Bryan Kohberger fancied himself a criminal mastermind — so why'd he make so many dumb mistakes?
Bryan Kohberger had been in a PhD in criminology program at Washington State University when he drove to the nearby Moscow, Idaho, and slaughtered four University of Idaho undergrads in 2022.
But for that crime, this student gets an 'F.'
Advertisement
It wasn't that he didn't try to cover his tracks: Kohberger clearly had a firm grasp of common investigative techniques and took pains to subvert them — including scrubbing his car meticulously clean after the killings.
But his attempts were so half-baked that they only made him seem more suspicious, according to prosecutors.
Experts say he attempted to cover his tracks, and was more careful than killers — but he made some obvious mistakes.
Advertisement
8 Bryan Kohberger appears at the Ada County Courthouse, in Boise, Idaho.
via REUTERS
'He was certainly smarter than most murderers,' a former federal prosecutor Neama Rahmani told The Post. 'But it wasn't the perfect crime.'
Rahmani noted that it took weeks for authorities to find the suspect, which is 'atypical now with advances in technology.'
These are some of Kohberger's biggest blunders.
Leaving his DNA behind
Advertisement
The murder weapon was never found, but a knife sheath smudged with male DNA left at the scene became the prosecution's best piece of physical evidence.
8 The shoes of four University of Idaho students who were stabbed to death in an off-campus house are removed on Wednesday, December 7, 2022.
James Keivom
8 A handwritten list of items seized from Bryan Kohberger's parents' home.
Rahmani said the blunder revealed that the the killings were harder than Kohberger expected — betraying a 'a chaotic scene when you're stabbing multiple people and you're just by yourself.'
Advertisement
'It's not easy,' he added.
Another former prosecutor and Court TV anchor Vinnie Politan said Kohberger likely 'ran into an unexpected situation,' when one of the victims, Madison Mogen, wasn't alone. She and best friend Kaylee Goncalves were sleeping together in the same bed.
They were the first victims. And the dropped sheath likely revealed that they did not die without a struggle.
'The women fought back, and in the struggle' the knife sheath fell out, Politan speculated.
'Then when he was leaving he ran into Xana [Kernodle] then Ethan [Chapin], two more unexpected victims,' Politan explained. 'He was exhausted and didn't have time to think, so he left without any realizing he didn't have the sheath.'
Buying the murder weapon on Amazon
Prosecutors said Kohberger purchased a KA-BAR military-style knife, a strap sheath, and a sharpener on Amazon while living at his parents' house in Pennsylvania months before the murders.
8 A sheath like the one found at the Idaho crime scene.
KA-BAR
He seemed to know his online purchases might be traced: He used a gift card, which can be anonymous, to make the payments and even tried to delete his purchase history.
Advertisement
But why make the purchase online at all when anyone can buy a knife with cash at any Walmart or truck stop?
Defense attorney David Seltzer said, 'clearly Kohberger left break crumbs linking him to the crimes, and we will never know why, or if they were heat-of-the-moment mistakes.'
Seltzer said he wouldn't be surprised if mental health played a role in Kohberger's crimes.
Driving his own car to the crime scene, then cleaning it too well
Kohberger's white Hyundai Elantra is what first landed him on detectives' radar.
Advertisement
Security camera footage showed the car circling the victims' block, parking behind their house, and then speeding away after the crime.
A search of white Elantra drivers included Kohberger, who had been pulled over near the University of Idaho campus months before the killings.
8 Bodycam footage of Bryan Kohberger being pulled over for running a red light.
Washington State Univ Police / MEGA
8 Bodycam footage of Bryan Kohberger's car at a traffic stop.
Washington State Univ Police / MEGA
He did thoroughly clean the interior of the car afterward, prosecutors said – but that only made him seem more suspicious, Latah County Prosecuting Attorney Bill Thompson revealed Wednesday.
Advertisement
'I think we can all look to our own cars. Those compartments in the doors where you try to keep them clean where you put stuff? There's always some degree of crud in there — they were spotless,' Thompson said. 'Defendant's car had been meticulously cleaned inside.'
Thompson noted that Kohberger has previously written a paper on crime scene evidence collection — making his deep-clean even more suspicious.
His phone also tracked him driving to Moscow, Idaho — the town where the killings happened — at least 23 times before the murders.
He kept his own phone
Anyone who's watched 'Breaking Bad' knows to use a prepaid, burner cell phone when they're up to no good.
Advertisement
8 Photo of four University of Idaho students hours before their deaths.
Instagram/@kayleegoncalves
8 Mugshot of Bryan Kohberger, inmate number 5356 at the Latah County Sheriff's Office.
Latah County Jail
But Kohberger kept a traceable cell phone.
He was careful to deactivate the device before driving to Moscow on the night of the murders, but it was only off between around 2:30 a.m. and 4:45 a.m. – the exact window of the killings.
He also reactivated the phone in another town 25 miles away from his apartment.
Rahmani said Kohberger should have just left his phone at home.
'He was careful,' the lawyer said. 'But he's not a genius.'
Taking out the trash
Kohberger knew that his DNA could tie him to the crime scene: He wore latex gloves to the supermarket and hid trash that contained his hair or saliva.
At one point during the four days he was surveilled at his parents' Pennsylvania home by the FBI prior to his arrest, Kohberger was observed putting trash from his family's house into neighbors' garbage bins around 4 a.m.
Kohberger clearly knew investigators search suspects' garbage, but it apparently didn't occur to him that agents might be watching the house — nor catch him dumping garbage in the small hours.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
Bryan Kohberger's Plea Deal Gives Him 'Upper Hand' Against Victims' Families, Allows Him Keep 'Secrets,' Expert Says
Crime author and murder case expert, Jeff Guin, has spoken about the implications of the plea deal accepted by Bryan Kohberger. The criminology grad student, who is accused of the gruesome killings of four University of Idaho students, initially had a not-guilty plea entered on his behalf months ago. However, Bryan Kohberger shockingly changed his mind ahead of his trial in August, choosing to take a plea deal that would block the death penalty and cancel his impending trial. On Wednesday, Kohberger, the man accused of murdering four Idaho students, took a plea deal, a move that has left many surprised. While the deal spares federal prosecutors the time and resources required for the trial scheduled in August, a crime author has warned that it may carry implications that are not favorable to the victims' families. "With no trial, he gets to keep certain secrets. The air of mystery and in some ways that gives him the upper hand," author Jeff Guinn told the New York Post. Guinn then emphasized that such secrets include details of what inspired Kohberger to allegedly murder Kaylee Goncalves, Madison Mogen, Xana Kernodle, and Ethan Chapin in their shared home. Additionally, it will also likely remain unknown if one or all were the intended targets and whether he had any form of relationship with them before the murders. Although Kohberger has not revealed why he changed his mind at the last minute, Guinn believes he made the decision to regain control of the narrative surrounding him, especially since the deal means that the death penalty is no longer on the table. "If he decides he wants to make a public statement, he's taking control through this deal because he's still living, breathing, and talking. As long [as] he can talk, he's got some control," said Guinn to the outlet. The Waco author also claimed that Kohberger could potentially go on to gain even more notoriety during his prison life, much like the infamous late criminal Charles Manson, who was imprisoned for life for the murders carried out by his cult. "[Charles] Manson set the paradigm for how much notoriety you can get, for how much you can live off your bloody exploits by getting that life imprisonment. Periodically, he would say or do something crazy and get his name back in the news," Guinn shared. He added, "In [Kohberger's] case, if you commit this kind of crime, you tend to think of yourself as sort of a God-like figure anyway. The plea gives him a further chance to exist in a way that will get more attention, and make him seem [to himself] more superhuman … I doubt he's taking this plea to quietly disappear into the penal system." Ahead of the deal being signed, one of the victims' families expressed dissatisfaction with the prosecutors' decision. "Idaho has failed. They failed me. They failed my whole family," said Steve Goncalves, father of Kaylee Goncalves, in an interview on NBC's "Today" show. "It's my daughter. It's our children. How can you say it's just when you haven't even talked to us to see what justice looks like for us?" he added. Goncalves further decried the manner in which the deal was made, revealing that the prosecutors chose to move ahead despite the "hard no" from his family. "They told us it's not really about us, it's about their process. Just shut up and get on board and deal with it, that's really what they told us," Gonclaves continued. In a chat with TMZ, the family of Xana Kernodle also expressed frustration, noting that prosecutors had floated the idea of a plea deal a few days ago and they strongly opposed it, as they wanted Kohberger to face a jury. Kim Kernodle, Xana's auntie, was especially furious, telling the news outlet that the prosecutors claimed the plea deal was to help "spare the families" the pain of a trial and prevent them from seeing the gruesome crime scene photos. However, Kim blasted this as ridiculous, saying, "We know the graphics. They were not trying to spare us." Bryan Kohberger was hit with four counts of murder and one charge of burglary in connection with the brutal killings of four University of Idaho students. He was arrested in December 2022 and has since spent years attempting to have the charges dismissed, challenging the death penalty, and filing multiple motions to delay the trial. During the hearing on Wednesday, to sign the plea deal, District Court Judge Steven Hippler asked Kohberger if he killed each victim "willingly, unlawfully, deliberately and with premeditation and malice with forethought." To this, the 30-year-old replied boldly, "Yes," according to E! News. Judge Hippler further noted that Kohberger's response was an "explicit admission to committing these crimes," and that it provided the court with a "factual basis" to accept his guilty plea into the record.
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
Fury Over Revelation That Bryan Kohberger Killed More People Than Inmates On Idaho's Death Row
Reports have revealed that Bryan Kohberger committed more murders than any current inmate on Idaho's Death Row. The former criminology student recently entered a guilty plea to the killings of four University of Idaho students, Madison Mogen, Kaylee Goncalves, Xana Kernodle, and Ethan Chapin. As a result of the plea deal, Bryan Kohberger avoided the possibility of the death penalty and is now set to be sentenced to consecutive life terms in prison. Earlier this week, Kohberger reached a plea deal with federal prosecutors, which partly saw him admit to four counts of murder in the deaths of University of Idaho students Madison Mogen, Kaylee Goncalves, Xana Kernodle, and Ethan Chapin. Signing the deal meant that Kohberger wouldn't be tried for the crimes; instead, he would be directly sentenced to consecutive life terms at a later date in July. It also implied that Kohberger wouldn't face the death penalty, which was on the table if the case had gone to trial. Had Kohberger gone to trial, been found guilty, and sentenced to death, he would have become the tenth person on Idaho's Death Row, per TMZ. However, he stands out among these inmates as the one who committed the highest number of murders, which has raised questions about why prosecutors chose to agree to a plea deal. Of the nine inmates currently on Idaho's Death Row, the closest to Kohberger's kill count is Robin Row, a woman who killed her husband and two children by setting their home on fire. A few others were sentenced for killing three people, while the rest were convicted of murdering one or two individuals. This new revelation has left several infuriated, with many insisting that Kohberger should have been tried and given the death penalty for the murder of the four Idaho students. One person on X said, "What kind of world do we live in that this guy is getting away with slaughtering those young kids? He needs to be tortured. No Question!" Another commented, "He should have been tried and fried. This ugly bastard. Should have made him say why for the families." Kohberger notably has never given a reason or motive behind his killings of the four students, even after pleading guilty on Wednesday. Pursuing a conviction in court could have resulted in a guilty verdict, but it would likely have triggered years of costly and time-consuming appeals from Kohberger. It also forces the victims' families to relive the deaths of their loved ones, an experience that can be profoundly traumatic. These reasons were hinted at in a letter written by prosecutors to the victims' families. "This resolution is our sincere attempt to seek justice for your family," they said, per ABC News. "This agreement ensures that the defendant will be convicted, will spend the rest of his life in prison, and will not be able to put you and the other families through the uncertainty of decades of post-conviction appeals," they added. "We hope that you may come to appreciate why we believe this resolution is in the best interest of justice." Some of the victims' families surprisingly supported the controversial plea deal offered to Kohberger. "We support the plea agreement 100%. While we know there are some who do not support it, we ask that they respect our belief that this is the best outcome possible for the victims, their families, and the state of Idaho," said Leander James, a lawyer for the Mogens, per News Nation. On the other hand, Steve Goncalves, father of Kaylee Goncalves and members of the Kernodle family, decried the agreement. "Idaho has failed. They failed me. They failed my whole family," said Steve in an interview with NBC's "Today" show. "It's my daughter. It's our children. How can you say it's just when you haven't even talked to us to see what justice looks like for us?" he added. While Kohberger has yet to make a statement since the plea, a crime author and murder case expert has offered possible reasons why he agreed to the deal. "He's taking control through this deal because he's still living, breathing, and talking. As long as he can talk, he's got some control," author Jeff Guinn told the New York Post. The Waco author also claimed that Kohberger could potentially gain even more notoriety during his prison life. "The plea gives him a further chance to exist in a way that will get more attention and make him seem [to himself] more superhuman … I doubt he's taking this plea to quietly disappear into the penal system," he added. Guinn further pointed out that with no trial, Kohberger gets to keep "certain secrets" about the murders, adding that it gives him the "upper hand."
Fox News
7 hours ago
- Fox News
120,000 fake sites fuel Amazon Prime Day scams
As millions prepare to snag the best deals during Amazon Prime Day, cybercriminals are preparing too, just not in the way you'd hope. Security researchers have uncovered more than 120,000 fake Amazon websites designed to scam excited shoppers during the retail giant's annual shopping event. With sales set to begin July 8 and run through July 11, the timing couldn't be more sinister. These scam websites, filled with phishing traps, malware and fake products, were created in the past two months, just in time for the Prime Day rush. Amazon Prime Day is one of the most anticipated online shopping events of the year, and that makes it a goldmine for scammers. Cybercriminals know shoppers are often in a hurry, eager to grab deals before they disappear. That urgency can lead to poor judgment and careless clicks. Amazon is actively fighting back against these threats. In 2024, the company initiated takedowns of more than 55,000 phishing websites and 12,000 phone numbers used in impersonation schemes. Amazon also partners with law enforcement agencies around the world to ensure scammers are held accountable, referring hundreds of bad actors to authorities for further investigation and prosecution. But the AI-amplified threats are coming faster than ever, which means you need to be more vigilant than ever when shopping for deals. While Amazon hasn't released a formal statement yet, the company maintains ongoing efforts to detect and remove fraudulent listings and suspicious domains. Amazon also reminds customers that it will never ask for payment via email or phone, nor request gift cards as a form of payment. Even so, the burden of protection often falls on consumers. Knowing what to watch for can make all the difference. Staying safe during Prime Day means slowing down and thinking before you click. Below are key ways to protect your personal and financial information from Amazon Prime Day scams. Always make your purchases through or the official Amazon app. Avoid clicking on links from texts, emails, social media posts or pop-up ads, even if they appear to come from Amazon. Scammers often use lookalike pages to steal your information. The best way to safeguard yourself from malicious links that install malware, potentially accessing your private information, is to have antivirus software installed on all your devices. This protection can also alert you to phishing emails and ransomware scams, keeping your personal information and digital assets safe. Get my picks for the best 2025 antivirus protection winners for your Windows, Mac, Android & iOS devices at Amazon will never call and ask for your login credentials, passwords or personal details. If you get a call that pressures you to "verify your account," hang up. It's a scam. No legitimate Amazon representative will ask you to pay using gift cards. If someone instructs you to buy a gift card and to send them the code, it's 100% a scam. End the conversation immediately. Scammers create fake websites with small, easy-to-miss spelling differences, like or Before you enter any sensitive info, take a second to look closely at the web address. If you encounter a scam attempt, report it to Amazon through their official support page. You can also report phishing sites to the FTC at Reporting helps shut down fraud faster. Make sure your Amazon account uses a strong, unique password that you don't use anywhere else. Consider using a password manager to generate and store complex passwords. Also, enable two-factor authentication (2FA) on your Amazon account for an extra layer of more details about my best expert-reviewed Password Managers of 2025 at Regularly update your computer, smartphone, and the Amazon app to patch security vulnerabilities. Cybercriminals often exploit outdated software to gain access. Public Wi-Fi networks can be insecure. Try to shop on Amazon using your private, secure internet connection rather than public Wi-Fi to reduce the risk of data interception. After making purchases, keep an eye on your financial statements for any unauthorized or suspicious charges. Early detection can minimize damage. If a deal looks unbelievably cheap or comes from an unfamiliar seller, double-check the product reviews and seller ratings on Amazon. Scammers often lure buyers with unrealistic prices. Amazon Prime Day scams are growing more sophisticated, and the sheer scale of fake websites, over 120,000, is alarming. But by staying alert, verifying websites, and following safe shopping habits, you can protect yourself and still take advantage of the sales. Remember, if a deal seems too good to be true, it probably is. Pause, check, and think before you click, and you'll stay one step ahead of the scammers. Who do you think should be doing more to protect shoppers from Amazon Prime Day scams, Amazon, the government, or the shoppers themselves? Let us know by writing us at Sign up for my FREE CyberGuy ReportGet my best tech tips, urgent security alerts, and exclusive deals delivered straight to your inbox. Plus, you'll get instant access to my Ultimate Scam Survival Guide - free when you join my Copyright 2025 All rights reserved.
