For Canadian economy, U.S. court ruling on tariffs brings hope, but also uncertainty
The initial ruling, by the U.S. Court of International Trade on Wednesday evening, struck down the Trump administration's 'Liberation Day' tariffs against more than 50 countries, along with tariffs Mr. Trump imposed on Canada, Mexico and China that were tied to fentanyl and border security.
The court found Mr. Trump overstepped his authority by bypassing Congress to impose the tariffs on national emergency grounds.
However, less than 24 hours later the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit granted the Trump administration's request to pause the lower court's ruling while it considers a challenge from the White House.
The frenetic period for U.S. tariff policies underscores the challenging and uncertain situation the Canadian economy finds itself in – but also suggests that further relief from punishing duties is possible.
'There is a glimmer of hope for Canadian exporters but the timeline for relief, if there even is relief, is still unknown,' said Julia Webster, a partner and trade lawyer at Baker McKenzie in Toronto.
The trade court ruling still left other tariffs in place, such as duties on all steel and aluminum imports, including from Canada.
Despite that, the decision offered reasons for optimism for Canada's economy, according to economists.
'If this ruling sticks and depending upon the course of actions from here, then the risk of recession in the U.S. and Canada has been sharply reduced,' wrote Derek Holt, an economist at Bank of Nova Scotia, in a research note on Thursday morning.
If the ruling holds, the average effective U.S. tariff rate on Canadian imports would drop by 1.2 percentage points to 2.6 per cent, while the tariff rate on goods from Mexico would decline by 2.3 percentage points to 2 per cent, according to research by Scotiabank's economics team.
However, the decision could trigger 'a game of Tariff Whack-a-Mole' in which Mr. Trump shifts the tactics he uses to impose tariffs, only for other court rulings to shut those down, Mr. Holt said.
In addition to the national emergency grounds, Mr. Trump still has at least five other mechanisms he can use to impose tariffs without the approval of Congress, including sector-specific tariffs such as those imposed on steel and aluminum under Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act.
If anything, the trade court ruling could heighten uncertainty 'by forcing Trump to consider other and more legally-secure ways to impose new tariffs over the next few days and weeks,' according to a report by economists Thierry Wizman and Gareth Berry at Macquarie.
The decision also would mean 'freer' trade agreements that may have emerged from negotiations with trading partners in the coming weeks would be 'put under a cloud of doubt,' they wrote.
Against the backdrop of conflicting court decisions, business leaders said what's needed most is a new trade deal between Canada and the U.S.
'The end of this trade war with the U.S. will not come through the courts,' said Candace Laing, president and chief executive officer of the Canadian Chamber of Commerce, in a statement. 'It will come when we have negotiated a durable, new agreement on trade that is trusted and respected by all involved.'
For now, companies would be wise to continue any duty-mitigation measures they've put into practice because 'the tariffs are in place until they're not,' Ms. Webster said.
If the ruling stands, importers who have paid tariffs to date could eventually submit refund requests to the U.S. government, she said. However with so much still up in the air, that paperwork may not be worth the time and effort.
Nor would the ruling answer more fundamental questions facing companies.
'This doesn't change what businesses have been struggling with the most, which is whether this is a wholesale reordering of the trading order that we've known to exist for decades,' Ms. Webster said. 'The waters have not settled.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
25 minutes ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Australia to reduce US beef import restrictions denounced by Trump as a ban
MELBOURNE, Australia (AP) — Australia will reduce restrictions on U.S. beef imports after U.S. President Donald Trump criticized what he described as an Australian ban on the meat, Agriculture Minister Julie Collins said. Collins said Thursday that relaxing the restrictions designed to keep Australia free of mad cow disease, also known as bovine spongiform encephalopathy or BSE, among its cattle herds would not compromise biosecurity. 'Australia stands for open and free trade — our cattle industry has significantly benefited from this,' Collins said in a statement. Australia has allowed imports of beef grown in the United States since 2019. But Australia has not allowed imports from the U.S. of beef sourced from Canada or Mexico because of the disease risk. But the U.S. has recently introduced additional movement controls that identify and trace all cattle from Mexico and Canada to their farms of origin. US cattle import controls satisfy Australian authorities Australian authorities were 'satisfied the strengthened control measures put in place by the U.S. effectively manage biosecurity risks,' Collins said. The timing of the new, reduced restrictions has not been finalized. Trump attacked Australian import restrictions on U.S. beef when he announced in April that tariffs of at least 10% would be placed on Australian imports, with steel and aluminum facing a 50% tariff. 'Australia bans — and they're wonderful people, and wonderful everything — but they ban American beef,' Trump told reporters then. 'Yet we imported $3 billion of Australian beef from them just last year alone. They won't take any of our beef. They don't want it because they don't want it to affect their farmers and, you know, I don't blame them, but we're doing the same thing right now,' Trump added. Lawmaker fears appeasing Trump endangers Australian cattle industry Opposition lawmaker David Littleproud suspected the government was endangering Australia's cattle industry to appease Trump. 'I want to see the science and it should be predicated on science. I'm suspicious of the speed at which this has been done,' Littleproud told reporters. 'We need to give confidence to the industry, but also to you (the public): this is not just about animal welfare, this is about human welfare, this is about BSE potentially coming into this country and having a human impact, so I think it's important the government's very transparent about the science and I don't think it's even beyond the question to have an independent panel review that science to give confidence to everybody,' he added. Around 70% of Australian beef is exported. Producers fear that export market would vanish overnight if diseases including mad cow or foot-and-mouth disease infected Australian cattle. Will Evans, chief executive of Cattle Australia who represents more than 52,000 grass-fed beef producers across the nation, said he was confident the agriculture department had taken a cautious approach toward U.S. imports. 'The department's undertaken a technical scientific assessment and we have to put faith in them. They've made this assessment themselves. They've said: 'We've looked at this, we've looked at the best science, this is a decision that we feel comfortable with,'' Evans told the Australian Broadcasting Corp. 'When you have a 75 billion (Australian dollar, $50 billion) industry relying on them not making this mistake, I'm sure they've been very cautious in their decision-making,' he added. US beef prices rise because of drought and a domestic cattle shortage Beef prices have been rising in the U.S. due to factors that include drought and shrinking domestic herd numbers. The average price of a pound of ground beef in the U.S. rose to $6.12 in June, up nearly 12% from a year ago, according to U.S. government data. The average price of all uncooked beef steaks rose 8% to $11.49 per pound. Australia's opposition to any U.S. tariffs will be high on the agenda when Prime Minister Anthony Albanese secures his first face-to-face meeting with Trump. Albanese and Trump were to hold a one-on-one meeting on the sidelines of a Group of Seven summit in Canada last month, but the U.S. president left early. Albanese expects the pair will meet this year, although no date has been announced. The two countries have had a bilateral free trade deal for 20 years and the U.S. has maintained a trade surplus with Australia for decades.
Globe and Mail
25 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
Teck Resources gives green light to $2.4-billion B.C. mine extension
Teck Resources Ltd. TECK-B-T said on Thursday that it is going ahead with an extension of its Highland Valley Copper Mine development that could cost as much as $2.4-billion, making it the largest critical-minerals investment in B.C.'s history. Teck said the project will extend the life of the mine from 2028 to 2046 to meet surging demand for copper for the electrification of the global economy. The Vancouver-based company said it would start construction in August after garnering the required permits last month. The project is expected to create about 2,900 jobs and generate $435-million in additional gross domestic product during the construction phase, it said. It will support 1,500 jobs over the life of the mine. 'This extension of Canada's largest copper mine, Highland Valley Copper, is foundational to our strategy to double copper production by the end of the decade,' Teck chief executive officer Jonathan Price said in a statement. High Teck: The Canadian miner bets its future on a copper mine in the Atacama Desert $30-billion in investment needed by 2040 to meet Canada's critical mineral demand, report finds Extending production at the site, about 75 kilometres southwest of Kamloops, will generate a 'robust' rate of return for the company and guarantee access to the metal for the next two decades, Mr. Price said. He added that Teck looks forward to collaborating with First Nations and local communities as it develops the project. Production from the Highland Valley mine is expected to average 132,000 tonnes per year over its life, Teck said. 'The project will strengthen Canada's critical-minerals sector, generate new economic activity, and support the continuation of the jobs and community benefits that HVC generates for many more years to come,' he said. The company has said that it expects demand for copper to double by the middle of the century as the world shifts to a low-carbon economy and population grows, especially in cities. Engineering for the project is more than two-thirds complete and Teck said procurement and contracting are well under way. Based on Teck's most recent studies, it expects the extension will cost $2.1-billion to $2.4-billion. The outlay will go toward development of infrastructure at the site, expansion of its mining-equipment fleet, grinding-circuit upgrades, increased capacity for tailings storage and improvements to power and water systems, Teck said. The company said the new estimate reflects updated assumptions based on current construction-industry risks and potential opportunities for cost reductions during the work. It also takes into account the potential impact of tariffs on construction materials. Federal Energy and Natural Resources Minister Tim Hodgson said the mine extension positions the country as a critical-minerals supplier of choice. 'Canada has the natural resources that the world wants – and it is projects like these that put us on the map,' he said in a statement. Teck said it has updated its 2025 financial targets and its 2028 production outlook to reflect its decision to green-light the project.
Globe and Mail
25 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
Canadian National Railway Reports Resilient Q2 2025 Results
Canadian National Railway Company ( (CNI)) has released its Q2 earnings. Here is a breakdown of the information Canadian National Railway Company presented to its investors. Elevate Your Investing Strategy: Take advantage of TipRanks Premium at 50% off! Unlock powerful investing tools, advanced data, and expert analyst insights to help you invest with confidence. Canadian National Railway Company (CN) is a leading North American transportation and logistics company, operating a vast rail network that connects Canada's coasts with the U.S. Midwest and Gulf Coast, facilitating the movement of over 300 million tons of goods annually. In its latest earnings report for the second quarter of 2025, CN demonstrated resilience in a challenging economic environment, achieving notable financial performance through strategic cost management and operational adjustments. Despite a slight dip in revenue, the company managed to increase its operating income and improve its operating ratio, reflecting efficient cost control measures. Key financial highlights from the quarter include a 5% increase in operating income to C$1,638 million, despite a 1% decrease in total revenues to C$4,272 million. The operating ratio improved to 61.7%, showcasing enhanced operational efficiency. Additionally, diluted earnings per share rose by 7% to C$1.87. However, revenue ton miles saw a slight decline of 1% to 59,215 million, indicating some challenges in freight volume. Looking ahead, CN has adjusted its 2025 earnings guidance due to ongoing economic uncertainties, now expecting adjusted diluted EPS growth in the mid to high single-digit range. The company remains committed to its capital investment plans, aiming to bolster its infrastructure and service capabilities amidst a volatile macroeconomic landscape.
