logo
Canadian government considers criminalizing hate and terror symbols

Canadian government considers criminalizing hate and terror symbols

OTTAWA—The Liberal government is weighing the criminalization of displaying terror and hate symbols, a potentially precedent-setting move in Canada that has prompted concerns about civil liberties.
It's not yet clear if a possible ban would focus on specific symbols, like the swastika, or if it would broadly cover any symbols related to designated terror groups. And no final decision has yet been made on whether to go through with the Criminal Code reforms, which were being mulled by the Trudeau government prior to Prime Minister Mark Carney's ascent to the Liberal leadership and his victory in the spring election, according to a transition
briefing
to the minister of justice from March 2025 that was made public last week.
During that campaign, Carney's Liberals, who are now preparing to introduce a crime bill this fall, committed to bail reforms, the criminalization of 'obstruction' and 'intimidation' outside of places of worship and other community spaces, among other things.
Criminalizing hate and terror symbols, however, was not in the Liberal platform, even though it has been requested repeatedly by Jewish groups in Canada.
In a statement to the Star, the Department of Justice confirmed the matter was still under consideration as the government looks at options for tackling a rising number of hate crimes, but it did not indicate what direction it was leaning towards.
'The Government of Canada takes the use of any hate symbols very seriously and remains committed to protecting everyone in Canada from hate and discrimination in all its forms,' spokesperson Ian McLeod said in a statement.
'This work is ongoing. Although no final decisions have been made regarding the criminalization of any specific symbols, we continue to consult with officials and stakeholders to ensure our approach reflects our commitment to safety and inclusivity.'
Canada's Criminal Code already has provisions against 'hate propaganda,' including advocating for genocide, incitement of hatred and 'wilful' promotion of hatred or antisemitism, but the display of terror or hate symbols is not outlawed explicitly.
The prospect of legislation to crack down on those symbols, however, has prompted questions about whether it might restrict freedom of expression, including in peaceful protests or artwork, for example.
The swastika is commonly associated with Nazi Germany's antisemitic and racist violence, and is often used by far-right, white supremacist and other ideologically motivated extremist groups who have been
gaining prevalence
in Canada. Meanwhile, at pro-Palestinian demonstrations against the war in Gaza, there have been some instances of protesters holding signs comparing Israel's treatment of Palestinians to that of Nazi Germany's towards Jews, prompting rebukes from some Jewish and pro-Israel groups. There have also been documented instances of protesters waving the flags of Hamas and other militant groups that are on Canada's designated terror list.
In 2024, a man was arrested and charged in Toronto after waving the flag of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, but the case was
dropped
because there was 'no reasonable prospect of conviction.'
'We're hopeful,' said Richard Robertson, the director of research and advocacy at B'nai Brith Canada, which has been calling for a ban on the swastika and the criminalization of displaying flags, emblems and symbols related to designated terror groups. 'Any efforts or considerations are welcome at this point.'
Shane Martínez, a human rights lawyer who represented the Toronto protester, said such a move would be a political and hypocritical attack on pro-Palestine demonstrators and predicted it would immediately face legal challenges.
'At best, it's misguided, and at worst, it is an intentional effort to silence people, knowing that it violates their Charter rights,' Martínez said.
The head of Toronto's police union said such legislation could give officers more clarity when policing protests, but said it should be accompanied by training.
'With the protests that have been going on, there's a lot of pressure and expectation on our members to be seizing certain items, if it's flags or other symbols that may be related to hate or terror organizations,' said Clayton Campbell, the president of the Toronto Police Association. 'And for our members, it's challenging as they can be confusing, right? Like, one flag, slightly adjusted may not be a terror symbol, may not be a hate flag.
'Anything that could help them do their jobs better would be good,' he said.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Gaza Talks Stall as Israel, US Pull Negotiators
Gaza Talks Stall as Israel, US Pull Negotiators

Bloomberg

timean hour ago

  • Bloomberg

Gaza Talks Stall as Israel, US Pull Negotiators

00:00 Earlier this week, there was some optimism that maybe we'd get a breakthrough on these ceasefire discussions. But there was no break for it. And in fact, it seems as though the talks once again have collapsed. So tell us the latest and why we think these these negotiations were not successful Yes, I think this definitely is a setback for these talks. There was a lot of optimism that if we weren't going to get a ceasefire announced this week, then then at least there would be a big breakthrough. And Donald Trump's main U.S. main envoy for the Middle East, Steve Witkoff, traveled to Europe. And the expectation or the hope, at least among many people, was that he would travel to Qatar, where the key the key negotiators for Israel and Hamas are. And if he did, that would be a sign that a ceasefire was imminent. But he hasn't gone there. And then last night, Israel said it was recalling its negotiators in the U.S. with doing the same. It's a little bit unclear, but obviously what what happened was that Israel studied Hamas's latest response, which came on Wednesday, and it wasn't satisfied. And some Israeli media are saying that Hamas upped its demands for the number of Palestinians that must be released from Israeli jails as part of the 60 day truce that they're negotiating. So that could have been a stumbling block. We did have one person involved in the mediation tell us that this doesn't mean the talks have collapsed completely. And we also had an Israeli official expressing some optimism that they could still go on. But clearly, this this you know, this is yet another instance of these of these talks stalling. Yeah, a setback Yesterday, the French President Macron made a big statement saying that France will move to recognize Palestinian statehood as soon as September over in the UK. The Prime Minister, Keir Starmer, is also under pressure to do the same. Why? Why now? What is it with this timing in particular? It's it's a good question. I think the bigger picture is that there's growing anger among world powers, especially in Western Europe. Well, in places like Western Europe and the Arab world over the continuation of the of the war in Gaza and the worsening humanitarian situation there, we had roughly 25 to 30 countries, including the UK and France and Japan and Norway and Australia, putting out a joint statement on on Monday in which they called for Israel to end the war immediately. And they said that the situation regarding supplies of food and and medicine to Gazans was and was horrific. And that's starvation was was growing. So that's the bigger picture. I think there's a lot of frustration in the rest of the world. Israel's relations with a lot of European countries have been severely damaged in recent months because because of all this and when it comes to Emmanuel Macron, he has been sort of among, let's say, key world powers, sort of at the forefront of saying he wants to recognize a Palestinian state and he's putting pressure on Keir Starmer, the UK prime minister, to do the same for Israel in the U.S. This is that very kind of frustrated by this move and they say it will threaten Israel's security.

Wall street investors react to Trump-Powell squabble
Wall street investors react to Trump-Powell squabble

CNN

timean hour ago

  • CNN

Wall street investors react to Trump-Powell squabble

'This is a soap opera': 'Einstein' & 'Ives' react to Trump-Powell squabble CNN's Erin Burnett talks with Dan Ives and Peter Tuchman about the awkward moment between President Donald Trump and Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell during their tour of the Fed's $2.5 billion renovation project. 02:12 - Source: CNN Automated CNN Shorts 11 videos 'This is a soap opera': 'Einstein' & 'Ives' react to Trump-Powell squabble CNN's Erin Burnett talks with Dan Ives and Peter Tuchman about the awkward moment between President Donald Trump and Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell during their tour of the Fed's $2.5 billion renovation project. 02:12 - Source: CNN Macron says France will recognize a Palestinian state French President Emmanuel Macron said France will recognize a Palestinian state in an announcement to the United Nations General Assembly in September. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has condemned the decision saying it 'rewards terror and risks creating another Iranian proxy, just as Gaza became.' 00:48 - Source: CNN How Hulk Hogan's historic lawsuit changed the face of media CNN's Chief Media Analyst Brian Stelter breaks down how a lawsuit brought by Hulk Hogan against the blog Gawker forever changed the media industry. The case, which was filed after Gawker published Hogan's sex tape, set the stage for a slew of A-list celebrities filing blockbuster lawsuits against media companies. 02:04 - Source: CNN Before and after photos show Trump's redesign of Rose Garden Before and after photos show the dramatic changes the Trump administration is making to the White House Rose Garden, including paving over the lawn. The garden has undergone several renovations since its creation by First Lady Ellen Wilson in 1913. 00:59 - Source: CNN Scientist unexpectedly finds shark devouring another shark Wildlife biologist Forrest Galante came across a rare instance of female spotted wobbegong devouring a young male shark in New South Wales, Australia. Discovery and CNN share a corporate parent, Warner Bros. Discovery. Catch Shark Week on Discovery all week long. 01:22 - Source: CNN All five acquitted in Hockey Canada sexual assault trial Within minutes of starting to read her verdict, the words of Justice Maria Carroccia resonated across Canada as she bluntly assessed that, 'I do not find the evidence of E.M. to be either credible or reliable.' Five professional hockey players -- Michael McLeod, Cal Foote, Carter Hart, Dillon Dube and Alex Formenton -- were all acquitted on Thursday, according to the Associated Press, on charges of sexual assault in connection with a June 2018 incident at a hotel room in London, Ontario, when they were members of the country's World Juniors hockey team. 01:19 - Source: CNN Palestinian Authority Prime Minister slams Israel for hunger crisis In an exclusive interview with CNN's Christiane Amanpour, Palestinian Authority Prime Minister Mohammad Mustafa reacts to Israeli government spokesperson David Mencer's assertion that 'there is no famine caused by Israel.' The government has denied responsibility and accuses Hamas of 'engineering' food shortages. 01:21 - Source: CNN Controversy over the Fed's renovation, explained The White House has seized on the Federal Reserve's $2.5 billion construction project as a potential legal opening to oust Fed Chair Jerome Powell. The renovation has become a new line of attack from President Trump, who has railed against Powell for not lowering interest rates enough. 02:18 - Source: CNN Trump and Powell clash over renovation costs at Federal Reserve President Donald Trump had an awkward exchange with Fed Chair Jerome Powell over the price of the Federal Reserve's $2.5 billion renovation. 00:49 - Source: CNN Detainees released from mega-prison CECOT An estimated 252 Venezuelans who had been imprisoned at the CECOT prison in March were released and returned to their home country in exchange for 10 US nationals and dozens of Venezuelan political prisoners, US officials said. Detainees celebrated their arrival home but also spoke about the conditions they faced - causing the Venezuelan government to open a formal investigation into several Salvadoran officials, including President Nayib Bukele, over the alleged abuse of Venezuelan migrants deported from the US. 01:42 - Source: CNN Anne Burrell's death ruled a suicide Anne Burrell, who was best known as one of the Food Network's most popular stars, has died. Her death has been ruled a suicide. Burrell appeared on 'Worst Cooks in America,' 'Iron Chef America,' 'Chef Wanted with Anne Burrell' and 'The Best Thing I Ever Ate,' among many others. 00:24 - Source: CNN

A look at details of the settlement between Columbia University and the Trump administration
A look at details of the settlement between Columbia University and the Trump administration

Yahoo

timean hour ago

  • Yahoo

A look at details of the settlement between Columbia University and the Trump administration

A deal between Columbia University and the Trump administration calls for the Ivy League school to pay more than $220 million to resolve multiple federal investigations into alleged violations of federal antidiscrimination laws. The agreement announced Wednesday clears the way for the school to keep billions of dollars in federal research money, including more than $400 million in grants canceled earlier this year. In return, the deal calls for a number of reforms in areas such as admissions, campus protests policies and its curriculum, including a number of changes the school agreed to previously in March. It is a document President Donald Trump's administration is calling a road map for settlements with other colleges accused of not doing enough to address campus antisemitism. Columbia University's acting president, Claire Shipman, said it protects the school's values and autonomy. Here's what's in the settlement: Financial payout The university will pay the federal government $200 million over three years. It will also pay $21 million to settle alleged civil rights violations against Jewish employees that occurred following the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas attack on Israel. A pledge to end diversity programs The university agreed to end programs 'that promote unlawful efforts to achieve race-based outcomes, quotes, diversity targets or similar efforts.' Columbia, as part of the agreement, must also issue regular reports to an independent monitor assuring that its programs 'do not promote unlawful DEI goals.' The agreement pushes Columbia to limit the consideration of race even beyond the Supreme Court's 2023 decision ending affirmative action. That decision left open the possibility that universities could consider an applicant's discussion of how their race affected their life, including in college application essays. The agreement says: 'Columbia may not use personal statements, diversity narratives, or any applicant reference to racial identity as a means to introduce or justify discrimination.' Faculty and curriculum changes Columbia agreed to review its Middle East curriculum and appoint new faculty to its Institute for Israel and Jewish Studies who will 'contribute to a robust and intellectually diverse academic environment.' To further support Jewish students on campus, the agreement calls for a new administrator to serve as a liaison on antisemitism issues. Reporting on international students Columbia University agreed to new vetting for prospective international students. The agreement calls for introducing 'questions designed to elicit their reasons for wishing to study in the United States' and establishes processes to make sure all students are committed to 'civil discourse.' The university also promised to provide the government with information, upon request, of disciplinary actions involving student-visa holders resulting in expulsions or suspensions. 'In several instances, the agreement codifies other practices or policies already in existence, or reviews already underway. We must always comply with government regulations regarding the international student visa program, for example,' Shipman said. The agreement says Columbia also will 'examine its business model and take steps to decrease financial dependence on international student enrollment.' International students make up about 40% of the enrollment at Columbia. Abiding Trump's interpretation on sex discrimination The agreement requires full compliance with the administration's interpretation of Title IX, the federal law barring sex discrimination in education. Trump officials have used the law to force the removal of transgender athletes from women's sports. Campus protest policies The deal calls for Columbia to abide restrictions it agreed to on campus protests, including a ban on face coverings used to conceal demonstrators' identity. It says protests inside academic buildings are not acceptable under the university's code of conduct. ___ The Associated Press' education coverage receives financial support from multiple private foundations. AP is solely responsible for all content. Find AP's standards for working with philanthropies, a list of supporters and funded coverage areas at

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store