
The troubled welfare bill has passed – but at what cost?
'So I ask the question, what are we supposed to be voting on tonight', he asked incredulously. 'Is it the Bill as drawn, or another Bill, because I'm confused. I think people in this chamber will need that clarification.' Another MP joked that she went out for a banana and by the time she came back, the bill had completely changed.
It was a moment of chaos that could have come at any time during the Theresa May premiership – except Keir Starmer's government has a working majority of 165.
The past six days have been torturous for the government. Last week, more than a third of Labour MPs backed a reasoned amendment which aimed to scrap the bill. Ministers were pushed out onto the defensive. Angela Rayner, Rachel Reeves and Wes Streeting were locked in negotiations with rebels, trying to bring them round to supporting the bill. The Deputy Prime Minister, who is cementing her position as one of the government's most influential cabinet ministers, still couldn't do enough to prevent the big concession we saw this evening.
In the run up to today's vote, the government offered the rebels two concessions: pushing back the implementation of the cuts to Personal Independence Payments to November 2026 and announcing a review of the assessment process to be conducted by Steven Timms. The Work and Pensions secretary, Liz Kendall, originally told MPs the review would report in Autumn 2026, but this was met with consternation that if the changes to Pip were set to come in at the same time – what would be the point of the Timms review? Those changes to Pip are gone now. They may never come back before the Commons, leaving the Treasury with a £2.5bn hole in its spreadsheets. Liverpool Wavertree MP Paula Barker spoke for many on the backbenches when she described the way this bill played out as 'incoherent and shambolic'.
This vote followed hours of impassioned debate from both sides of the Commons. Marie Tidball, the only visibly physically disabled MP was openly emotional in her contribution, 'I cannot support the proposed changes to Pip,' she said, 'and since April I have been engaging with government at the very highest level'. Tidball said she would vote against the bill.
One thing was clear, even in the contribution of some of those who said they would be voting for Kendall's reforms: most MPs are cognisant that this was intended to be a cost-saving measure. Jeremy Corbyn, the former Labour leader, argued 'the whole origin of this bill was a demand to save £5bn'. He added: 'I simply say this is a ridiculous situation that the secretary of state has put us in. Withdraw the bill now.'
Subscribe to The New Statesman today from only £8.99 per month Subscribe
This was a hollow victory for the government. Even though the bill passed, and these reforms will eventually be implemented, the management of its passage has been damaging. Many rebels are furious over how they were treated by senior members of the government (whether those who voted against will face any consequences remains to be seen). Starmer will need to do a lot of crisis management over the coming weeks to repair Number 10's relationship with the PLP. If not, who's to say any future disagreements between this Labour government and its backbenches won't be one hundred times worse.
But in some ways, it is also a serious failure for Starmer and his project. While some rebels are furious with how they have been treated, they also likely feel galvanised after winning this war of contrition with the government. In sustaining pressure on the government, they have succeeded in moulding these reforms to their own agenda. Following the concession that no changes would be made until the Timms review had reported, one MP told me simply, 'amazing'. The government have been backed into a corner. With the money saved by these reforms slashed in half, Labour will likely have no choice but to raise taxes in the Autumn, something they have repeatedly failed to commit to. The money will need to come from somewhere. Over to you, Rachel Reeves.
Related
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Telegraph
28 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Labour urged to make it harder to sack sick staff
Labour has been urged to make it harder to sack sick workers in a bid to stop disabled staff from leaving the workforce. The Resolution Foundation - which was until last year headed by pensions minister Torsten Bell - has called on the Government to implement a raft of new rules including a 'right to reintegration' for staff on sick leave. Louise Murphy, economist at the think tank, said extra rights for disabled workers similar to those given to new mothers could transform employment prospects. 'The Government should do more to incentivise firms to employ disabled people, especially those who have been out of work for long periods. But employers need to do more in return,' she said. 'A new right to reintegration could help disabled workers back into work in the same way that maternity rights transformed women's employment prospects a generation ago.' The report said that rising levels of poor health means the Government has little chance of boosting employment to its 80pc target unless it takes steps to boost hiring of disabled workers.


The Herald Scotland
41 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
Labour Government ‘deeply committed' to recognising Palestine, Reynolds says
The Prime Minister is under increasing pressure to fulfil Labour's promise to recognise Palestine. Smoke billows from an explosion in the northern Gaza Strip on Wednesday (Ohad Zwigenberg/AP) Mr Reynolds told LBC Radio: 'We are deeply committed to the recognition of Palestine as a state, which was part of our manifesto, but obviously we want that to be meaningful. 'Now, at the minute, there is not a Palestinian state there. There is no political agreement between the two principal Palestinian territories in the West Bank and Gaza. 'We have taken other steps in relation to the intolerable situation in Gaza. We've obviously sanctioned two Israeli cabinet ministers. I myself have ended arms exports to Israel that could be used in the conflict in Gaza. 'We've ended our talks with Israel on a more enhanced trade agreement and trade relationship. So we have taken those immediate steps. 'And we do want to see Palestine recognised. I want that to be meaningful. I want that to be working with partners, other countries around the world.' The UK must immediately recognise Palestinian statehood. There can be no two state solution if there is no viable state left to call Palestine. — Sadiq Khan (@SadiqKhan) July 23, 2025 Labour's London Mayor Sir Sadiq Khan has piled pressure on Sir Keir to 'immediately recognise Palestinian statehood'. He said that the UK 'must do far more to pressure the Israeli government to stop this horrific senseless killing', as aid groups have warned of starvation in the Gaza Strip. More than 100 organisations, including Doctors Without Borders and Save the Children, have put their names to an open letter in which they said they were watching their own colleagues, as well as the Palestinians they serve, 'waste away'. It comes as the Archbishop of York, Stephen Cottrell, labelled the situation in Gaza 'a stain on the conscience of the international community'. He said: 'With each passing day in Gaza, the violence, starvation and dehumanisation being inflicted on the civilian population by the government of Israel becomes more depraved and unconscionable.' Hamas-led militants based in Gaza abducted 251 people in the October 7 attack in 2023 that triggered the war and killed around 1,200 people. Fewer than half of the 50 hostages still in Gaza are believed to be alive.

Western Telegraph
44 minutes ago
- Western Telegraph
Labour Government ‘deeply committed' to recognising Palestine, Reynolds says
Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds stressed that such a move would have to be meaningful and come as part of a 'genuine move towards a two-state solution and a long-term peace settlement' with Israel. The Prime Minister is under increasing pressure to fulfil Labour's promise to recognise Palestine. Smoke billows from an explosion in the northern Gaza Strip on Wednesday (Ohad Zwigenberg/AP) Mr Reynolds told LBC Radio: 'We are deeply committed to the recognition of Palestine as a state, which was part of our manifesto, but obviously we want that to be meaningful. 'Now, at the minute, there is not a Palestinian state there. There is no political agreement between the two principal Palestinian territories in the West Bank and Gaza. 'We have taken other steps in relation to the intolerable situation in Gaza. We've obviously sanctioned two Israeli cabinet ministers. I myself have ended arms exports to Israel that could be used in the conflict in Gaza. 'We've ended our talks with Israel on a more enhanced trade agreement and trade relationship. So we have taken those immediate steps. 'And we do want to see Palestine recognised. I want that to be meaningful. I want that to be working with partners, other countries around the world.' The UK must immediately recognise Palestinian statehood. There can be no two state solution if there is no viable state left to call Palestine. — Sadiq Khan (@SadiqKhan) July 23, 2025 Labour's London Mayor Sir Sadiq Khan has piled pressure on Sir Keir to 'immediately recognise Palestinian statehood'. He said that the UK 'must do far more to pressure the Israeli government to stop this horrific senseless killing', as aid groups have warned of starvation in the Gaza Strip. More than 100 organisations, including Doctors Without Borders and Save the Children, have put their names to an open letter in which they said they were watching their own colleagues, as well as the Palestinians they serve, 'waste away'. It comes as the Archbishop of York, Stephen Cottrell, labelled the situation in Gaza 'a stain on the conscience of the international community'. He said: 'With each passing day in Gaza, the violence, starvation and dehumanisation being inflicted on the civilian population by the government of Israel becomes more depraved and unconscionable.' Hamas-led militants based in Gaza abducted 251 people in the October 7 attack in 2023 that triggered the war and killed around 1,200 people. Fewer than half of the 50 hostages still in Gaza are believed to be alive.