logo
Defence says deadly Amqui, Que., truck crash 'was an accident' — Crown says it was murder

Defence says deadly Amqui, Que., truck crash 'was an accident' — Crown says it was murder

CBC18-06-2025
Crown and defence lawyers presented very different versions of events during closing arguments Wednesday in the first-degree murder trial of Steeve Gagnon, accused of running down and killing three people with his pickup truck in Amqui, Que., in March 2023.
"It's possible this was an accident. This was a man with impulsive tendencies, who made an error. It was not premeditated," defence lawyer Hugo Caissy told jurors in his closing argument at the courthouse in Rimouski, Que.
The Crown offered a different version.
"Ask yourselves: is the theory of an accident credible? Or is it nebulous to the point of being incomprehensible?" Crown prosecutor Simon Blanchette countered during his closing statement.
Gagnon is facing three counts of first-degree murder and two counts of attempted murder using a motor vehicle.
He admits he was driving the vehicle that struck and killed three people and seriously injured three others.
In order to find Gagnon guilty of first-degree murder, jurors would have to find he intentionally ran down those people, and that he planned the crime in advance.
"Yes, he's responsible for the deaths and injuries," Caissy told jurors.
"But the analysis doesn't stop there. You have to be able to conclude that these actions were intentional."
Accident theory
Caissy said Gagnon was driving when he dropped something on the floor of his vehicle, reached down to pick it up, and then lost control of the vehicle and struck the pedestrians.
Gagnon testified that once he realized what happened, everything went fuzzy for him and he doesn't have a clear memory of what happened next.
Caissy said testimony from a psychiatric expert suggested Gagnon may have been suffering from a dissociative disorder that would prevent him from remembering details of the incident.
"The fact that he doesn't have precise memories doesn't mean he's not telling the truth," Caissy said.
Caissy also told jurors even if they conclude that Gagnon intentionally ran down the pedestrians, there's no evidence he planned the crime in advance.
He said expert psychiatric testimony showed that Gagnon was impulsive, which could explain his actions that day.
Caissy also referenced Gagnon's testimony in his own defense, which was often hard to follow and punctuated by outbursts, insults, profanity and threats.
"It's not because the accused is confused or lost at times that his version is not the right one," Caissy said.
Planned attack theory
During the prosecution's closing argument, Blanchette reminded jurors that Gagnon had lost his job as a trucker the year before the incident because of a back injury, that he was unable to find another job, and that he learned in the days before the accident that his social assistance benefits would not be renewed.
"Steeve Gagnon was living a difficult period. He made a plan to get revenge on society," Blanchette said.
Blanchette said that plan was made clear in a series of videos Gagnon recorded just two days before the crash, where he described running down children in a schoolyard with his truck.
Blanchette reminded jurors the day of the crash, Gagnon stopped at a schoolyard, but there were no students there because it was a pedagogical day.
Six minutes later, the first pedestrian was hit.
"I submit to you he planned to run down children, then adapted his plan when that wouldn't work," Blanchette said.
The defence argued the video did not constitute premeditation.
"That demonstrates nothing other than a person telling a story," Caissy said, noting Gagnon recorded many videos airing multiple grievances the same day.
Starting Thursday morning, Judge Louis Dionne will begin giving instructions to the jury.
Jurors will likely be sequestered later Thursday to begin their deliberations.
The three men killed were 65-year-old Gérald Charest, 73-year-old Jean Lafrenière and 41-year-old Simon-Guillaume Bourget.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

3-year-old drowns at Long Sault, Ont. beach: OPP
3-year-old drowns at Long Sault, Ont. beach: OPP

CTV News

time20 minutes ago

  • CTV News

3-year-old drowns at Long Sault, Ont. beach: OPP

An Ontario Provincial Police crest is pictured on an officer's uniform. (Supplied) Police say a three-year-old child died after drowning at an eastern Ontario beach Saturday afternoon. Ontario Provincial Police say emergency services responded to Mille Roches Beach in Long Sault, Ont. at approximately 5:45 p.m. A caller told police that a child had no vital signs and that off-duty medical professionals were conducting resuscitation efforts. Cornwall paramedics rushed the child to hospital under a police escort as efforts to revive the child continued, OPP said in a news release Sunday. The child was later pronounced dead, police say. Their identity is not being released. The St. Lawrence Parks Commission website says Mille Roches Beach remains closed until further notice. Woodlands Beach remains open. It's the latest in a string of deadly incidents on eastern Ontario waters this summer. On Thursday, a three-year-old child drowned at Sandbanks Provincial Park in Prince Edward County. Last weekend, OPP reported two incidents on East Lake in Prince Edward County and one on the St. Lawrence River near Ganonoque. OPP reported earlier this week that it had already responded to double the number of drowning deaths it saw at this time last year in eastern Ontario. There have been two reported drownings in Ottawa so far this summer.

Grande Prairie residents charged after RCMP seize drugs, weapons, contraband cigarettes
Grande Prairie residents charged after RCMP seize drugs, weapons, contraband cigarettes

CTV News

timean hour ago

  • CTV News

Grande Prairie residents charged after RCMP seize drugs, weapons, contraband cigarettes

Two people have been charged after Grande Prairie RCMP executed a search warrant that led to the seizure of drugs, weapons and contraband cigarettes from a residence. On July 17, officers executed the warrant at a duplex in Scenic Ridge in Grande Prairie, where they seized 900 grams of suspected cocaine, 100 grams of suspected mushrooms, 11 firearms (including three prohibited firearms that were loaded), over 15,000 rounds of ammunition, four prohibited devices, 16,000 contraband cigarettes and materials consistent with drug trafficking. A 50 year old man and a 36 year old woman, both residents of Grande Prairie face a total of 17 charges including two counts of trafficking in a controlled substance, possession of stolen property, careless use or storage of a firearm, unauthorized possession of a firearm and fraud. Following a bail hearing, both were released on conditions. They're scheduled to appear in court in Grande Prairie on July 28. 'The combination of drugs and firearms is a bad mix for any community," said Cst. Satbir Sall in a media release. 'We are thankful that as a result of this investigation, those drugs are firearms are no longer on the streets of Grande Prairie. 'Grande Prairie RCMP remains fully committed in building safer communities by working in partnership with our community, as well as through investigative and enforcement efforts, to achieve this goal.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store