‘Picking Kuldeep can be the right move but how would you fit him in?': Steve Harmison says India might have to make some tough calls at Manchester
'The wicket in the fourth Test is not going to offer bounce to Kuldeep, but it will spin as the Test match progresses. And with the last three Tests all going deep into the fifth day, India have to seriously consider playing a second or even a third spinner,' Harmison said.
'At the moment, their side is well-balanced. But the challenge lies in finding a way to bring Kuldeep Yadav in. You cannot drop Washington Sundar or Ravindra Jadeja. So, can you play three spinners? That would be a big call, especially considering the situation around Jasprit Bumrah. Picking Kuldeep can be the right move, but how would you fit him in? There may have to be a tough decision — is it Sundar who misses out? I wouldn't want to be the one making that call,' he added.
Harmison also expects conditions at Old Trafford to mirror those at Edgbaston and Lord's — low-scoring, lacking in pace and bounce, but breaking up as the match wears on.
'If it's going to rain anywhere in England, and it hasn't rained here in almost three months, it'll be in Manchester. If there's any venue where you might consider playing two spinners or even three spinners, it's Manchester,' he said.
While he expects India to weigh up the spin-heavy option, Harmison said England were unlikely to follow suit.
'England won't go that route, they have got Liam Dawson, but India might consider it. I expect a wicket very similar to what we saw at Edgbaston and Lord's, one that will break up as the game progresses and offer turn later on.
'But I don't see much pace or bounce in it, and once again, we could be looking at a lower-scoring affair.'
(With agency inputs)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News18
an hour ago
- News18
Joe Root Breaks Records, Surpasses Ponting in England's 4th Test Win Over India
Joe Root scored his 38th century, helping England reach 433 for four against India on day three of the fourth Test. Joe Root scored his 38th century as England continued to dominate India, reaching 433 for four at tea on day three of the fourth Test on Friday. Washington Sundar provided much-needed relief for India after a wicketless morning session by dismissing Ollie Pope (71 off 128 balls) and Harry Brook (3 off 12) after lunch. Root, who was batting on 121 off 201 balls, kept accumulating runs and reached his century with a four down the leg side off Anshul Kamboj, establishing a 75-run lead for the hosts. Shortly after, Root surpassed Ricky Ponting to become the second-highest run-scorer in Tests, trailing only Sachin Tendulkar, who amassed 15,921 runs. India relied on spinners Washington and Ravindra Jadeja from both ends despite taking the new ball. Sundar succeeded by having Pope caught at first slip and Brook stumped when he couldn't connect on a charge. Root effectively played on the back foot against the spinners, using the reverse sweep skillfully. Towards the end of the session, Root took a single off Kamboj to surpass Ponting in the all-time leading run-scorers list. England captain Ben Stokes (36 batting off 68) supported Root at the other end, with the pair sharing an unbeaten 84-run partnership for the fifth wicket. Adding to India's troubles, Bumrah bowled just one over with the new ball before leaving the field. Upon returning, the umpires reminded him that he could only bowl post tea. In the morning session, the Indian bowlers didn't pose enough threat to the experienced Root and Pope, who guided England to 332 for two at lunch. After a disappointing evening session on day two, the Indian bowling attack again failed to penetrate the England batting. Apart from the occasional ball keeping low from the James Anderson end and another bouncing from the opposite side, Bumrah and Co didn't trouble Root and Pope. The Indian pacers continued to offer loose balls, releasing pressure on the opposition, a problem noted from Thursday. Bumrah started his day by bowling a full ball into Root's pads, which the England veteran flicked for a four. Later in his spell, Pope and Root quickly pulled Bumrah for boundaries when he pitched it short. Starting the day at 225 for two, England comfortably moved to 266 for two in the first hour of play. Kamboj, who had a challenging start to his Test career on day two, created a chance in his opening spell, but Dhruv Jurel couldn't hold onto a tough opportunity, with Pope on 48 at the time. Washington was introduced as late as the 69th over, and Root immediately put him under pressure by reverse sweeping him for a boundary. view comments Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Watch: Ben Stokes retires hurt with cramps - can he come to bat again in IND vs ENG 4th Test?
Ben Stokes comes up smiling after taking a tumble while reverse sweeping for four during Day Three of the 4th Test Match vs India at Old Trafford (Photo by) Ben Stokes retired hurt on Day 3 of the crucial fourth Test at Old Trafford, walking off after scoring a gritty 66 as England continued to pile on the pressure against India. The England skipper called time on his innings late in the day, handing over the baton to youngster Jamie Smith. Stokes had played a composed knock, scoring 66 off 116 deliveries, including six boundaries, at a strike rate of 56.90. As he left the field, there were visible signs of discomfort — a slight limp as he walked off and climbed the steps to the dressing room. While the exact nature of the issue remains unclear, supporters will be hoping that it is nothing more than a cramp. Go Beyond The Boundary with our YouTube channel. SUBSCRIBE NOW! With England in a commanding position and enjoying a hefty first-innings lead, Stokes' decision to retire appeared precautionary. However, with the match still delicately poised in the context of the series, fans and team management alike will be hoping the injury is not serious. — SkyCricket (@SkyCricket) Importantly, under cricket's laws, Stokes is eligible to resume his innings later, should England require him to bat again in their first innings. A similar scenario unfolded earlier in the Test, when India's Rishabh Pant retired hurt on Day 1 before returning to bat the following day — earning a standing ovation from the Old Trafford crowd. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like This Could Be the Best Time to Trade Gold in 5 Years IC Markets Learn More Undo Poll What do you think about Ben Stokes' decision to retire hurt? Smart precautionary measure Unnecessary, he should have continued I'm unsure, it depends on the injury England will now wait and watch over their captain's fitness, with Day 4 set to bring more clarity. For now, the focus shifts to whether Jamie Smith and the rest of the lower order can stretch the lead further, or if Stokes will be needed once again. For real-time updates, scores, and highlights, follow our live coverage of the India vs England Test match here. Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
Hindustan Times
2 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Ravi Shastri asked to enter Indian dressing room after Joe Root inflicts pain with record-breaking knock
India's sorry state of affairs at Old Trafford in Manchester prompted former England captain Mike Atherton to ask Ravi Shastri to enter the dressing room and lift them up. Shastri, a former India head coach, who is renowned for being an excellent man manager, often used to stir the dressing room up with his adrenaline-pumping speeches during his tenure. Atherton felt the current Indian side, led by Shubman Gill, was in desperate need of something similar to stop England from punishing them. Ravi Shastri and Shubman Gill Atherton made the comment when Shastri entered the commentary box as England crossed 460, stretching their first innings lead past the 100-run mark. "Go out there Ravi, your team needs a bit of motivation in the dressing room," Atherton said, welcoming Shastri into the commentary box. Shastri agreed that were in a difficult position in the Test match. The former India all-rounder said India made a tactical mistake while picking their XI. With Anshul Kamboj and Shardul Thakur being their third and fourth seamers, the onus was always on Jasprit Bumrah and Mohammed Siraj to do all the work. Shastri said if they had someone like a Prasidh Krishna in their ranks, then they could have used his pace to deploy different tactics like bowling short balls from around the wicket. Joe Root produced a sublime 38th Test century on Friday to propel England into a dominant position. Backed by solid contributions from Ollie Pope and captain Ben Stokes, England piled on the runs. Root was the headline act once again with a 150-run knock that saw him climb to second on the all-time list of Test run-scorers, surpassing Australia legend Ricky Ponting. Only Sachin Tendulkar now stands ahead of the 33-year-old Englishman, whose elegance and poise dismantled a lacklustre Indian bowling effort. The day began with England resuming at 225 for two, and the morning belonged entirely to the hosts. Pope and Root continued from where they left off, extending their third-wicket partnership to 144 before Washington Sundar provided a much-needed breakthrough. Pope, who had brought up his half-century earlier in the session, was caught at slip by KL Rahul for 71 after misjudging the drift. Sundar struck again shortly after, removing Harry Brook for just three, stumped by stand-in keeper Dhruv Jurel. But any hopes of an Indian fightback were swiftly quashed by Root and Stokes, who steadied the innings and kept the scoreboard ticking at a healthy rate. Root's innings was a masterclass in controlled aggression and calm under pressure. He effortlessly manoeuvred the field, played late, and found the gaps with precision. His century — brought up with a flick to fine leg off debutant Anshul Kamboj — was his 38th in Tests, equalling Sri Lanka great Kumar Sangakkara. India's bowling, by contrast, continued to disappoint. Jasprit Bumrah lacked rhythm, offering loose deliveries early in the day, while Mohammed Siraj and Kamboj failed to maintain consistent pressure. A couple of half-chances — including a failed LBW review and a missed run-out — came and went, but overall India lacked the intensity required to match England's intent. Root's rise past the likes of Rahul Dravid, Jacques Kallis, and Ponting on the all-time runs chart underscored his greatness.
