Power struggle in corporate watchdog led to garda roles not being filled
Mr Drennan also sought the outward transfer of four gardaí previously seconded to the authority. He said 'fresh ideas, perspectives and experience' were needed and that replacement gardaí will be assigned in due course.
The chief executive provided details of the dispute in the CEA's annual report which was published this week. It is the first time he has publicly commented on tensions within the CEA which have led to allegations of a toxic work environment in the organisation.
Mr Drennan said, during 2024, the CEA experienced 'an unprecedented unwillingness to accept decisions, as well as difficulty in obtaining information, explanations, and clarifications sought in respect of criminal enforcement activity.'
READ MORE
He did not specify to whom he was referring, but referenced disputes over the CEA's entitlement to oversee officers' work and arguments regarding the 'true nature' of secondments of gardaí.
One of the key areas in dispute was whether seconded gardaí are subject to CEA supervision and oversight, he said.
Dealing with these arguments, which Mr Drennan called a significant distraction, led to financial expense and absorbed 'considerable senior management time' during the year, he said.
The chief executive said if arguments over the CEA's power were advanced to their logical conclusion, it might have to 'completely cease its criminal enforcement activity pending, potentially very significant, legislative amendment'.
As a result, the CEA decided to 'temporarily defer' the filling of vacant garda roles in the authority in October 2024.
There are normally 16 gardaí seconded to the CEA, but this number has been depleted recently due to retirements and transfers.
Mr Drennan said it was later determined these arguments did not reflect the statutory regime underpinning the CEA. In early 2025, it recommenced engagement with the Garda regarding vacancies.
Regarding gardaí assigned to the CEA whose secondments were rescinded, Mr Drennan said as a growing organisation, the authority must 'renew its criminal investigative capabilities'.
'In particular, it is important that the organisation's criminal investigative complement periodically benefit from fresh ideas, perspectives and experience.'
He said in this context, he requested Garda Commissioner Drew Harris 'to rescind the secondments of four secondees'.
New gardaí will be assigned in due course, 'through a combination of both temporary transfer and through competitive processes', he said.
The four seconded gardaí objected to the move and were represented in talks with management by the
Garda Representative Association
(GRA), it is understood.
A least one civilian staff member has also this year lodged a case with the
Workplace Relations Commission
over their work conditions.
In a meeting with Minister for Enterprise
Peter Burke
last March, Mr Drennan said a cultural audit of the organisation was to take place as part of a new strategy. The audit will be carried out by an outside body.
The ODCE was rebranded as the CEA in 2022 following significant public criticism over its handling of the prosecution of former Anglo Irish Bank chief executive and chairman Seán FitzPatrick.
The late banker was accused of misleading Anglo's auditors about millions of euro worth of loans during the banking crisis.
In 2017, following a 126-day trial, all charges were dropped on the direction of the court.
The judge criticised the ODCE's handling of the case and said its inquiries had fallen short of the unbiased, impartial, balanced investigation to which the accused was entitled.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
26 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Irish house prices continue to rise and pharma's tariff options
Irish house prices continue rise despite the negative sentiment about Donald Trump's tariffs and what impact it might have on the Irish economy. owned by The Irish Times, said asking prices nationally rose by more than 7 per cent annually in the second quarter while the Dublin increase was above 5 per cent. Barry O'Halloran reports. Barry also has the details of the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission's letter to the motor industry, warning it intends to crack down on attempts to stop drivers from using independent garages for repairs. Dealers could face fines of up to €50 million for breaches of competition law. It has long been conventional wisdom that a boss who is prepared to reveal fear, uncertainty or some other form of uselessness is in luck, writes Pilita Clark. It's thought they will be more trusted and respected, especially by younger staff who are said to yearn for 'authenticity', and are therefore more valuable to an organisation. There is a strong logic for US pharma companies to continue making drugs in Ireland for non-US markets, writes our columnist John FitzGerald, as he explores the potential impact of Donald Trump's threatened tariffs on the sector here. READ MORE In our Q&A, a reader wonders if Prize Bonds are a good investment. Dominic Coyle offers a view. If you'd like to read more about the issues that affect your finances try signing up to On the Money , the weekly newsletter from our personal finance team, which will be issued every Friday to Irish Times subscribers. In Me & My Money, author Eimear McBride explains how her 'pension plan is to die before I'm no longer able to earn'. She spoke with Tony Clayton-Lea. The Changing Times Brewery, which was founded by the families behind some of Dublin's best-known pubs , is expanding the number of premises serving its beers and moving outside the capital for the first time. Colin Gleeson has the details. In a wide-ranging interview, EasyJet founder Stelios Haji-Ioannou talks to Mark Hennessy about his new North-South awards aimed at fostering cross-Border entrepreneurship, his Irish family members, and his relationship with Ryanair's Michael O'Leary. Tesco plans to add 400 new jobs here as part of a €40 million investment to expand its operations with the opening of 10 new stores over the next 12 months. Barry O'Halloran has the details. In our Opinion piece, Bank of Ireland executive Susan Russell says the EU could crack down on fake digital ads by forcing online platforms to ensure they are dealing with a reputable entity, especially as they earn income from these scam ads. BP's woes persist in spite of talk of a takeover by Shell , which the company has denied. Stocktake offers a view.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
A Revolut user encounters ‘evasive' customer service after €1,850 fraud
On May 22nd a reader's mother, a woman in her 70s, contacted Vodafone Ireland to report poor wifi and was promised a call back from a technician. The following day the call she was expecting came – or so she thought – but what happened next has left her traumatised and substantially poorer. The caller referenced the wifi issue 'and said she was eligible for a refund,' her son writes. 'She was sent a text link and asked to click it to 'verify' the refund.' She did as she was asked to do by the person claiming to be from Vodafone but after following the link and inputting some key details her banking app was compromised, her Revolut account remotely accessed and €1,850 sent to a sterling account in the UK. READ MORE 'She immediately reported it to Revolut, Vodafone, and An Garda Síochána, submitting screenshots of all the suspicious activity, a signed statement and the full context of the scam,' her son writes. He tells us that she was asked by Revolut 'to upload this same dossier five times [and] Revolut never called her, despite promising to'. He describes Revolut's support system as 'opaque and evasive, consisting of scripted replies and AI loops, with no clear case management or human escalation'. He says that when he asked 'a basic admin question – what documents are needed to file a fraud report in Ireland – they refused to answer, citing GDPR, even though I never asked about her account,' he says. [ 'Sorry you lost the money': Couple loses thousands of euro of wedding savings in Revolut 'ordeal' Opens in new window ] He also says Vodafone has 'not yet explained how someone knew about the wifi complaint and used that to engineer the scam'. Our reader points out that the funds 'were sent to another Revolut account, raising questions about their fraud controls and whether the funds were frozen. 'At this point, we just want honest answers and a fair process. My mum has done everything asked of her, but she's getting nowhere – and it feels like the system is built to exhaust people into giving up.' He says that 'everything is handled by bots with repeated requests for the same info, vague timelines, and generic cut-and-paste responses. Even now, weeks later, she still hasn't received a proper update, and it's genuinely shaken her confidence in using digital banking at all. It's an insane system and the fact you can't talk to a human is ludicrous.' He says that when Revolut wanted his business account, 'the office would receive regular phone calls and emails from reps looking for the business. How could they not provide the same support to existing clients? Has Revolut quietly built a wall between customers and accountability?' There are two troubling strands to this scam. Did the criminals know she had contacted Vodafone and were able to time their first contact with her to coincide with the exact time she was expecting a call from that company? And why are the systems that Revolut have in place so opaque and why has it proved to be impossible for this family to speak to a human being or even get a sense that Revolut is addressing this issue with the seriousness that it deserves? First we contacted Vodafone and shared the details of this scam with them. The company checked its systems and said that there was no evidence of a data breach on its side and a spokesman could not definitively say how it was that our reader – or at least their mother – would receive a call purporting to be from Vodafone less than 24 hours after she had contacted the company. It could be simple coincidence. Scammers make many, many such calls everyday and they must sometimes get lucky. We also contacted Revolut. In a statement the company said it was sorry for this person's experience 'and any instance where our customers are targeted by ruthless and sophisticated criminals. Revolut takes fraud, and the industry-wide risk of customers being coerced by organised criminals, incredibly seriously. Each potential fraud case concerning a Revolut customer is carefully investigated and assessed independently of other cases.' The statement stresses that it has 'a fervent focus on improving the customer experience at Revolut, and the protection of our customers' money is paramount to that. We provide customer support 24/7 in-app via chat because it is the most secure method to communicate with customers, and helps to ensure that they can be certain they are connected with a member of our team. 'Any reported fraud automatically triggers human intervention from our customer service team, ensuring a user's case is handled by skilled live agents with expertise in financial crime.' It said that in recent months it had introduced in-app calls 'to give users a secure way to engage with our customer service team over the phone and help them to expose phone call scams.' Revolut said that last year it had prevented more than €700 million in potential fraud against customers by implementing in-app calls, real-time AI fraud-detection systems, transaction limits, in-app warnings and delayed payments for suspicious transactions, biometric authentication requirements, and providing educational resources to help consumers remain informed about potential risks. 'Revolut's financial crime prevention team now represents almost a third of our global workforce and, alongside many other payments firms, we deploy a number of different interventions that are solely designed to 'break the spell' of scammers and fraudsters,' it said. 'Whilst Revolut is unable to comment on the specifics of these interventions, so as to not provide any insight that could help ruthless criminals socially engineer their victims and bypass these, we are constantly innovating and testing a range of eye-catching warnings. 'While we are fully determined to protect our customers as best we can through our fraud prevention technologies, and go to every length to ensure scams are avoided, there is no denying that fraud is an industry-wide issue that needs to be tackled at source, particularly by the telecoms companies and social media apps that are enabling this. Banks and financial institutions should be the last line of defence, not the only line of defence.' The story does have a happier-than-expected outcome. Initially the company wrote to her and outlined its processes and the steps it had taken to prevent any suspicious transactions taking place before determining that it was not at fault and as such no money would be refunded. A day later we heard back from our reader again. 'You won't believe this. We went from that email yesterday to my mother getting her cash paid back today.' In a letter the company sent to her a representative said that 'upon further investigation of your case, we have identified a mistake in how it was previously handled. Subsequently, we have reclassified the situation as an account-takeover fraud and organised a full reimbursement of €1891.50 along with €150 as a compensation for the stress caused by the whole situation. The payment was sent directly to your Revolut account.'
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Stelios Haji-Ioannou of Easyjet: I was asked ‘how are you going to fly into Belfast with an orange airline?'
Stelios Haji-Ioannou's interest in Ireland came in stages – first when EasyJet began flying out of Belfast in the late 1990s and then, more importantly, after he met a Kerry woman, Orla Murphy, and, later, became father to Aria, the couple's seven-year-old daughter. The Greek Cypriot billionaire knows a few things about divided islands: 'One of my earliest memories as a kid is the invasion of Cyprus in 1974. I remember we were all scared,' he says, 'it was a very vivid memory.' Today, Haji-Ioannou – better known simply as Stelios – has created the inaugural North –South Business Co-operation Awards with Co-operation Ireland to encourage cross-Border entrepreneurship and start-ups on the island of Ireland. His connection with Ireland goes back to the early days of the low-cost carrier EasyJet. In 1995, he had considered flying out of Belfast but shied away because 'it was considered always a difficult route'. READ MORE Fortunes, however, changed after the 1998 Belfast Agreement, with EasyJet beginning with three flights a day from Belfast. Today, it carries seven out of every 10 people who fly into or out of Northern Ireland. Stelios Haji-Ioannou of EasyJet at Glin Castle. Photograph: Mark Hennessy Remembering the early days, he tells The Irish Times: 'I remember one of the comments in '98 was, 'How are you going to fly into Belfast with an orange airline?'. I mean, can you imagine?' The billionaire is speaking in a bedroom in Glin Castle, one of three temporarily converted into offices while the family holiday in Co Limerick on the banks of the Shannon, in the ancestral home of the Knights of Glin. The historic location – the home of the Black Knight of Glin, one of the Fitzgeralds of Desmond, since the early 14th Century – is popular with the family because it 'is close to home' for his partner, whom he met after she had moved to Monaco. 'My daughter's name is Aria, A-R-I-A. We chose a name equally easy to pronounce in Greek and English. We tried others, but they weren't so easy to pronounce,' Haji-Ioannou says. In time, he hopes his daughter will take charge of the family's philanthropic arm, the Stelios Foundation: 'I wanted to do something more substantial in Ireland because, obviously, I'm spending time here. 'I have family here now. One day, hopefully, this foundation will be run by her, and I want to have a bigger project in Ireland.' Stelios Haji-Ioannou is no longer involved as an executive in EasyJet. Photograph: Chris Radcliffe/Bloomberg Many of his relatives left Cyprus after the 1974 invasion. In 2004, he returned after the border crossings that divided the Mediterranean island were opened: 'It was a time when I had started seriously to think about giving back to society.' So began in 2008 the Stelios Bi-Communal Business Co-Operation Awards, which offers more than €400,000 in prizes annually to Greek Cypriot and Turkish Cypriot business people who are prepared to work together. It started quietly because he was not sure how welcome the awards would be: 'Because very often in Cyprus, there is misinformation that, you know, you're a traitor if you're doing business with the other side.' Bar Covid interruptions, the awards have flourished. Winners like prizes, he says with a smile: 'But the other thing they like is the endorsement, the clarification that it's actually approved, it's legal, it's lawful to do business with the other side.' The idea to bring it to Ireland came after Haji-Ioannou listened to a speech from former Irish ambassador to London and Washington Dan Mulhall at a lunch in Monaco attended by the principality's Prince Albert. 'I approached him, and I said, 'I'm doing this in Cyprus. Do you think it might work in Ireland?' Immediately, he said 'yes', and the rest is history. He introduced us to Ian Jeffers of Co-Operation Ireland,' he says. The awards will be made in Castle Leslie in Co Monaghan in October: 'Hundreds of applications have been downloaded, so people are thinking about it. Hopefully, we're going to have a good set of first winners and then they will become the ambassadors.' Today, he divides his time in three – a third is spent on the Easy family of brands, a third goes on his philanthropic work and the remainder on investments that have diversified his interests far beyond aviation. No longer involved as an executive in EasyJet, he still gets 25c for every passenger the airline flies. Last year, it carried more than 70 million passengers: 'The best decision I ever made after creating EasyJet was to keep the name in my own company.' Aviation is getting tougher, with higher fuel costs and future emissions charges, but Haji-Ioannou sees no return to the crippling charges that passengers paid in an era before EasyJet and Ryanair. Questioned about his one-time direct opponent, Michael O'Leary of Ryanair, Haji-Ioannou says: 'He's made a lot of money, so I think he's a very successful businessman. There's no doubt about it.' The two men clashed repeatedly and bitterly during the 1990s and 2000s, with the Greek Cypriot once calling Ryanair's customer service 'appalling', while O'Leary had to apologise for calling him a liar. 'He's made a lot of money for himself, for his shareholders. Some of the rhetoric is designed to reduce customer expectations. He has this philosophy that if you lower the expectations of the customer, you can lower your costs. 'I remember O'Leary as an accountant, ex-KPMG who was very shy and didn't talk to the media. He's become this very, very prominent personality largely because the media give him a lot of time,' he says. 'I haven't spoken to him for years. In the early days we used to every now and then meet or speak. Nothing personal. Because I don't have a day-to-day role in EasyJet, I don't have a reason to speak to Michael O'Leary.'
