Driver appeals sentence over deadly wedding bus crash
Brett Andrew Button, 60, had been driving too fast and engaged in risk-taking behaviour before the deadly crash, which also injured 25 people, in the NSW Hunter Valley region in June 2023.
He was sentenced in September to a maximum jail term of 32 years with a non-parole period of 24 years.
At the time, NSW District Court Judge Roy Ellis said he was unaware of any other case that had such a devastating impact on so many people.
Button has filed a challenge to his sentence which was briefly heard in the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal on Thursday.
A hearing has been scheduled for October 3.
Prosecutors expect voluminous evidence to be tendered, including victim impact statements from the families of those who died or were injured in the crash.
The court will consider a psychological report for Button and several references attesting to his good character.
The bus driver will not be appealing against his conviction.
He pleaded guilty in the District Court to 10 charges of dangerous driving causing death, nine counts of driving causing grievous bodily harm and 16 counts of causing bodily harm by wanton driving.
Button was told in 2022 that he was dependent on the opioid Tramadol.
He admitted taking more than the prescribed amount prior to the crash.
The vehicle entered a roundabout on Wine Country Drive on the way to Singleton after a wine estate wedding at an estimated 52km/h.
It then accelerated to about 56km/h when on the roundabout, the District Court was earlier told.
The speed required to tip the bus over was only 31km/h.
A class action has been filed by those injured and family members of the deceased against the NSW government alleging failings in the design of the roundabout.
The speed limit through the interchange was also allegedly too high.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
9 hours ago
- ABC News
A look inside the courtroom of Erin Patterson's triple-murder trial
It was a Sunday afternoon early in the trial and I was grabbing fruit at a local supermarket when someone I know stopped me. It took about a minute for the conversation to shift unprompted from pleasantries to one of the most extraordinary cases that hasn't just captured Australia's attention, but the world's. Conversations with friends, family, and even friends of friends over the 10 weeks of the Erin Patterson trial invariably went the same way. "What's it like covering the trial?" And the question that usually followed, always asked in hushed tones, was: "She did it, didn't she?" I'd answer the first question generally before giving a non-answer to the second, saying there was a lot of evidence to come and pointing out questions of guilt or innocence were a matter for the jury. As the heart of Victoria's power industry, reporters tended to only make the trip down the highway to Morwell, a town in the Latrobe Valley east of Melbourne, every couple of years when developments about coal and electricity made headlines. But for the first time in living memory, the town was the centre of sustained global attention, with the 10-week trial attracting reporters from as far as London. The Latrobe Valley Law Courts sit on the main street of Morwell. It's a two-storey concrete building with large glass windows that offer a panoramic view of the courtyard and the police station below. Every day it hears Victorian Magistrates' Court matters — assaults, traffic and drink driving offences, and the occasional County Court trial. But not murder. On day one of the trial, photographers and camera crews lined the street outside the court, poised to get fresh pictures of the family members and legal teams. They'd remain there for the duration, their numbers swelling throughout the trial. Inside the courtroom, space was limited. There were 23 seats available to members of the public, a number of seats reserved for members of the Patterson and Wilkinson families. Six seats for media were allocated by ballot throughout the trial. The remaining media watched a live stream of the hearing from what was dubbed the media "overflow room", usually the jury pool room, down the hall from the courtroom itself. Recording hourly reports for radio, logistically it made sense to operate from the overflow room where entering and exiting was easier. Numbers in the overflow room ebbed and flowed throughout the case. On key days, such as during Erin Patterson's cross examination, the room would fill up with international correspondents returning to hear the evidence. As Morwell swelled with journalists, lawyers, and curious onlookers, the local community reaped unexpected rewards. When the reporters and legal teams weren't in court, they could usually be found at one of the nearby cafes. According to recently released figures from Morwell's local council, spending in the town was up by $2.5 million compared with last year, while businesses raked in more than $300,000 extra. The trial was expected to last six weeks and at one point the legal teams discussed the possibility of it ending after a month. But the jury wouldn't retire to consider its verdict until the beginning of the trial's 10th week. And by that time, those who had travelled to Morwell for the trial had a knowledge of the local restaurant scene that would rival that of most locals. While the jury was deliberating on Saturday, I was outside the court when an older local woman approached me and asked if there was a verdict. When I told her there wasn't, she said she hoped it would end soon. Two days later, news of a verdict came through during the lunch break prompting a mad dash to join the queue to get into the courtroom — the first time I had been inside since the beginning of the trial. I took a seat on a wooden bench just inside the door. I couldn't see Justice Christopher Beale, the prosecutors or the jury. But I was facing the dock with a clear view of Erin Patterson. She remained emotionless as the jury foreperson announced that she was guilty of all charges. Waiting outside was a wall of cameras, eager for the first pictures of any participants in the trial leaving the court. The courtyard was full of reporters broadcasting the verdict live and with locals who had raced to the court to find out the details. Within minutes of walking outside, a radio station was already calling, eager for a firsthand account of the courtroom as the jury delivered its verdict. I had a further 15 interviews, or crosses, with radio programs across the country outlining the day in court, the reaction and what was likely to happen next. When I left the courthouse at 6pm, the locals and most of the media had left, leaving just the television reporters who were gearing up for their broadcasts into the evening news. After a week of waiting to find out whether Erin Patterson was guilty, the verdict was delivered in minutes and the following hours passed in a blur.
ABC News
20 hours ago
- ABC News
The evidence that convicted Erin Patterson
The jury in Erin Patterson's trial sat through weeks of evidence before convicting her of murder.
The Advertiser
2 days ago
- The Advertiser
Duo jailed after brewing up coffee grinder meth plot
A young man lured with $50,000 to pay off gambling debts will spend years in jail after taking part in a major methamphetamine import. Two coffee grinders that arrived at Brisbane Airport from Guatemala in Central America on January 6, 2024, were found to contain 286 blocks of the drug. The shipment - arranged using stolen identification - contained 53.4 kilograms of pure methamphetamine estimated to have a street value of $80 million. The drugs were replaced by Australian Federal Police and returned to the courier facility. The grinders were then put on a truck to Sydney on January 29 and into the hands of Jimmy Ong, 25, and Nguyen "Daniel" Thanh Huy La, 27. Ong and La were sentenced in the NSW District Court on Monday after pleading guilty to attempting to possess a commercial quantity of a border-controlled drug. Sobs and wails were heard from family members and supporters in the court's public gallery as the pair were jailed. The plot was organised using encrypted messaging application Threema, Judge Sharon Harris said. The shipment was delivered to Ong's grandparents' address in Cabramatta in Sydney's southwest, where he attempted to unpack the drugs with another man, 22-year-old Steven Chan Bao Le. Ong used his driver's licence and mobile phone to rent a forklift to remove the grinders from the truck, while La was enlisted to drive the forklift itself. Ong owed up to $30,000 in gambling debts to family and friends and was enticed to participate in the importation after being offered $50,000, Judge Harris said. He knew the grinders contained illegal drugs, but only learned at a late stage how much was contained within. The amount of cash offered to La was not known and he was unaware of the amount of drugs, she said. NSW Police pounced on the Cabramatta premises on January 31, 2024, as Ong and Le were trying to deconstruct one of the coffee grinders. Ong was arrested immediately, while Le was seized by officers in a nearby street after trying to flee. La was arrested in August. In sentencing Ong and La, Judge Harris noted both had apologised for their actions and taken steps towards rehabilitation, including getting psychiatric help. She said Ong displayed a "notable level of naivety" in the unsophisticated scheme. Both men had identified themselves by name organising the forklift and had used traceable phone numbers. The pair were exposed to domestic violence, and the impacts of others addicted to gambling and alcohol during their troubled childhoods, the judge said. Both received a 25 per cent discount for their guilty pleas. Ong was jailed for up to six years with a non-parole period of three years, expiring on May 25, 2028. La was jailed for a maximum of five years for his lesser role, with a non-parole period of two-and-a-half years, expiring on July 19, 2027. Le pleaded guilty in May to one count of attempting to possess an unlawfully imported, commercial quantity of a border-controlled drug. He will be sentenced on July 28. A young man lured with $50,000 to pay off gambling debts will spend years in jail after taking part in a major methamphetamine import. Two coffee grinders that arrived at Brisbane Airport from Guatemala in Central America on January 6, 2024, were found to contain 286 blocks of the drug. The shipment - arranged using stolen identification - contained 53.4 kilograms of pure methamphetamine estimated to have a street value of $80 million. The drugs were replaced by Australian Federal Police and returned to the courier facility. The grinders were then put on a truck to Sydney on January 29 and into the hands of Jimmy Ong, 25, and Nguyen "Daniel" Thanh Huy La, 27. Ong and La were sentenced in the NSW District Court on Monday after pleading guilty to attempting to possess a commercial quantity of a border-controlled drug. Sobs and wails were heard from family members and supporters in the court's public gallery as the pair were jailed. The plot was organised using encrypted messaging application Threema, Judge Sharon Harris said. The shipment was delivered to Ong's grandparents' address in Cabramatta in Sydney's southwest, where he attempted to unpack the drugs with another man, 22-year-old Steven Chan Bao Le. Ong used his driver's licence and mobile phone to rent a forklift to remove the grinders from the truck, while La was enlisted to drive the forklift itself. Ong owed up to $30,000 in gambling debts to family and friends and was enticed to participate in the importation after being offered $50,000, Judge Harris said. He knew the grinders contained illegal drugs, but only learned at a late stage how much was contained within. The amount of cash offered to La was not known and he was unaware of the amount of drugs, she said. NSW Police pounced on the Cabramatta premises on January 31, 2024, as Ong and Le were trying to deconstruct one of the coffee grinders. Ong was arrested immediately, while Le was seized by officers in a nearby street after trying to flee. La was arrested in August. In sentencing Ong and La, Judge Harris noted both had apologised for their actions and taken steps towards rehabilitation, including getting psychiatric help. She said Ong displayed a "notable level of naivety" in the unsophisticated scheme. Both men had identified themselves by name organising the forklift and had used traceable phone numbers. The pair were exposed to domestic violence, and the impacts of others addicted to gambling and alcohol during their troubled childhoods, the judge said. Both received a 25 per cent discount for their guilty pleas. Ong was jailed for up to six years with a non-parole period of three years, expiring on May 25, 2028. La was jailed for a maximum of five years for his lesser role, with a non-parole period of two-and-a-half years, expiring on July 19, 2027. Le pleaded guilty in May to one count of attempting to possess an unlawfully imported, commercial quantity of a border-controlled drug. He will be sentenced on July 28. A young man lured with $50,000 to pay off gambling debts will spend years in jail after taking part in a major methamphetamine import. Two coffee grinders that arrived at Brisbane Airport from Guatemala in Central America on January 6, 2024, were found to contain 286 blocks of the drug. The shipment - arranged using stolen identification - contained 53.4 kilograms of pure methamphetamine estimated to have a street value of $80 million. The drugs were replaced by Australian Federal Police and returned to the courier facility. The grinders were then put on a truck to Sydney on January 29 and into the hands of Jimmy Ong, 25, and Nguyen "Daniel" Thanh Huy La, 27. Ong and La were sentenced in the NSW District Court on Monday after pleading guilty to attempting to possess a commercial quantity of a border-controlled drug. Sobs and wails were heard from family members and supporters in the court's public gallery as the pair were jailed. The plot was organised using encrypted messaging application Threema, Judge Sharon Harris said. The shipment was delivered to Ong's grandparents' address in Cabramatta in Sydney's southwest, where he attempted to unpack the drugs with another man, 22-year-old Steven Chan Bao Le. Ong used his driver's licence and mobile phone to rent a forklift to remove the grinders from the truck, while La was enlisted to drive the forklift itself. Ong owed up to $30,000 in gambling debts to family and friends and was enticed to participate in the importation after being offered $50,000, Judge Harris said. He knew the grinders contained illegal drugs, but only learned at a late stage how much was contained within. The amount of cash offered to La was not known and he was unaware of the amount of drugs, she said. NSW Police pounced on the Cabramatta premises on January 31, 2024, as Ong and Le were trying to deconstruct one of the coffee grinders. Ong was arrested immediately, while Le was seized by officers in a nearby street after trying to flee. La was arrested in August. In sentencing Ong and La, Judge Harris noted both had apologised for their actions and taken steps towards rehabilitation, including getting psychiatric help. She said Ong displayed a "notable level of naivety" in the unsophisticated scheme. Both men had identified themselves by name organising the forklift and had used traceable phone numbers. The pair were exposed to domestic violence, and the impacts of others addicted to gambling and alcohol during their troubled childhoods, the judge said. Both received a 25 per cent discount for their guilty pleas. Ong was jailed for up to six years with a non-parole period of three years, expiring on May 25, 2028. La was jailed for a maximum of five years for his lesser role, with a non-parole period of two-and-a-half years, expiring on July 19, 2027. Le pleaded guilty in May to one count of attempting to possess an unlawfully imported, commercial quantity of a border-controlled drug. He will be sentenced on July 28. A young man lured with $50,000 to pay off gambling debts will spend years in jail after taking part in a major methamphetamine import. Two coffee grinders that arrived at Brisbane Airport from Guatemala in Central America on January 6, 2024, were found to contain 286 blocks of the drug. The shipment - arranged using stolen identification - contained 53.4 kilograms of pure methamphetamine estimated to have a street value of $80 million. The drugs were replaced by Australian Federal Police and returned to the courier facility. The grinders were then put on a truck to Sydney on January 29 and into the hands of Jimmy Ong, 25, and Nguyen "Daniel" Thanh Huy La, 27. Ong and La were sentenced in the NSW District Court on Monday after pleading guilty to attempting to possess a commercial quantity of a border-controlled drug. Sobs and wails were heard from family members and supporters in the court's public gallery as the pair were jailed. The plot was organised using encrypted messaging application Threema, Judge Sharon Harris said. The shipment was delivered to Ong's grandparents' address in Cabramatta in Sydney's southwest, where he attempted to unpack the drugs with another man, 22-year-old Steven Chan Bao Le. Ong used his driver's licence and mobile phone to rent a forklift to remove the grinders from the truck, while La was enlisted to drive the forklift itself. Ong owed up to $30,000 in gambling debts to family and friends and was enticed to participate in the importation after being offered $50,000, Judge Harris said. He knew the grinders contained illegal drugs, but only learned at a late stage how much was contained within. The amount of cash offered to La was not known and he was unaware of the amount of drugs, she said. NSW Police pounced on the Cabramatta premises on January 31, 2024, as Ong and Le were trying to deconstruct one of the coffee grinders. Ong was arrested immediately, while Le was seized by officers in a nearby street after trying to flee. La was arrested in August. In sentencing Ong and La, Judge Harris noted both had apologised for their actions and taken steps towards rehabilitation, including getting psychiatric help. She said Ong displayed a "notable level of naivety" in the unsophisticated scheme. Both men had identified themselves by name organising the forklift and had used traceable phone numbers. The pair were exposed to domestic violence, and the impacts of others addicted to gambling and alcohol during their troubled childhoods, the judge said. Both received a 25 per cent discount for their guilty pleas. Ong was jailed for up to six years with a non-parole period of three years, expiring on May 25, 2028. La was jailed for a maximum of five years for his lesser role, with a non-parole period of two-and-a-half years, expiring on July 19, 2027. Le pleaded guilty in May to one count of attempting to possess an unlawfully imported, commercial quantity of a border-controlled drug. He will be sentenced on July 28.
