Not priority to devolve youth justice in Wales says UK minister
Lord Timpson says the criminal justice system faced "huge pressures" and there needed to be "stability" before "further changes" were considered.
Under the system of devolution established in 1999, the Senedd and Welsh government have never had control over criminal law.Various reports, including one from the former Labour Prime Minister Gordon Brown, have called for more devolution on criminal justice including youth justice and the probation service.Last summer's Welsh Labour manifesto said the party would "explore" the devolution of probation "to enable them to be more locally responsive".It was planned as part of a strategic review into probation and added it would "consider" the devolution of youth justice.Speaking to the Senedd's equality and social justice committee, the Prisons' Minister Lord Timpson told MSs that "we need to be in a much more stable position before we can think about further changes".Mick Antoniw, the former chief legal adviser to the Welsh Government, says there are "volumes of evidence" that devolution of probation "needs to happen and quickly".The Labour former counsel general told the committee that there was "no logical response to that other than we've had a decade of delay on actually looking at the enormous accumulation of evidence".Questioning Lord Timpson, he said: "What you seem to be suggesting is that we are going to go through that process of just continually looking at the evidence without ever really coming to a proper conclusion."Former Plaid Cymru leader Adam Price added: "Are you ruling out for the foreseeable future the full devolution of executive and legislative powers?".Lord Timpson said he wanted to "stabilise" a "bruised" service but added: "I'm not ruling anything out, I'm not ruling anything in. "What I'm focused on is trying to sort out the crisis in our justice system."
After the meeting committee chair, Labour MS for Cardiff Central, Jenny Rathbone said the committee was "very disappointed"."The Welsh government has already started the groundwork to prepare because it believed there was a realistic prospect that these aspects could be devolved soon," she said."This is in stark contrast to Lord Timpson's evidence before the Committee today which seemed to pour cold water on the prospect."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
23 minutes ago
- BBC News
Derby city centre safe despite shop attack, say police
A senior police officer has insisted Derby city centre is safe despite an attack on a shop in broad people in masks and black clothing targeted Ramsdens Pawnbrokers in St Peter's Street at about 13:45 BST on Monday.A large window was damaged as a number of shoppers looked on and while no-one was injured, staff were left shaken, police to BBC Radio Derby, Supt Rebecca Webster, who oversees city centre policing, said: "I do believe the city is safe. There is a lot of good work going on." Adam Marsh, who works at Quad in the city centre, said: "We've seen an increase in rough sleepers, particularly violent rough sleepers who we have had an issue with."We have certainly seen more anti-social behaviour in the city centre but that has gone hand-in-hand with the Market Hall opening and bringing in lots of new people."Perhaps consideration needs to be made into bringing some sort of reassuring presence into the city."Responding to criticism of policing in the city, Supt Webster, said: "I do believe it is safe. "There is a lot of good work going on and a lot of good work that takes place that doesn't get publicised as much unfortunately."We carry out numerous stop searches, there are significant arrests for highlighted crimes, I believe it is getting better." 'Unprecedented demand' However she admitted the brazenness of the attack was unusual."Yes I am surprised by it but throughout all my years in policing I am glad I am surprised because I wouldn't want it normalised," she said."My family live and work in Derby so I want it to be a safe place for them as well."She said there were "approximately 15" police officers and PCSOs assigned to patrol the city centre but shifts meant there would be about five at any one time, depending on other pressures. But she pointed to "unprecedented demand" with nearly 1,500 emergency calls last weekend - more than on New Year's said: "In relation to visible patrols, I absolutely accept and understand why the community and public feel that is what is needed."We are working hard to achieve that but we cannot be everywhere 24 hours a day."We have finite resource but we are working hard to achieve the best results we can with the resources available."Police have renewed their appeals for information on the attack and said they were working with the city council to review CCTV.
The Independent
23 minutes ago
- The Independent
Rachel Reeves inadvertently breached rules on declaring freebies, watchdog finds
Rachel Reeves inadvertently breached parliament's rules by failing to declare gifts on time, the standards watchdog has found. The chancellor was probed by the standards commissioner over free theatre tickets, which she failed to add to her register of interests within 28 days. She blamed 'an oversight' for her initial failure to declare the gifts, which included tickets to an adaptation of the classic children's novel Ballet Shoes at the National Theatre over Christmas. Ms Reeves had only listed the donation in the register for ministers, not MPs. In an email to standards commissioner Daniel Greenberg, Ms Reeves suggested the tickets were received in her capacity as chancellor, but that 'there is often ambiguity as to whether hospitality I receive is purely as a result of my role as a minister, or whether it is additionally received in my capacity as an MP'. 'Therefore, to be as transparent as possible, it is my ongoing intention to declare hospitality of this nature on both registers,' Ms Reeves added. After investigating the entry, Mr Greenberg accepted there had been an inadvertent breach, but told the chancellor she could have avoided the mistake by paying 'greater attention to the rules'. Ms Reeves apologised and promised future gifts would be registered in line with Commons rules. The investigation centred on two donations of tickets by the National Theatre. One was a show and dinner last March, valued at £265, and the other was for the December show, valued at £276. The inquiry came at a damaging time for Ms Reeves and Sir Keir Starmer, as it was announced on the eve of the local elections, in which the party suffered heavy losses. She previously faced criticism from MPs for accepting free tickets to a Sabrina Carpenter performance while outlining plans to cut benefits by £5bn. Last year, she also pledged she would not accept any more free clothes from donors after Labour's first months in power were overshadowed by a row over freebies. It came after the chancellor used her Mansion House speech to vow to 'take the boot of regulation off the throat of businesses', unveiling a bonfire of red tape to boost the economy. She said: 'In too many areas, regulation still acts as a boot on the neck of businesses, choking off the enterprise and innovation that is the lifeblood of growth. 'Regulators in other sectors must take up the call I make this evening not to bend to the temptation of excessive caution but to boldly regulate for growth in the service of prosperity across our country.' She told her audience of bankers and investors: 'We have been bold in regulating for growth in financial services and I have been clear on the benefits that will drive with a ripple effect across all sectors of our economy, putting pounds in the pockets of working people.'
Daily Mail
23 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE Constance Marten's 'life was ruined' by joining a Nigerian religious cult that beat women with horsewhips and whose leader required followers to call him daddy
Following Constance Marten and Mark Gordon's convictions for the gross negligence manslaughter of their baby daughter Victoria, the Mail has released exclusive podcasts revealing never-before-heard details about the couple. This second episode follows Constance's life story, from her multimillionaire father leaving the family to live in a truck in Australia to her induction into a religious cult based in Lagos, Nigeria. The cult was called SCOAN (The Synagogue Church of All Nations) and its leader, TB Joshua, targeted the UK for new, wealthy recruits by infiltrating Evangelical churches in the south of England. Through her connections to one of these churches, Constance's mother, Virginia, was persuaded to travel to Nigeria with her daughter to the sect's compound in 2006. Virginia believed TB Joshua, who styled himself in internet videos as a miracle healer, could rid her daughter of her 'rebellious spirits'. Speaking to Trial Plus hosts Caroline Cheetham and Jack Hardy, author Matthew McNaught, who wrote a book about the cult and its abuse of British recruits, described how SCOAN operated and how Marten became affiliated with it. 'I became interested in SCOAN because I grew up in an Evangelical Church in Winchester called Emmanuel', McNaught told the podcast. 'Some church members came across this ministry in Nigeria – there were videos being sent around for publicity. They were incredibly graphic, very dramatic videos showing seemingly incredible things. 'I was very sceptical of TB Joshua from the start – the videos were so extreme and gross. You would see sores and bare breasts, gore and nudity that was incredibly hard to watch. 'As soon as people started becoming disciples – their personalities began to change. They withdrew from old friendships and people within my church started to become suspicious. 'Constance was in Lagos for six months. She got in contact with me in 2013 after I wrote a blog detailing TB Joshua's abuse. Her experience was the same as many others I had spoken too. 'She had gone out there a passionate, young Christian and had been pulled into this horrible community and dynamic. 'I believe she left because she had offended TB Joshua in some way, she was essentially kicked out. 'She told me she struggled for a long time afterwards and that she was keen to reconnect with those who had a similar experience. 'In my conversations with her, she came across really well… she wanted to help people to break through the isolation people suffered after being SCOAN. It feels sad to see that her life has taken this turn.' On Monday, Marten and her lover Mark Gordon were convicted of killing their daughter, Victoria, after going on the run to stop her being taken into care. They will be sentenced for gross negligence manslaughter on September 15. Bisola Johnson, who was close to the cult's leader and interacted with Constance Marten during the socialite's time in Nigeria, described some of the worst abuses of the organisation. Bisola described herself as TB Joshua's 'right-hand woman' who feels deep regret for her role in his regime of terror. She said: 'I worked as a video editor for SCOAN for many years. I was only there for about a week before TB Joshua invited me to his room and introduced sex to me. 'Most young girls there would visit his bedroom. People were called out of the dormitory at midnight to sleep with him or massage him as he lay there naked. 'There was verbal and emotional abuse. We would be beaten with horse whips if we didn't do something right. It was like a concentration camp. 'If you argued, you'd be ostracised – you'd not be given food, no one wanted to talk to you. It was mental torture. 'Constance got in contact with me in 2013, she said something had happened to her in SCOAN. Everybody had depression after leaving the group. You couldn't believe you'd accepted such mental torture. 'I wanted to help her, but I couldn't because she threatened to return with a body camera. I was afraid for her… she said she'd contact Al Jazeera. Before she even called them, I knew her body would disappear, and I didn't want to be involved in that.' From his investigation into Marten's time in SCOAN, co-host Jack Hardy provided insight into the psychological damage the experience had on her. 'It's clear it completely shattered her', Hardy said. 'One friend who spoke to us told us she always used to be wild, but also happy, kind and buoyant. 'When she came back, she was darker – she found things more difficult. Another friend we spoke to put things more bluntly, TB Joshua ruined her life.' To listen to the bombshell episode in full, subscribe to The Crime Desk, the home of arresting podcasts from The Daily Mail.
