Legislative subpoena adds to SAHRC complaint against Emfuleni municipality
The Emfuleni municipality is being placed under increasing pressure by administrative forces.
A complaint against the municipality has been submitted to the South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) and officials have also drawn the ire of the Gauteng provincial legislature (GPL).
Under phase two of Operation Vulindlela, Emfuleni is highlighted as one of the eight worst run municipalities in the country and is subject to national government intervention.
SAHRC complaint
The DA on Wednesday laid a complaint with the SAHRC, citing a violation of the right to access water and forcing residents to live in filth to due to regular sewerage spills.
Emfuleni racked up R562 million in wasteful expenditure spent on overtime pay for service delivery projects that yielded little results.
Additionally, the municipality returned R636 million of its municipal infrastructure grant despite its service delivery challenges.
'These failures reflect systemic corruption, mismanagement, and a disregard for residents' dignity,' stated the DA's SAHRC complaint lodged by Emfuleni North constituency head Kingsol Chabalala.
'The actions taken by the provincial government to place Emfuleni under administration, have not produced any significant advancements, and the residents still suffer due to poor governance at the provincial and local levels,' he said.
Emfuleni municipality and the SAHRC were contacted for comment by The Citizen but no response had been received at the time of publication.
GPL subpoena
Emfuleni officials have been criticised by the GPL for not attending to service delivery requests and proposals set out by residents.
The standing committee on petitions said that roughly only 12% of petitions submitted to the municipality received a formal response – some dating back to 2013.
'Alarmingly, no senior accountable officials from Emfuleni were present to respond to the remaining seven petitions or to account to the committee or the petitioners,' the GPL said on Thursday.
ALSO READ: Mashatile: How national government is aiming to reform local municipalities
Issues addressed in the unresolved petitions include the hijacking of properties, municipal rates disputes, relocation of informal settlement residents and a government housing project.
The lack of response by the municipality has prompted the GPL to take further steps to receive answers.
'As a result, the committee has taken a firm and decisive decision. Emfuleni municipality will be subpoenaed to appear before the committee in the coming weeks.
'This is to ensure full accountability and progress on the petitions which remain unresolved to this day. The residents of Emfuleni deserve answers – not continued neglect.
NOW READ: Emfuleni sewerage disaster continues despite multiple contractors being paid millions
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
2 hours ago
- The Citizen
‘Barrelling towards collapse': Concerns mount as Godongwana puts pressure on Morero to fix Joburg's finances
The finance minister's intervention should not be taken lightly, according to the DA. Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana has given Johannesburg Mayor Dada Morero a two-week deadline to address the city's escalating financial troubles. The City of Joburg continues to struggle financially, despite an increased budget of R89 billion for the 2025/2026 financial year. Adding to the crisis, the metropolitan municipality has been without a Finance MMC since African Independent Congress (AIC) councillor Margaret Arnolds vacated the position a month ago following her re-election as council speaker. Godongwana demands action from Morero over City of Joburg's finances The situation has become so dire that Godongwana sent a strongly worded letter to Morero on 30 July, reprimanding the mayor for failure to address unnecessary spending and repeated non-compliance with the Municipal Finance Management Act (MFMA). The municipality incurred R1.4 billion in unauthorised expenditure, R22 billion in irregular expenditure, and R705 million in fruitless and wasteful expenditure in the last fiscal year. ALSO READ: Joburg mayor Dada Morero survives motion of no confidence According to the Sunday Times, Godongwana has set a 14 day deadline for Morero to propose a plan addressing the financial issues and to hold accountable those responsible for the mismanagement. The letter warns that failure to act may lead to National Treasury invoking Section 216(2) of the Constitution, which would allow the department to withhold grant funding from the city. DA warns of collapse The Democratic Alliance (DA) has expressed concern over the developments, emphasising that the minister's warning was 'no empty threat' and should not be taken lightly. 'Johannesburg's R89 billion budget is funded through a mix of grants, loans, revenue collection and conditional grants. 'Conditional grants, which form a significant portion of the city's funding, can only be spent on what they are intended for. 'If Treasury pulls back or suspends these funds, as the minister warns in his letter, the city's ability to deliver the little basic services it is currently able to deliver, will collapse entirely,' DA Joburg caucus leader Belinda Kayser-Echeozonjoku said in a statement on Sunday. READ MORE: ActionSA-ANC slams Zille's plans for Joburg: 'They do not believe in black excellence' Kayser-Echeozonjoku claimed that the DA had consistently warned both Morero and the national about the 'financial rot' in Joburg. 'The DA has sent letters to the National Treasury, outlining that those heading up key departments were not doing their jobs, and warning of a total lack of consequence management in Joburg. 'Leaving the ANC in Joburg to do as they please will now come back to bite residents. We are pleased, however, to see that the minister of finance agreed with the DA's summation of what's been going on,' she said. She also warned that the city is 'barrelling towards collapse under the ANC, faster than ever before'. 'The ANC has proven, time and again, that it cannot govern Johannesburg responsibly. 'The city's finances are in freefall, service delivery is grinding to a halt, and now the very funding that keeps Johannesburg afloat is under threat.' Auditor-General flags long-standing issues Earlier this year, the Auditor-General raised red flags over Johannesburg's ongoing failure to improve its audit processes. The official from the Auditor-General's Gauteng office revealed in Parliament that the city has faced long-standing issues related to financial health, including poor debt collection, declining revenue, and recurring compliance problems. In addition, the Auditor-General expressed concern over inadequate investment in infrastructure, pointing out that the lack of funding for both maintenance and new projects has had a negative impact on service delivery. City of Joburg's 'bomb squad' Morero in June appointed a special 'bomb squad' team to address the city's ongoing service delivery issues. The 12-member team, led by ANC veteran Snuki Zikalala, will serve for the next two years. The unit's objectives include deployig rapid response teams to areas experiencing service delivery crises and provide oversight for the mayor. NOW READ: Morero's vision to make Johannesburg a world-class African city
Eyewitness News
3 hours ago
- Eyewitness News
Treasury threatens to stop funding Joburg municipality if it doesn't get its finances in order
JOHANNESBURG - National Treasury has threatened to stop grant funding to the Johannesburg municipality if it doesn't get its finances in order. Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana has written to the Joburg Mayor Dada Morero, saying he needs to do more to curb the city's wasteful, irregular and unauthorised expenditure. The letter, dated the 30th of July, has sounded alarm bells among the opposition in the city. Like most municipalities, the City of Johannesburg receives grant funding from the National Treasury. This funding goes towards capital projects like roads, water and electricity infrastructure. Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana said he's unhappy how some of these funds are being spent by the city. The Minister highlights the fact that in the 2023/24 financial year, the city racked up over 22 billion in unauthorised, irregular, fruitless and wasteful expenditure. Democratic Alliance (DA) Johannesburg caucus leader Belinda Kayser-Echeozonjoku said the city cannot afford to lose any funding. 'Funding that keeps our Johannesburg's finances and services running. Without it, our R89billion budget will collapse and residents will pay the ultimate price.' The DA said Mayor Dada Morero is not the right man to lead Johannesburg.
The Star
8 hours ago
- The Star
FW de Klerk Foundation urges South Africa to diversify trade amid US tariffs
Bongani Hans | Published 17 hours ago Apartheid's last president, FW De Klerk's foundation has added its voice in calling for South Africa to stop being overly reliant on America and look elsewhere for trade deals amid concerns over President Donald Trump's 30% tariffs on exports. In what could be seen as the country's population bending together against the economic squeezing tariffs, the foundation echoed DA leader John Steenhuisen in calling for the country to spread its wings wider, looking for alternative markets across the world. Steenhuisen, in his capacity as Agriculture minister, said recently that the country is strengthening its trade alliances with the likes of Chile, Peru, and New Zealand 'to jointly lobby for fair and stable trade treatment of fresh produce' through the Southern Hemisphere Association of Fresh Fruit Exporters. He also said the state had finalised new phytosanitary protocols for the export of avocados to China, table grapes to Vietnam and the Philippines, and maize to India. FW de Klerk Foundation's Ismail Joosub called for the strengthening of trading ties ' with our BRICS partners and Africa'. The foundation was concerned about the South African Reserve Bank warning that the tariffs could cost the country around 100,000 jobs, 'hitting our agriculture and automotive sectors the hardest.' South Africa is a member of BRICS, which the US sees as a threat to its global economic and political dominance. 'China's vast market, for instance, can buy more of our minerals, wine, and fruits. 'India, Brazil, and others present growing export destinations if we proactively pursue them,' Joosub said in a statement. He issued the statement on Friday, the same day Trump implemented the tariffs, which he said would be effective on August 7. According to, Charles A. Ray, a chairperson of the US-based Foreign Policy Research Institute's African Program and former US ambassador to Cambodia and Zimbabwe, US was unhappy with South Africa's proximity to China and Russia and its membership with BRICS. He said it ' has since become an alternate political forum to the US-led West, seeking to shift the global order more to the advantage of China and to move away from the US dollar's domination of the global economy'. According to one of Trump's Executive Orders, South Africa was undermining the US's foreign policy and posed threats to the US and its allies' security and interests. ' Our government is already working with industry to find alternative markets for our goods and support affected sectors with contingency plans. 'We should build on this by ramping up trade promotion in Asia, the Middle East and across Africa. 'In short, if one door closes, we must be ready to open many others,' said Joosub. He said another step to protect and grow the economy was to invest in youth, skilling young people by taking advantage of an initiative that China has established through its Luban Workshops, which are vocational training centres in nearly 20 countries. 'South Africa should welcome such initiatives and even expand them here at home, [as] at last year's BRICS summit in Johannesburg, a BRICS Skills Challenge showcased how collaboration in fields like robotics, data science and aerospace can help our youth develop critical skills. 'Millions of talented South African youth remain on the margins, [so] we need to harness their potential through education, training and entrepreneurship support,' he said. Joosub also called for the country to look at technical exchange programs, scholarships, and joint research with programmes with China, India and others to help the country cultivate much-needed skills in engineering, artisans and the innovation sectors. 'By equipping young South Africans with world-class skills, we not only reduce unemployment but also make our economy more competitive globally. 'Our Constitution's preamble enjoins us to ' free the potential of each person , ' and there is no greater potential waiting to be freed than that of our youth,' he said. The foundation was concerned that unemployment was already at 32,9% and youth unemployment exceeded 46%. 'We cannot afford further blows. It's a stark reminder that nearly half of young South Africans struggle to find work,' he said. He said the US was punishing South Africa for its domestic policies, including affirmative action and Black Economic Empowerment, and the country's diplomatic stance on the Russia-Ukraine war and a genocide case against Israel , which he said the US views as creating barriers or running counter to its interests. 'We should be candid: while the American approach is blunt, it has exposed fault lines in our own house. 'This tariff standoff is, in part, a reaction to our policy choices - and it compels us to reflect on whether those choices are achieving their intended goals,' said Joosub. President Cyril Ramaphosa believes his administration will still be able to find a way out of the 30% tariffs before August 7. [email protected]
