Destruction of CDRs raises serious doubts over integrity of 11/7 probe: HC
MUMBAI: Bombay high court questioned ATS over the "integrity" and deletion of call data records (CDRs) in its probe into the 11/7 train blasts, adding "reluctance of the prosecution to bring CDRs on record and their destruction raises an adverse inference against the prosecution".
HC said the prosecution's case was that conspiracy meetings were held at the residence of a planter in Bandra, attended by four other accused. In May, a prosecution witness met the planter and others near Shams Masjid, in Mira Road, where the witness was instructed by the planter to call another accused there. Besides, confessions of two accused said one handed over his mobile phone to the other near Lucky Hotel, Bandra, at 4.15pm, the judgment said.
In its claim of one eyewitness seeing an alleged blast conspiracy meeting, "prosecution could have easily established location and movement of accused at the relevant places and times through CDRs. Instead, the CDR was destroyed. This act raises serious doubts over the integrity of the investigation and amounts to a grave violation of right to a fair trial," the HC special bench of Justices Anil Kilor and Shyam Chandak held.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
American Investor Warren Buffett Recommends: 5 Books For Turning Your Life Around
Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List
Undo
HC said CDR was of critical importance, particularly because first arrest in 11/7 case was made based on a mobile number allegedly belonging to accused Kamal Ansari (who died in 2021 after conviction in Nagpur prison) from which a religious SMS was sent, arousing suspicion in minds of ATS. HC said prosecution appeared to have done no probe to corroborate the witness's claim of having met near the masjid or at accused's house.
"Prosecution could have produced the CDR of either the witness or the accused to establish their location," HC held.
The witness' statement is shrouded in doubt. Besides, while his statement was said to be recorded by an ACP at Chandan Chowki, the certified logbook shows the ACP "did not even go" there that day. Prosecution said allegedly "as per the Al-Qaeda Manual and training given to the accused, they were not supposed to use their mobile phones for operational purposes".
"In the absence of direct evidence of conspiracy, a chain of events has to be completed from which a conclusion of guilt of the accused can be drawn," HC said. The court added that with the eight unreliable eyewitnesses, the chain could not be completed, and the witness was of no help in establishing the conspiracy claim.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
29 minutes ago
- Time of India
Belgian woman in Madurai to trace roots, suspects adoption racket
1 2 Madurai: Aruna Leruitte, a 33-year-old Belgian national, arrived in Madurai on Wednesday to trace her biological family, nearly three decades after she was adopted from a now-blacklisted agency suspected of child trafficking. Aruna was adopted in 1994 through Malaysian Social Service (MSS), an agency later exposed for fabricating documents and kidnapping children for international adoption. Her adoption papers mention Palayam, a village in Madurai district, as her place of origin. She is now preparing to file a petition in the Madras high court, seeking access to her birth records. "This December, I will complete five years of searching for my mother," said Aruna, who works as a secretary in Belgium. Aruna was raised with love by her adoptive mother, who died of cancer when Aruna was 16. She now lives with her adoptive father and brother, also adopted, from Bengaluru. She said she had constantly faced bullying in Belgium for her dark skin. Her legal counsel, Anjali Pawar of the Adoptee Rights Council, said there are significant inconsistencies in Aruna's records. According to available documents, she was admitted to the MSS Child Care Centre in 1993 as a child born out of wedlock. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Indonesia: New Container Houses (Prices May Surprise You) Container House | Search Ads Search Now Undo "But the timeline suggests she may have been taken from her family without consent when she was around 1.5 years old," Pawar said. MSS came under scrutiny in 2005 for sending kidnapped children abroad under the guise of legal adoption. "It's still happening in different forms," Pawar said, adding that oversight by the Central Adoption Resource Authority (CARA) needs to be decentralised. "After Kolkata, Tamil Nadu has become a major hub for such rackets. These truths surface only when someone goes looking," she added. MSID:: 122885111 413 |
Time of India
29 minutes ago
- Time of India
Justice served: 59-year-old convicted for sexual assault on minor, sentenced to 20 years
Representative image YAMUNANAGAR: The Yamunanagar district police's efforts and robust legal advocacy have led to the conviction of a 59-year-old man, Om Chandra alias Chandgi Ram of Sadhaura, for sexually assaulting a 12-year-old minor girl. The additional district and sessions judge (ADSJ) Ranjana Aggarwal, sentenced him to 20 years of imprisonment and imposed a fine of Rs 50,000 in a case registered under Sections 65 (2) (punishment for rape) and 351 (3) (criminal intimidation) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) and Section 6 (punishment for aggravated penetrative sexual assault) of the POCSO Act at Sadhaura Police Station. The case dates back to August 29, 2024, when a woman from a village under the Sadhaura police station area reported an incident of sexual assault with her minor daughter. The woman alleged that her 12-year-old daughter had gone to dispose of garbage outside their home but did not return for some time. After a frantic search, the mother heard her daughter's screams near a cattle shed owned by the convict, located close to the village's sports stadium. Upon reaching the shed, she found the gate locked from the inside. When she raised an alarm, Om Chandra opened the gate and fled. Inside, the mother discovered her daughter in a distressing state, with her clothes removed. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Top 15 Most Beautiful Women in the World Undo The minor revealed that the accused had forcibly detained her and attempted to sexually assault her. Following the complaint, a case was promptly registered under relevant sections of the BNS and Pocso Act. The investigation, led by women's assistant sub-inspector Sharmila, was thorough and meticulous, incorporating scientific evidence and strong legal groundwork. Under the guidance of district SP Kamaldeep Goyal, the police's Operation Conviction Monitoring Cell ensured rigorous follow-up and advocacy in court. The case was presented before the court of ADSJ Ranjana Aggarwal, where the prosecution's compelling arguments and evidence led to the conviction of Om Chandra. On July 24, 2025, the court delivered its verdict, sentencing the accused to 20 years in prison and a Rs 50,000 fine. The Yamunanagar police spokesperson hailed the verdict as a testament to the district police's commitment to justice, particularly in protecting vulnerable children. 'This conviction reflects our dedication to ensuring that perpetrators of heinous crimes face the full force of the law,' the spokesperson stated.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
STF nabs man with 8 pistols, Sikligar arms smuggling racket busted in Rudrapur
Dehradun: Eight semi-automatic pistols meant to be sold during panchayat elections were recovered from a man in Rudrapur on Wednesday night, exposing for the first time the alleged involvement of the Sikligar community from Madhya Pradesh in illegal arms trafficking in Uttarakhand. Khajan Singh, 24, a resident of Rudrapur in Udham Singh Nagar district. He was arrested by the special task force (STF) of Uttarakhand police from Rudrapur bus station following a tip-off, SSP (STF) Navneet Singh Bhullar said. "He was accompanied by three other acquaintances in a car. They dropped him at the bus station and sped away, followed by an ongoing investigation to nab them too. After nabbing Singh, police frisked his bag and recovered eight semi-automatic pistols from his possession," Bhullar said. Singh was then taken into custody. During interrogation, he told police he had travelled to Burhanpur in Madhya Pradesh on July 20 to procure the weapons from a Sikligar village and intended to sell them in Uttarakhand during the ongoing local body elections. He returned to Rudrapur on the night between Wednesday and Thursday. He revealed that he bought the pistols from Sartaz Singh, a notorious arms smuggler belonging to the Sikligar community in MP and admitted to sourcing weapons from him on earlier occasions too. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like American Investor Warren Buffett Recommends: 5 Books For Turning Your Life Around Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo Singh, who had previously been lodged in jail for loot and arms smuggling cases, said he planned to sell the pistols for Rs 60,000 to Rs 1.5 lakh each. STF officials said Singh's statement pointed to a deeper supply chain of locally made firearms feeding into electoral violence. "A probe is on to find out about his customers and nab his associates involved in the crime," Bhullar said. The Sikligars, who are found among both Hindu and Sikh communities, were historically gunsmiths in Guru Gobind Singh's army. After the colonial-era ban on arms-making, many families from the community — particularly those in Burhanpur, Dhar and Khargone — are suspected to have continued the trade clandestinely. In recent years, several police operations in MP have uncovered large caches of locally fabricated pistols, Mausers and revolvers made using truck springs, bicycle frames and scrap iron in makeshift furnaces. An investigation on the same by the MP police also revealed that they were supplying illegal arms to at least 19 states. The weapons are often trafficked across state borders to Punjab, Delhi, UP, Rajasthan and Uttarakhand through a network of carriers and buyers. In one such case, Punjab police busted a similar module in Khargone linked to radical outfits and gangs. Officers added that Singh's case was a direct example of how these low-cost weapons — some of which take up to 10 days to manufacture — enter electoral hotspots and fuel local crime. The demand around elections allows smugglers to push prices from Rs 1,000–2,000 for crude pistols to as high as Rs 1.5 lakh for improved semi-automatic models
