logo
Government accused of ‘running scared' over bid to block sentencing guidelines

Government accused of ‘running scared' over bid to block sentencing guidelines

New guidance from the independent Sentencing Council would have recommended a pre-sentence report (PSR) be sought before sentencing offenders from ethnic, cultural or faith minorities.
Pre-sentence reports provide information about the offender's background, circumstances of their offence, the risk they pose and suitability for certain types of sentence.
The use of these reports has been linked to higher rate of community, rather than prison sentences.
The Government brought forward the Sentencing Guidelines (Pre-sentence Reporters) Bill to block the new guidelines, arguing that it would lead to a differential treatment under the law and a 'two-tier' justice system.
The implementation of the updated rulebook has been put on hold to allow Parliament to consider this legislation.
However, supporters of the guidance argued that the UK already has a 'two-tier' justice system, due to entrenched racial bias.
The Lammy Review, published in 2017, found disparities in outcome across the justice system for those from minority backgrounds compared to their white counterparts, including in sentencing.
As the House of Lords debated the Government's Bill during its second reading, Green Party peer Baroness Jones of Moulsecoomb argued that politicians were trying to 'interfere' with the workings of an independent body.
She said: 'The Sentencing Council is an independent body that saw a problem and tried to do something about it.
'It has done what it was designed to do and now the Labour Government is running scared of these rather nasty right-wingers who are trying to interfere.
'I think it was Elon Musk, perhaps amongst others, who first said that Britain had a two-tier justice system.
'And he was right, that is exactly what we have, because some groups are worse treated than others.
'We do not have equality under the law.
'We've known about women being less fairly treated for decades, with women being imprisoned for things that men would not be.
'The Sentencing Council came up with the mildest of changes to address that issue and has been slammed for it….
'When the Government says it wants equality under the law, everybody wants that.
'But the difference is that I accept the evidence that we currently have a two-tier system of justice where you can end up receiving worse treatment because you're a woman or because of the colour of your skin.'
The Bishop of Gloucester, the Anglican bishop for prisons, branded the Bill 'theatrical' and unnecessary, brought on by 'am-dram politics'.
The Rt Rev Rachel Treweek said: 'In a world of sufficient resources, there would be comprehensive pre-sentencing reports for everyone to which careful attention was paid in court.
'But if we have to prioritise PSRs, then it makes sense to prioritise those that we know are especially vulnerable or where there is evidence of disproportionate outcomes from the justice system.'
Referring to the Lammy Review, she asked: 'Does the Government believe the issues raised in the landmark report by the current Foreign Secretary almost eight years ago are now a thing of the past?
'Is there no role for judges in mitigating the issues raised in that report?
'The use of the Sentencing Council guidelines to apparently feed a culture war is distressing, and the allegation of two-tier sentencing based around race, religion, belief or cultural background is so damaging to public understanding…
'We cannot pretend that circumstances and characteristics do not matter.'
However, unaffiliated peer Baroness Fox of Buckley hit back at the culture war argument, branding it a 'slur'.
She said: 'The popular critique of criminal justice as 'two-tier', that actually really resonated, particularly in relation to the sentencing post-last summer's riots, was sneeringly dismissed as a far-right conspiratorial myth by many ministers and politicians.
'It was written off as some culture wars trope, and we've heard similar slurs here today.'
She criticised the 'tendency to try and use criminal justice to compensate for perceived racial unfairness and alleged social injustices'.
Responding, prisons minister Lord Timpson said: 'Implementing a sentencing guideline, which could lead to differential treatment before the law, puts trust in the legal system at risk, which is why we acted quickly to address this…
'The Government's objective is to help ensure equality before the law. We are clear that an offender should be judged by a court on an individual basis according to the particular facts and circumstances of their case.
'It is not for the Sentencing Council to set in guidance that judgments should be made on the basis of personal characteristics like race or ethnicity.
'Any reference to preferential treatment for a particular cohort is unacceptable.'
He insisted that tackling disproportionate outcomes within the criminal justice system is 'a policy matter' to be determined by the Government, not judges.
However, he acknowledged the need to tackle inequalities and told peers that the Government has commissioned a review into data held by the Ministry of Justice on racial disparities and will 'carefully consider next steps'.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Full justice devolution to Wales ‘not on the agenda'
Full justice devolution to Wales ‘not on the agenda'

South Wales Guardian

time22 minutes ago

  • South Wales Guardian

Full justice devolution to Wales ‘not on the agenda'

In 2019, an independent commission – led by Lord Thomas, the former head of the judiciary – recommended that justice policy should be 'determined and delivered' in Wales. But, nearly six years on, devolution has stalled, with Welsh and UK ministers suggesting a phased and piecemeal approach to transferring powers as happened in Greater Manchester. Giving evidence to the recent Senedd equality and social justice committee ministers implied the Welsh and UK Governments will pursue the co-commissioning model. Lord Timpson, the UK prisons and probation minister, intimated that devolution would not be a priority amid 'massive pressures' on the justice system. Mick Antoniw, the former counsel general or chief legal adviser to the Welsh Government, pointed to 'volumes of evidence' that devolution of probation 'needs to happen and quickly'. Lord Timpson said: 'If we lurch from problem to problem, we are just going to put sticking plasters all over everything." He said he was more concerned about challenges in probation than prisons – warning the service is unstable, with probation officers having an average caseload of 35. Labour's Jenny Rathbone questioned why more than 25 per cent of the 5,000 Welsh prisoners are held in English jails when Wales has nearly 6,000 prison places of its own. Lord Timpson pointed to capacity pressures with prisons 98.2% full, security in terms of organised crime, and the lack of a category A (high risk) or women's prison in Wales. Following the meeting on July 14, the Senedd's equality and justice committee criticised the 'deeply disappointing' evidence from Lord Timpson. Ms Rathbone said: 'We are very disappointed to hear Lord Timpson say that the UK Government could row back its promises on the devolution of youth justice and probation. 'The Welsh Government has already started the groundwork to prepare because it believed there was a realistic prospect that these aspects could be devolved soon."

Fire stations, care homes and libraries get share of £10m for clean energy
Fire stations, care homes and libraries get share of £10m for clean energy

Glasgow Times

time39 minutes ago

  • Glasgow Times

Fire stations, care homes and libraries get share of £10m for clean energy

Publicly-owned Great British Energy has awarded grant funding for mayoral authorities to install solar panels on public buildings, as well as batteries to store and use renewable energy and electric vehicle (EV) chargers, in a bid to save communities money, improve services, and cut emissions. The funding comes alongside GB Energy's push to deliver clean energy projects for around 200 schools and hospitals with £180 million funding. The Government said the grants range from rooftop solar on Merseyside care homes and leisure centres to solar and batteries for libraries, fire stations, police stations and sports centres – as well as EV chargers – in Greater Manchester. Funding is also going towards solar schemes including police headquarters in Cambridgeshire, an outdoor covered market in Yorkshire and a former colliery in the East Midlands. In West Yorkshire, Leeds City Council's Arium plant nursery and Lotherton Hall estate will be among those benefiting from clean energy funding. Officials estimate the schemes could produce around £1 million a year in savings, and £35 million lifetime savings, on energy bills, as well as improve energy security and create good jobs. Energy Secretary Ed Miliband said: 'Your local sports hall, library and community centre could have their energy bills cut by Great British Energy, the government's publicly-owned clean energy company. 'Our plans will mean more money can be spent on the services that make working people better off and help strengthen the ties that bind us in our communities.' Great British Energy chief executive Dan McGrail said: 'Today's support for new clean power projects in every region in England shows our mission in action – providing a lasting positive impact for the country by creating new jobs, lower bills, and a cleaner future. 'It's important that communities feel the benefits of the energy transition and that we demonstrate the very real benefits it can bring,' he said.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store