Gardaí criticised for alleged strip searches of protestors following vigil for Gaza
Fourteen people who attended the Mothers Against Genocide group protest against the Israeli war in Gaza were arrested after an entrance to Leinster House in Dublin was blocked.
Advertisement
The group said some of the women who were arrested at a group protest were strip-searched, and one was subjected to a cavity search.
In documents seen by
BreakingNews.ie
, there were 132 correspondences to the Department of Justice on how protestors were treated by gardaí that day, and the alleged cavity and strip searches.
The gardaí's actions compared to how they handled other protests were brought up to the Department of Justice, as one person said: "I have not seen this level of aggressiveness directed towards people who were literally running riot on our streets or those burning down buildings dedicated to housing immigrants, or camping out and stoking racism in sites such as Coolock. "
In another email to the Minister for Justice, a member of the public said: "Given the nature of the protest, there are legitimate questions to be asked about why this level of force was deemed necessary.
Advertisement
"In particular, there is concern about the apparent disparity in Garda responses to this protest when compared with other demonstrations, for example by far-right groups, which at times have involved threatening or intimidating behaviour with a visibly lighter."
The number of gardaí involved in the protest was also brought into question, with people saying the number of gardaí heavily outnumbered the protestors.
"The high level of Garda presence is very difficult to comprehend. These women were mothers, and were present at the Dáil as part of a Mother's Day Vigil to honour the murdered mothers and children of Palestine. They hoped to deliver a letter to incoming TDs this morning regarding Ireland's part in all of this."
Another person compared their experience in needing the gardaí in a different situation and questioned why such a large force was necessary.
Advertisement
"I recently called the Gardaí in a serious situation, and it took 20 minutes for officers to arrive. How was such a large force available so
quickly for a non-violent gathering?"
An email to the Taoiseach's Office was also forwarded to the Department of Justice, where concerns were raised over alleged strip searches.
"This practice raises significant human rights concerns and has the potential to cause undue distress and humiliation, particularly when conducted without sufficient justification or oversight.
"Numerous reports have highlighted instances where strip searches were carried out in circumstances that may not have warranted such invasive procedures.
Advertisement
"The lack of clear safeguards, transparency, and independent oversight leaves room for potential abuse and a violation of individuals' dignity and rights. Furthermore, strict guidelines, accountability measures, and independent oversight must be implemented to prevent the misuse of strip searches. "
A joint letter from Senators Lynn Ruane, Alice-Mary Higgins, Frances Black and Eileen Flynn was sent to the Department questioning how protestors were treated when arrested.
"From our knowledge, some of those arrested were strip searched and visually cavity-searched. Can you outline for us the reasons for such an escalation on behalf of the Gardaí for what was a peaceful protest?
"We are very worried about the lack of standardised policing practice that was applied to different individuals who were arrested. It is our understanding arrested protestors received different levels of treatment at different Garda stations, with significantly different levels of invasiveness.
Advertisement
"We request that you seek a full report from each Garda station as to the steps and decisions they took.
"Specifically, we also want to ask you what are the internal policies are in the Gardaí when it comes to respecting cultural and religious norms in the event of a strip search, with particular regard to hijabs?"
Both the Department of Justice and gardaí were contacted, and both said they had nothing further to comment on the story.
Back in May, Garda Commissioner Drew Harris said: 'I can confirm the Garda members involved in conducting the searches acted at all times professionally, lawfully, and in accordance with established procedures and legislative provision."
Mr Harris said statements made by People Before Profit TDs Richard Boyd-Barrett, Paul Murphy, and Ruth Coppinger on the arrests and alleged strip-searches were "wholly inaccurate".
'As a direct consequence of these wholly inaccurate statements and the widespread coverage of them in the media, I am deeply concerned about the damage that may be caused to public confidence and trust in policing."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Mother and daughter, six, are killed after horror crash involving car and a van
A mother and daughter, six, died after a horror crash involving a car and a van in Co Donegal, Ireland. They have been named locally as Natalie McLaughlin and daughter, Ella. The little girl died in the collision, which occurred on the R240 at Glentogher, Carndonagh, on Wednesday evening. Her mother, aged in her 20s, was taken to Altnagelvin Hospital in Londonderry following the crash and was later transferred to the Royal Victoria Hospital, Belfast, where she died on Thursday evening. A man in his 30s and another girl, who was a rear seat passenger in the car, are being treated for non-life-threatening injuries at hospitals in Northern Ireland. Mark Durkan, the Social Democratic and Labour Party leader for Foyle, said that Ms McLaughlin was 'well known and respected in the area'. In a social media post alongside a photograph of the mother and daughter, he said: 'This is the beautiful young mum and daughter, Natalie and Ella McLaughlin, who were tragically killed in a collision near their home in Carndonagh on Wednesday night. 'Natalie was a nurse in a local doctor's surgery and was well known and respected in the area. 'Wee Ella was just six. 'Our thoughts and prayers are with all affected by this terrible tragedy.' Fianna Fail councillor Martin McDermott told the BBC that people locally were finding it difficult to 'comprehend what has happened'. He said: 'This is a young mother and a young child, it has a real effect on people, on the community, people just don't know what to say. 'Everybody's life in that circle is changed forevermore.' He added: 'It has been very, very difficult over the last couple of days, it will be difficult over the next number of days, over the weeks and months ahead particularly for the families involved.' An Garda Siochana is appealing to anyone who may have witnessed the collision to contact them. A spokesperson said: 'Any road users who may have camera footage, including dashcam, and were travelling in the area between 6pm and 6.30pm on Wednesday July 2, are asked to make this footage available to investigating gardai. 'Anyone with information is asked to contact Buncrana Garda station at 074 932 0540, the Garda Confidential Line on 1800 666 111, or any Garda station.'
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Charlotte Church joins unions and campaigners in opposing ban on Palestine Action
The singer Charlotte Church and veteran peace campaigners are among hundreds who have signed a letter describing the move to ban the group Palestine Action as 'a major assault on our freedoms'. Trade unionists, activists and politicians have also added their names to the letter opposing the group's proscription under anti-terrorism laws last week. Church said: 'I sign this letter because history shows us that when people stand up to injustice, those in power often reach for the same old playbook: label dissent as dangerous, criminalise protest, and try to silence movements for change by branding them as extremists or terrorists. 'From the suffragettes to the civil rights movement, what was once condemned as radical disruption is now celebrated as moral courage. We must remember this pattern – and refuse to let our rights be eroded by fear. This is not new, and we will not be silenced.' 'By signing this letter I am not inviting support for any proscribed organisation – people can make their own minds up – but I am making a clear and strong stand against the abuse and misuse of terrorism laws to malign direct action protest.' A ban on Palestine Action, which uses direct action to mainly target Israeli weapons factories in the UK and their supply chain, was voted through by parliament this month. Being a member of, or showing support for the group is now a criminal offence after a last-minute legal challenge to suspend the group's proscription failed. The open letter states: 'Peaceful protest tactics which damage property or disrupt 'business-as-usual' in order to call attention to the crimes of the powerful have a long and proud history. They are more urgent than ever in response to Israel's genocide against the Palestinian people.' Other signatories to the letter include the environmental and human rights campaigner Angie Zelter, who was acquitted after disarming a BAE Hawk Jet and who also destroyed infrastructure supporting Britain's Trident nuclear weapons system. She said: 'Effective protest often disrupts 'business as usual'. Halting the cruel arms trade and the dangerous militarisation of our society is really important to me. I have been involved in peaceful civil resistance for decades. I am in full support of civil resistance and of people involved in upholding international law.' Elected representatives who have signed the letter include James Dornan, the Scottish National party MSP for Cathcart who last week put a motion to the Scottish parliament calling for the proscription of the Israel Defense Forces as a terrorist organisation. It was also signed by Gerry Carroll, the socialist activist and member of the legislative assembly for West Belfast, along with Plaid Cymru, Labour and Co-operative councillors. A spokesperson for Glasgow Trades Union Council, which is collectively backing the letter, said: 'As the UK government is attacking our civil liberties, we must ask ourselves if not now, then when?' One of the organisers of the letter was Anne Alexander, a researcher and UCU activist at the University of Cambridge, who said more than 900 people had signed. She said: 'The response to this open letter shows that people up and down the country want to stop arms going to Israel and that they don't agree that a direct action group are 'terrorists' because they tried to disrupt the supply chain fuelling a genocide.' Other signatories include Leanne Wood, the former leader of Plaid Cymru, and Suresh Grover, the veteran civil rights and anti-racist campaigner who was a founder of the Southall Monitoring Group and led campaigns to help the families of Stephen Lawrence, Zahid Mubarek and Victoria Climbié. The draft order to amend the Terrorism Act 2000 and proscribe the group, laid by the home secretary, Yvette Cooper, passed the Commons on 2 July by 385 votes to 26. The order also bans two neo-Nazi groups, the Maniacs Murder Cult and the Russia Imperial Movement. Some MPs and human rights organisations critical of the government's position suggested that bundling Palestine Action with the white supremacist groups had put political pressure on MPs to back the measure.
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
BBC needs to get a grip quicker after controversies, Ofcom head says
The BBC needs to "get a grip quicker" and complete reports and investigations sooner following controversies such as the broadcast of Bob Vylan at Glastonbury, the head of regulator Ofcom has Melanie Dawes said the corporation had "some own goals" over its handling of the punk-rap duo's performance last month and a documentary about Gaza that was withdrawn in Glastonbury Bob Vylan led a chant of "death, death to the IDF [Israel Defence Forces]" and made other derogatory BBC previously issued an apology to viewers, especially the Jewish community, and promised to take action to "ensure proper accountability". Reports into both broadcasts are expected to be published review looking into the broadcast of Gaza: How to Survive a Warzone is due to be published next week, Dame Meanie said. The programme was pulled by the BBC after a link between its 13-year-old narrator and Hamas emerged. Speaking on the BBC's Sunday With Laura Kuenssberg programme, Dame Melanie said: "I think it's very frustrating that the BBC has had some own goals in this area, with the Gaza documentary and then with the Glastonbury coverage, and it does start to erode public trust and confidence."I think I would say that, above all what frustrates me and others, is that when these things go wrong it can take a long time for the BBC to see that something's happened when everybody else was there within a matter of hours."So I would say to the BBC I think they need to get a grip quicker, get these reports and investigations concluded sooner, otherwise there is a real risk of a sort of loss of confidence in the BBC, which is a shame." On the review into the Gaza documentary, a BBC spokesperson said findings will be published as soon as possible, adding: "It is vital that this work is done as quickly as possible, but it must also be thorough and follow a proper process."The BBC is also expected to answer a series of questions asked by Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy over the Bob Vylan a letter to Director General Tim Davie, Nandy asked him to explain by 14 July the broadcast delays, staffing, decisions making, contingency plans and the next BBC also said it will no longer broadcast live performances deemed "high risk" - as Bob Vylan had been assessed - and its director of music, Lorna Clarke, also reportedly stepped back from her day-to-day duties. Asked on the programme whether Dame Melanie had faith in the BBC leadership, she replied: "I think it is a tough job at the top of the BBC. "I think the [BBC] Board and senior team need to get a bit quicker at recognising when something has gone wrong and get a grip of the actions that they need to take or there is going to be a real risk that the BBC loses confidence in what it delivers for the public."We are going to have to see over the next week, I think we are expecting the Gaza report early in the coming week. We have asked a lot of questions about the Glastonbury coverage, the BBC has got a lot on its plate that it needs to address."I think it is important to also recognise that they do deliver a very high-quality job for the public usually, but it is these own goals that are very frustrating they need to be quicker to get on to, quicker to grip and quicker to put right." Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander told the programme the BBC needed "to do a rapid investigation of what has happened in relation to the Glastonbury incident".She said: "They need to do it thoroughly because at the end of the day the BBC needs to maintain the trust of its audience."Shadow home secretary Chris Philp said Bob Vylan was "inciting violence and hatred" and suggested the BBC should be prosecuted for broadcasting the footage."There should be an investigation and if, in the police's opinion, the Crown Prosecution Service's opinion, there is a reasonable prospect of conviction then it should be taken to court."That's the right process and they should go through that, for sure. There's no exemption just because it's the BBC."
