NordVPN vs Surfshark: I put price, features and streaming to the test

Independent

15-05-2025

When choosing the best VPN, two names often rise to the top: NordVPN and Surfshark. Both offer powerful privacy tools, fast speeds and strong security, but which one is actually the best?
At a glance, they seem almost identical. Each comes with thousands of servers, support for WireGuard and OpenVPN protocols, and features like split tunnelling, kill switches and ad blocking. But dig a little deeper, and there are a few key differences, particularly around pricing, device limits and advanced security extras that might make one a better fit for your setup.
It's also worth noting that both VPNs are owned by the same parent company, Nord Security, after merging in 2022. That means they share similar infrastructure and privacy policies, but they're still operated independently. Below, we break down the pros and cons of NordVPN and Surfshark to help you decide which is the best VPN for you.
How we tested
Both of these VPNs were tested on multiple devices. We put them through their paces on an Android Nothing Phone (2a), an iPhone 15 Pro Max, a MacBook Pro laptop and a Windows laptop.
We analysed each VPN's speed, measuring how quickly they connected, buffered and streamed, then compared them to each other. We also assessed security and privacy claims, and tested out bonus features like split tunnelling, kill switches, and double VPNs.
All our recommended VPNs are tested under ideal conditions to keep tests fair, but we also try them in areas with poor wifi to see how they buffer under pressure. We've also tested them in public hotspots like cafes to ensure that they can handle dodgy security setups and heavy traffic. We've even tried them on streaming sticks.
Why trust us
Senior tech critic Alex Lee has reviewed hundreds of different tech products, especially VPNs. Over his career, Alex has tested every major VPN service, assessing their budget and premium offerings to understand every inch of the market.
NordVPN vs Surfshark: Price
If you're looking for a VPN that won't break the bank, both NordVPN and Surfshark are reasonably priced. However, Surfshark is generally cheaper on long-term plans. NordVPN isn't exactly pricey, but it costs about £1 more per month than Surfshark when you commit to a longer subscription. That said, it's still more affordable than ExpressVPN, and for what you get, we'd say it's worth considering.
NordVPN has three tiers – basic, plus and ultimate. The cheapest option is the two-year basic plan, which costs £62.16 up-front (about £2.59 per month). The one-year plan costs £45.48 (£3.79 per month), and if you don't want to be locked into a long contract, the monthly plan costs £10.09.
The plus plan, which adds malware protection and a password manager, costs £81.36 for two years (£3.39 per month), £55.08 for one year (£4.59 per month) or £10.79 per month. The ultimate plan, which includes 1TB of secure cloud storage and cyber insurance covering up to £5,000 if you get scammed online, costs £126.96 over two years (£5.29 per month), £77.87 for one year (£6.49 per month), or £12.79 per month.
All plans come with a 30-day money-back guarantee, so if it's not for you, you can cancel within a month for a full refund.
Surfshark also has three tiers – starter, one and Surfshark one+. Prices fluctuate due to promotions, but generally, a 24-month Starter plan is the cheapest, costing £45.63 upfront (about £1.69 per month). A 12-month plan costs £38.85 (£2.59 per month), while the monthly plan is a steep £12.29 – making it more expensive than NordVPN's equivalent monthly option. Surfshark offers a seven-day free trial on mobile, and like NordVPN, it has a 30-day money-back guarantee if you decide it's not for you.
The biggest perk of Surfshark? Unlimited device connections. You don't need to worry about which devices are logged in – you can connect as many as you like. NordVPN recently upped its limit to 10, which is better than before, but still doesn't match Surfshark's unlimited number of devices.
Also, one word of advice: If you go for a long-term NordVPN or Surfshark plan, set a reminder to cancel before it renews. Once the initial contract is up, the renewal price shoots up significantly, and you might not want to be locked into another two years at a much higher rate.
We've seen customers locked in battles with VPN companies over unexpected auto-renewals, struggling to get refunds or cancel their plans. While both NordVPN and Surfshark allow cancellations, it's always better to be proactive than to deal with a frustrating back-and-forth with customer support. If you think you won't need it for that long, just go for the one-month option; it'll work out cheaper in the long run.
Winner: Surfshark
Surfshark takes this one. It's cheaper on long-term plans, lets you connect unlimited devices and offers the same 30-day money-back guarantee. But if you don't want to commit to a lengthy subscription, NordVPN's one-month plan is actually the better deal.
NordVPN vs Surfshark: Privacy and features
Both NordVPN and Surfshark come with all the security bells and whistles you'd expect from any bog-standard VPN. They both give you AES-256 encryption, support for WireGuard and OpenVPN protocols, a kill switch and split tunnelling support. They also both offer multi-hop connections – NordVPN calls it Double VPN, a feature that routes your traffic through two servers for extra security.
But there are differences in the feature set. NordVPN throws in more security features up front, like Onion over VPN, which lets you route your traffic through the Tor network for extra anonymity. It also has dedicated P2P servers for torrenting, optimised for faster speeds. Another small but handy perk with NordVPN is its pause feature, which lets you temporarily turn off the VPN without fully disconnecting – something Surfshark doesn't offer. NordVPN wins here when it comes to features at the basic tier.
If you upgrade to a higher tier, things start to even out. NordVPN's plus and ultimate plans include NordPass, a password manager, and a dark web monitoring tool, which scans for leaked credentials. Surfshark's one and one plus plans also include a password manager and data breach alerts, so neither has an edge. Both offer ad and malware blockers – NordVPN calls it Threat Protection Pro, while Surfshark calls it CleanWeb – but these are only available on paid plans above the base tier. We also found NordVPN's Threat Protection Pro better at filtering out ads and trackers than Surfshark's CleanWeb.
Higher tiers of Surfshark also come with a handy search engine, a private search engine that delivers organic results without tracking or ads. It's nice and clean, and a nice perk over NordVPN.
Where they really differ is in extra cybersecurity tools. NordVPN's ultimate plan includes 1TB of encrypted cloud storage and cyber insurance that covers up to £5,000 if you get scammed online. Surfshark doesn't offer those, but its top-tier plan includes Alternative ID, which generates a fake email address and phone number for extra privacy.
Winner: NordVPN
NordVPN gives you more security tools in its base plan without making you pay extra, making it better value for anyone serious about privacy. Surfshark is still a great option if you need unlimited devices, a private search tool or Alternative ID, but NordVPN includes more privacy features up-front without forcing an upgrade.
NordVPN vs Surfshark: Logging and transparency
Both NordVPN and Surfshark promise that they don't log user data, and both have been independently audited to prove it. NordVPN has had five separate audits – PWC checked its no-logs policy in 2018 and 2020, while Deloitte ran further audits in 2022, 2023 and the most recent one in late 2024, confirming it doesn't store user data. Surfshark has been audited fewer times, but it still passed its no-log audits. Cure53 assessed its browser extensions in 2018 and its server infrastructure in 2021, finding no major issue, and in late 2022, Deloitte verified Surfshark's no-logs claims, giving it the same kind of stamp of approval as NordVPN.
Both VPNs also run on RAM-based servers, meaning no data is stored long-term, and everything is wiped on reboot. NordVPN operates out of Panama, a country with no mandatory data retention laws, while Surfshark is based in the Netherlands, which is part of the Nine Eyes intelligence-sharing alliance. Some privacy-conscious users might prefer NordVPN's location, but since neither VPN keeps logs, it shouldn't matter in practice.
That said, NordVPN nor Surfshark have been completely free from security concerns. NordVPN suffered a server breach in 2018, where a hacker gained access to a third-party data centre in Finland. No user data was compromised, but NordVPN didn't disclose the breach until a year later, which understandably led to some trust issues. Surfshark hasn't had a breach like that, but in 2021, researchers found that some of its old Indian servers were still online after it claimed they had been shut down, so you might be concerned about how its infrastructure is managed.
Winner: Draw
Neither instance resulted in any leaked user data, and both VPNs have taken steps to improve their security since. Still, NordVPN has been more proactive with its third-party audits, and Surfshark has worked on improving its infrastructure. If complete transparency is a dealbreaker, NordVPN's delayed breach disclosure might give you pause, but if audit frequency matters, it's ahead of Surfshark. They're both trustworthy VPNs, so there's no real winner in terms of logging.
NordVPN vs Surfshark: Performance and speed
The NordVPN desktop app is a little cluttered, with a large interactive map that takes up more space than it probably needs to. Surfshark's simpler layout is easier to navigate, especially for beginners. That said, NordVPN gets a lot of things right. The pause button is easy to access, searching for specific servers is straightforward and useful settings like the kill switch are enabled by default, so you don't have to mess around with them.
NordVPN's sidebar is also pretty handy, giving quick access to threat protection, dark web monitoring and usage stats. Mac users also get handy server presets for speed, downloads and browsing, and we could even create custom presets with our preferred settings. The one downside is that split tunnelling is only available on Windows. This split tuneling is flawed, too – we ran into occasional hiccups with certain streaming services detecting the VPN despite whitelisting them.
Surfshark's interface is much more streamlined. Instead of a large map, it sticks to a simple alphabetical server list on the left, along with quick-connect buttons for static IP addresses and multi-hop servers. It feels more beginner-friendly while still giving advanced users plenty of options. Surfshark's browser extensions for Chrome and Firefox also work well, mirroring the desktop experience, though they lack access to features like the kill switch and Whitelister. If you can, the desktop app is the better option.
In terms of speed, NordVPN remains one of the fastest VPNs we've tested. Using its quick-connect UK server, we saw only a four per cent drop in download speed on a 67 Mbps connection, while connecting to the US only slowed things down by about nine per cent. That's incredibly fast, making it a great option for streaming, gaming and downloading content.
Surfshark has also improved massively in this area and now keeps up with NordVPN. On the WireGuard protocol, Surfshark's UK servers only dropped speeds by around five per cent, while even more distant servers saw just an 11 per cent drop. Streaming on UK services like BBC iPlayer and ITVX was seamless, with no buffering or lag.
Winner: NordVPN
In terms of raw speed, NordVPN takes the edge, but Surfshark has closed the gap and is no longer as sluggish as in previous tests. Surfshark also has a more user-friendly interface, whereas NordVPN offers more customisation and additional features. If speed is your main concern, NordVPN is the faster option, but for ease of use, Surfshark is the simpler choice.
NordVPN vs Surfshark: Streaming
If you're travelling abroad and want to stream your favourite shows or catch up on sports from back home, both NordVPN and Surfshark make that possible. While using a VPN to access geo-restricted content isn't illegal, it does violate most streaming services' terms of service, so there's always a risk of platforms cracking down on VPN usage. That said, both let us stream Netflix, BBC iPlayer, Disney+ and more without running into annoying proxy errors.
NordVPN is particularly good for streaming thanks to its obfuscated servers, which mask VPN usage so platforms couldn't detect we were using one. In our tests, streaming services never flagged the connection, and we were able to watch BBC iPlayer, Sky Go, ITVX, Channel 4 and Prime Video on an iPhone, Mac and Windows laptop without interruption. Speeds were fast enough that we didn't experience buffering, even when streaming live sports. Another big plus is that NordVPN rarely requires switching servers – it just works straight away, without the hassle of finding a working connection.
Winner: Draw
Surfshark performs just as well for Netflix, Disney+ and BBC iPlayer, and in our tests, we could stream on desktop, iOS and Android with no buffering issues. Prime Video worked fine, though it's worth noting that Amazon ties accounts to billing regions, so if you try to access Prime Video from another country, it might still flag you as travelling rather than fully changing your region. Ultimately, both VPNs let us stream BBC iPlayer, ITVX and Channel 4, with very little buffering or proxy errors.