MEP Regina Doherty not sure if 2022 evidence on gender would 'stand up today'
Dublin MEP Regina Doherty has said she is not sure if evidence she gave in the Seanad in 2022 that there are nine genders would stand up to scrutiny today, after being criticised by Senator Michael McDowell.
On RTÉ's The Week in Politics, Ms Doherty was asked about Independent Senator McDowell's article in the Irish Times earlier this week.
In the article, Senator McDowell said: "To the best of my knowledge, neither she nor any of her colleagues in government ever attempted to enumerate these other genders, despite many requests that they should do so."
Ms Doherty said she normally would not respond when someone tries to make a political weapon of an issue, but added:
"For all my political life what I've tried to do is to support transgender people, to support people who have a medical condition, that are undergoing a transition, that are exceptionally vulnerable, and all they're trying to do is to live a normal life, the same way as you and I would.
"That's something that we probably take for granted, when I see politicians trying to polarise and politicise this issue ... it makes me really sad."
Ms Doherty was Minister for Employment Affairs and Social Protection when a review of the Gender Recognition Act was carried out in 2017.
Speaking on the programme in Brussels, Ms Doherty said: "These are vulnerable people, there's a tiny percentage of the population, but unfortunately it's growing that have been treated by our gender services, and we need to treat them with respect, notwithstanding the issues that women have raised.
"You don't need to address women's issues by politicising people who have a medical condition who are exceptionally vulnerable, as Michael McDowell has sought to do, and I think that's a real pity, and it's not something that I've ever done, and I mightn't have got everything right, and I really don't know, you know, whether the evidence that I gave based on the interactions that I had with TENI at the time would stand up today."
Transgender Equality Network Ireland (TENI) represents transgender people and their families and advocated for Minister Doherty (as she was at the time) to lower the age of gender self-identification.
The article by Senator McDowell followed a decision by the UK Supreme Court that ruled that sex is binary, and that the legal definition of a woman and a man are based on biological sex at birth.
Following that decision, Sinn Féin TD David Cullinane said on social media that the ruling was "common sense", an opinion he later withdrew.
Sinn Féin MEP Lynn Boylan was asked about her party colleague on The Week in Politics.
She said that Deputy Cullinane was right to withdraw the remarks.
"I have trans people in my circle of friends and have known trans people for years. Trans people exist, and that's what they want, is the right to exist. And I feel that they're now being, it's been completely weaponised.
"They're under attack on all fronts. And we need to show compassion and empathy for the trans community, who are getting dragged into fights and political rows that they don't even want to be involved in, and I will always stand by the trans community."
Pressed on whether she represented the Sinn Féin position, Ms Boylan said: "We have had our Ard Fheis motions in terms of gender recognition and the right of people to express their gender, and that is party policy."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
11 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Fiosrú taking no further action in Carlow gunman case
The Police Ombudsman, Fiosrú, has said it has decided to take no further action in relation to the case of Evan Fitzgerald, who fired shots in the air in a Co Carlow shopping centre before taking his own life. Garda Commissioner Drew Harris said this week that he had referred "serious allegations" made about the garda handling of the case to the ombudsman. Questions were raised in the Oireachtas about the way in which gardaí conducted their investigation into Mr Fitzgerald, who, prior to his death, was awaiting trial for possession of illegal weapons. The weapons had been supplied to him by gardaí as part of an undercover operation after they became aware that the 22-year-old tried to buy guns on the dark web. The weapon he used at the Carlow shopping centre was not one supplied to him by gardaí. Independent Senator Michael McDowell and Labour TD Alan Kelly raised concerns about the techniques deployed by gardaí in the case. In the Seanad, Senator McDowell said the case was one of "entrapment" and also claimed that "untruths" were told to a District Court judge when he was deciding whether to grant Mr Fitzgerald bail. On RTÉ's This Week programme, Senator McDowell suggested it may have been "premature" of Fiosrú not to take any further action. He said he did not know if the police ombudsman's office listened to the digital audio recording from the District Court. He said if they have not, it was premature of them not to take further action in relation to what he described as "a serious issue". Mr McDowell said he asked the Department of Justice to arrange for the matter to be fully investigated. The senator said there were other options available to the gardaí, including confronting Mr Fitzgerald and his family about what he had done. Commissioner Harris told the Oireachtas Public Accounts Committee this week that he took note of the comments made in the Seanad by Mr McDowell and referred them to Fiosrú for consideration. Fiosrú told RTÉ's This Week programme that Mr Harris has no authority to ask the ombudsman to investigate any matter. It added that after considering the two notifications of concern from An Garda Síochána in relation to this case, it decided that no further action was required by the police ombudsman. At the Oireachtas Public Accounts Committee, Commissioner Harris described the garda investigation as "a very successful operation in which we made sure that a threat to the public did not arise from the circumstances we were dealing with". "Subsequent events, tragic as they were on 1 June, were obviously very tragic, but they did not arise from our operation that we conducted," he said.
The Journal
11 hours ago
- The Journal
Junior housing minister says homelessness crisis 'a really difficult challenge to tackle'
IRELAND'S HOMELESSNESS CRISIS is a 'really difficult challenge to tackle', junior housing minister Christopher O'Sullivan has said. A total of 15,747 people were living in emergency accommodation in May, according to figures published on Friday . It is the highest-ever figure recorded in Ireland, a continuing trend over the last number of months. It also includes 4,844 children – 69 more than April. Speaking on the issue today during RTÉ television's The Week In Politics, O'Sullivan conceded that the figures are currently unacceptable. He said the government is 'acutely aware' of the housing crisis and the impact it is having on homelessness. The Fianna Fáil TD said: 'Obviously, we're particularly struck by the words of the Children's ombudsman, essentially highlighting the devastating impact that emergency accommodation and homelessness in general is having on children and the long term impacts. Advertisement 'This is a really, really difficult challenge to tackle. That's been proven over the last number of years, and we have thrown the kitchen sink (at) it, but I will say this, there's no doubt that it's a priority for Taoiseach, it's a priority for this government.' Social Democrats TD Gary Gannon told the same programme that there is too much reliance on private accommodation and the use of hotels to house those who are living in emergency housing. Gannon said that environment has long-term impacts on children, citing issues with speech and language, an inability to play with other children and mobility issues. He added that the state needs to zone land as affordable. He said: 'We need to have the state getting back and building in a massive, significant way. We also need to take a step back and understand the impact that these living provisions are having to children in this state.' Children's ombudsman Dr Niall Muldoon said that Government's housing initiatives continuously fail children. The comments were echoed by homelessness charity leaders on Friday, following the publication of the latest emergency accommodation figures. Sinn Féin TD Claire Kerrane pointed to the thousands of empty council homes in need of renovation. She said there needs to be a renewed effort to improve the properties to house families. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
RTÉ News
12 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Plans to redevelop GPO a betrayal of history, says Sinn Féin
Plans approved by the Government to redevelop the GPO in Dublin city have been branded a shameful betrayal of Ireland's proud revolutionary history by Sinn Féin. Earlier this week the Government backed plans to redevelop the GPO into a mixed-use precinct, to include possible retail components, offices, the retention of a post office and significant cultural use. Sinn Féin said the Government wants to turn the GPO into a shopping mall and is turning its back on the rich revolutionary history associated with the building. On RTÉ's This Week, Louise O'Reilly said Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael cannot be trusted on this. "To take the Louvre in Paris for example, they protect and preserve their heritage," she said. "How we treat the GPO is a measure to how we respect and treat the history and culture of our capital city." "This is an issue that is very, very dear to Dubliners and to every person that lives on this island." "This will be resisted," added Deputy O'Reilly. "We're bringing a motion to the Dáil on Tuesday and I would encourage all people to engage with it. We need to preserve the GPO. It is a site of incredible historical importance." In response, Fine Gael's James Geoghegan said that it is the Government's intention that it "would be put into museum, cultural use" . "Of all manufactured rows Sinn Féin has been involved in, this one really takes the biscuit" he said. "The GPO is not the building of any political party," said Deputy Geoghegan. "The GPO is the most important building in the foundation of our state. It's a monument to the heroism of the most ordinary people in this country." "In the GPO, right now, there are 25 retail units along the Henry Street end of the building," he added. "The GPO building is an enormous building. In truth what the building has been, until relatively recent time, has been our general post office. "What we're talking about it how do we make the GPO a place that is filled with people again... and reflects the importance of that building to the foundation of the state."
