The water dispute that goes to the heart of the tensions between India and Pakistan
It is sad that when Cyril Radcliffe, the man who drew the India-Pakistan boundary in August 1947, approached Jawaharlal Nehru and Muhammad Ali Jinnah with his Indus Waters proposal, he was snubbed by both.
Radcliffe wanted both leaders to run the river-canal system as a joint Indo-Pakistan venture. However, Jinnah told him that he would 'rather have Pakistan deserts than fertile fields watered by courtesy of Hindus', while Nehru curtly informed him that what India did with its rivers was India's affair.
The issue of shared waters between the two neighbours has remained contentious ever since.
Simren Kaur
Jalandhar City, Punjab, India
SIR – Unless the long-standing Kashmir dispute is resolved there will be no lasting peace or friendship between India and Pakistan. Britain should be part of the dialogue because the origin of the disagreement goes back to the messy and unplanned borders that were the result of partition in 1947.
The plebiscite recommended by the United Nations never took place. It should be held now.
Hyder Ali Pirwany
Okehampton, Devon
SIR – Rising tensions and the prospect of war between India and Pakistan highlight the indispensable nature of the British Indian Ocean Territory, which gives Britain a strategic presence in a region of global interest.
In light of the changing situation, will the Government finally suspend the giveaway of the Chagos Islands?
Robert Frazer
Salford, Lancashire
SIR – The escalation of the dispute between India and Pakistan shows the sheer stupidity of allowing unstable regimes to have nuclear weapons. We have the same situation with North Korea, and potentially Iran. Weak governments in the West have let this happen and we are now seeing the potential for nuclear Armageddon in these countries.
We must never permit Iran to gain access to nuclear weapons, or we could see mass destruction in the Middle East, with dire consequences for oil and gas supplies.
Stan Kirby
West Malling, Kent
SIR – The Australian journalist Murray Sayle, who covered the Indo-Pakistani war of 1971, told of a press briefing given by the Indian Air Force, which reported that there had been intense activity, but that no planes had been shot down on either side.
Afterwards, he asked the briefing officer why so much effort had achieved no result. 'My dear fellow, you can't shoot down your friends,' came the reply. 'We were all at RAF Cranwell together.'
John Carter
Shortlands, Kent
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
8 hours ago
- Reuters
India backs Dalai Lama's position on successor, contradicting China
DHARAMSHALA, India, July 4 (Reuters) - A senior Indian minister has said that only the Dalai Lama and the organization he has set up have the authority to identify his successor as the spiritual head of Tibetan Buddhism, in a rare comment contradicting rival China's long-held position. The Dalai Lama, who fled to India in 1959 after a failed uprising against Chinese rule, said on Wednesday that upon his death he would be reincarnated as the next spiritual leader and that only the Gaden Phodrang Trust would be able to identify his successor. He previously said the person will be born outside China. Beijing says it has the right to approve the Dalai Lama's successor as a legacy from imperial times. Kiren Rijiju, India's minister of parliamentary and minority affairs, made a rare statement on the matter on Thursday, ahead of visiting the Dalai Lama's base in the northern Indian town of Dharamshala for the religious leader's 90th birthday on Sunday. "No one has the right to interfere or decide who the successor of His Holiness the Dalai Lama will be," Indian media quoted Rijiju as telling reporters. "Only he or his institution has the authority to make that decision. His followers believe that deeply. It's important for disciples across the world that he decides his succession." India's foreign ministry did not respond to a request for comment on the Dalai Lama's succession plan. Rijiju, a practising Buddhist, will be joined by other Indian officials at the birthday celebrations. India is estimated to be home to tens of thousands of Tibetan Buddhists who are free to study and work there. Many Indians revere the Dalai Lama, and international relations experts say his presence in India gives New Delhi a measure of leverage with China. Relations between India and China nosedived after a deadly border clash in 2020 but are slowly improving now.
Reuters
18 hours ago
- Reuters
Explainer: Why are farm goods holding up the India-U.S. trade deal?
MUMBAI, July 3 (Reuters) - U.S. and India trade negotiators were pushing on Wednesday to finalise a tariff-reducing deal ahead of President Donald Trump's July 9 negotiating deadline, but disagreements over U.S. dairy and agriculture remained unresolved. Agriculture and its allied areas contribute just 16% to India's $3.9 trillion economy, but sustain nearly half of the country's 1.4 billion population. As farmers remain the most powerful voting bloc, Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government was forced into a rare retreat four years ago when it tried to push through controversial farm laws. The prospect of cheaper imports from the United States threatens to drive down local prices, handing the opposition a fresh opportunity to attack the government. New Delhi has traditionally kept agriculture out of Free Trade Agreements with other nations. Granting market access to the U.S. could force India to extend similar concessions to other trading partners. The average Indian farm comprises just 1.08 hectares, compared to 187 hectares in the United States. In dairy, the average herd size in India is two to three animals per farmer, compared to hundreds in the United States. This difference makes it difficult for small Indian farmers to compete with their U.S. counterparts. Farming in India remains largely unmechanized because small, fragmented land holdings leave little room for large machinery. In many regions, farmers rely on techniques passed down through generations, a sharp contrast to U.S. farms, where cutting-edge equipment and AI-driven technologies have raised productivity. The United States is pressing India to open its markets to a wide range of American products, including dairy, poultry, corn, soybeans, rice, wheat, ethanol, citrus fruits, almonds, pecans, apples, grapes, canned peaches, chocolates, cookies, and frozen French fries. While India is willing to grant greater access to U.S. dry fruits and apples, it is holding back on allowing imports of corn, soybeans, wheat, and dairy products. India does not allow genetically modified (GM) food crops, while most U.S. corn and soybean production is GM-based. Dairy remains a sensitive issue in India, where cultural and dietary preferences strongly influence food choices. Indian consumers are particularly concerned that cattle in the U.S. are often fed with animal by-products, a practice that conflicts with Indian food habits. A key aim of India's Ethanol Blended Petrol (EBP) program is to cut dependence on energy imports by blending domestically-produced ethanol with gasoline. Significant investments by domestic companies mean that India is now close to achieving its ambitious target of blending 20% ethanol. Importing ethanol would undermine those companies. The EBP also helps manage surpluses of rice, sugarcane, and corn by diverting them to ethanol production. Allowing imports of U.S. ethanol would be a serious setback for India's emerging distillery sector.
BBC News
19 hours ago
- BBC News
Wetin hapun as India Prime Minister Narendra Modi make historic visit to Ghana
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi say im kontri dey try to deepen ties wit Africa and ensure shared growth and prosperity, as im start a tour of five kontris. Di PM wen im visit Ghana, sign plenty agreements wit di kontri President John Dramani Mahama wia dey aim to make trade and business better. Im describe India-Ghana relationship say "e don sweet pass sugarloaf pineapple." President Mahama bin announce during one press conference say dem bin sign healthcare agreement to "promote traditional medicinal education, training and research." Im also tok say dem sign oda agreement to promote cultural exchange wit anoda one to "enhance quality of di trade between di two kontris." Di one wey pipo sabi say na ogbonge agreement na di one wey India go support Ghana to build vaccine manufacturing and production hub. President Mahama tok say "dis agreement wey we don sign go help our dreams and push our aspirations for cooperation across di economy like agriculture, energy, manufacturing, infrastructure development and security." Ghana and India bin get relationship since Ghana im first President Dr Kwame Nkrumah bin take inspiration from Mahatma Gandhi wen im form non-violent movement wey fight for independence for India from di British for 1947. Ghana also bin gain her independence ten years afta India for 1957. Since den, both countries don dey make dia relationship strong; na so dem get vibrant Indian community of more dan 15,000 pipo for Ghana. Out of dis number, 3,000 dey hold Ghana nationality. Plenty businesses wey India pipo dey run for Ghana dey employ many young pipo, na so goment say make more companies enta di kontri to do business. PM Modi for one address for di Ghana parliament tok say "India go waka shoulder to shoulder wit Ghana as committed partner for dis journey." India bin dey support Ghana since - for 2008, dem bin give Ghana moni through di exim bank to build di presidential candidate palace at di time Ghana bin dey celebrate 50 years of independence. Dis $135m project now be di kontris seat of goment. For 2021, Ghana na one of 150 kontris wey India bin support wit AstraZeneca vaccines during di Covid 19 pandemic. For November last year, Ghana goment bin commission one 97.7km Tema-Mpakadan railway line wia dem construct wit $447m India export-import bank credit facility. Prime Minister Modi explain say dis projects don dey show India im commitment to Africa. "We don dey spread our diplomatic presence to 46 countries across Africa wia we don support ova 200 projects for di continent to boost connectivity and industry." Im add say India go support Africa development framework agenda 2063 to make sure say di continent get bright future. "Di goals of Africa na our priority, we dey hope to grow togeda as equal." Indian dey try to soon become di third largest economy for di world, according to di PM. "India na tech and innovation hub, wia pipo don recognise us as di pharmacy of di world, wia we also bin get women wey dey do ogbonge tins for science, aviation and sports." "Di pipo of India don tok say dem go make di kontri become developed kontri by 2047, di time wia we go celebrate 100 years of independence." PM Modi go continue im 5-nation tour to Namibia, Trinidad & Tobago, Argentina and Brazil wia im go attend di Brics summit between 5-8 July. Ghana President John Mahama carry di country ogbonge award take celebrate di India PM. Dis na 'di officer of di order of di star of Ghana', one award wey dey recognise pesin wey don do many many tins to contribute to di country or di world. During im two-day visit for Ghana, PM Modi bin visit di tomb of Ghana first President Dr Kwame Nkrumah, wia im lay wreath for im graveside.
