time Liberal politicians in the province is normal and healthy, as it paves the way for new faces in the House of Assembly. "Politics is draining," he said. "You just need energy." But with ridings opening up for new competition, Marland said those newly elected faces could belong to a different party and lead to a change in government. "It's ultimately challenging for the premier to show momentum, and politics is so much about momentum," Marland said. That doesn't mean Hogan can't win the upcoming provincial election, but Marland said losing big names poses a challenge. There is also a pattern in Newfoundland and Labrador. Since 1972, whenever the province's governing party elects its third leader, they lose in the following provincial election. "I immediately think of Paul Davis," Marland said. "There's a lot of factors at play, but the thing that is constant is the longer you are in government, the harder it becomes to stay in government." He said that's because the government develops a record, and people want change. Sometimes, change occurs when a new leader takes office with a new cabinet. It can also lead to a change in the governing party. With an eye on the PCs, Marland said a good strategy for the party would be recruiting star candidates who want to be part of PC Leader Tony Wakeham's caucus. Marland said star candidates are people with a public profile, and they are often mayors.
