Debunked: How misinformation spread within minutes of a garda being stabbed on Capel Street
The garda was
attacked yesterday evening
during a routine, high-visibility patrol on Capel Street.
He was wounded on his upper arm, and his stab vest sustained some impact damage, before the suspect was subdued and detained.
The injured garda has since been discharged from hospital after being treated for his injuries.
However, false rumours about the suspect soon spread online.
'We have some people with their own agenda try and inflame situations like this for their own ends,' Paul Cleary, Assistant Commissioner for the Dublin Metropolitan Region, said on Morning Ireland today.
Many posts with inaccurate claims about the incident, that have accumulated hundreds of thousands of views, can still be seen on social media.
One post to Facebook calling the suspect a 'non-national' has accumulated more than 92,600 views since being posted just before 8pm yesterday.
Another post that appeared half an hour later, which says that the stabbing was carried out by a 'migrant who went Tonto [crazy]', has been seen 22,800 times, according to statistics from Meta, Facebook's parent company.
Advertisement
Multiple other posts on Facebook blamed the stabbing on a 'foreigner' without providing any evidence.
Posts on the social media platform X alleging that the suspect was a non-Irish person have been viewed more than 100,000 times, according to metrics on that site.
One of the earliest posts blaming the stabbing simply read: 'Garda stabbed by foreigner on Capel street 10 minutes ago' responding at 6.55pm to a well-known far-right activist who had been complaining about Ireland being a '3rd world country' because of immigration.
Similar narratives quickly spread on X, including claims that Ireland was being overridden by foreign criminals. 'This street has gone to the dogs,' reads a 7.02pm post about the Capel Street stabbing that has been viewed more than 13,100 times. 'Every single day we have foreign nationals, drinking, shitting and pissing on the street in Broad daylight.'
Similar arguments that
exaggerate how dangerous Dublin is are common in anti-immigrant groups, which often portray non-Irish people are inherently criminal.
However, claims that the suspect was a migrant or a non-national contradicts all mainstream reporting on the case, as well as statements made by the Gardaí.
The suspect is an Irish citizen who was born in the country, according to numerous outlets,
including RTÉ
.
The suspect is expected to be charged this evening.
Baseless accusations that foreigners are responsible regularly
appear online
almost as soon as crimes occur.
Some of these accusations have been associated with real-life violence, including the case of an Indian man who was
brutally attacked
by a mob in Tallaght last week after being falsely accused of inappropriate behaviour around children.
Want to be your own fact-checker? Visit our brand-new
FactCheck Knowledge Bank
for guides and toolkits
The Journal's FactCheck is a signatory to the International Fact-Checking Network's Code of Principles. You can read it
here
. For information on how FactCheck works, what the verdicts mean, and how you can take part, check out our Reader's Guide
here
. You can read about the team of editors and reporters who work on the factchecks
here
.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
It is vital that we surface facts from noise. Articles like this one brings you clarity, transparency and balance so you can make well-informed decisions.
We set up FactCheck in 2016 to proactively expose false or misleading information, but to continue to deliver on this mission we need your support.
Over 5,000 readers like you support us. If you can, please consider setting up a monthly payment or making a once-off donation to keep news free to everyone.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Crime by offenders on bail rises 20% as prison overcrowding hits crisis levels
Recorded crimes committed by people already on bail for other offences has jumped by 20% in the last two years. Cork City and Dublin's north inner city show the sharpest rises in urban areas, with a large number of county divisions also experiencing significant increases. Senior sources said the increases were part of a wider "crisis in the criminal justice system", reflected by a severe, and worsening, overcrowding crisis in the country's jails. The latest figures show new records were set on Wednesday, with prison numbers hitting 5,581, more than 900 more that can be accommodated in Irish jails. Consequently, prison overcrowding reached a new high of 120% overcapacity. Cork Prison has experienced one of the worst increases in overcrowding during 2025, and is now 132% over capacity. Prison sources are most concerned about potential violence and security issues at older prisons with small cells, like Mountjoy Prison, and Cloverhill Remand Prison, which has larger cells but with up to four inmates in them. Cloverhill also has a high number of inmates, including homeless people, with serious or severe mental health issues. 'Gardai are doing their job, arresting and prosecuting offenders and the courts — and there have been a large number of extra judges appointed — are doing their job by convicting them or remanding them to prison, but the prisons are overflowing and have no space to hold them,' a senior justice source said. That means those sent to prison are either processed, placed in a holding cell for an hour or whatever, and then released back out. Or, if they have to be held — say it's a serious charge or conviction — other prisoners have to be released, on temporary release. The source added: 'We have reached the stage, and have for a while, where there is a crisis in the criminal justice system.' Prison sources have previously said use of temporary release has already passed its maximum safe usage, with numbers topping 600 on Thursday. In a case reported in the Irish Examiner on Thursday, a man who spat phlegm in a garda's face in Cork was jailed for five months, but was turned away from prison. The man was jailed for five months at Midleton District Court. However, due to overcrowding in Cork prison, he was back out. A second justice source said judges and gardaí knew prisons were full when bail was being considered. The source said: 'But if it's a repeat shoplifter or a homeless guy or an addict constantly causing trouble, what are they going to do on bail? They will continue.' Official figures on the number of crime incidents, where at least one of the suspected offenders was on bail at the time, reveals: 42,603 incidents in 2024, compared to 39,250 in 2023 and 35,478 in 2022 — an increase of 20% in two years; 2,211 incidents in Cork City in 2024, up 31% on 2022 (1,691); 9,718 incidents in Dublin North Central in 2024, up 31% on 2022 (7,397); Meath/Westmeath division saw a 72% increase, from 1,121 to 1,927; Kerry reported a 34% rise, from 565 to 755; Louth/Cavan/Monaghan had a 24% increase, from 1,686 to 2,092. All but two divisions experienced a rise in incidents in the last two years.
The Journal
5 hours ago
- The Journal
Tánaiste says any gardaí showing 'brazen' disregard for roads policing 'letting colleagues down'
ANY GARDAÍ WHO have shown a 'brazen' disregard for roads policing are 'seriously letting their colleagues down', Tánaiste Simon Harris has said. The Fine Gael leader was responding to comments by Garda Commissioner Drew Harris, about a report that found some gardaí showed a 'blatant disregard' for roads policing duties while they knew their actions were being reviewed. The Journal / YouTube It comes amid a focus on road safety in Ireland, with the Government introducing new speed laws and after the Garda Commissioner mandated that frontline gardaí dedicate 30 minutes of road policing duties per shift. Simon Harris said he did not want to 'tar any one group with one brush', and said he has the utmost respect for gardaí. 'Indeed, it's not that long since we were at a funeral of a member of An Garda Síochána killed while on road traffic policing duties,' he said at Government Buildings. 'Having said that, I am concerned with what I've heard, and I'd like to be in a position to read it. So I think it's important that what the commissioner said he intends to do does happen, that he publishes the report so that we can actually see this and analyse it directly. 'Because any member of An Garda Siochana who is acting in the way that the commissioner outlined is seriously letting their colleagues down in the first instance, colleagues who work every day to keep us safe and would absolutely be undermining our road safety efforts in this country. 'There are far too many empty seats at far too many kitchen tables in Ireland. We've worked extremely hard as a country, I don't just mean as a government, as a country, to improve road safety over many years. 'That progress had stalled in recent years and indeed we'd seen a negative trend, and this is disappointing and concerning. 'But I think it's important that we have the opportunity to see the report, rather than to comment on a comment about the report.' Advertisement Asked if he was surprised that a member of government had not seen the report, considering the policing authority had seen the report in June, he said: 'I am somewhat, but I haven't had an opportunity to discuss this with colleagues in government yet, and I'd obviously like to discuss it in the first instance with the Minister of Justice.' Sean Canney, a junior minister with responsibility for road safety, said the reported findings were 'shocking' and 'serious'. 'There's no point in us bringing in laws, reducing speed limits, doing all of this kind of thing, if we don't have a functional enforcement section within the Gardaí,' he said on RTE Radio. Canney said his thoughts were with the families of the 95 people who had died on Irish roads so far this year. He said he had not read the report from consultancy firm Crowe, which has carried out investigations on behalf of An Garda Síochána previously, but planned to meet Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan and both the outgoing and incoming Garda commissioners. 'I'll be talking to the commissioners to express my deep concern with what is in this report,' he said. He said the independent Crowe report was conducted while the reviewer was 'sitting in the car with a garda that wasn't doing his duty and didn't seem to have a problem with that'. 'So I think there is definitely a serious case to be answered here as quickly as possible.' Harris said he commissioned the examination after he received an anonymous report from a whistleblower. The chairwoman of the Policing and Community Safety Authority, Elaine Byrne, said the report was 'shocking' and found some gardaí showed a 'blatant disregard' for road policing while they knew their actions were being reviewed. 'They were openly hostile to doing their job,' she said, in what she described as a 'wake-up call' for An Garda Siochana. She also described an issue with fear among Garda managers of carrying out poor performance management, which she said Harris agreed was an issue.
The Journal
5 hours ago
- The Journal
Indian man attacked in Dublin says his community ‘no longer feels safe' here
AN INDIAN MAN who was attacked last weekend in Dublin has said that the Indian community 'no longer feels safe' in Ireland. Santosh Yadav was assaulted at around 11.15pm on Sunday, 27 July close to Clondalkin train station. Yadav told The Journal that he was walking with his friend back to his apartment after having dinner when the assault happened. 'Suddenly there is a group of five or six teenagers, some of them on bicycles and electric scooters,' said Yadav. 'They approached from behind, I couldn't see them, and they snatched my glasses and broke them. 'They started hitting me and it all happened within three minutes or so but I was shocked, I was not aware that any such thing could happen.' Image of the broken glasses Santosh Yadav Santosh Yadav He said the group hit him all over his body. 'I was bleeding and after hitting me, they immediately left. 'My friend was screaming and she was trying to save me.' He was taken by ambulance to Blanchardstown Hospital and was there for close to 15 hours. He suffered a broken cheek bone and said that he whole face was swelled after the attack. Yadav said he feels that he was attacked 'based on my skin colour' and added that his attackers were 'white teenagers'. Santosh Yadav's face after the attack Indian Embassy warning Earlier today, the Indian Embassy in Ireland issued a safety advisory to citizens after a recent increase in physical attacks against citizens. Advertisement The Embassy said it has been in touch with the relevant authorities concerning an 'increase in physical attacks reported against Indian citizens in Ireland'. It has advised Indian citizens to 'take reasonable precautions for their personal security and avoid deserted areas, especially in odd hours'. On such assault occurred on 19 July, when a man in his 40s was assaulted by a group of youths in the Parkhill Road area of Kilnamanagh in south-west Dublin after being falsely accused of inappropriate behaviour. The man was stripped of his pants and underwear by the gang during the vicious attack. Gardaí have appealed to anyone who may have witnessed the assault to come forward and no arrests have been made so far in connection with the assault. Yadav told The Journal that it is 'very unfortunate' that the Indian Embassy had to issue the safety advisory. 'This country used to feel very safe, but now things are not that good,' said Yadav. 'The Indian Embassy came to my house and they also reported the incident, and the gardaí came to my house too. 'There are so many other incidents happening and lot of people are being targeted.' Yadav has called for 'concrete measures' to be taken to prevent these incidents and make member of the Indian community 'feel safe to walk on the streets'. Yadav said that he and others like him are 'immigrants who are here to work hard'. 'We have left our family in another country and we are here to live peacefully.' He added that in Ireland, it 'feels as though there is no law against these teenagers'. 'More is needed to ensure that these teenagers are going in a good direction.' He called for more education in school so that teenagers can learn 'human values and ethics and empathy' in order to be 'a good human being'. 'If they are doing this now, once they grow up, they will keep on doing these kind of incidents if nothing changes.' Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
