Mayor claims she was exonerated of VBS graft allegations
VBS Mutual Bank customers queue outside the bank , demanding their money in Thohoyandou, Limpopo, on 20 June 2018. Picture: Gallo Images/ANTONIO MUCHAVE/SOWETAN
Bojanala Platinum district municipality mayor Suzan Nthangeni is disputing that she is implicated in a forensic report into VBS Mutual Bank investment graft at Madibeng local municipality.
Instead, Nthangeni, who was MMC for finance at Madibeng municipality in 2017, the time of the illegal investment of R50 million of the municipality's funds into the VBS Bank, said the report by independent firm Movundlela Consulting that implicated her and three senior officials lacked credibility.
The report accused Nthangeni, manager of financial reporting Lucky Steenkamp, manager of expenditure and acting chief financial officer Siza Rikhotso and Bonolo Koitsiwe, head of cash, investment and grant management, of being involved in the VBS investment graft and recommended that criminal cases be opened against them with the SA Police Service for contravening the Municipal Finance Management Act (MFMA).
ALSO READ: Is Ramaphosa's refusal to fire Simelane a survival strategy?
The forensic investigation, instituted by then chief financial officer Morris Maluleke, said Steenkamp failed to keep an original contract document signed between Madibeng and VBS on the investment, as required by policy. The document went missing.
The report said Steenkamp and Rikhotso allegedly took the decision to invest with VBS and Nthangeni allegedly suggested VBS be allowed to submit a quote. Rikhotso allegedly instructed that the bank to be chosen for the investment.
It also found they allegedly contravened the MFMA and were suspected of graft.
But when the Movundlela report was tabled in council in 2018, it was rejected by council because it was instituted by Maluleke, who was chief financial officer, as that constituted a conflict of interest and natural justice.
Nobody was implicated by the provincial probe or charged for the VBS matter.
ALSO READ: Former CFO gets 5-year sentence and R150k fine in VBS scandal
Maluleke subsequently became a municipal manager and Rikhotso a chief financial officer.
The provincial administration instituted another forensic investigation by audit firm SikelaXabiso and its report was tabled in council and its recommendation adopted. The report absolved Nthangeni, Steenkamp, Rikhotso and Koitsiwe of any wrongdoing.
Recently, some ANC members called for Nthangeni to be removed as Bojanala mayor as the party policy is that no member implicated in the VBS scandal should be appointed to a state position. But Nthangeni said she was innocent as the provincial forensic investigation report, which was adopted by council, exonerated her.
NOW READ: Floyd Shivambu may have seen MK as a 'haven' with VBS cloud hanging over him
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The South African
2 hours ago
- The South African
New R50 million tidal pool planned for Hout Bay Beach
A brand new tidal pool project at Hout Bay Beach has been approved, with the first step reportedly set to begin soon. According to IOL , the project, led by Sandy Daniel and the Feel Good Initiative (FGI), aims to create a safe, inclusive, and environmentally sensitive swimming space. It is intended to benefit underserved communities such as Imizamo Yethu and Hangberg, who have limited access to secure recreational coastal facilities. Other goals for the tidal pool project include improving ocean safety, supporting marine education, boosting eco-tourism, and ensuring minimal environmental impact. The design will also blend with the natural shoreline and replace an ageing revetment. The tidal pool is estimated to cost about R50 million. FGI is preparing a sponsorship prospectus to secure funding. 'This is a major community project we are working on through The Feel Good Initiative. The first phase of the project involves appointing a qualified Environmental Assessment Practitioner (EAP), and we are in the process of securing the necessary funding to move this stage forward.' Daniel said, as per IOL . The proposed tidal pool site also lies within a Marine Protected Area, and FGI stressed its commitment to protecting sensitive ecosystems by incorporating natural rock formations, consulting marine biologists, and ensuring ongoing environmental monitoring. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1. Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
TimesLIVE
4 hours ago
- TimesLIVE
Disbarred advocate, ex-Limpopo MEC Seth Nthai sentenced for corruption
Disbarred advocate and former Limpopo safety MEC Seth Nthai has been sentenced to two years behind bars or a fine of R500,000 after he pleaded guilty to corruption. Nthai tried to solicit a R5m bribe from Italian businessman Mario Vittorrio Marcenaro and his associates 16 years ago. On Wednesday Nthai entered into a plea agreement with the state in the Johannesburg high court. He was then found guilty and sentenced. The court ordered him to pay the first R50,000 immediately after the order. Thereafter he would pay R50,000 monthly until March 2026. In exchange for the R5m gratification he offered to accept from Marcenaro, he would use his influence to get the government to agree to settle the matter [dispute] with each party paying its own costs Court documents At the time he asked for a bribe, Nthai was representing the government, which was locked in a mining dispute with Italian businesses. According to the state, not only did Nthai solicit a bribe, but he also disclosed the merits of the government's case, defences, technical strategies, possible settlement and possible reward if the case was settled in favour of Marcenaro or other claimants of the case. 'In exchange for the R5m gratification he offered to accept from Marcenaro, he would use his influence to get the government to agree to settle the matter [dispute] with each party paying its own costs,' according to court documents. Nthai was disbarred in 2013 but later readmitted by the Limpopo High Court which found depression and anxiety could explain his attempt to solicit a R5m bribe. The Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) later overturned his readmission to the bar and referred the ruling to the National Prosecuting Authority to consider possible criminal charges. The SCA at the time ruled that on his own version there was no escape from the fact that his attempt to solicit a bribe constituted a serious crime, for which he was not charged.
The Citizen
8 hours ago
- The Citizen
Outa urges probe into R56 million Polokwane tender scandal
Polokwane municipality has rejected corruption allegations as politically motivated, claiming the tender processes were lawful. The non-profit civil rights group, Organisation Undoing Tax Abuse (Outa), has called on relevant authorities to investigate allegations of more than R50 million worth of corruption involving the Polokwane mayor and municipal manager. Outa CEO Wayne Duvenage was reacting to allegations that mayor John Mpe and municipal manager Thuso Nemugumoni awarded a R56.3 million tender to a company linked to a Zimbabwean national believed to be close to them. Whistle-blower report prompts Outa's call for action The allegation surfaced recently after the matter was reported by local media and shared on social media. 'These allegations should be investigated, more so if the anonymous whistle-blower provides sufficient evidence/facts about the allegations,' Duvenage said. 'The extent of corruption and patronage in municipalities is outrageous. All oversight entities and the criminal justice system must act with urgency to assess the facts, suspend the individuals concerned and ensure accountability and if necessary, criminal charges are applied soonest.' Opposition reveals scale of irregular contracts DA councillor Jacques Joubert said the allegations contained in the documents 'show that there were irregularities with about 28 foreign-owned companies awarded tenders amounting to more than R740 million. 'The spreadsheets outline bid numbers and contract values mostly awarded between 2022 and 2023,' said Joubert. ALSO READ: DA wants Joburg tenders linked to Kenny Kunene investigated 'According to the documents, the tenders were given to people with proximity to the high-level officials. Where there is smoke, there is often fire. Mayor urged to support independent investigation 'The outcome of the investigations that we want on the matter should be made public to ensure full transparency and accountability. If the mayor and city manager indeed feel they have nothing to hide, they should welcome any independent investigation into the matter. 'I understand the mayor has ambitions to become premier, so he would need to tackle this cloud over his name.' Polokwane municipality dismisses allegations Municipal spokesperson Thipa Selala denied the allegations and said it was a smear campaign aimed at discrediting the two officials. Selala defended the mayor and municipal manager. 'We would like to address the recent defamatory claims circulating on digital platforms. It is both necessary and urgent to clarify the facts and expose the political motives behind a series of orchestrated attacks aimed at undermining the integrity of the municipality and its leadership. Officials blame political motives and selective outrage 'The people of Polokwane deserve the truth, not sensationalised fiction designed to destabilise the municipality that is focused on service delivery, clean governance and inclusive development,' Selala said. 'We have noted with concern, contempt and disappointment the continued circulation of unfounded, malicious and misleading allegations on anonymous online platforms. ALSO READ: Man sentenced for defrauding Amtola Water Board in tender scam 'These claims attempt to falsely implicate the mayor and manager and we reject these allegations as baseless, defamatory and politically motivated.' Selala said the matter was an orchestrated smear campaign and politically motivated. 'These attacks often resurface around politically significant periods and are part of a broader agenda by individuals and factions that have lost democratic influence.' He added that the municipality did business with more than 100 companies and service providers across diverse categories of work. It was concerning and suspicious that only a select few were being singled out. 'Why is Polokwane municipality being singled out?' 'It is also important to note that many of the companies listed in recent allegations have been awarded contracts through lawful, competitive bidding processes, before the appointments of both the mayor and municipal manager.' He said that some of the accused companies and others had ongoing relationships with the municipality as far back as 2017, 2018 and 2020 – well before the current leadership team. 'Why is Polokwane municipality being singled out? The answer lies not in procurement irregularities – of which there are none – but in an intensifying campaign of targeted misinformation.' NOW READ: Gauteng health maintains court 'misinterpreted law in waste tender matter
