Cops accused of squatting in uber-exclusive Long Island getaway after breaking in with crowbars: ‘Not seen in 200 years'
The peace on bucolic Fishers Island – an uber-exclusive getaway far off Long Island only reachable by boat – has been shattered by a platoon of police officers who broke into a home with crowbars and forcefully kicked out ferry workers living there, a shocking new lawsuit claims.
The $2 million suit filed by Fishers Island Ferry District officials argues the snooty town and Southold police have been trespassing at 357 Whistler Ave. for half a year – and brazenly broke property laws prohibiting wrongful evictions.
Advertisement
The 'actions have not been seen in this country, if at all, in at least 200 years,' the lawsuit argued.
3 Cops on ritzy Fishers Island are accused of squatting in a home.
Google Earth
The tempest on the isolated isle began soon after Southold cops took over the island's policing duties in November.
Advertisement
But the island's deteriorating police barracks – which were vacated by state police in 2023 – evidently weren't up to snuff, so town officials offered the Ferry District's home a few houses over as a temporary place for the cops to set up shop, according to the lawsuit.
Instead, Southold town board members voted on Dec. 17 to revoke the Ferry District's control of the property, without referring to any law permitting the action, the lawsuit contends.
The Ferry District didn't approve of the idea, given they had renovated and got it permitted for staff housing, the lawsuit states.
District board members rejected the planned seizure in a vote of their on Dec. 30, but on New Year's Day the cops still forced their way inside, the suit claims.
Advertisement
'In the face of the Ferry District's refusal… the Town Board directed the police department to engage in self-help by breaking into and occupying the property,' the complaint states.
3 Southold Town Police Department cops are now occupying the Fishers Island home.
Facebook/Southold Town Police Department
3 Southold took over policing duties on Fishers Island in November.
Facebook/Southold Town Police Department
The lawsuit claims the police department forcibly kicked out the Ferry District's staff and cops have been living there illegally for more than five months, threatening to arrest anyone who tries to remove them.
Advertisement
The district is now working to obtain a court order to remove the allegedly squatting cops from the property, declaring the 'occupation' as unconstitutional, and seeking $2 million in damages.
Southold Town Supervisor Al Krupski declined to comment, but said the town remains committed to renovating the abandoned police barracks.
Both sides are due in court for a pre-motion conference on June 25 before Suffolk Supreme Court Justice Joseph Farneti.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
11 hours ago
Lone wolf actor biggest threat to 4th of July festivities in New York, San Francisco: FBI, DHS bulletins
A lone wolf actor poses the biggest threat to Fourth of July celebrations in New York and San Francisco, according to multiple intelligence bulletins obtained by ABC News. The Department of Homeland Security and the FBI are concerned about the potential for copycat attacks from the New Orleans terror attack on New Year's Day, as well as homegrown extremists. "We are concerned about the potential threat of copycat attacks inspired by the 2025 New Year's Day vehicle-ramming attack in New Orleans and continued [foreign terrorist organizations] messaging calling for attacks against Western targets," both bulletins say. Those who could be inspired by terrorist organizations who are in the U.S., are of concern for law enforcement, according to the bulletins. In New York, officials are concerned about individuals "motivated by a broad range of racial, ethnic, political, religious, anti-government, societal, or personal grievances." "Of these actors, US-based violent extremists supporting FTOs and [Domestic violent extremists] not linked to FTOs represent two of the most persistent threats," the bulletins say. "Lone offenders, in particular, remain a concern due to their ability to often avoid detection until operational and to inflict significant casualties." In San Francisco, "malicious actors, including violent extremists and criminals, could potentially exploit or target First Amendment-protected demonstrations via mass casualty or opportunistic attacks; dangerous, destructive, or disruptive activity; or other criminal disruptions, as we have seen with other events in the past," according to DHS. "We remain concerned that these malicious actors and violent extremists may attempt to create public safety hazards using weapons, chemical irritants, bodily fluids, or other hazardous materials, and enter and disrupt designated event areas that are closed to public access," say both bulletins dated June 23, 2025. Authorities are also concerned about drones, which may pose a danger to participants, attendees and law enforcement, authorities say. The conflict in the Middle East between Israel and Hamas is also of concern, and authorities cite last month's Molotov cocktail attack in Boulder, Colorado, and bias against the Jewish community as an indicator. "Individuals with grievances linked to the conflict could also perceive large gatherings, such as Independence Day celebrations, as opportunistic targets symbolic of the West in general," according to the law enforcement bulletins.
Boston Globe
5 days ago
- Boston Globe
Cohasset man who allegedly killed, dismembered wife wants Google searches tossed
Walshe's consent was necessary at the time because State Police hadn't obtained a warrant for the devices. In Thursday's filing, Walshe's lawyers said the agreement covered 'all communications' between Dec. 25, 2022, and Jan. 6, 2023, the date the electronics were turned over. The sole exception was for communications between Walshe and his lawyer, the filing said. Advertisement Miner testified that the agreement did not include GPS location data or any browser or Internet searches, the defense said. Walshe's current lawyers said investigators 'obtained the internet searches and GPS/data location information in the same act of illegality, exceeding the scope of the consent.' According to the memo, State Police began a forensic search of the devices on the night of Jan. 6, 2023, and continued into the early hours of Jan. 7. An investigator who conducted the work alerted colleagues on the evening of Jan. 7 to the Internet searches in question, which were later referenced in an affidavit for a search warrant, records show. But before a warrant was issued, the filing said, 'police willingly and knowingly violated the agreement by exceeding the agreed-upon scope by downloading and searching the entire content of' Walshe's phone, his son's laptop, and a third laptop with a cracked screen that he turned over. Advertisement The filing didn't detail the Google searches, but at Walshe's January 2023 district court arraignment for allegedly killing his wife, They included 'how to embalm a body,' '10 ways to dispose of a dead body if you really need to,' 'how to stop a body from decomposing,' and 'how long before a body starts to smell.' They were made between 4:55 a.m. and 5:47 a.m. on New Year's Day, prosecutors said. In court, Walshe at one point shook his head during the recitation of the searches. Days before allegedly killing his wife, Walshe, who in 2021 pleaded guilty to scamming a Los Angeles art collector out of $80,000, had inquired online about divorce, Assistant Norfolk District Attorney Lynn Beland said at his arraignment. 'On Dec. 27, the defendant Googled 'what's the best state to divorce for a man?' ' Beland said. 'Rather than divorce, it is believed Brian Walshe dismembered Ana Walshe and discarded her body.' Additional search terms, Beland said, included 'can you throw away body parts,' 'what does formaldehyde do,' 'how long does DNA last,' 'can identification be made from partial remains,' 'dismemberment and best ways to dispose of a body,' and 'what happens when you put body parts in ammonia,' as well as 'hacksaw best tool to dismember,' and 'can you be charged with murder without a body.' Advertisement During Walshe's April 2023 Walshe had been closely monitoring the Instagram page of a man he believed his wife was having an affair with, prosecutors said. When he lost touch with Ana Walshe for about 24 hours around Christmas 2022, he and his mother hired a private investigator to follow her around Washington, D.C., where she had taken a new job with a real estate company, according to court documents. On New Year's Eve 2022, the couple hosted Ana Walshe's former employer at their house, who left around 1:30 a.m. 'That was the last time someone had seen Ana Walshe alive outside of the defendant,' prosecutor Greg Connor said. The guest told investigators he had dinner with the couple and they shared champagne and wine, according to an affidavit. Brian and Ana Walshe were in a good mood and everyone enjoyed themselves, he said, adding that Ana Walshe appeared to be a bit 'tipsy' from the alcohol, while Brian Walshe appeared unimpaired. By 4:50 a.m., authorities allege, Ana Walshe, 39, was dead, and the disturbing Google searches started. Over the next several days, prosecutors allege, Walshe dismembered his wife's body in the basement and discarded her clothes and other evidence in a dumpster at a liquor store near his mother's home in Swampscott. He also allegedly disposed her remains in dumpsters at apartment complexes in Abington and Brockton. Police also allegedly found blood in the basement of the couple's home. Seven days after Ana Walshe's disappearance, police searched the dumpster near the home of Brian Walshe's mother. Inside, they found a COVID vaccination card for Ana Walshe, a Hermes watch, and clothing Ana Walshe was known to wear, according to prosecutors. Forensic testing showed her DNA on items found in the dumpster, prosecutors said. Advertisement Walshe, 50, has pleaded not guilty to charges of first-degree murder, lying to investigators, and disinterring a body. He remains held without bail, and his trial is scheduled to begin in October, records show. Material from prior Globe stories was used in this report. Travis Andersen can be reached at
Miami Herald
6 days ago
- Miami Herald
Man fatally attacked on New Year's and urinated on, MO cops say. Now, 1 sentenced
A 20-year-old and a 22-year-old launched a deadly attack on a man on New Year's Day 2024 to rob him for beer and cigarette money, Missouri police said. Now, one of the accused attackers has been sentenced to 20 years in prison. Nathan Kehn, 20, pleaded guilty to second-degree murder, armed criminal action and robbery in the death of 52-year-old Tyrone Venney, according to a June 23 news release from the St. Louis, Missouri 22nd Judicial Circuit Court. His attorney could not be reached for comment. Kehn and Branden Leachman, 22, brutally attacked Venney by punching, kicking, stomping and hitting him on the head with a glass bottle, according to a probable cause affidavit filed on Jan. 2, 2024. They knocked the man unconscious, stole his wallet and urinated on him, according to police and prosecutors. Kehn and Leachman took the man's money and used it to purchase beer and cigarettes from the store across the street, the affidavit said. Leachman told police he recorded the attack, according to the probable cause statement. Kehn told police he tried to kill the man by breaking his neck, police said. Venney was paralyzed and taken to an intensive care unit, police said. He died in June 2024 in a long-term care unit in Illinois, officials said. Leachman was indicted on the same charges in December 2024, according to a superseding indictment. His jury trial is scheduled for Sept. 9.
