C&C's accounting errors under the microscope
The imbroglio compelled the group to restate three years of earnings due to errors and led to the resignation of chief executive Patrick McMahon in June 2024. Having taken on the role in 2023, the former chief financial officer barely had his feet under the desk when the group acknowledged the errors publicly and announced his departure.
Will DoorDash takeover of Deliveroo mean better pay and conditions for gig economy workers?
Listen |
28:33
Tennents NI is a distribution company in the group that also produces and markets well-known brands like Tennent's, Magners Irish Cider and Five Lamps. In 2023, the company overstated its operating profits by almost £250,000 (€290,000), according to a note in its latest set of accounts. The restated figure in the 2024 accounts is just over £2.3 million compared with some £2.57 million in the previous, inaccurate financial statements.
The value of the company's stocks was also overstated to the tune of £455,000 in the 2023 filings, according to the note, 'due to the incorrect treatment applied to the inventory of branded glassware'. Tennents NI also understated its 2023 operating expenses by a sizeable £7 million due to 'errors' related to the 'classification of excise duty payments'. Turnover, meanwhile, was understated by a more modest £52,000 in 2023, the correct figure being £61.2 million.
READ MORE
Overall, C&C said last year the errors cost the group €11 million in adjustment charges related to its 2021, 2022 and 2023 financial statements.
[
C&C plunges after chief executive quits amid accounting errors
Opens in new window
]
Bruising though the scandal was, C&C's new chief executive, Roger White, is grappling with more pressing matters currently. In March, just two months after his appointment, the group cut its full-year earnings guidance, largely due to softer cider sales in Britain. It now expects to report underlying earnings in the range of €76 million to €78 million for the year ended February 28th 2025, below targets due to softer trading in January and February.
Consequently, C&C's share price is down by about 1.2 per cent this year and more than 13 per cent over the past 12 months. The group's full-year results, due on May 28th, are keenly awaited, it's safe to say.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
8 hours ago
- Irish Times
Hotelier Noel O'Callaghan takes legal action against two sons
Hotelier Noel O'Callaghan claims in Commercial Court proceedings that two of his sons, who took over the running of his business in 2016, have excluded him and prevented him from exercising his right to retake control. Mr O'Callaghan (74) stepped back in 2016 from the business he built from scratch over 40 years. The first hotel his group acquired was the Mont Clare in Dublin in 1984. In addition to five hotels it operates, it also owns the 450-acre Mountarmstrong stud farm outside Cashel in Co Tipperary, along with around 100 rent apartments owned by Só Living. In his proceedings, Mr O'Callaghan claims he stepped down from the day-to-day management of the group to focus on Mountarmstrong and his bloodstock business, leaving the day-to-day running to his sons. READ MORE The transfer was done ahead of his 66th birthday in order that substantial capital gains tax relief would not be lost. It is claimed that, in agreeing the transfer of his shares in Saira Co Dublin Unlimited Company, in which he is a director along with his sons Paul and Charles who now run the group, he wanted a 'fallback position in the event of any future dispute' whereby he could retake control of Saira. Accordingly, Paul and Charles, along with his third son Bryan who was involved in the business until he departed in 2023, signed a form of proxy appointing their father to act as each of their proxy and vote on their behalf at meetings of the Saira board. The proxy is still extant and binding, it is claimed. As part of the 2016 agreement, Mr O'Callaghan snr was to be paid an annual salary of €500,000 for the rest of his natural life and to have his credit card expenses discharged along with the benefit and control of Mountarmstrong. After Bryan left in 2023, a new shareholders' agreement was made but, it is claimed, this did not replace the 2016 agreement. The stud farm, which comprises a large number of racehorses, was operated by Saira subsidiary, Sherborough Development Co Unlimited Company, and Noel O'Callaghan is the full or partial beneficial owner of the bloodstock, it is claimed. It is alleged that, since 2024, Paul and Charles have attempted to exercise control over the bloodstock with instructions for valuations and sales of some animals done without their father's consent. In 2024, Noel sold his interest in a commercial property called the Archers Building in Fenian Street, Dublin, to Saira. It is claimed that there was a failure to disclose KBC Bank was negotiating the surrender of its lease on the building, which was eventually done for €16.6 million, and this resulted in an undervaluation of the building at the time the father sold his interest. It constituted a material non-disclosure and secret profit, it is claimed. Noel O'Callaghan's relationship with Paul and Charles began to deteriorate in 2024 with the purchase of residential properties in Warrenpoint for their personal use, the withdrawal of instructions to prepare board packs for directors' meetings and the payment of a dividend of €3.2 million to the two sons. When Noel challenged these decisions, his sons began to 'freeze' him out by removing clerical support and the cancellation of payments to him by Saira, including health insurance. The proceedings by Noel are against Paul and Charles O'Callaghan, Saira and Sherborough. On Monday, the case was admitted on consent to the Commercial Court on the application of Martin Hayden SC who said, in reply to a question from Mr Justice Mark Sanfey, that mediation had been tried already. The judge said in cases involving close family members mediation was desirable. He approved agreed directions for the progress of the case and adjourned it to November.
Irish Times
8 hours ago
- Irish Times
McKillen jnr sues receivers over taking possession of three properties
Paddy McKillen junior is in a dispute with receivers who took possession of three valuable Dublin office properties, allegedly due to millions of euro in rent arrears on them. Perfect Stripe Ltd, trading as Grafter, is suing Ken Fennell and Brendan O'Reilly, of Interpath Advisory, who were appointed joint receivers over three companies which rented the properties at Stephen's Green, Leeson Street and Ely Place from Perfect Stripe. The three companies, Wonderbay Ltd, Crossville Properties Ltd and Discovery Dawn Ltd (all in receivership) were McKillen group-related firms. Perfect Stripe claims that on the morning of June 23rd, agents of the receivers broke into the properties having unlawfully purported to have forfeit the leases. The locks were changed and Perfect Stripe and its agents were prevented from gaining access. The claim of breaking in is denied. READ MORE The purchase of the buildings was funded largely through loans from RELM Loan Opportunities DAC, which appointed the receivers after calling in the loans. Perfect Stripe says the forfeiture happened despite discussions with the defendants about rent adjustments. It believed the parties were negotiating in good faith and that no steps would be taken towards any enforcement until those negotiations concluded. The defendants claimed the sums due on each of the properties in rent arrears at the time was some €2.7 million for Stephen's Green, around €321,000 for Ely Place and some €530,000 for Leeson Street. Perfect Stripe, in its statement of claim, says the defendants have unlawfully forfeited the properties 'under the guise of seeking inflated amounts in excess of the interest due' under the loan agreements. It also says they have 'misappropriated the plaintiff's business in order to achieve a higher sales price for the properties'. On Monday, Mr Fennell and Mr O'Reilly, in their capacity as receivers of the three defendant companies, applied to have the dispute admitted to the fast track Commercial Court. James Doherty SC, for the defendants. said the total debt now due in arrears was in excess of €4.1 million and the leases were forfeited and possession taken some five weeks ago. Counsel said there was mediation for a short time which was unsuccessful. The claim of misappropriation by the defendants of the business to themselves is 'wholly without foundation', he said. Counsel also disputed a claim by Marcus Dowling SC, for Perfect Stripe, that from his client's perspective, what had happened was the receivers agents breaking into the premises in the middle of the night. Mr Dowling said his side was neutral on the application to admit the case to the commercial list. Mr Justice Mark Sanfey said it was clearly a matter suitable for entry to the Commercial Court. He approved agreed directions and adjourned the matter to later this year.
Irish Times
10 hours ago
- Irish Times
Ballsbridge Post Office site tipped for bar/restaurant with retail and gallery space
The hospitality group which operates Hogan's pub on Dublin's South Great George's Street has lodged plans for a new pub restaurant at the former Ballsbridge Post Office in Dublin 4. The group, led by Declan O'Regan, has lodged plans through Telfer Ltd with Dublin City Council to change the use of the two-storey former post office on Shelbourne Rd to a licensed bar restaurant with retail and gallery space. The application comes as revenues at the pub group jumped by €1.3 million last year. The most recent accounts for Telfer Ltd show that it recorded pretax profits of €1.25 million as revenues increased by 11 per cent from €11.32 million to €12.6 million in the 12 months to the end of May 2024. READ MORE A planning conservation report drawn up by Crimmins Architects and lodged with the new application states that the objective of the proposed works 'is to stop the deterioration of the building by sensitive repair and adaptation and to give it a use that can support its survival both physically and economically'. Built in 1889, Ballsbridge Post Office is on the Record of Protected Structures held by Dublin City Council for its architectural social quality, which contributes to the character and heritage of the city. The report says existing signage 'will remain an important aspect of the proposal. Any original memorabilia relating to An Post will be retained and featured as an opportunity to nod to the original use'. Crimmins says its clients 'are keen to maintain the character of the space with the fit out. This will have an overall positive impact'. 'All efforts will be taken to ensure that necessary new work on the historic structures looks appropriate and is in keeping with the fabric, materials and style of the original work,' its report says. It adds that the proposed works will 'have minimal detrimental impact on the character of the protected structure'. 'The proposal to change the use of the building to a licensed bar restaurant with retail and gallery along with the proposed repairs and removal of late 20th century partitions will have a hugely positive impact,' the Crimmins report adds. In Telfer's 2024 accounts, directors said they were satisfied with the results after the company 'enjoyed another profitable year'. Numbers employed increased from 129 to 133 as staff costs rose from €3.7 million to €4.6 million. A connected Declan O'Regan pub firm, The Secret Bar Ltd, recorded pretax profits of €175,746 on revenues of €3.96 million in the 12 months to the end of May last.
