North West officials evade responsibility for Madikwe elephant crisis, say MPs
In a scathing parliamentary session on Tuesday, 10 June members of the Portfolio Committee on Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment accused North West officials of gross mismanagement and evasion of responsibility for the ongoing elephant crisis in the Madikwe Game Reserve.
The crisis, years in the making, has led to mass starvation and death among elephants, extensive environmental degradation and a controversial proposal to cull as many as 1,200 of them.
The most damning testimony came from Douglas Wolhurter, manager of the Wildlife Protection Unit at the National Council of Societies for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (NSPCA), whose presentation laid bare a catalogue of failings by the North West Parks and Tourism Board (NWPTB) and the provincial Department of Economic Development, Environment, Conservation and Tourism.
'This is not a sudden crisis,' Wolhurter told the committee. 'It is the result of decades of inaction. The elephant population did not explode overnight – these animals breed slowly. Every warning sign was ignored.'
According to the NSPCA, Madikwe Game Reserve now holds more than 1,600 elephants – more than triple the reserve's original carrying capacity of 500, and more than six times the 250-elephant maximum suggested by early management plans. The consequence has been catastrophic: at least 70 elephants have died of starvation since August 2024, with many more in advanced stages of malnutrition.
The NSPCA documented suffering animals and dead elephants whose tusks had not been removed or logged in accordance with the law – a breach of the Animals Protection Act and TOPS (Threatened or Protected Species) regulations.
Wolhurter's presentation triggered a sharp reaction from members of the committee.
'This is probably one of the most shocking presentations I've seen,' said DA MP Andrew de Blocq. 'It's absolute neglect. What concrete actions have been taken to hold the board and management accountable for what they themselves admit is severe mismanagement?'
Questions by a number of parliamentarians cut to the heart of the crisis: why were long-term preventative measures like immunocontraception denied by NWPTB even though they were offered repeatedly for free by the Humane World for Animals – in 1998, 2020 and 2023?
Why were the NSPCA, despite their legal mandate under the Animals Protection Act, excluded from the second and subsequent meetings of the provincial task team overseeing the crisis response? Why has no independent investigation been launched?
The North West response was weak at best.
Jonathan Denga, acting CEO of the NWPTB, confirmed that the province had known about the issue for years but offered no justification for the failure to act. 'Yes, the elephant population is a serious problem,' Denga said. 'But many of the management options have been exhausted. We are trying to bring balance.'
Pressed by a number of MPs, Denga and NWPTB chairperson Khorommbi Matibe admitted that the NSPCA had not been invited to the task team as promised and gave no timeline for actual action. 'Unfortunately, we were not privy to the NSPCA's presentation beforehand,' said Matibe. 'We need time to study it before responding in detail.'
That response drew a sharp rebuke from committee chairperson Nqabisa Gantsho, who issued a stern directive: 'You have three days to respond. We expect answers by Friday, June 13.'
Wolhurter had previously noted that even though a draft culling plan was shared with the NSPCA in December 2024, the organisation had received no formal updates or invitations to task team meetings since then. 'We were told we'd be included as key stakeholders,' he said, 'but that never happened.'
Meanwhile, public scrutiny is intensifying. A tender issued in May by the NWPTB proposes the trophy hunting of 25 elephants, two black rhinos and 10 buffalo in Madikwe – a move widely condemned by conservationists and tourism operators, who say it risks damaging the reserve's reputation and undermining non-lethal wildlife management strategies.
The North West Parks tender to buy hunting and culling 'packages' for Madikwe game reduction.
Although sold as a 'game reduction' strategy, critics argue that the tender was rushed, non-transparent and economically motivated. 'This is a reputational nightmare,' one lodge operator said anonymously. 'Tourism partners were not even consulted before this tender was issued.'
Scientific assessments presented by the NWPTB and echoed by Wolhurter confirm that the elephant density in Madikwe – at 2.7 animals per square kilometre – is likely to be the highest of any enclosed reserve in South Africa. In contrast, the average for state-run reserves is just 0.79 elephants per square kilometre.
While all sides agree that the current population is unsustainable, the divergence lies in how to respond. The NSPCA has called for immediate inclusion in the task team, independent oversight of any culling process and long-term ecological restoration – beginning with invasive species removal and veld recovery.
But even the basics are missing. 'We're still waiting for a detailed ecological restoration plan,' De Blocq pointed out. 'There is nothing measurable in place to rehabilitate the veld or ensure that the reserve can sustain its intended population.'
In closing, Gantsho didn't mince her words: 'This is a matter of urgency. We have seen suffering animals. We have seen death. We have seen degradation. The time for delays is over.'
This week will reveal whether North West can rise to the occasion – or continue evading accountability. DM
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
a day ago
- The Citizen
One million trees campaign kicks off at Botanical Gardens
One million trees campaign kicks off at Botanical Gardens The Department of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment (DFFE) recently launched its One Million Trees campaign at the National Botanical Gardens. Led by Deputy Minister Bernice Swarts, various stakeholders attended the July 7 launch. It followed the One Employee, One Tree launch at the DFFE Head Office in April. 'The country has borne the brunt of climate change and the resultant devastation it causes in communities and economies. We have witnessed fires, deadly heatwaves, heavy rains, floods, and prolonged droughts. These events underscore our shared vulnerability, but also our shared responsibility to act, to adapt, and to do so in a way that leaves no one behind,' Swarts said. President Cyril Ramaphosa has directed that 10 million trees, comprising 60% fruit and 40% indigenous, be planted in the country over five years, ending in 2026. Among others, attendees included: – Deputy Minister of Women, Youth, and Persons with Disabilities, Mapaseka Steve Letsike – Dean of the Diplomatic Corps and Ambassador of Eritrea, HE Mr Salih Omar Abdu – High Commissioner of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, HE Mr Malik Muhammad Farooq – His Majesty Morena Moremoholo Motebang Mopeli of the Bakoena Royal House (Qwaqwa). The DFFE plans to use the campaign to create employment opportunities through tree planting and tackle the high cost of living by integrating fruit trees into food security efforts. 'Tree planting is one of the mitigating factors that are recommended to slow down this environmental threat. It is for this reason that the department is pursuing the co-ordination and implementation of the National Greening Programme,' Swarts stated. She said that if trees that are suitable for a particular area are planted, and we continue working with researchers, the battle against climate change will slowly be won. The DFFE has developed a list of suitable trees that can be planted in different provinces and climate zones. They have also developed a database of nurseries where trees will be sourced through the QR system developed to access the pledge form and the catalogue of the nurseries. Swarts said, 'We have made a provision to accommodate those sponsors who intend to contribute trees. The South African National Biodiversity Institute (SANBI) has designated spaces to be used as a tree bank, where the donated trees will be stored. 'The donated trees will be stored at the 11 National Botanical Gardens across the country and DFFE nurseries, while we are finalising logistics for the one million trees planting day, September 24. We are dedicating that day to planting trees across the country, as we commemorate Heritage Day.' The department has also identified spaces where trees will survive for generations, and the trees will be planted there. These are areas where most of the requirements to plant and care for trees, such as availability of water, dedicated people to take care of the trees, security or fencing, are met. These include public institutions, early childhood development centres, churches, schools, police stations, clinics, some low-cost housing units, and many other places. To date, a list of sites where trees will be planted has been developed and is being refined as input from stakeholders is gathered. Swarts closed off with a quote from the first African woman to receive the Nobel Peace Prize, Kenyan Wangari Maathai: 'When we plant trees, we plant the seeds of peace and hope.' Do you have more information about the story? Please send us an email to [email protected] or phone us on 083 625 4114. For free breaking and community news, visit Rekord's websites: Rekord East For more news and interesting articles, like Rekord on Facebook, follow us on Twitter or Instagram or TikTok. At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!
Daily Maverick
3 days ago
- Daily Maverick
New regulations gazetted to shield fragile marine ecosystems from oil spill risks in SA
The government has released stricter draft regulations on offshore ship-to-ship transfers in an attempt to protect South Africa's fragile marine ecosystems. Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment Minister Dion George has now gazetted new draft regulations to manage offshore ship-to-ship transfers, including bunkering, to mitigate environmental impacts on the coastal environment. This is the second iteration of the draft regulations for the environmental management of offshore ship-to-ship transfer and was gazetted on Friday, 4 July 2025, for a 30-day public comment period (until 3 August 2025). This follows a previous iteration and public consultation. The regulations introduce stricter controls, particularly in ecologically sensitive areas like Algoa Bay, to protect critically endangered species such as the African Penguin. Daily Maverick previously reported on concerns raised about the initial draft, particularly from environmental groups like the Biodiversity Law Centre (BLC). Ship-to-ship bunkering, included in ship-to-ship transfers, is a process of refuelling ships at sea, avoiding port levies and securing a faster turnaround time, but more significantly, and as said by the Southern African Foundation for the Conservation of Coastal Birds (Sanccob): 'It is a process that is effectively eradicating a variety of endangered species inhabiting Algoa Bay.' Announcing the gazette of the new draft regulations, the Department of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment said that this was part of the minister's 'steadfast commitment' to safeguarding South Africa's marine biodiversity, and especially the critically endangered African penguin. For years, the practice of offshore bunkering in South African waters has been a flashpoint of environmental concern. The refuelling of ships at sea has been intrinsically linked to a disturbing rise in oil spills, increased vessel noise, and a catastrophic decline in African penguin populations, especially in Algoa Bay. One of the core debates has been around the fact that ship-to-ship bunkering was not specifically listed under the Environmental Impact Assessment regulations of the National Environmental Management Act of 1998. This omission meant that approvals could be granted without a thorough assessment of direct, indirect, or cumulative impacts, effectively sidelining crucial stakeholder input. The Biodiversity Law Centre had consistently advocated for the urgent inclusion of bunkering within the environmental regulatory framework, noting that four significant oil spills since 2016 had severely affected seabirds, and that the once-largest African penguin breeding colony on St Croix Island in Algoa Bay had plummeted by approximately 85% since 2016 — with the sharp decline directly linked to ship-to-ship bunkering activities in the area. From the four oil spills since 2016, 260 endangered African penguins and other marine species were affected, according to George. Sanccob has also argued that ship-to-ship bunkering comes with 'a vortex of destructive consequences' for marine life in Algoa Bay. This is the only area where the practice is permitted by the Transnet National Ports Authority. 'Ship-to-ship bunkering is synonymous with underwater noise pollution, oil pollution, and increased vessel traffic in an area once home to the largest breeding colony of African penguins on St Croix Island,' said Sanccob. In a statement announcing the second iteration of draft regulations, George said: 'The African penguin is an iconic species, and its survival is non-negotiable. These draft regulations represent a critical step in balancing environmental protection with sustainable maritime activities, ensuring our marine ecosystems thrive for future generations.' Recent oil spill in the Eastern Cape Just last week, several African penguin fledglings were recovered, covered in oil, from the Garden Route to Jeffrey's Bay in the Eastern Cape. According to Sanccob, three penguins were rescued by the Seabird and Penguin Rehabilitation Centre, Tenikwa, and CapeNature, while a fourth was rescued in Jeffrey's Bay by a Sanccob first responder and taken to Sanccob Gqeberha. Suspected oil globs were also observed near Cape St Francis, and the South African Maritime Safety Authority and the Department of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment were notified. Sanccob said that the source of the pollution was still unknown, with no official oil spill reported. But they said that this incident underscored the significant deficiency in South Africa's maritime pollution monitoring, leading to reactive rather than proactive response efforts and potentially allowing polluters to go undetected. 'African penguins are often the first indicators of a marine pollution event. Their inability to fly and diving behaviour make them especially vulnerable to oil contamination. As a Critically Endangered species, any pollution event — no matter how small — continues to pose a serious threat,' said Sanccob in response to this incident. Key provisions and amendments in the new draft regulations George said that the primary objective of this new legislation was to ensure that the actual and potential environmental impacts of offshore ship-to-ship transfers were effectively mitigated and avoided, or, where avoidance was not possible, minimised and remedied. To do this, the updated draft regulations introduce several critical provisions and amendments from their first iteration, reflecting consultations with stakeholders including the South African Maritime Safety Authority, Transnet National Ports Authority, the Department of Transport, and South African National Parks (SANParks). Below are some of the key provisions and amendments: A notable change is the renaming of the regulations from 'bunkering' to 'ship-to-ship transfer', which clarifies the broad scope of activities covered, including the transfer of various liquid bulk cargoes such as chemicals, oil, petroleum products, and liquified natural gas, in addition to fuel. The regulations also explicitly state that they bind all persons and organs of state, ensuring universal compliance. To protect ecologically sensitive areas, the regulations introduce strict prohibitions. No ship-to-ship transfer is permitted within marine protected areas, five nautical miles of a marine protected area's boundary, five nautical miles of an aquaculture development zone, or within three nautical miles of the high-water mark. According to the gazette, critical biodiversity areas were removed from the prohibitions due to a lack of legislative clarity and objective determination — the focus is on clearly defined exclusion zones. When it comes to Algoa Bay, the regulations permit continued operations but with more stringent controls. A cap of three operators and six ship-to-ship transfer tankers is imposed, along with restrictions during the African penguin breeding season (April 1 to August 31) in Anchorage Area 2, which is closest to the breeding colonies. New draft regulations have been gazetted to manage offshore ship-to-ship transfers, including bunkering, to mitigate environmental impacts on the coastal environment. This means that now, authorised ship-to-ship transfer operators in Algoa Bay may only operate within anchorage areas 1 and 2 as detailed in this map. (Source: Forestry, Fisheries & The Enviroment) The outright ban on nighttime bunkering has also been adjusted in the regulations. Nighttime operations are now allowed under stringent conditions, requiring approval from the South African Maritime Safety Authority for the operator's ability to detect, manage, and respond to spills at night, including a nighttime emergency spill response drill, and an approved nighttime spill detection and recovery plan as part of the Ship-to-Ship Environmental Management Plan. The regulations also mandate a constant watch for marine mammals and penguins 30 minutes prior to and during ship-to-ship transfer. They require the installation of active hydrophone systems with live streaming capabilities to detect marine mammals within 500m of the operation. Operations must cease if a marine mammal or penguin is sighted or detected within 500m of the site. Operators are also required to immediately report injured, deceased, entangled, oiled, or disorientated marine wildlife and are responsible for collecting and transporting oiled wildlife to authorised facilities. To prevent spills, operators must use drip trays, implement leak detection and repair programmes, use low-toxicity biodegradable detergents for cleaning, and deploy inflatable curtain booms. An oil spill response vessel must be on standby within 30 minutes of an incident, rather than requiring it to be on-site at all times, balancing safety with operational practicality. Last, but not at all least, is that Ship-to-Ship Environmental Management Plans must be developed by independent specialists and approved by the minister within 90 days. These Environmental Management Plans must include: Site-specific environmental and ecological risk identification and mitigation measures. A wildlife preparedness and response strategy based on international guidelines. A comprehensive contingency plan, including risk assessment of spills, operational protocols, and details of spill response vessels and personnel. Underwater noise mitigation and management measures. Emergency response procedures for collisions or entanglements involving marine life. A monitoring programme for surface currents, oil spills, noise, and impacts on marine life. All crew members involved in ship-to-ship transfer must also undergo environmental awareness training, covering marine wildlife awareness and avoidance, understanding environmental impacts and mitigation measures, and emergency preparedness. While the new regulations demonstrate progress, certain concerns raised by environmental groups like the Biodiversity Law Centre persist. The centre continues to advocate for offshore bunkering to be listed as an activity requiring a full Environmental Impact Assessment under the National Environmental Management Act, which would necessitate public participation before authorisation. These new draft regulations, though seemingly technical, carry implications for everyone, directly affecting the environment, the economy, and the quality of life along the nation's vast coastline. Comments on the new draft regulations can be mailed to [email protected] with more information on the department's website. DM
Daily Maverick
02-07-2025
- Daily Maverick
World wetlands guardian calls for urgent report on SA's ‘forgotten' reserve
The custodians of the world's most valuable wetland areas have sent another reminder to South Africa to submit a long-overdue report about the long-standing threats facing the Ndumo Game Reserve in KwaZulu-Natal. In a report published ahead of the 15th meeting of the Ramsar Convention on Wetlands in Zimbabwe next month, the treaty secretariat has once again requested a detailed report on the future of the 10,000-hectare Ndumo reserve, which lies on the border between northern KZN and Mozambique. Noting that a status report on Ndumo has been outstanding for more than six years, the secretariat has now urged South Africa to give 'high priority' to compiling and submitting this report. The international convention, focused on the conservation and sustainable use of globally important wetlands – such as the Pantanal in South America, the Okavango Delta in Botswana or The Sudd in South Sudan – is named after an Iranian city where the global wetlands convention was signed in 1971. Ndumo is one of 31 sites in South Africa recognised for their global importance in wetland conservation, but it was occupied by subsistence farmers just before the 2009 election season, when they were promised initial access to a small 20ha patch of the reserve to plant vegetables in some of the wettest and most fertile soils of the reserve. Since then, well more than 600ha of Ndumo has been cultivated or transformed by human activity, an area at least 30 times larger than the original area promised to communities. Ndumo, which celebrated its 100th anniversary last year, was proclaimed in 1924 mainly to provide sanctuary for the rapidly vanishing hippos of the Maputaland region, which once ranked as the third-largest hippo population in South Africa. Recent academic studies suggest that hippo and crocodile numbers in Ndumo have declined dramatically, coupled with a major escalation in wildlife poaching, the felling of forest vegetation for firewood and gillnetting of fish from the Phongola River. The Ezemvelo KZN Wildlife agency reported seeing more than 500 cattle in the eastern part of the reserve during a recent helicopter game census, along with more than 150 boats that are used to access farming fields or to place illegal gillnets. In terms of article 3.2 of the convention member nations are required to report any threats to Ramsar sites 'at the earliest possible time'. It remains unclear what official notification procedures South Africa has followed since the first threats emerged about 17 years ago, but according to briefing documents on the Ramsar website, the secretariat opened a file on Ndumo in June 2019 following a third-party report that the reserve was under threat from 'extensive farming activities coupled with significant management issues'. Earlier this year, Daily Maverick sent queries about this issue to the Department of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment, which acts as the country's Ramsar administrative authority. In response to questions, the department said on 6 March that no article 3.2 reports on Ndumo had been submitted to Ramsar, although the department was 'aware of the challenges' facing the reserve. It added that the department was awaiting the results of a water quality assessment report on Ndumo, but gave no clear indication of the reasons for the long delay in providing information to Ramsar. The department has also not responded to further questions from Daily Maverick sent on 23 June, requesting reasons for the six-year delay in providing information to Ramsar. Dr Simon Pooley, a conservation researcher at Birkbeck, University of London who has been trying to call attention to the threats facing Ndumo for several years, has expressed dismay about the apparent inaction and 'obfuscation' by the department. He noted that Ndumo's crocodile population had suffered a 'catastrophic collapse', declining from about 1,000 in the 1990s to about 300 in 2023. The number of hippo in Ndumo had also dropped from 300 to just 80 over a similar period. Though there are now just more than 2,500 Ramsar sites globally, covering more than 2.5 million km², convention signatories remain concerned about the rapid loss of wetland areas across the world. At the convention's 15th meeting in Zimbabwe from 23 to 31 July, treaty members will be asked to endorse the Victoria Falls Declaration on global wetland protection. A draft version of the declaration on the Ramsar website calls on government ministers and delegation heads at the Victoria Falls meeting to 'recognise the urgent need for strong political will and concrete action to advance the conservation, restoration, management and wise and sustainable use of all types of wetlands'. DM
