Religious freedom battle erupts as New Jersey town attempts to turn church property into pickleball courts
Christ Episcopal Church in Toms River, New Jersey, found itself at the center of a highly charged legal battle after its leaders moved to expand outreach to the area's homeless population and proposed a 17-bed overnight shelter.
"It didn't take long for neighbors to become concerned," Harvey York, the church's attorney, told Fox News Digital.
On April 30, the Toms River Township Council placed an ordinance on its agenda to condemn the church's 10-acre site, which includes the parish house, auditorium, school, sanctuary and deacon's residence, under its eminent domain power.
Church Fights New Jersey Town Over Plans To Seize Property And Turn It Into Park
The town's plan is to turn the congregation's property into a recreational area.
Read On The Fox News App
"Any governmental agency has the right to condemn property for governmental purposes. That's clear. However, the township has never thought of this as a recreational site," York said. "For them to say they need recreational land flies in the face of the facts and their master plan."
York and his legal team argue that the move to seize the property is the township's direct response to the church's shelter initiative.
"It is clear that this is being done in retaliation for the church making an application for a homeless shelter," he said, pointing to both the constitutional protections for freedom of religion and the federal Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act.
"I don't know that you'll find a lawyer who will say, 'Oh, yeah, they have every right to do this; they're going to win.'"
Despite rising community support, from local congregants to offers of amicus assistance nationwide, reactions remain mixed within the New Jersey town.
"There are people that are thrilled that the mayor is going to condemn the property," York said, but he believes "the majority of the community is shocked and dismayed."
Business Owners Take On City They Say Is Playing 'Musical Chairs' With Property In Eminent Domain Case
As for the church's next steps, litigation is certain.
"The plan will be decided by the diocese," York said. "But they certainly will litigate the issue, and I believe it will be successful."
The church's attorney said the government should "mind their own business and stay out of the religious affairs of the community."
Five or six hearings have taken place, and the next zoning board meeting is scheduled for May 22. Fox News Digital has reached out to the Township of Toms River for comment on the pending litigation and the hearings.
The church originally applied in July 2023 to operate an outreach center for the homeless, an effort that was approved. According to York, their application for the shelter fully complies with local and state regulations.Original article source: Religious freedom battle erupts as New Jersey town attempts to turn church property into pickleball courts
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Could a Canadian Zohran Mamdani win an election here? Party insiders have hopes — and tips
A former Ontario MPP says the NDP should be looking south to inspire their new federal leader As the federal New Democratic Party starts its search for a new leader, one former Ontario MPP says the NDP should be looking south for inspiration: Zohran Mamdani. Joel Harden tells Yahoo Canada there is an appetite for policies similar to the New York City mayoral hopeful's here — Canadians just need to see a candidate embrace those ideas. 'Canadians are hungry for these ideas,' Harden said. 'They're hungry for a candidate and a campaign that can lead them to believe that if we vote for this, there's a good likelihood these things will happen.' Mamdani, 33, beat former New York state governor Andrew Cuomo after polling at just 2 per cent earlier in 2025. Mamdani will now be the Democratic nominee for mayor of New York City. The democratic socialist is campaigning on policies like free transit, a $30 minimum wage, increased taxes on the super-rich, rent freezes and government-run grocery stores. Mamdani's underdog campaign was praised by Toronto Metropolitan University political science professor Bryan Evans, who told Yahoo Canada the reason Mamdani won was his focus on affordability, followed by a direct communication style that used humour effectively to connect with people. A team of about 50,000 volunteers also canvassed for Mamdani across New York. Cuomo was the favourite to win, despite not having a great track record as governor, including accusations of bullying, corruption, and sexual harassment. 'You add all that up… it's quite the remarkable achievement,' Evans said. Jared Walker: Mamdani ran 'relatable' campaign that resonated amid affordability crisis Former NDP speech writer and executive director of the non-profit Canadians for Tax Fairness, Jared Walker, told Yahoo Canada that Mamdani had an air of authenticity that other politicians have struggled to achieve. 'He's talking about affordability in a relatable way,' Walker said. '(It is) spoken by a messenger that is believable on the issue.' Walker said Mamdani's platform could just as easily work in Canada, and that all of his policies have at least been discussed at one point by the NDP. That makes the main lesson from his success how he communicated those policies and connected with voters, according to Walker. He admitted that the federal NDP could do a better job at those campaign elements, but attributed the party's poor showing in the last election to U.S. President Donald Trump's threats of making Canada the 51st state, which the Liberals were able to capitalize on. Praise for Mamdani from Ontario NDP leader: 'We're inspired' Ontario NDP Leader Marit Stiles congratulated Mamdani after his win in a post on X. 'What you've built goes far beyond New York City,' she said. 'You've captured the imagination of progressives everywhere with a blueprint for how we can win: with hope, with values, and with the belief that politics can be a force for good. We're watching — and we're inspired.' Could a Canadian Mamdani be victorious? But some political analysts suggested Mamdani was a tough sell as a mainstream politician given his democratic-socialist policies and years-long support for Palestine, often breaking with U.S. Democrats to call for a ceasefire and call out Israel's breaking of international law. Top Democrats still have not endorsed Mamdani. Former NDP MPP Sarah Jama was expelled from the party's caucus for a statement shortly after Hamas' October 7, 2023, attack on Israel that was critical of Israel. In January 2025, Jama's application to run again as a member of the NDP was denied by party officials. She ran as an independent and lost. Jama was also censured by Ontario's legislature for wearing a keffiyeh in the hall, which was deemed political apparel and against a dress code. Harden, who also wore a keffiyeh in parliament and was ejected along with Jama, said it was a very difficult time but figures like Jama still have a future in politics. He praised how Mamdani has handled the issue, saying that he didn't fall into any political traps but stayed on message and was direct. Mamdani was also endorsed by Brad Lander, who was also running to be the Democratic nominee for mayor of New York City. Lander is a progressive Jewish comptroller, and Harden says this helped show Mamdani had no animus toward Jewish New Yorkers. 'I think the world is ready for adult conversations that don't succumb to the gotcha politics and traps that some folks will lay,' Harden said. 'It is really important that everybody anywhere in the world can feel safe being who they are, can advocate for the things they believe without being smeared or mischaracterized.' Election data from New York City's mayoral Democratic primary showed a surge of young voters. Mamdani was clearly able to mobilize this demographic. New rules for the NDP's search for a new federal leader might have already taken notice. Signatures gathered by prospective leaders are now required to include at least 10 per cent from NDP members under 25 years of age.
Fox News
19 hours ago
- Fox News
Dems are trying to ‘court' voters on communist messaging: NY state assemblyman
New York state Assemblyman Jake Blumencranz discusses how Democrats are looking to win back younger voters on 'The Will Cain Show.'
CBS News
21 hours ago
- CBS News
To former prosecutors, everything about the Justice Dept. interview with Ghislaine Maxwell looked unorthodox
Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche met for a second day with convicted sex trafficker Ghislaine Maxwell, without offering more than a broad rationale for his hours of questioning. Multiple former federal prosecutors told CBS News they were bewildered by his decision to launch into such talks and described the unfolding events as both unorthodox and concerning. "She's somebody who has been sentenced by a court to 20 years in prison, and she is likely also desperate to get out from under that sentence," said Elizabeth Oyer, a former Justice Department pardon attorney and federal public defender. "It's hard to really believe that the Justice Department would rely on anything that she might have to say." Oyer suggested that Maxwell was speaking with Blanche "in the hope that she might be able to cut a deal that will benefit her, and that raises fundamental questions about the credibility of any information she could possibly provide." Maxwell's defense lawyer, David Markus, said after the meeting that she answered everything asked of her "and she didn't hold anything back." Asked whether Maxwell is seeking a pardon, Markus said, "We haven't spoken to the president or anybody about a pardon just yet," adding, "We hope he exercises that power in the right and just way." "It's unprecedented for the deputy attorney general to be directly involved in interviewing someone who's been convicted of a crime and may be interested in cooperating to get leniency," one former senior Justice Department official told CBS News on the condition he not be identified. "It strikes me simply as an effort to address a political concern, which is not what the Justice Department does." Blanche is a senior Justice Department official who previously served as a personal attorney to President Trump. He is also a former federal prosecutor for the Southern District of New York. He announced his decision to travel to Florida to meet with Maxwell after days of public attention swirled around the administration's mixed messaging about the possible release of files on Jeffrey Epstein, who died in jail in 2019 as he was awaiting trial on sex trafficking charges. Maxwell was convicted in 2021 for her role in the trafficking ring. Several aspects of the Blanche decision appear to break with longstanding Justice Department practices. Among the most concerning, former officials said, is having Blanche conduct the interviews, rather than the line prosecutors who helped win a conviction in the Maxwell case, and who are continuing to combat her efforts to appeal the outcome. Adding to the complication is that the prosecutor who led the Maxwell case, Maurene Comey, was fired by the Trump administration a week ago. One former prosecutor said a key reason for having a line prosecutor handle such an interview is their comprehensive knowledge of both Maxwell and the facts of the case against her. Otherwise, this attorney said, it could be very hard to determine whether Maxwell is being truthful — especially since there were already past questions about her willingness to be fully candid about the misconduct that led to her arrest, and Epstein's. "The best way to determine that is to ask questions you already know the answers to," the former prosecutor said. "Todd Blanche is in no position to assess the truth if he doesn't know all the facts." Because Blanche's meetings were occurring behind closed doors, it is unclear if he was accompanied by other Justice Department officials or FBI agents. The Justice Department has not responded to a request for comment. Experts told CBS News that meetings of this nature almost always include an FBI agent who can memorialize the discussion in formal interview notes that could later have evidentiary value, if needed. "If Blanche was meeting with Maxwell alone, that's obscene malpractice," another former federal prosecutor, who had decades of experience, told CBS News. "He can't testify and become a witness, nor can he write a report of their meeting." Prosecutors are not permitted to write up interview reports and are not sworn law enforcement officers with training to document an interview of this kind. "It would be a mess," the former official said. "The first rule of a meeting with a witness is to have an agent present." As another former prosecutor put it: "This is not typical." "It's not the most effective way" to work if the goal is to gather additional evidence or identify potential targets for future prosecution, this person said. Mr. Trump has never been accused of misconduct in connection with Epstein's criminal activity, and he has consistently said he cut ties with Epstein before Epstein's first arrest in 2006 for his conduct with underage girls. Mr. Trump has sought to push past the crush of attention on the topic, even referring to it as "the Jeffrey Epstein hoax." Blanche explained his decision to meet with Maxwell by saying he would "pursue justice wherever the facts may lead." "If Ghislane Maxwell has information about anyone who has committed crimes against victims, the FBI and the DOJ will hear what she has to say," Blanche said. Like Oyer, many former federal prosecutors saw the meeting as a political move intended to dampen growing mistrust about the decision not to make public the files connected with Epstein's case. Multiple former prosecutors spoke with CBS News about the matter, but asked not to be identified because they feared retribution against them or their current employers.
