Concern over chemicals in mass sewage discharges into Shotover River
Photo:
RNZ / Tess Brunton
Wastewater being discharged into Queenstown's Shotover River could breach national ammonia limits, Otago Regional Council says.
In March, the Queenstown Lakes District Council (QLDC) used emergency powers to
begin pumping treated effluent into the river
each day from its wastewater treatment plant - the equivalent of nearly five Olympic-sized swimming pools a day.
It retrospectively applied for consent in May, then last week
applied for the case to be handled
by the Environment Court.
However, a letter now published online shows Otago Regional Council (ORC) had already assessed the application, and placed it on hold due to several concerns.
In the letter dated 19 June, Consents Processing Planner Hannah Goslin said QLDC needed to provide more evidence to support its claim the discharge would have "less than minor" impacts.
"The application relies on a small amount of monitoring data to support the conclusions reached in terms of the scale and significance of effects," she said.
ORC raised concerns about ammonia and phosphorus concentrations observed in the river.
It said monitoring at five sites suggested "potential for the discharge to cause exceedances of the national bottom line for ammonia", and it asked why QLDC had not set a discharge quality limit for phosphorus.
It said QLDC claimed the river would dilute the treated wastewater by 15 to 25 times - but had not backed that up with any hydraulic modelling, dye tests, or flow calculations.
ORC also wanted more evidence to support QLDC's claim there was an initial "flush" of germs when the discharge began.
It also called for a public health risk assessment to evaluate the likelihood of illness from disease-causing microorganisms in the treated wastewater - particularly given the river's "suitability for bathing."
ORC gave QLDC until 11 July to respond to its letter.
"If the information you provide raises more questions, your application will remain on hold until sufficient information has been provided to enable processing to continue," Goslin said.
On Friday, QLDC said the Environment Court was already familiar with the Shotover discharge situation and "would help to provide an efficient and comprehensive decision from a neutral arbiter."
However, ORC would still oversee public notification, submission timeframes, and the technical assessment of the application, it said.
RNZ has approached QLDC and ORC for comment.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter
curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Prescription confusion may have contributed to woman's death
Close-up of MORPHINE SULFATE 1 MG/ML VIAL Photo: David GABIS / 123RF A coroner says Health New Zealand should centralise medicine dispensing records after he found a mistake with a morphine prescription may have contributed to a Levin woman's death. Coroner Mark Wilton found 71-year-old Norma Collins' death, at her home in May 2022, was associated with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), with a background of excessive morphine administration. He could not determine the exact cause of Collins' death because she was cremated before it was reported to the coroner, and no post-mortem or toxicological analysis was done. But he found a GP at Ōtaki Medical Centre inadvertently prescribed a higher strength and dosage for Collins, which the pharmacist did not know about - and could not alert crucial people to. Collins suffered from end stage COPD with type 2 respiratory failure, pulmonary hypertension and anxiety. In the lead-up to her death she was prescribed morphine at 1mg strength at a dose of 2.5 to 5ml every three hours as needed by doctors at the Arohanui Hospice. Her daughter, who was Collins' carer, administered the morphine. She was advised to contact Ōtaki Medical Centre for repeat prescriptions. She did this in late May, concerned the liquid morphine was running out. A GP at the practice - who was not Collins' usual doctor, nor the lead practitioner at the centre - prescribed a higher dosage of 50ml of liquid morphine, at a higher strength of 10mg, administered at 1mg amounts. The GP told the Health and Disability Commissioner he checked prescribing records and the Ministry of Health database for Collins' medication history, but could find no previous prescription for liquid morphine, only one for a slow-release 10mg morphine tablet. He said he had not had specific palliative care training. "He said that he was unaware that Collins had previously been prescribed liquid morphine of a different dose and concentration by a doctor at Arohanui Hospice," Wiltobn said. The prescription was sent to Berrys Tararua Pharmacy, which had not dispensed the first prescription for Collins. It did not have access to her dispensing records so did not advise her daughter of any change. Wilton's report found Collins' daughter administered the drug as she had been doing - noticing her mother was drowsy and sleeping for hours at a time. "Collins' daughter did not think this was unusual as her mother had slept for long periods of time previously." She was found dead in her bed the morning of 31 May. Wilton said Health NZ should centralise dispensing records and share dispensing information through the New Zealand Electronic Prescription Service, following a previous finding by Coroner Alexandra Cunninghame. The service allows communication between prescribers and pharmacists, including emailing prescriptions and notifications for medications that have not been dispensed. He said if Berrys Tararua Pharmacy had access to dispensing records, the pharmacist could have checked out the different prescription. "This would have allowed the pharmacist at [Berrys Tararua Pharmacy] the opportunity to alert Collins' daughter to the difference in strength and dosage, or to question the GP at [Ōtaki Medical Centre] about the difference." Health NZ told Wilton it was making progress towards centralising dispensing records, but ultimately depended on funding allocation. Wilton said the Health and Disability Commissioner made recommendations to both the Ōtaki Medical Centre and Berrys Tarurua Pharmacy for future changes, and that the commissioner was satisfied this had been met. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
4 hours ago
- RNZ News
Health Minister announces Elective Boost programme
The Health Minister, Simeon Brown, said the Elective Boost programme would cut surgery waiting times as 21,000 more elective procedures are funded over the next year. He spoke to Charlotte Cook. Tags: To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.
RNZ News
5 hours ago
- RNZ News
Woolworths recalls beef mince over potential plastic contamination
Photo: Supplied / Woolworths Woolworths say potential plastic contamination of beef mince has forced a recall of products. The 1kg and 500g packs of Woolworths branded 18 percent beef mince - dated best before 5/7/25 - have been recalled. They were sold at Woolworths and Countdown stores in the North Island. The supermarket advised customers not to eat the mince and return the products for a full refund. Woolworths said there had been no reports of illness or injury but anyone with concerns after consuming the meat should seek medical advice. There were no other beef products involved in the recall.
