Textile sector may return to costlier CPPs: PD's PPP projections to Nepra draw sharp criticism
The National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (NEPRA) held a public hearing chaired by Waseem Mukhtar, with participation from Member (Technical) Sindh Rafique Ahmad Shaikh, Member (Technical) KPK Maqsood Anwar Khan, and Member (Law) Amina Ahmed.
Discussions revolved low hydrology levels, inflation, interest rate forecasts, GDP growth, solar tariffs, and fuel price assumptions. The Power Division team, led by Additional Secretary Mehfooz Bhatti and CPPA-G's Naveed Qaiser, presented seven scenarios using sensitivity analysis based on demand, hydrology, fuel prices, and exchange rates. In scenario one, CPPA-G has projected PPP at Rs 24.75 per unit, scenario 2- Rs 26.04 per unit, scenario 3- Rs 25.88 per unit, scenario 4- Rs 26.33 per unit, scenario 5- Rs 26.70 per unit, scenario 7- Rs 26.55 per unit and scenario 7, Rs 26.22 per unit. In response to a question, the representative of CPPA-G said that scenario 4 and 5 are likely to be implemented next year. Across the analyzed scenarios, indigenous fuels constitute 55% to 58% of the overall energy mix, while clean fuels contribute between 52% and 56%. Scenario 5 — marked by a high exchange rate of Rs 300/$, low hydrology, standard fuel prices, and normal demand—yields the highest projected PPP at Rs. 26.70/kWh. In contrast, Scenario 4 which assumes normal demand and an exchange rate of Rs 280/$, results in the lowest PPP at Rs. 24.75/kWh, primarily due to reduced capacity charges.
Policy overhaul needed for textile sector
CPPA-G representative Naveed Qaiser noted that the GDP growth, inflation and interest rates were projected on the information from IFIs, Finance Ministry and domestic financial experts.
Amir Sheikh from Lahore stated that industry demands that electricity tariff decreases and in no way increases from July onwards as compared to the April/May/June quarter.
'Already the quality of power from grid is very poor resulting in up to 10% production loss as compared to captive generation and industry is considering switching back to captive. If tariff also increases, then it would lead to big fall in consumption,' he said adding that despite major renegotiations with IPPs, industry is amazed that the proposed tariff for next year is almost the same as last year and the benefit from renegotiations is nowhere to be seen.
'The various price deductions that were announced by Nepra were all time-bound till June. Therefore, if base tariff is not decreased from July 1, 2025 the tariff may increase by Rs 5-6 after the benefit of negative QTA and FCA will be over,' Amir Sheikh said.
Chairman Nepra Waseem Mukhar directed Power Division to look into the viewpoint of industry, especially with recent poor quality of power supply from Discos, which is an irritant for industry and to provide future projections of power rates so that industry can make its plans accordingly.
Mehfooz Bhatti, Additional Secretary Power said that abrupt suspension of supply is a serious issue and he would look into it through Power Planning and Monetary Company (PPMC).
Arif Bilwani said that hydrology assumptions are very critical as we are facing substantially reduced water flows because of draught like conditions. Nepra has already directed the CPPA to prepare report and share and requested that the report be displayed on Nepra website.
'GDP growth figure is also on higher side as the World Bank has revised its projections downward from 2.8% to 2.7%. Demand growth is also not reflecting ground realities. Consistent decline in industrial demand particularly from LSM is being reported for the last 1 1/2 years, he added.
'Benefits of renegotiation with IPPs and GENCOS is not being reflected in Capacity Payments. Further increase in CPP (Rs. 60 billion) will accrue due to Jamshoro imported coal power plant. There is no mention/impact of renegotiation with the left out IPPs, GENCOs & Chinese power plants,' Bilwani argued.
Kibor has been assumed at 11.9% although it is expected to be further reduced during the year reaching single digit. Inflation has been assumed at 8.65% which is extremely high, although the country is already witnessing, as per GOP, the lowest inflation in decades. There is a need to readjust the two figures.
Bilwani further stated that the impact of solar Net Metering has not been properly accounted for in the assumption and requires to be looked at.
The representative of Punjab Power Board enquired as to what was the financial impact of renegotiated IPPs and have the PPAs been made part of the assumption as projections of capacity payments are the same as last year.
Naveed Qaiser responded that government had projected Rs 4 trillion reduction in capacity but reduced it to Rs 2 trillion to 2.4 trillion due to COD of Jamshoro Power Plant which will cost Rs 60 billion and Shahtaj Sugar Mills.
Member KPK, enquired as to how much will the industrial tariff be reduced? The representative of CPPA-G stated that electricity rates can be reduced from 1 per cent to 8 per cent.
According to Qaiser, projections for GDP growth, inflation, and interest rates are based on input from IFIs, Finance Division and other relevant entities.
Nepra Chairman Waseem Mukhtar instructed the Power Division to take the concerns of industry seriously, particularly regarding poor service quality from Discos and future power pricing so industries can plan accordingly.
Bhatti acknowledged that sudden power interruptions are a major issue and added that there is a commitment to addressing them through the PPMC.
Tanveer Barry, representative from KCCI Karachi said that the projected power purchases ranges between Rs 24.75/kWh and Rs 26.22/kWh is still very high. This level of tariff undermines industrial competitiveness and increases the cost of doing business and may deter export growth.
He further argued that the government claimed that it has saved trillions of rupees through negotiated agreement but capacity charges are still very high. In Pakistan industrial sector is paying almost double the electricity price as compared to other regional countries. Time of Use power tariff structure for industrial consumers should be abolished. Industrial consumption is declining because of expensive electricity. Expensive power plants should be shut down and replaced with efficient power plants and renewable energy.
Rehan Jawed stated that the government should take a decision on net metering otherwise it will be become a big issue for the power sector like IPPs issue.
The representative of Aptma, Amir Riaz criticised the planners for making irrelevant decisions. He proposed integrated approach to reduce electricity rates for the industry.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
15 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Crypto mining, other sectors: IMF rejects Pakistan's subsidised power tariffs proposal
ISLAMABAD: The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has rejected Pakistan's proposal to offer subsidised electricity tariffs to crypto mining and certain industrial sectors, warning that such moves would create new complications in the already strained power sector. Testifying before the Senate Standing Committee on Power, chaired by Senator Mohsin Aziz, Secretary Power Dr Fakhray Alam Irfan stated that all major power sector initiatives must be cleared by the IMF. He noted that although Pakistan has surplus electricity, particularly in winter months, the IMF is cautious about any pricing mechanisms that could distort the market. In September 2024, the Power Division proposed a six-month incremental consumption package (October–March) at marginal cost (Rs 23/kWh), based on last year's usage. However, after two months of discussion, the IMF only approved a three-month version, citing potential market distortions. The curious case of Bitcoin mining in Pakistan In a subsequent plan shared in November 2024, the Power Division suggested a targeted marginal cost-based package (Rs 22–23/kWh) for energy-intensive industries such as copper and aluminium melting, data centers, and crypto mining, arguing it would boost consumption of surplus electricity and reduce capacity charges. Still, the IMF rejected the proposal, stating it resembled sector-specific tax holidays that have historically created imbalances. 'As of now, the IMF has not agreed,' Dr Irfan confirmed, adding that the plan is also under review by the World Bank and other development partners. He emphasised that the government has not withdrawn the proposal and remains engaged with international institutions to refine it. During the session, a heated debate also emerged on the government's recent agreement with scheduled banks to reduce the circular debt stock of Rs 1.275 trillion. Senator Shibli Faraz criticised the deal, stating that banks were 'forced at gunpoint' to offer the loans. 'If I were a banker, I would have refused,' he said, warning that the burden would fall on consumers through future levies. Secretary Power rebutted this claim, clarifying that no new levies have been imposed. He stated that the existing Debt Servicing Surcharge (DSS) of Rs 3.23/kWh will continue for the next five to six years to recover the amount. He also highlighted that circular debt inflows have been reduced through timely subsidy injections. On consumer facilitation, Dr Irfan reported that over 500,000 people have downloaded the 'Apna Meter Apni Reading' app, allowing users to upload photos of their meter readings to potentially reduce inflated billing. He said the app will soon be extended to K-Electric (KE) users. The committee also expressed displeasure over the absence of the Federal Minister for Power, who was expected to answer questions on Independent Power Producers (IPPs) and sectoral inefficiencies. Senator Mohsin Aziz said the establishment of certain IPPs was an injustice and questioned why excess profits have not been recovered. Senator Shibli Faraz alleged that inflated project costs were used to justify higher returns, adding that no real steps have been taken to curb the circular debt crisis. 'The public is bearing the burden of government inefficiencies,' he said. Senators raised concerns about forced load shedding, especially in areas like Tharparkar, Matiari, and Umerkot, where daily outages last up to 14 hours, despite consumers paying their bills. Senator Poojo Bheel accused local officials of corruption, claiming they take bribes for illegal connections and restore disconnected supplies for a 'fee'. He emphasised that even paying customers are facing denial of their rights due to systemic failure. In response, Dr Irfan explained that revenue-based load shedding occurs in areas with losses exceeding 20%, citing a tragic case where a SEPCO employee was fatally stabbed during a disconnection drive. KE's Chief Distribution Officer Sadia Dada said that out of 2,100 feeders, about 30% face load shedding due to high electricity theft, often through Kundas (illegal hooks) in informal settlements. She said consumer bills are now offered in instalments to ease payment difficulties. Dr Irfan stated that 58% of consumers fall under the 'protected' category, paying Rs 10 per unit. With the approval of international partners, the government will allocate Rs 250 billion in subsidies, while also rolling out more tech-based solutions for theft control. So far, 500,000 people have downloaded the meter reading app, with 250,000 registered users. Senator Haji Hidayatullah raised an over-billing case involving a Rs 2.3 million charge on a property in Peshawar that had already been cleared by PESCO. He claimed PESCO officials offered to settle the bill for Rs 300,000, calling it blatant corruption. The Secretary Power assured that the matter will be investigated. The CEO of HAZECO also briefed the committee on issues in Sub-Division Lora Chowk, including estimated billing, feeder faults, and pending ELR work under release numbers 46241, 51911, and 51910. Following extensive deliberations, the committee expressed displeasure at the Power Division's repeated deflection of questions and directed the department to submit comprehensive answers at the next meeting. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Express Tribune
19 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Power Division grilled over IPP costs, circular debt
During the rallies and sit-ins, the residents raised slogans against the government and Power Division. PHOTO: FILE The Senate Standing Committee on Power on Wednesday grilled the Power Division over its failure to provide clear answers on the cost and efficiency of the IPPs, the unchecked rise in circular debt and persistent electricity load-shedding during peak summer months. The committee, chaired by Senator Mohsin Aziz, expressed strong dissatisfaction with the Power Division's lack of transparency. "We asked for a global comparative analysis of IPP power plants over a year ago, but no data has been shared," Senator Aziz said. He lamented the division's continued reluctance to share heat efficiency figures, calling the IPP arrangements unjust from the outset. Senator Shibli Faraz lambasted the Power Division for dodging questions. "Over the past four years, we've received no clear answers. These projects were the result of collusion. Costs were artificially inflated to increase profits, not due to genuine investment. This has crippled our economy and burdened generations," he said. He condemned the ongoing use of bank loans to settle circular debt, saying, "We celebrate borrowing like it's a success story". Faraz also stressed that the Power Division must stop hiding behind task forces and face parliamentary scrutiny head-on. Responding to criticism, Power Secretary Rashid Mahmood Langrial explained that circular debt payments were now linked to existing debt-servicing surcharges and assured the committee that no new financial burden would be passed onto consumers. He defended the government's decision to reduce electricity subsidies, saying it helped control the circular debt. Langrial admitted that certain IPPs had been granted excessive rates of return and said, "We have already recovered an additional Rs30 billion in excess profits from IPPs earned through fuel and O&M margins."
Express Tribune
19 hours ago
- Express Tribune
PM lauds KSA's role in truce with India
Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on Wednesday appreciated the efforts by Saudi Arabia for peace in the Middle East as well as its significant role in the ceasefire understanding between Pakistan and India. The prime minister said this in a meeting with Ambassador of Saudi Arabia in Islamabad Nawaf bin Saeed Al Malkiy, while fondly recalling his warm and cordial telephone conversation with the Saudi Crown Prince on June 24 to discuss the regional situation. He conveyed his respectful regards to the Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques King Salman bin Abdulaziz Al Saud and Saudi Crown Prince and Prime Minister Prince Mohamed bin Salman bin Abdulaziz Al Saud. The prime minister told the ambassador that as Pakistan had assumed the rotating Presidency of the UN Security Council for the month of July, it would count on Saudi Arabia's support to ensure that its tenure was conducted smoothly and successfully. The Saudi ambassador thanked the prime minister for Pakistan's role in peace and stability in the region. FBR Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on Wednesday applauded the Ministry of Finance and the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) for achieving a historic 42% increase in federal tax revenues during the fiscal year 2024-25 - the highest surge in the past decade. The prime minister chaired a high-level weekly review meeting on the digitization and reform agenda of the FBR, whereas during the briefing, it was revealed that reforms and enforcement of new tax laws enabled the government to collect an additional Rs 865 billion in revenues compared to the previous year, an eightfold increase.
