Police raid at a rare island of dialogue in Jerusalem sparks fears of a free speech crackdown
While the well-known store and its smaller branch across the street were open Tuesday, the bust saw detectives confiscate books in trash bags and arrest two members of the owner's family. The incident has raised broader concerns about the status of shared places where Israelis and Palestinians can peacefully come together and debate.
'I, like many diplomats, enjoy browsing for books at Educational Bookshop. I know its owners, the Muna family, to be peace-loving proud Palestinian Jerusalemites, open for discussion and intellectual exchange,' Steffen Seibert, Germany's ambassador to Israel, said in a post on X.
'I am concerned to hear of the raid and their detention in prison,' he added.
The store, founded on Salah al-Din Street in 1984 by the Muna family, sells books in many languages that largely focus on the Middle East and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and has long been known in the area as an intellectual oasis where readers from across the political divide can share ideas.
Security footage from Sunday afternoon that the Muna family shared with NBC News showed plainclothes officers rifling through books and taking away some of them in garbage bags.
During the raid on the predominantly English-language store, officers also arrested the manager, Mahmoud Muna, and his nephew Ahmad. Both have since been released.
Mahmoud's brother, Morad, said that the police had taken books with a Palestinian flag or icon printed on them and that they used Google Translate to help understand what the material was saying.
'In our book, anyone from any religion, from any side, can say his opinion without being afraid. He can discuss any kind of thing,' he said.
'In the west side of Jerusalem, there are English bookstores that have the same books that we have, and you will never hear that they arrested the owners,' he added.
A spokesperson from the Israeli police said that the two were arrested on suspicion of 'selling books containing incitement and support for terrorism at bookstores in Jerusalem.'
Police added that the detectives had confiscated from the store 'numerous books containing inciteful material,' pointing to the children's coloring book titled 'From the River to the Sea,' written by South African author Nathi Ngubane, as one example. The police added that they had also raided a bookshop in Jerusalem's Old City last week, which had material supporting Hamas, Hezbollah and the Islamic State group.
The title of the coloring book is also a pro-Palestinian slogan often used at protests against Israel and refers to the geographical area between the River Jordan and the Mediterranean Sea that encompasses Israel and the Palestinian territories.
The American Jewish Committee says on its website that the slogan 'can be used to call for the elimination of the State of Israel and/or ethnic cleansing of Jews living there,' while the South Africa Jewish Board of Deputies protested the publication of the book when it was initially released.
Wasim Khalis, who owns a clothing store next door to Educational Bookshop, said he had been drinking coffee in the bookstore around 3 p.m. local time when four plainclothes officers entered. After a few minutes, he said, the officers flashed a warrant and asked customers to leave, while a second group of officers went across the street to another store owned by the family.
'It was very strange,' he said. 'This isn't a new store; it has been here for decades. They took items that were very normal and could be found anywhere, including on the internet.'
Some 10 diplomats including those from the European Union and the United Kingdom sat in on a debate Monday on the Munas' release date at Jerusalem's District Court. Meanwhile, supporters of the Educational Bookstore wrote about their alarm at the raid online, with a smaller number gathering outside the courthouse.
'We fear that the raid on the store, the confiscation of books from it, and the imprisonment of its owner under the pretext of 'violating public order' is a regime provocation designed to erase the Palestinian cultural narrative and harass those involved in it,' Israeli author Ilan Sheinfeld said in a post on X.
One of the in-person protesters was Galit Samuel, an Israeli patron who had traveled from Tel Aviv to be there. She said of the Munas that 'they are both men of peace, and they are promoting Palestinian culture in peaceful ways.'
'It's unimaginable that such people were arrested and books were confiscated,' she added. 'It's a grave attack on free speech and free thinking.'
This article was originally published on NBCNews.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
8 minutes ago
- New York Post
Kash Patel's country singer girlfriend fends off ‘disheartening' conspiracy theories she's honeypotting the FBI boss
FBI director Kash Patel's girlfriend Alexis Wilkins has been forced to fend off the 'incredibly disheartening' conspiracy theories that she is honeypotting the bureau's head honcho for a foreign government. The 26-year-old country artist said the skeptics are contorting her backstory, even as she acknowledged she can 'understand' it. 'I think people see certain pieces and I get it,' Wilkins told the 'Megyn Kelly Show' on Wednesday. Advertisement 'They want to connect things, they want to justify, some of the pain that they've been through watching the last four years, and there's pieces of this that, you know, I can understand,' she continued. 'I think that they've taken just these pieces of evidence that you laid out and tie them together in all of the wrong ways.' 4 FBI director Kash Patel's girlfriend Alexis Wilkins denied being a spy for a foreign government. Getty Images Advertisement 4 Alexis Wilkins expressed her frustrations at dealing with conspiracy theories about her relationship with FBI Director Kash Patel. The Megyn Kelly Show / YouTube Conspiracy theories about Wilkins exploded on the internet after the Justice Department and FBI's July 6 memo about convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein, which concluded that the evidence suggests Epstein killed himself in prison and did not keep an 'incriminating client list.' Some of the trolls speculated that the Arkansas-raised singer was a Mossad agent intended to compromise Patel, 45, and at least one of them misidentified her as Jewish. Advertisement One thread used to make that conspiratorial leap is Wilkins' work for PragerU, a conservative nonprofit that seeks to educate the public on key political issues. The CEO of PragerU, Marissa Streit, previously served in the Israeli army. Wilkins is Armenian and Christian and does not appear to have any known ties to Israel. 4 Alexis Wilkins began dating FBI Director Kash Patel years before he began leading the bureau. Getty Images Advertisement When Kelly asked point-blank whether she was a spy for any foreign government, Wilkins replied, 'Definitely not, that is a firm no on that front.' Earlier this month, the country singer ripped into the online conspiracy theorists, raging that they are 'farming' for attention 'because their engagement dried up after Trump's win.' 'It's disappointing to see people with no real contribution to political discourse spin ridiculous conspiracy theories out of thin air,' Wilkins bemoaned in an X post. 'These accusations are obviously insanely ridiculous.' Patel and Wilkins met at a friend's event in Nashville in 2022 and began dating several months later in early 2023. 'We just happened to meet,' Wilkins recounted, noting that the 19-year age gap she has with him always felt irrelevant. 'I have always liked [him], when I met him, I just liked that he was so, so honest,' Wilkins gushed. 'He's exactly who he is all the time. His character is incredible. His values are incredible. 'We both are very patriotic. So obviously there are things there that we definitely agree on, but he's just the most honest, you know, most integrity I've really experienced in a person, he's fantastic.' Advertisement The country singer, who hosts a Rumble show, acknowledged there's 'not enough information out there about me to glean a real conclusion on all of this kind of vigilante research.' She mused that those gaps have given room for internet trolls to fill with conspiracy theories, which she lamented as 'incredibly disheartening.' Patel has been 'very frustrated' and 'unhappy' with the hate and suspicion directed her way over the Epstein drama, Wilkins said. 4 Alexis Wilkins revealed that FBI Director Kash Patel is frustrated that she's taking heat. Getty Images Advertisement She also underscored that Patel's work on the Epstein drama is 'limited to the government side' and that she has 'no awareness besides what everyone else is seeing.' 'If people stop calling me a spy, absolutely,' she replied when asked if she wants to see more Epstein files released.
Newsweek
9 minutes ago
- Newsweek
Recognizing a Palestinian State Is Important but No Substitute for Ending the Atrocities in Gaza
On Monday, a plastic water bottle washed up on a beach in Gaza, half filled with red lentils. Nestled among the pulses was a handwritten note which read: "Forgive us, dear brothers. This is all we are able to do." The bottle likely originated in Egypt, where scores of families have poured dried foods into empty containers and launched them into the Mediterranean, in a bid to symbolically pierce Israel's monthslong blockade of vital aid into Gaza. The simplicity of the gesture—a small quantity of grain dispatched in the most rudimentary of vessels—draws a contrast with the technologically dominant Israeli state, a U.S.-backed nuclear power deploying the most advanced weaponry against a weak and captive population, nearly half of whom are children. Moreover, the sender's expression of both solidarity and helplessness captures well the mood of an outraged regional and global public, reckoning with its powerlessness in the face of the accumulating moral depravity in Gaza. Displaced Palestinians at the Nuseirat refugee camp haul food parcels and other items they managed to get from a GHF aid distribution point at the so-called Netzarim corridor in the central Gaza Strip on July... Displaced Palestinians at the Nuseirat refugee camp haul food parcels and other items they managed to get from a GHF aid distribution point at the so-called Netzarim corridor in the central Gaza Strip on July 30, 2025. More EYAD BABA/AFP via Getty Images The injustice in Gaza has taken on the shape of Matryoshka dolls. In the context of an unprecedented military campaign widely accepted as amounting to genocide, itself nested within a brutalizing and unlawful 75-year occupation, encased within a larger ideology of racial superiority, Israel has now systematically weaponized hunger against 2.2 million civilians. In July, 63 people died from Israel's enforced starvation. Alongside, more than 1,000 men, women, and children have been shot dead by Israeli forces while seeking food at the few remaining aid sites. Fresh out of reasoned arguments, Israeli leaders are left invoking Hamas' attack on October 7 as justification for their own crimes. On Tuesday, Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Sa'ar insisted that Israel was not to blame for what he would only concede were "tough conditions" in Gaza. "Who is responsible for this war?" he put to a roomful of journalists. "Hamas. Hamas initiated the war with its October 7th massacre. Hamas is responsible for the war's continuation." Similarly, when the Likud official Michael Kleiner was pressed about Israel's bombardment and blockade, he said, "My complaint is against people in Europe who don't support us and don't put their finger on the real party to blame, the one who started the war. [Without] October 7th, not one single baby in Gaza would have been harmed." But this position is morally and legally indefensible. In international law, as in the just war traditions of almost all civilizations, there is a clear separation between the legality of going to war in the first place (jus ad bellum), and the legality of how a war is conducted once it starts (jus in bello). Even if Israel's long occupation is bracketed and it is accepted that Hamas began the war on October 7, that reality should have no bearing whatsoever on how Israel can prosecute its response. The purpose of jus in bello, or international humanitarian law, is to limit the suffering in war, no matter who started it. Moreover, summoning the horrors of October 7 only brings into sharper focus the scale of Israel's atrocities. It is precisely because October 7 was so terrible that what Israel has wrought in Gaza is intolerable. The murder of 1,200 people, including 36 children, in a surprise attack by a terrorist group was an abominable crime. By extension, the slaughter of 60,000 people, including at least 14,000 children, and the imposition of manmade famine, in a pre-meditated campaign by a US-allied democracy, is many more times as criminal. After 21 months of medieval destruction in Gaza, and after the worst-case scenario of famine has already been realized, the international community is finally groping for a response. The European Commission has proposed to partially suspend Israel from its flagship research funding initiative. Brazil has withdrawn from the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance. For G7 states like Britain and France, the central line of effort is promising to officially recognize a Palestinian state at the U.N. in September. Acknowledging Palestinian self-determination is an overdue and essential symbolic step. However, it is unclear how the lightening rod of Palestinian statehood will end the daily massacres in Gaza or reverse the ongoing famine, particularly as Israel remains both defiant and cosseted by the U.S. Alone, the recognition of Palestinian sovereignty will surely represent cold comfort to the mothers rendered bystanders as their infants waste from hunger, to the famished civilians who will be shot by Israeli snipers while queuing for food, or to the children who will be murdered, maimed, or orphaned by Israeli bombs in the coming hours, days, and weeks. The celebrated Lebanese composer and playwright Ziad Rahbani, son of the iconic singer Fairuz, died suddenly on July 26. Among his most famous lines, from the play Bennesba Libukra Chou, is the urgent question: "They say tomorrow will be better. But what about today?" Dr. Alia Brahimi is a non-resident senior fellow with the Atlantic Council's Middle East Programs and the author of Jihad and Just War in the War on Terror (Oxford University Press). The views expressed in this article are the writer's own.
Atlantic
9 minutes ago
- Atlantic
Hamas Actually Wants a Famine
This week, the world seems to be finally paying attention to the magnitude of the suffering in Gaza. The futile policies pursued by the Israeli government—prodded by the far-right cabinet ministers Bezalel Smotrich and Itamar Ben-Gvir—have reduced the supply of humanitarian aid, food, and supplies in Gaza. Israel has unnecessarily reengineered the distribution of aid, failing to achieve its goal of separating the civilian population from Hamas while further constricting its supply. And for these decisions, it has attracted the justified condemnation of the international community. Despite the surge of hundreds of trucks into Gaza over the past four days, very few supplies have made it into warehouses to be distributed to the population. Aid shipments are being seized by a combination of desperate civilians, lawless gangs, clan-affiliated thugs, and merchants of death. Chaos and apocalyptic scenery are the norm, not the exception. There is no denying the reality of the widespread malnutrition and hunger in the Gaza Strip. In recent days, I've spoken with dozens of Gazans who are furious about what is unfolding around them. They are angry, one told me, at the 'hordes of selfish people who are attacking aid convoys to steal and collect aid in a horrific manner without caring for Gazans who chose not to participate in these humiliating and demeaning displays of inhumanity, no matter the level of hunger.' But their anger is directed primarily at Hamas, which they hold responsible for putting the people of Gaza in this position, and for its continued refusal to end the war that it started. 'Hitler fought in his bunker until he killed himself in World War II in the Battle of Berlin,' another person said, complaining that Hamas is hunkered down in its tunnels, willing to see Gaza destroyed to the very last child. Yair Rosenberg: The corrupt bargain behind Gaza's catastrophe Hamas actually wants a famine in Gaza. Producing mass death from hunger is the group's final play, its last hope for ending the war in a way that advances its goals. Hamas has benefited from Israel's decision to use food as a lever against the terror group, because the catastrophic conditions for civilians have generated an international outcry, which is worsening Israel's global standing and forcing it to reverse course. Online supporters of the terror group have consistently attacked any efforts to alleviate the crisis. In posts and videos, they have dismissed efforts to send in food by convoys of trucks from Egypt and Jordan, pointing to the chaotic scenes as desperate Gazans scramble for aid. They have likewise attacked the airdrops that are now under way and called for them to be stopped immediately. Hamas's evident desire to extend and deepen the crisis of hunger helps explain the recent breakdown of cease-fire negotiations, even as Gazans are needlessly dying. The group's intransigence led both Israel and Trump's envoy, Steve Witkoff, to walk away from the talks. If the hunger crisis and humanitarian issues are addressed, Hamas can no longer use the suffering of Gazans to generate an international outcry or use the resultant leverage to end the war on its own terms. But the two-state-solution conference convened by France and Saudi Arabia at the United Nations shows the way forward. In a remarkable statement, endorsed by the European Union and the Arab League, the participants condemned the October 7 attacks and the taking of hostages, and declared that 'Hamas must end its rule in Gaza and hand over its weapons to the Palestinian Authority.' The conference envisions the end of hostilities, the establishment of an international mission in Gaza, and the ultimate return of the Palestinian Authority to govern the strip. Many Arab states have been reluctant to call out Hamas publicly, even though they do so privately on a regular basis, for fear of upsetting their own populations. But now they have recognized the importance of openly and transparently calling for Hamas to give up control of Gaza and disarm. Both Israel and the international community should capitalize on this shift, to isolate the terrorist organization and give hope for a better trajectory for Gaza's future. If Hamas believes that the suffering of Gazans bolsters its cause, Israeli decision makers should take that to heart. They should abandon their misguided and inhumane policies and cease their efforts to pressure the population as a means of pressuring the terror group. The best way to undermine Hamas's position is to instead flood Gaza with food, and to alleviate the suffering of its people.
