India wrestles with how census can count tribe that shuns contact with outside world
At the heart of the dilemma are the Sentinelese, a hunter-gatherer tribe living on the thickly forested North Sentinel Island, who have a long history of repelling intruders using bows and arrows. Now, a government census notice is stirring debate about whether attempts should be made to count them at all.
'Trying to do a census of the Sentinelese is pointless,' says Manish Chandi, a former member of the research advisory board of the Andaman and Nicobar Tribal Research and Training Institute. 'It's far more important to protect the island's reef, marine resources and the tribe's isolation than to come up with a number,' he told the Hindustan Times.
The last time India conducted a census was in 2011. Since then, officials have enforced a 5km exclusion zone around North Sentinel Island. This 'eyes-on, hands-off' policy is aimed at shielding the tribe from diseases to which they have no immunity and protecting their autonomy.
Earlier censuses weren't invasive. Officials would travel by boat, circling the shores of North Sentinel Island, close enough to glimpse the inhabitants but far enough to avoid being struck by arrows. RF Lowe, who supervised the census in 1921, wrote that with the Sentinelese 'being uniformly hostile, no attempt was made at direct enumeration'.
The 2001 census listed 39 individuals seen on the beach. The 2011 census put the number at 15. Both figures are seen as 'guesstimates' based on offshore observations. London-based Survival International, which advocates for Indigenous peoples' rights, says the population is estimated to be anywhere from 50 to 150.
Believed to have migrated from Africa more than 50,000 years ago, the Sentinelese hunt, fish and forage using bows, arrows, spears and stone tools. Some anthropologists believe them to be the most isolated tribe in the world.
When the British established a penal colony in the Andamans in 1858, the islands were home to an estimated 5,000 people from various tribes. Within decades, many had died, either killed or wiped out by measles, influenza, syphilis and other diseases brought in by settlers
No Indian official has set foot on the 59 sq km island since 2014, not even to retrieve the bodies of four intruders killed by the Sentinelese, including US missionary John Allen Chau, 26. He landed on the island illegally in 2018 and, according to the fishers who ferried him, was shot dead with arrows.
Despite the tribe's hostility to outsiders, North Sentinel Island still attracts adventurers. In March, a 24-year-old Arizona YouTuber, Mykhailo Viktorovych Polyakov, was arrested after filming himself sailing to the island and bringing a can of Diet Coke and a coconut as offerings, and blowing a whistle to draw attention to himself.
'The government used to land coconut-laden boats on the beach until the late 1990s,' says M Sasikumar, joint director of the Anthropological Survey of India. 'But that was stopped because of the risk of disease. A virus could wipe them out.'
With the 2027 census looming, officials have been considering using drones and satellite imagery to estimate the Sentinelese population, but experts warn this could do more harm than good.
'It's hard to imagine that such populations could be accurately assessed using drones, as both the Sentinelese and Shompen live in dense rainforest,' says Jonathan Mazower of Survival International. Using drones 'would just feel intrusive', he adds.
Flying drones could also cause panic among the islanders, experts warn. After the 2004 tsunami, the Sentinelese famously fired arrows at helicopters sent to check on their welfare.
The Sentinelese are not the only people who defy easy enumeration. Others, such as the Shompen of Great Nicobar and the Jarawa of Middle and South Andaman, have varying levels of contact with outsiders. Some accept medical help or provisions; others live near settled areas and are increasingly exposed to tourism and development.
'The Shompen live very deep inside the forests on the west coast,' says Barnabas Manju, chair of the Little and Great Nicobar Tribal Council. The 2011 census counted 229 Shompen – 141 males and 88 females – but that figure too is seen as unreliable.
Access to the Shompen is logistically difficult. Roads were damaged by the tsunami, which means that reaching the Shompen requires days of trekking while many avoid outsiders.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
3 hours ago
- The Independent
UK Air India crash victim's mum sent wrong body back for burial
The mother of an Air India flight 171 crash victim, Amanda Donaghey, received the wrong body for burial due to a botched repatriation scheme. Her son, Fiongal Greenlaw-Meek, and his husband Jamie were among the 260 people killed when the flight crashed less than a minute after takeoff from Ahmedabad. Despite initial DNA identification in India, a second test conducted in the UK revealed the remains sent to Ms Donaghey were not her son's. The family has been unable to lay Fiongal to rest with his husband and is urging the British government to help locate his remains. The incident is expected to be raised by Sir Keir Starmer with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, while Air India has offered interim compensation to affected families.
Daily Mail
14 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Eye-watering amount Aussie taxpayers have forked out for an Indigenous treaty as state edges closer to finalising negotiations
The Victorian government has already spent at least $382million of taxpayer money negotiating an Indigenous treaty, according to new analysis. A treaty is expected to be finalised later in 2025, nine years after the state government became the first in the country to formally commit to treaty talks in 2016. According to treaty reports and budget papers, $382.4 million has been given to the 'self-determination' process over the past decade, The Herald Sun reported. Some money has gone towards setting up the Treaty Authority, which is overseeing negotiations, with members of the panel earning up to $380,000 a year. Funding has also supported preparations by First Nations groups for negotiations, public events to inform Indigenous communities about the process, and roundtable discussions on the treaty framework. Right-wing think tank the Institute of Public Affairs suggested the total figure could be higher. Their report found that 727 meetings related to treaty development were held between July 2016 and June 2025. That number could reach 968 by June 2026 if it continues at its current pace, with one meeting taking place every two to three business days. The Institute's review of government budget papers estimated that a combined $776 million has been spent over the past decade on the treaty, 'self-determination' programs, and Indigenous community initiatives. However, the documents do not provide a detailed breakdown of spending. Institute of Public Affairs Research Fellow Margaret Chambers criticised the government's handling of the process. 'The Victorian government is not being honest and upfront with Victorians about its plan to divide the community on racial grounds,' Ms Chambers told the Herald Sun. 'With a treaty scheduled to be finalised inside the next 12 months, and despite the volume of secret meetings over the past decade, very little is known about what this treaty will entail. 'Any treaty will fundamentally change Victoria's legal structure and will likely require already financially stretched Victorian taxpayers to pay billions of dollars to activists aligned to the Allan government.' New legislation related to the treaty is expected to go before Victoria's parliament in the coming months. It is understood the bill will enshrine an expanded First Peoples' Assembly. That would effectively establish a state-based version of the Voice, which was rejected in a national referendum in 2023. The Victorian government is also negotiating separate treaties with local Indigenous groups. The details of these agreements and associated costs have not been disclosed. At the beginning of July, the Victorian government released the findings from the Yoorrook Justice Commission investigating the state's colonial roots. The Truth Be Told report detailed massacres and frontier violence, labelling it a 'genocide' and investigating the ongoing harms against Aboriginal people. A Victorian government spokesman slammed the 'cherry-picked analysis from the Liberal Party-aligned think tank'. 'If you listen to the people directly affected by policies, you get better outcomes - that's commonsense,' he said. 'Treaty is about making a better and fairer state for all Victorians - negotiations are underway and we look forward to bringing treaty to the Parliament.'
The Independent
17 hours ago
- The Independent
Mexico City marks 700 years since its founding by Indigenous people
Mexico City is marking the 700th anniversary of its founding with a series of public events on Saturday, including artistic performances honoring the city's Indigenous origins. Artists in Indigenous clothing reenacted the founding of the Aztec capital in front of the country's top officials in Mexico City's main square. Later, hundreds of dancers dressed in traditional clothing, feather headdresses, drums, and ankle rattles made of seeds performed sacred dances meant to connect with nature. The anniversary commemorates the establishment of Tenochtitlan, the capital of the Mexica, a group also known as the Aztecs, who settled in the Valley of Mexico in 1325. As recorded by early Spanish chroniclers, Mexica elders told of a divine sign from their patron god Huitzilopochtli: an eagle on a cactus, signaling where to settle. That place became Tenochtitlan, the center of Aztec civilization and the site of today's Mexico City. That symbol was later recorded in the Codex Mendoza, which contained historical accounts of the Aztec empire. It became central to Mexican identity and appears today on the national flag. 'Mexico was not born with the arrival of the Spanish; Mexico was born much earlier with the great civilizations,' said President Claudia Sheinbaum in a speech in which she urged the eradication of the racism that still persists in the country. Tenochtitlan began as a village on an island in a lake ringed by volcanic peaks. But historians say many other details that have come down in history are based heavily on legend, and that the exact founding date is unknown. By the time the Spanish arrived in the 16th century, they were awed by a city filled with palaces, bridges, canals and bustling trade, according to Spanish chronicler and conquistador Bernal Díaz del Castillo. Historian Miguel Pastrana of the National Autonomous University of Mexico's Historic Investigations Institute, an expert on Tenochtitlan, said the weekend's festivities are 'political and civic" and do not reflect the latest historical research. The historical record describes the Mexica as a people who migrated from a place called Aztlan, supposedly an island whose exact location remains unknown. They knew how to fish, gather aquatic plants and hunt birds, as well as build dams, and they tried to settle in several places before arriving in the Valley of Mexico. The main island in the lake was already populated by the Tepaneca people, but they allowed the Mexica to settle there in exchange for tribute payments and other services, Pastrana said. Little by little, the Mexica's power grew. They were strong warriors and commercially prosperous, and they were effective at making alliances with other peoples. Tenochtitlan became a great city at the center of an empire until the Spanish conquered it in 1521.
